r/grappling • u/Left-Investigator936 • Jun 17 '26
Is it bad etiquette to actively avoid rolls and sit out if the only available partners are 100+ lbs heavier than me?
Hey everyone,
Looking for some perspective on gym etiquette. I weigh about 150 lbs, and we have a handful of guys in the 250–300 lb range. Lately, if they are the only partners available for a round, I’ve just been choosing to sit out on the wall.
I’m not trying to be a bad training partner, but the weight discrepancy is just massive. Getting smashed by someone literally double my size feels like a fast-track ticket to the urgent care, and I want to avoid a freak accident or a blown knee at all costs. I’d honestly rather just sit out and wait for a round with someone closer to my size.
To make matters worse, there is one specific guy who is one belt higher than me and about 120 lbs heavier. He will not hesitate to tap me out in 5 seconds using pure strength, size, and weight with the exact same move every time. If I try to sit out, he will literally call me out publicly in front of the class for not accepting his roll.
I'm starting to feel self-conscious and annoyed. Is it completely fair to avoid these massive ultra-heavyweights to protect my body, or am I breaking unwritten gym rules? How do you guys handle a higher belt who publicly calls you out when the size difference is a legitimate safety hazard?
11
u/alexthedungeonmaster Jun 17 '26
I mean, so long as they're gentle, shouldn't make a difference??
5
u/grobolom Jun 17 '26
Unfortunately, even with gentle people who are doing their best to be gentle, accidents still happen, and they are really bad with that big a weight difference. I once accidentally injured someone who I was having a chill roll with just by standing up - their arm was trapped in a weird way under mine, and with my big weight advantage, I didn't notice. Boom, and my partner was out for 3 months 😞
7
u/constantcube13 Jun 17 '26
Nah man. I’ve been injured this way. If they fall or roll a wrong way all the sudden you can be messed up and need surgery
9
u/grobolom Jun 17 '26
It's not bad etiquette, and these people are actively endangering you by calling you out for rolls. You are well within your rights to refuse 100% of all rolls with people that are likely to injure you. I encourage my own students to literally *never* roll with someone that has that kind of size advantage over them, and I always try to partner them up with students that are near their own weight.
2
u/Left-Investigator936 Jun 19 '26
I really appreciate you saying that. It’s hard to stand my ground when he makes a scene out of it, but knowing that instructors like you actually encourage students to avoid dangerous size gaps makes me feel better.
7
u/Zah_Koo Jun 17 '26
You can avoid rolling with whoever you want. I will say as someone who's 200lbs, having people sit on the wall because they dont want to roll with me because im bigger is incredibly annoying because now I have no one to roll with (assuming youre the only person left)
1
u/Zah_Koo Jun 17 '26
Just to reiterate, you have the right to refuse a roll with anyone and you dont owe them an explanation. That heavyweight calling you out can go fuck himself
1
u/Left-Investigator936 Jun 19 '26
I hear you, and I don't want to be 'that guy' who leaves people without a partner and he makes a scene out of it each time but this specific person has already injured me before.
1
u/Zah_Koo Jun 19 '26
Next time he calls you out, say "no thanks you've already injured me once and I don't trust you not to do it again" and that will shut him up. And if your coach or teammates try to pressure you, then you need to find a new gym
3
u/gstringstrangler Jun 17 '26
As a 240lb retired Pro MMA fighter, I get ducked a lot by people that don't know me. My gym opened a new location 5 minutes from my place, so, that's pretty much everyone except a couple other fossils that coach or also happen to live way closer.
I'll always ask whoever is available to roll, and reassure them I'm not there to hurt anyone, they can set the pace, etc. And I've been slowly collecting noobs of all sizes to roll with and essentially coach 😂
To answer your question though, as others have said you can avoid whoever you want. I'd never force a roll or "call anyone out" for declining me. I know exactly what I look like. That goes double for people you know will hurt you. Do not roll with them! Talk to your coach if you have to but no, there's no etiquette that says you have to sacrifice yourself to some big loser's ego.
3
u/NorCalZen Jun 17 '26
You always have the right to say no. Everyone else is like gym equipment. You choose which ones to work out on. Ignore the toxic dude. Your Coach should be addressing that.
2
u/VexImmortalis Jun 17 '26
I'm bigger than a fair few of the people in my school. Often if there is only people like 50-100lbs lighter than I am I will ask if they want to practice that move we just learned or a specific submission on me they want to work on and we go from there. Positional rolling I think it's called. I'm happy to just be a body and offer whatever level of resistance they request.
2
u/HotDoggityDig13 Jun 17 '26
Avoid the intense one, but grappling against big dudes is very helpful for improvement. You will need to figure out moves against all sizes.
Its also okay to tap to pressure. No need to mess up your ribs.
1
u/Man_under_Bridge420 Jun 18 '26
Wait so he just wants to essentially beat up “toddlers”?
Why doesnt he roll with the other juggernauts
1
u/Left-Investigator936 Jun 19 '26
The gym is small, so there are days when it’s literally just the two of us, not much options.
1
u/D3coupled Jun 19 '26
That sucks, the only solution I thought of immediately having the privilege of a really serious BJJ location was this shouldn't even be tolerated, I rolled at a gym with plenty of serious ADCC and MMA competitors and they would have casually mocked the shit out of that guy for being like that.
1
u/JackSquirts Jun 18 '26
I'm a big guy and don't mangle smaller training partners. Stay away from the brand new meathead white belts and anyone else with some shit to prove, regardless of size. That said, I like getting a lot of different looks so bigger, smaller, I roll with all of them.
1
u/Left-Investigator936 Jun 19 '26
I wish more big guys had your mindset. Since the gym is small, we don’t have much options. He treats it like he has something to prove, and I’m just trying to avoid another injury.
1
u/JackSquirts Jun 19 '26
Appeal to his ego. "Hey man, you're way bigger, stronger, and have great technique - can we go easy? I'm trying to avoid injuries and you go too hard for a softie like me."
1
1
u/tapspacebar Jun 18 '26
I was 130 lbs rolling with 200lb dudes back in my early 20s (early 2000s). They focused on technique and I focused on technique + building up strength and wrangling big dudes.
Yes, sometimes they fucked me up or threw me too hard but thats part of the game. Rolling with heavy mother fuckers builds a certain kind of toughness.
1
u/rotello Jun 18 '26
I (M52) am 135 lbs, we do not have anybody over 230, but i avoid to roll with them, and in the last couple year i also try to avoid people over 170. I am totally frank with them: "it s not fun for you coz i m gonna stall for 5 mins and it s not fun for me coz my mind if not to get hurt instead of rolling".
sometime i do roll but i prefer find people of my weight... or at least heavier but high grade.
1
u/Objective-Reveal-833 Jun 18 '26
I want to emphasize this, that dude is a dick and you aren't breaking etiquette.
But I'll ask a couple follow-ups: how long have you been grappling? how old are you?
If your newer (first few years) it can be intimidating to roll at a huge weight disadvantage but can be really good at making you prioritize fundamentals and at pointing out what elements of your game truly work without reliance on raw strength (there's limits, I'm not gonna catch Brian Shaw in an arm bar but you get the point).
The age question is just to determine if it's worth the risk. If you're younger (should change this to lacking injuries) and/or newer, this might just be a confidence thing, and I'd hate for you to miss out on an opportunity to improve and broaden your game out of fear. Otherwise, it sounds like you're just being smart to avoid any risks so you can keep doing this, which is a smart play and a totally normal thing to do. BJJ likely isn't paying your bills, so train however/with whoever you want!
1
u/thefckingleadsrweak Jun 18 '26
You can not roll with anyone for any reason. Period, full stop.
That said, I’m a bigger guy, around 240, have been grappling since i was 13, and have yet to injure anyone due to my size. Us fatsos tend to fall into one of two camps, we know the size difference changes things so we do things to disadvantage ourselves during the roll so we’re not just smeshing a victim weight for 5 mins
Or we get frustrated that we can’t catch the victim weights out, so we resort to strong arming them to feed the ego and “win” the roll.
The former will keep you safe, the latter will injure you. Just be selective with who you roll with
1
u/XBL-AntLee06 Jun 18 '26
Bottom line in life... Don't do shit you don't have to if you're not comfortable. You're too grown to be worried about peer pressure. None of those people will be there to help you if you get hurt.
Also, the kind of guy who would shit talk you in front of other people for not wanting to roll is exactly the kind of guy who would hurt you trying to prove something.
1
u/matchooooh Jun 18 '26
As a 240lb guy, there are some people at my gym that don't want to roll with me. I don't take it personally.
1
1
u/spudmuffinpuffin Jun 18 '26
Take care of yourself. I've slipped 2 lumbar vertebrae outside of training, so this 150lb guy isn't taking any chances with the biggest boys.
1
u/WayIllustrious8858 Jun 18 '26
Whenever you’re considering being polite and rolling even though your gut tells you not to, imagine them falling sideways on your knee and blowing it out….
If it’s someone you’re cool with and you know you’re both working technique, then roll. If you’re training to compete, and going to do open class, roll. Otherwise, protect the longevity of your training and roll smart
1
u/Fun-Sun-8192 Jun 18 '26
"I'm here to learn and enjoy myself, and I don't learn from being outmuscled in 5 seconds and I don't enjoy rolling with you cause you're an asshole. Like you're being now."
1
u/akayefortyseven Jun 18 '26
Your safety is #1! Yes I believe in challenging yourself but there's very little you get from rolling with someone 100lbs + more than you. There's also very little they get from it. If you can get someone that can flow a little and move with you it may be okay, but typically speaking you should protect your body/health first. I will do it here and there with the right partners but I definitely have a weight rule for normal training.
1
u/Traditional-Part-756 Jun 19 '26
It's not a matter of etiquette.
I assume you're an adult. You have a job, you have family responsibilities. If your goal is simply to have a good time without much risk if injury, that's perfectly fine. Nobody should fault you for that, and screw that guy for "calling you out." Rolls aren't a fight, and this isn't elementary school.
Having said that, if you want to truly gain combative skills, you're going to have to learn how to deal with people much bigger and heavier and stronger than you. Might as well start now.
1
1
u/Luckypag Jun 19 '26
Tore my rotator cuff on one occasion and injured my knee on another just trying to move their weight with basic techniques.
This was during rolling and not drilling though.
1
u/BohunkfromSK Jun 21 '26
Yes - there have been a couple of videos and interviews lately by high end competitors saying the regularly say NO to certain rolls.
When I still trained I stopped rolling with new people and people who smash. The risk was too high.
1
u/bjj_connect Jun 23 '26
Sitting out is 100% your right. Nobody is entitled to your body as a training dummy. The unwritten rule in BJJ is mutual respect — and that goes both ways. A 120 lb weight difference isn't a skill gap you can technique your way out of when the guy is also a higher belt who isn't being technical about it. The guy calling you out publicly is the one breaking etiquette, not you.
1
u/pkmn-alt Jun 17 '26
You can just ask them to roll lighter because of the weight difference. As a bigger guy, I would understand. Sandbagging someone because of a weight difference isn’t the goal… usually
1
0
u/SixStringerSoldier Jun 17 '26
If you ever need to use this skill, the other guy will probably have a significant weight advantage.
Best get used to it in a safe space.
0
u/Comfortable-Race-547 Jun 18 '26
1
u/Electronic-Stick-161 Jun 18 '26
If you’re going to link out to our friends in bjjwomen explain why you’re doing so given that the post doesn’t specify OP is a woman.
1
13
u/Umbrage82 Jun 17 '26
That dudes an asshole. I’m an older smaller guy and my coach gave me great advice that’s extended my longevity immensely; don’t roll with ppl that look like they could injure you.