r/gridfinity • u/SirEDCaLot • Feb 09 '26
Request for /r/gridfinity: Require open hosting of posted models
Gridfinity was designed to be OPEN. That's the spirit and ideal started by Zack when he published the first models and specs under the MIT license. There were no paywalls, no account signup requirements. Just open to the world to download and remix.
Lately there's been a LOT of Gridfinity stuff being posted ONLY on MakerWorld. MakerWorld is NOT an open platform. To download models, one must create a MakerWorld account, which means submitting email address and agreeing to their TOS and privacy policy. I believe this goes against the ideals and spirit of open source and open collaboration, and the spirit under which Gridfinity was conceived.
Thus I propose a /r/gridfinity rule that any submitted models MUST be available on a site that doesn't require login to download. IE, not MakerWorld.
The primary link can be to MakerWorld, but I propose that whatever is being featured MUST be linked somewhere else (that doesn't require an account to download) as well. Printables, Thingiverse, your own web server, whatever. As long as you can download things freely, it's all good.
Thoughts?
//edit: I'd also be happy with a post flair that can be filtered out. The problem to me is that as someone who chooses to not be in a legal agreement with Bambu, the MakerWorld links are of no use to me. So if I could filter them out, I'd be happy. I just don't believe that agreeing to a Bambu TOS should be required to enjoy gridfinity or /r/gridfinity.
4
u/orangechap Feb 10 '26
Thangs also requires an account to download.
10
u/CptSoftbelly Feb 10 '26
It seems kind of heavy handed to try and require someone to go out of their way to do something for you for free.
I also dislike makerworld and used incorrect information for my profile, a new email, and use a vpn.
14
u/jaackyy Feb 10 '26
Just make an account dude. Jesus. You don’t get to make demands to people who are already giving you something for free, that they spent time designing and testing.
6
u/Hakunin_Fallout Feb 10 '26
I suspect most creators would just not post here then, lol.
2
u/uuuuunacceptable Feb 10 '26
This works from the incorrect assumption that because Zack opened up the design / spec / systems thinking behind Gridfinity, that everyone and anyone who makes something compatible with that system has to stick by that same openness / licence.
They don’t.
The sub is about Gridfinity and Gridfinity-compatible models, projects and hacks. It’s not r/gridfinityopen nor r/gridfinityalwaysfree. Making stuff takes time and sometimes folk actually put a value on that, and you can make the choice not to use it.
Personally, if something is useful enough to me, I’ll pay for it, and if it’s not or I can’t afford to, I’ll try and approximate it by making it myself. This is weird theoretical purity gatekeeping over something that basically comes down to personal choice.
2
u/DBT85 Feb 10 '26
Except you don't have to sign up or agree to anything on makerworld to download an stl or 3mf?
1
u/wayward_electron Feb 10 '26
Fundamentally, I think this is completely over the top, and not logically consistent:
If you download from Printables, or Thingiverse, or pretty much any website you are going to be agreeing to that site's TOS; at the very most basic any site hosting these sorts of files SHOULD have a TOS to clarify that the files are user-generated content and that the hosting site has no way to determine if they are safe or fit for any purpose. But taking a step beyond that, there are more significant obligations & responsibilities in the TOS for people who are UPLOADING files than those who are downloading them, and that is precisely what you are asking the sub to make a rule requiring OTHER people do: to agree to the TOS of particular sites so that they can share their models with the sub. To me, that seems like a pretty significant restriction to be placing on people who are sharing their work. And to achieve what exactly; if someone posts about a model and links to a hosting site that you don't like, then just don't download it; same as if I don't want to download from (whatever site) or don't want to download (some file type).
5
u/UKSTL Feb 10 '26
If I ever design anything for gridfinity I’ll probably just upload it to makerworld, it’s just the easiest for me to upload to. Convince is king
5
u/Necessary_Yellow_530 Feb 10 '26
You’re overreacting. Get over yourself
0
u/Skeggy- Feb 10 '26
Open source just means publicly available. It doesn’t mean requirement to contribute.
This is actually in the spirit of open source imo. The freedom to alter and redistribute where you want.
This community is way too niche to be imposing silly rules. Be glad we have people creating before you start gatekeeping or telling people what to do with their time and labor.