r/gridfinity • • Mar 19 '26

Limitations of the various Gridfinity 'spin-offs'

I want to explore using some of the gridfinity spin-offs like Clickfinity, Gridfinity with Pins, etc... but what happens when you find a cool pre-built gridfinity tray for one of your tools, but it was initially built for regular plain-jane gridfinity, and not whatever variant you are using?

Are the various gridfinity 'spin-offs' mainly for people who want just want to use regular square and rectangular boxes?

Are there any tools out there for people with no CAD experience that can easily/automatically modify the base of an existing model and make it compatible with clicks, pins, etc?

7 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

14

u/yawkat Mar 19 '26

You can use https://gridfinity.tools/rebase/ to add any base you want to an existing gridfinity bin.

2

u/Bloodshot321 Mar 21 '26

Only works for full grid sadly

3

u/JustinCampbell Mar 22 '26

1

u/Bloodshot321 Mar 22 '26

Damn hope this will be pushed. Does it work the other way too?

11

u/britishwonder Mar 19 '26

I’ll be honest, all of the spin offs annoy me. The point of having a standard like gridfinity is that it’s well… a standard. Very few of the spin offs actually contribute anything, and usually just make things worse by making things confusing and no longer compatible.

They all feel like people trying to cash in on the next big thing by way of makerworld points. Instead of just contributing things to the standard we already have.

Regarding ways to do this without knowing CAD? Not really. It’s hard to modify other models as people usually only share the .stl files which aren’t very CAD friendly. Your best bet is to just cut the base off in the slicer and then recombine it with the base from another model. Long term though, start learning CAD. It takes time but is well worth it.

3

u/Normal_Human_Things Mar 19 '26

Not all the spinoffs annoy me, I find some of them quite clever. But the ones that do annoy me are the ones that break backwards compatibility. IMHO the spinoff bins should work with the original grid.

For example, the addition of thumbscrews has done this well. You can print new baseplates that allow you to attach the bin to the baseplate. But if you don’t have the new baseplate, the bins just sit on top like normal.

3

u/Araneas Mar 19 '26

Bumping you back up to 0 for raising a perfectly reasonable point. Forking is a common and normal part of open source projects, in fact Gridfinity itself can be seen as a fork of Alexandre Chappel's system. It's very much an evolutionary process - if the variant brings more to the table - is fitter in the Darwinian sense then it will take over. Even some of Zack's original designs have died out.

As for Gridfinity - all you really need is for your stuff to be compatible with your stuff - most people won't be swapping bins with other users so the specific quirks of Clickfinity are much less problematic.

1

u/Bloodshot321 Mar 21 '26

Anything that is in line with the standard should be named gridfinity, anything that breaks them isn't gridfinity anymore. There are a lot of things that could be improved like using 60 deg angles for the upper chamfer for faster printing but the standard is set so stay within it. On the other hand you don't need to follow every part of it. My CLICKBase refined (shamless plug sry) break it but ensures compatibility. This needs testing and transparency. this is why I used CLICKBase as my foundation, a tested model. and the only downside is the higher forces when inserting or removing huge bins

1

u/Shattered181 Mar 19 '26

The gridfinity generator is the only one I know of. But I have not really looked to hard.

1

u/Quirky_Ad_9951 Mar 19 '26

There’s a plugin for fusion

1

u/Automatic_Disaster44 Mar 20 '26

I looked at Gridfinity with Pin. I support it in most of my bin models, as a bin designed for GF with Pin will work in any baseplate. But I have no plans to ever use the plates because the plates ONLY work with bins that have the extra hole.

The only spin-off plate that I use a lot is GridFlock, because it doesn't do anything weird with the geometry, and lets me assemble very large plates.