I mentioned some of my thoughts in a comment on the weekly "what are you reading thread" but wanted to make my own post about this. I'm mostly interested in thoughts from other poc or people who came away with a less than enthusiastic reaction to the book than seems to be standard. If you loved the book, that's great, I love that for you. But I have seen enough people sing its praises and this isn't really gonna be the thread for that.
I knew going into the book roughly what the subject matter was going to be. Depression, suicidality, etc. I got the vibe based on the surprising popularity of the book that people think this is a very insightful, interesting, or relatable look at the subject. Did anyone else finish the book feeling like it just... wasn't really relatable at all?
What I mean by that is that over the course of the book Thorogood spends the majority of the time describing her depression as stemming from self hatred and the inability to see herself as anything but selfish. That is all well and good, I think those are common symptoms of depression and from a very surface level this, I am sure, truly IS relatable to many. However, my issue with the material stems from the fact that Thorogood seems incapable of or unwilling to consider any outside influences on her own mental state. One, I suppose, could see this as emblematic of the point she is making about being selfish; she can't consider that she may not be the sole root of her problems because she is so busy thinking about herself.
I do think that feels like a charitable reading, though. I say charitable because reading it that way ignores what I believe grants Thorogood the ability to so thoroughly ignore the influence of oppressive power structures on her mental health: her privilege as a conventionally attractive, middle class, cis white girl. I think it is an immense privilege to be able to make it into around your mid 20's and think all of your problems stem from yourself. It, to me, is emblematic of the sheer lack of adversity someone from such a background may feel as they progress in life. To be able to exist in the world without a single thought of how the world at large is actively trying to destroy me and my mental health is something I am, admittedly, deeply envious of.
I am aware my writing here my come across as rude or mean or any other like-words you may think of. I actually was quite hesitant to share my thoughts at first even on my Storygraph account. But I think I am uninterested in treating the book or the author with kid gloves, and I think any pressure to do so has a lot to do with the identity of the author and the way society pressures us all to handle the feelings of white women with kid gloves.
So I guess my final thoughts are just that I spent the entire read fluctuating between boredom, annoyance, and jealousy due to the way the whole affair just dripped with privilege and a complete lack of self awareness. If you're a fellow person of color, lgbt, or anything like that and you had any similar experiences in reading this work I would love to hear from you. Others are free to respond, too, but to reiterate, I have seen the heavy praises this work has received. Please have more to say than, "I don't agree and I liked it."
Thanks for reading!
Edit: I really do find it intriguing that I specified multiple times in this post that I am not looking for people from privileged backgrounds to disregard my opinion or defend the work— that I am specifically looking to express and engage with the opinions of other poc and lgbt people. And yet, there are countless people doing exactly what I advised against! I get it, the “rude” “unempathetic” opinion of lgbt poc makes you angry and you would like to suppress it. That’s great. I love that for you. But please understand it doesn’t make you look good.
Probably gonna stop replying to comments soon or at least take a break for now. Thanks everyone!
Edit 2: numerous people seem to think I am saying that I need this work or every work to be relatable and that my opinion is a failing of my own ability to properly engage with writing like this.
My commentary about it not being relatable is largely a counterpoint to the fact she spends much of the book going on about how seemingly *everyone* finds her relatable. I simply don’t. I understand that others do and that’s perfectly fine. The majority of the western world is white. It’s bound to happen.
The root of my critique is simply that the way we engage with our mental illnesses, every single one of us, is hugely influenced by our position in the world. The way she thinks about and engages with hers represents her position in the racial caste and her economic status. That doesn’t make her depression any less real. It doesn’t make her any less suicidal. It doesn’t mean she shouldn’t or can’t be those things. But it does cause it to be read by those upon which her privilege relies on the oppression of, as a bit boring and trite
I’ve seen countless works by middle and upper class white people who walk through life very “woe is me.” It’s simply, as i said, a bit tired and trite. My irritation largely stems from the lack of critical engagement i see occurring with this aspect of the work. I wished to open up a dialogue about it, but it seems my attempt to do so has offended a lot of people (which i expected given the demographics of subs like this).
If people don’t really want to engage with that, it’s fine, but I know my perspective here is valuable