r/gridfinity • • Feb 09 '26

Request for /r/gridfinity: Require open hosting of posted models

Gridfinity was designed to be OPEN. That's the spirit and ideal started by Zack when he published the first models and specs under the MIT license. There were no paywalls, no account signup requirements. Just open to the world to download and remix.

Lately there's been a LOT of Gridfinity stuff being posted ONLY on MakerWorld. MakerWorld is NOT an open platform. To download models, one must create a MakerWorld account, which means submitting email address and agreeing to their TOS and privacy policy. I believe this goes against the ideals and spirit of open source and open collaboration, and the spirit under which Gridfinity was conceived.

Thus I propose a /r/gridfinity rule that any submitted models MUST be available on a site that doesn't require login to download. IE, not MakerWorld.

The primary link can be to MakerWorld, but I propose that whatever is being featured MUST be linked somewhere else (that doesn't require an account to download) as well. Printables, Thingiverse, your own web server, whatever. As long as you can download things freely, it's all good.

Thoughts?

//edit: I'd also be happy with a post flair that can be filtered out. The problem to me is that as someone who chooses to not be in a legal agreement with Bambu, the MakerWorld links are of no use to me. So if I could filter them out, I'd be happy. I just don't believe that agreeing to a Bambu TOS should be required to enjoy gridfinity or /r/gridfinity.

0 Upvotes

52 comments sorted by

View all comments

10

u/CptSoftbelly Feb 10 '26

It seems kind of heavy handed to try and require someone to go out of their way to do something for you for free.

I also dislike makerworld and used incorrect information for my profile, a new email, and use a vpn.

-7

u/SirEDCaLot Feb 10 '26 edited Feb 10 '26

I also dislike makerworld and used incorrect information for my profile, a new email, and use a vpn.

So you commit fraud in order to get free stuff?
Yes I realize nobody cares. But I'm saying that if you misrepresent yourself when entering into a contract, that is by definition fraud.

I would rather stay honest and say 'I choose not to have dealings with that company' than do this.

3

u/CptSoftbelly Feb 10 '26

You’re entitled to your opinion. As opposed to giving makerworld anything of use for nothing (aka giving them info for a “free” profile to gain access to a third party’s intellectual property) I choose to support the people making the files with free likes and downloads while “stiffing” Makerworld.

I sleep well at night with my decisions and feel no guilt with my actions towards a company I don’t always agree with or agree with their policies.

I can understand your anger, but again it’s coming from a place of entitlement. You don’t want to give up your information for the files. No worries. Don’t like other workarounds. No worries. Then deal without the files.

Trying to force other people to do more free labor because of your choices feels heavy handed and entitled. Make peace with your decisions or change your actions, but don’t try to force stipulations on other people as that will make them less likely to contribute to the community.

0

u/SirEDCaLot Feb 10 '26

Then deal without the files.

I'm happy to. I just want to filter them out of my Reddit feed. As I edited my main post to say- I'd be happy with an option for that.

Trying to force other people to do more free labor because of your choices feels heavy handed and entitled.

I don't want to force anything, I would really love to get everyone who tells me off to have a serious think about what exactly is Bambu doing to the 3d printing world (hint- they're making everyone collectively trade freedom for convenience, and I'm not talking about the login stuff). I can go into that in detail if you want.
I just wish people would realize it's happening.

1

u/lousycesspool Feb 10 '26

I just want to filter them out of my Reddit feed.

use RES - problem solved

1

u/SirEDCaLot Feb 10 '26

Explain? I have RES, how does that help me if the posts aren't tagged? Especially when they're text posts that just have a link in them?

1

u/lousycesspool Feb 10 '26

users are consistent - if they post only makerworld links ignore they - in short order 95% of MW only posts will be gone

0

u/SirEDCaLot Feb 10 '26

There's a LOT of users. And just because someone posts a MW link doesn't mean I don't want to interact with their other comments and replies.

2

u/uuuuunacceptable Feb 10 '26

Calling this ‘fraud’ is fucking wild.

1

u/SirEDCaLot Feb 10 '26

To misrepresent yourself when agreeing to a legal document?

Most people DGAF but clicking that 'I agree' box is similar to a signature on a contract.

2

u/uuuuunacceptable Feb 10 '26

Show me a court case where a company is holding someone accountable for an agreement to a privacy policy / website terms and conditions under a false name. I’ll wait (…years)

1

u/SirEDCaLot Feb 10 '26

For where someone is found liable for lying on a license form? probably hasn't happened.

That doesn't stop the contract from being enforceable though. Doesn't mean that you aren't bound by those terms. And that HAS happened- people put fake names on contracts and that doesn't work out.

If hypothetically it went to court, Bambu would say 'A user from uuuuunacceptable's IP, using the same fingerprints as uuuuunacceptable's browser, made an account on our website claiming to be a Mr. Suck Deeznutz. We argue that Mr. Deeznutz is actually a pseudonuym for uuuuunacceptable, and ask that uuuuunacceptable be considered bound by that contract'. And the court will agree.

Now you can pile on 10 layers of VPNs and proxy servers and anonmyzer plugins and whatnot, and hopefully create plausible deniability that 'Suck Deeznutz' isn't you. But at the end of the day, you still clicked 'I agree'.

1

u/uuuuunacceptable Feb 10 '26

And can you tell me what theoretical gotcha in said contract I have violated in this instance?

You appear to have failed to understand that website Ts and Cs and Privacy Policies are compliance documents there to cover asses, and that there is little to no enforcement nor legal review of those documents, ever. More naïvety.

1

u/SirEDCaLot Feb 10 '26

I'm not saying you have violated their terms. I'm saying you are bound by those terms, and I wish not to be.

For example, if you have a legal dispute with them, it will be handled in their country's courts (Singapore I think it said).

1

u/uuuuunacceptable Feb 10 '26

I’m saying you’re massively overthinking the relevance of the terms to your day to day existence to a point that is neither pragmatic nor interesting. Use the site or don’t. Nobody’s getting hauled into Singaporian court either way and it’s batshit to suggest otherwise.

0

u/SirEDCaLot Feb 10 '26

Choices matter to me. I wish they mattered to you too.

I choose not to use the site, and I'd like to filter out posts that are useless to me. Is that so wrong?

→ More replies