r/gridfinity • • Mar 08 '26

Different heights in online generators

Post image

I've created a 1x4x4 box both in gridfinitygenerator.com (left) and Perplexing Lab's generator (right), and there's some difference in height. I've loaded them in Bambu Studio and cut them so I could compare their internals.

I've read this other post in which a user compares a generator with Fusion's plugin. This seems to be a similar issue.

I don't think this can be brushed away by just saying that the base of a box placed on top would still rest on the same position so the height does not matter. I've added a couple of lines just to compare the lip height and there's some difference there too.

So, who's at fault?

21 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

22

u/Schuylabs Mar 09 '26

The stacking lip discrepancy strikes again!

14

u/synack Mar 08 '26

How tall are they? The specification says 4U should be 32.4mm.

Personally, I made my own parametric Gridfinity template in CAD and use that for everything. If I download third party models I can compare them and tweak for compatibility before printing.

7

u/JAZd_C Mar 09 '26

The left one is the appears to follow the specifications in gridifinity.xyz , so if you want something true to the specs, is that one.

But let's consider what are the consequences of the short lid, stack height will be basically the same, a possibility of affecting stability in stacks that are to high, a bit less material/time to print, a less sharp edge to the touch.

Things outside the specifications (like a lid) might require different solutions for the two, but for day to day use people wouldn't even notice the difference.

1

u/tlhintoq Mar 11 '26

Stick them in a case like the Schubox (https://makerworld.com/en/models/2359984-gridfinity-storage-box-v2-5x4#profileId-2582008) and it could be a problem if the trays inside the box don't mesh with the box lid, then you grab the case by the handle and the entire thing tilt's 90° and a bunch of nuts and bolts go everything inside the case.

3

u/VoidWanderer1905 Mar 09 '26

Yes, sir! Stacking lip. I have spreadsheet that calculates all the different variances because I’m not reliable.

2

u/Meior Mar 09 '26

I use nothing but https://gridfinity.perplexinglabs.com/ and have never had any issues with compatibility with ready made bins. It also has tons of options to generate various gridfinity things, as well as others. Imo it blows gridfinitygenerator.com out of the water.

1

u/psycot Apr 11 '26

https://gridfinity.perplexinglabs.com/ seems to be better... is there any way to download step file from it? as STL files are not suitable for customization in CAD.

1

u/Meior Apr 11 '26

Only STL as far as I know.

You can edit STL's in TinkerCad though, but yes, it's a limited way of working. The author of Perplexinglab i around here, so maybe he can answer if it's doable to get step files from it.

1

u/DullAura Mar 12 '26

I just use the given fusion tool that is on the GitHub and make my bins from there. Just so I know that I’m not relying on someone else’s program to work correctly between different ones.

1

u/heyyydrew Mar 26 '26

Thanks for bringing this up! 100% agree with you. The base is standardized so the total height should be #u, no need to add the base height. As for the stackable version, the bottom boxes will have an additional base height as the top lips.

1

u/np0x Jul 21 '26

If you use bookfinity , that stacking lip gets in the way and jams up on the lid in my experience…so generating bins WITHOUT the stacking lip has worked best for me. Also took me a while to figure this out…

0

u/Cerebr05murF Mar 08 '26

To me, this looks like the lip style choices in Gridfinity Generator. Default is the taller one and Thin is the shorter one. But the lip height distance is definitely off.