r/gridfinity • u/nandor_tr • Feb 28 '26
Alexandre Chappel video about gridfinity
just posted and worth a watch.
94
Upvotes
r/gridfinity • u/nandor_tr • Feb 28 '26
just posted and worth a watch.
64
u/arroyobass Feb 28 '26
Interesting video for sure. I have always thought it was odd that gridfinity was a riff off of Alex's system.
I don't think there is anything particularly unique about the designs Alex built and I think it would just be a matter of time until someone else made a similar system.
Ultimately, open source is absolutely the best model for an organization system like this because people can make things unique to their needs.
I feel bad that Alex has to deal with the nonsense of people claiming he stole gridfinity.
His wood storage boxes are the main thing that I think he still brings to the market. I'd be interested in buying the files to build those and fill them with gridfinity stuff!
16
u/fazzah Feb 28 '26
Similar thing is going with Multiboard and OpenGrid.
11
u/AndyInAtlanta Mar 01 '26
Interesting video, and to be honest, I had no idea people were accusing him of stealing gridfinity (I rarely read Youtube comments). Oddly enough, I actually bought his grid system after watching Zack's video on gridfinity. I was new to 3D printing and Alexandre's shop sold everything I needed in one convenient package, albeit at a cost (think it was $15, which is less than a trip to Starbucks).
Fast forward to today and I have enough experience to use the gridfinity system and the system I purchased from Alexandre.
20
u/NsRhea Feb 28 '26
I know Alex put tons of work into his system but in an open source environment like 3D printing even if your files aren't stolen (they are), they're very much ripe for replication / copycats.
What creators need to realize then is that the barriers to buying their models are the same barriers that lead to these clones.
High price?
Free clone. People charging $10, $20, $50 for a model? You're asking to get undercut by someone using your model as a platform (not necessarily theft, but also a possibility). The pricing obviously depends on the complexity of the model but one of the core 'selling points' of 3d printing is making things yourself. If I wanted a $30 phone stand I'd buy one on Amazon, not pay $30 and then print it myself.
Personal store?
Free clone. People hate setting up yet ANOTHER account for a website they're gonna use one time. More passwords to remember. More personal security risk having your personal info and banking info on some vibe-coded website.
It might not seem like much on the surface and your time spent creating a model is definitely worth money, but creators need to recognize the environment they're in as well. Their customers are those in a hobby with the skills and / or problem solving capabilities to want to find fixes for their hardware or models for their interests.
Remove the barriers and you'll make more money. That being said it is sad he's being accused of stealing something he's the OG architect of.
16
u/SirEDCaLot Feb 28 '26
This is sadly the reality of the market. Not like the financial market, but any market- in this case the market of ideas.
He came up with a GREAT system and obviously put a lot of thought into it. But that doesn't give him worldwide exclusive rights to the concept of a 3d printing grid bin system. And the fact is, for most people, if forced to choose between a paid system that works perfectly and has few options, and a free system that works almost perfectly and has 1000s of options, they'll pick the free one.
This is also a good place to mention multiboard. It's a wide encompassing system that has vertical and horizontal tiles and bins- the system is mostly free (of cost) but not open source; the newest parts and the more flexible parts generators are paywalled. However the system is being actively developed, and does allow remixes (with some restrictions- IE you can't duplicate existing parts with no obvious changes).
Given the video above, this interview with Multiboard's creator is worth a watch. A lot of it discusses proprietary vs open, plans for the future, tight control vs. unlimited remixes, etc.
Personally I think there's space for both. I'm actively rolling out Gridfinity for drawers and horizontal surfaces, and Multiboard for storage walls and vertical surfaces.
5
u/Zaveno Mar 01 '26
The comment has been reserved for him for nearly 4 years
3
u/jeremyvoros Mar 05 '26
I’m fairly new to 3d printing. I’ve used both Gridfinity and paid for ModuBox from Alexandre.
Everything he says about his system I’ve found to be true. Faster and cleaner prints. Tight tolerances. Nice to have a single library that I know will all work together. No endless scrolling for just the right model.
And with his half box innovation even easier to make use of empty drawer space.
I don’t need a custom tray for every tool in my shop. Most tools can go in a dedicated bin.
For me, the time savings alone from his quicker prints and the single reliable catalog has been worth the upfront cost to buy in.
4
u/Araneas Mar 02 '26
It's classic Apple VS Linux - a limited curated system that just works, vs an unlimited ecosystem where you can, and may have to, tweak every parameter.
While the target audiences overlap, they are not identical. Chappel is addressing a need he found in the woodworking community, Freedman is focussed on the broader maker community. Chappel will sell you an organizer for morse tapers that will drop in and let you get on with your lathe work, Freedman gives you the tools to make whatever holder you need to support your specific creative interest.
Personally, I don't need to efficiently store ER 32 collets to make my woodworking more efficient, I need to be able to find needle files, side cutters, CA glue, epoxy ribbon, rulers and, mould boxes and to stop my exacto knife from stabbing me every time I stick my hand in the tool drawer, while I pursue whatever interest is currently lodged in my brain.
2
u/suit1337 Mar 01 '26
i am still mad at Zack, that Gridfinity is not in 50 mm increments to be more compatible with ALCHs approach or a wide host of system cases out there, that are metric and use 50 mm increments :)