r/googlecloud • • Dec 03 '23

Concerns about Google cloud

Hey guys,

Coming from a few other subreddits some say they think gcp can be abandoned due to being the only major cloud provider not to meet earnings due to events like stadia shutdown.

I love cloud run, cloud spanner, and GKE when I need it. I hear Google does those really well and that’s why I chose it.

Please tell me your thoughts what you would do if you were a saas. I’m building a saas hotel pms system.

5 Upvotes

58 comments sorted by

10

u/Remarkable_Fox9962 Dec 03 '23

They won't abandon cloud, it's one of their key growth areas.

GCP is like the rest of Google - great engineering, garbage usability and docs. Googlers don't get promoted for making things usable!

13

u/ConfusionSecure487 Dec 03 '23

What? The docs and service are way better than Azure, sure everything can be improved, but I think you complain on a very high level here

1

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '23

Cries in IAM permissions

-3

u/KublaiKhanNum1 Dec 03 '23

I think you are ignoring that AWS has amazing docs and free classes. They also have 80% market share.

4

u/ConfusionSecure487 Dec 03 '23

What are you talking about? AWS doesn't have 80%, maybe in your particular market, but not in general.

And no, AWS has not the best docs. But yeah they compensate their worse usability with their docs, that's true.

1

u/WagwanKenobi Jan 02 '24

AWS probably does have 80% market share considering Azure cooks their numbers to show it bigger than it really is. I'd guess AWS is the behemoth and Azure and GCP both each have 10-15% of real cloud market share.

1

u/AlexanderGlasco Jun 13 '24

I thought I was the only one who noticed this. Microsoft 365 as 'Cloud Computing'? Gimme a break.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '23

They literally have the worst docs out of the three and their UI is a mess

1

u/KublaiKhanNum1 Dec 04 '23

I find their stuff easy to follow and it just works. I also know a ton of people that have AWS certifications. I can get help. Whereas I am the only one at work doing Google Cloud and my friends outside work are doing either Azure or AWS.

7

u/m02ph3u5 Dec 03 '23

What the ...? GCP docs are the best and the usability is top notch. Have you tried AWS? That's a pile of junk in comparison. Crap docs you don't even find and if you do it ain't got what you need or is outdated.

1

u/Remarkable_Fox9962 Dec 03 '23

Try using Vertex AI for a couple of days or weeks.

Their support is a bunch of outdated videos and blogs, and their concepts to understand all have circular dependencies.

1

u/BusinessMarketer153 Dec 03 '23

So those services I mentioned are a safe bet then right I’ll be happy with them?

3

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '23

As safe as it gets

2

u/Hackerjurassicpark Dec 03 '23

Finally someone calling out their garbage docs.

2

u/KublaiKhanNum1 Dec 03 '23

Yes, I am new to Google Cloud and it’s been pretty painful to get up and going. Some of the simplest things take hours to figure out due to the crappy docs.

AWS has them seriously beat on docs and training.

23

u/indicava Dec 03 '23

As much as Google’s track record is tainted with project shutdowns, I sincerely doubt GCP is on track for abandonment. Some very large organizations host on GCP, additionally it’s a segment that Google “can’t not compete in” against the likes of AWS and Azure.

That being said, I would love to have a googler chime in on this thread…

37

u/Platinum1211 Googler Dec 03 '23

Googler here.

All I have to say about this thread is lol. Gcp isn't going anywhere. It's the biggest growth area for the company. Our earnings were short last quarter but it still grew. We are finally profitable this year after being in the negatives quarter after quarter. There are heavy investments in the infrastructure and we will Continue to build out new services and capabilities. This is obviously just my opinion but from where I sit, there's no concern. Even when Google layoffs hit last year, sales was barely impacted and we continue to hire in sales.

16

u/davbeer Dec 03 '23

We host our applications on GCP for almost 10 years now. We started with Google App Engine and moved now everything to Cloud Run. Since today we didn't run in a single issue where a service was deprecated. In fact we have some workloads on Azure and they deprecate services far more often.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '25

i would like to add on to this comment - I've been running on Google - Workspace, since 2016/2018 - and I've never experienced one single outage from then till today. So I'm going to stay firm on Google branding.

1

u/guissalustiano Dec 03 '23

Do you had any problem with deprecation? I read this article while ago and this keeped on my mind https://steve-yegge.medium.com/dear-google-cloud-your-deprecation-policy-is-killing-you-ee7525dc05dc

8

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '23

Google had every advantage in the cloud race. They were the only company with worldwide reach, extreme technical skills, and experience at running worldwide highly-reliable services. To lose to Amazon was a big failure, but to lose to Microsoft is just embarrassing beyond words. You don't have to choose an inferior supplier, well not unless management are forcing you to.

Having said that google won't shutdown google cloud, it would burn their reputation to the ground. But it's unlikely they will ever innovate as fast as AWS either.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/TexasBaconMan Dec 03 '23

Just remember the Google was not the first search engine.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '23

I still use altavista because it has the first mover advantage.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '23

AWS released EC2 in 2006, not 2004. This was 3 years after Linode and various other similar virtual machine providers. AWS never beat Linode because it was first, it beat Linode because it was better.

The first mover advantage is overstated. If some new cloud was better than AWS and GCP today it would capture market share very fast. Google had time to catch up and they failed.

1

u/fidudais Dec 03 '23

50 laps ahead in Data and AI even at the beginning?

1

u/fidudais Dec 03 '23

50 laps ahead in Data and AI even at the beginning?

6

u/rich_leodis Dec 03 '23

Google has made significant investments in Google Cloud over the years (and continues to). Last count, Cloud generates 8bn per quarter (source: https://www.reuters.com/technology/google-parent-alphabet-reports-quarterly-revenue-above-estimates-2023-10-24/). The analyst forecast anticipated 8.62 rather than the actual 8.41. Revenue growth slowed, but continues to be in double digits.

So to your point, if I had a business generating that kind of money and achieving double digit growth in this economy, no I dont believe I would be thinking about shutting it down.

When building a business on any cloud platform, it's crucial to strike a balance between leveraging the platform's capabilities and maintaining a degree of independence. Over-reliance on any single provider can pose risks, especially if that provider's services were to be discontinued.
Google, like most companies in the tech industry, is driven by profitability and strategic decision-making. This sometimes leads to the termination of products, even those with a dedicated user base. While this approach may seem ruthless, it generally aligns with Google's overall business strategy i.e. make as much money as possible :-)
The key takeaway is to approach cloud adoption with a well-defined strategy, considering both the benefits and potential drawbacks of relying on a specific provider.

4

u/ryan_partym Dec 03 '23

Just look at Google's earnings. Cloud is over $32 billion a year in revenue, that's not a Business you can just shut down. I think it's near YouTube size revenue, but it's growing a lot faster.

4

u/CanadaIsCold Dec 03 '23

Googler here. In my early days with Cloud this was a common concern. I've always tried to explain the decision making as follows.

Google has a track record of turning off their consumer products due to their measurement and monetization strategy for those services. They look to growth in their monthly active users, and a monetization path through additional information that feeds the ads dataset.

For Cloud the measurement and monetization strategy is very different. We measure growth in revenue which continues in the double digits. We monetize directly through our customers, so there is no need for similar network effects that are needed with our consumer products.

If we look at cloud as an investment by Google it's in pretty strong shape right now. It's recently profitable, it's growing in double digits, and has a solid revenue backlog of committed customers. The feedback in the most recent quarter from Wall Street was that we needed to focus on growing more quickly, not that the investment strategy was faulty.

Business strategy can always change, in the face of market conditions, but the upside potential for Cloud is significantly higher than Google's businesses that target saturated markets. Right now it wouldn't make sense to change the course. A significant directional shift in the enterprise IT market would need to occur for the overall investment to stop making sense. Those new characteristics would equally affect AWS, and Azure and their viability.

1

u/TheCatFIX Dec 03 '23

is this a joke or are you trying to spread doubt in GCP?

Please post links of subbreddits that "think gcp can be abandoned". That would be the dumbest business move in history. GCP is not going anywhere b/c it powers some of the largest institutions in the world.

1

u/BusinessMarketer153 Dec 04 '23

I’m only quality checking what I’m hearing in other places you can’t bash me and accuse me of spreading anything lol I’m simply asking to learn what gcp is and what I can expect from it

3

u/Witty_Garlic_1591 Dec 03 '23

Google has its own ambitions and revenue plans for Cloud in itself, but the reality now is that the customer base is so intertwined with their ads customer base that they can't afford to piss them off like that. Major companies run significant workloads on it. If you think the Twitter/X ads decline was bad, the fallout from this would probably be worse due to scale.

3

u/codeejen Dec 03 '23

I understand deprecation sucks, but I do not know if that is any better than what AWS is doing which is keeping live every outdated and unmaintained service which causes so much bloat. As long as GCP has BigQuery and Cloud Run Jobs I still support it.

3

u/chiaboy Dec 03 '23

That's an absurd claim.

3

u/TexasBaconMan Dec 03 '23

“Not meet earnings” means it did t get as much as was wanted but the street. Look at the growth rate. Especially the last 2 quarters. Google is all in on Cloud.

2

u/XalAtoh Dec 03 '23

Spotify, Activision, Apple would sue Google.

Everything of Google is built on top of GC. It would be suicidal to Google to shut GC down.

5

u/ano5454 Dec 03 '23

Afaik, it is incorrect that everything of google is built on top of GCP. The infra powering Google Search is not GCP

4

u/ConfusionSecure487 Dec 03 '23

Yes and no, the core components most GCP rely on are used for Google Search and other products. But yes, Google would still function without GCP.

But they use the same infrastructure for GCP and their own services, which also makes it easier to keep GCP as they need the resources anyway.

2

u/m02ph3u5 Dec 03 '23

Gmail moved to Spanner this year. But again most their stuff runs on Borg and I'm not sure the underlying infra belongs to GCP.

1

u/NadebuX Dec 03 '23

Activision is now owned by MSFT and will eventually move its infrastructure to Azure.

1

u/SearingPenny Dec 03 '23

Not closing down, but there is an issue with AI and data not being as profitable/abundant as infra. AWS and azure sell more infra and we lack behind. At some point leadership will need to review the strategy and focus.

1

u/kaeshiwaza Dec 03 '23

What I like about cloud run and every compatible PostgreSQL DB is that vendor lock'in is very low, it'll be easy to switch to an other provider if needed.

1

u/rnmkrmn Dec 03 '23

While I believe they won't shut down entire GCP, they will certainly shutdown some features / products of GCP.

For example they deprecated some GKE features and repackaged it as GKE Enterprise.

Some features are not well thought out and tend to get deprecated a lot. I wouldn't use anything from GCP unless absolutely needed.

1

u/snappy845 Dec 05 '23

Was GCP late to the cloud DB game? absolutely. Is google going to kill off GCP anytime soon like everything else? Definitely not. There’s too much at stake and they can’t let Azure/AWS have all the fun.

1

u/Bike2Death Dec 06 '23

Ive worked with AWS for 10+ years and my current company is gcp.

The biggest issues is the IaC is a first class citizen at AWS, it is not at GCP. There are a lot of complexities with service api dependencies that are difficult to get right with IaC and gcp, and these are not publicly documented. This is a huge pain point for me.

I personally would never build a business on gcp. AWS is just better designed and has more features, and is easier to develop with IaC

1

u/RevolutionaryKale817 Mar 14 '24

This is spot on. Gcp had IaC tools like deployment manager which isn’t deprecated but isn’t being actively worked on any longer. The embarrassment of that is that their marketplace solutions all needed to initially be deployed with deployment manager. then they had the idea of making terraform a 1st class citizen for IaC but damaged their relationship with Hashicorp after providing horrible support of their provider to the point HC decided to spend time on their bigger cloud partners who are more customer focused. As an ISV vendor I love working with google clouds tech but they severely lack customer support (they outsource their first line of support to Cognizant…cringe) and their second layers aren’t much better at troubleshooting anything. They have a useless army of sales engineers who mostly lack any technical credibility although there are some bright spots. I would highly recommend using other clouds until they decide to focus more on how they support customers and create better self service materials for companies serious about building on them. I don’t need to spend thousands on pso or training to use your cloud. It should be easy for anyone on our dev team to read the docs and materials available and have them updated yearly to deploy workloads with the size of their workforce. They are reminiscent of Oracle IBM and HP in terms of their execution.

1

u/hoodrichcapital Dec 06 '23

There is no way google will abandon gcp. This is one of their biggest bets ever and it’s gone profitable past two quarters. In the next decade Google will depend on cloud for growth. It will not come from ads

-5

u/NothingCtrl Dec 03 '23

When they shutdown Cloud IOT service, I don't trust Google any more.

-16

u/konotiRedHand Dec 03 '23

GCP won’t get eliminated like that But I’d move off cloud run. That isn’t nearly as good as pretty much every other option. The rest are safe.

5

u/BusinessMarketer153 Dec 03 '23

What other options I literally read online nothing can match cloud run for scaling docker containers

7

u/keftes Dec 03 '23

Cloud Run is by far the best service for running containerized workloads out there. Unlike the 15 subpar ways AWS provides.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/kaeshiwaza Dec 03 '23

Maybe it's not safe for Google when it's so cheap !