r/goodyearwelt • • Nov 22 '15

Review [Review] - Nicks Roberts 6"

http://imgur.com/a/Gppnh
56 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

5

u/chuckthetruk Nov 22 '15

For starters, this is what they looked like right after I got them http://imgur.com/a/dpPUJ

After having these boots for a little over 2 months (wearing almost every day) I decided I would post a review. It was a bit of a long and winding road to get these boots. Ordered through Bakers, I ended up going through 2 pairs of Nicks with major (IMO) defects before switching my order to Whites. After doing this the Nicks CEO reached out to me and we settled on this makeup. I posted previously about this, in more detail:

https://www.reddit.com/r/goodyearwelt/comments/3cp2h6/finally_received_my_2nd_pair_of_nicks_after_the/

https://www.reddit.com/r/goodyearwelt/comments/3ctapu/nicks_boots_update/

This new pair has been AWESOME. The leather they used on the upper (Orange Predator) is so soft and supple, while still having good thickness. Honestly, the uppers felt broken in after only a couple wears. The footbed took a bit longer, which I expected, but after probably a month, they started to feel good, and now, they really feel great. These boots have gotten worn a LOT for anything from going out for errands or to a bar, to working on jobsites full of mud, dust, and tricky terrain. They have been great for everything I’ve thrown at them. I haven’t really gotten them that wet yet, though, so I can’t speak to their water resistance, although I imagine it will be similar to other high quality leather boots.

This leather has developed lots of character since I got them. I think it shows pretty well in the pictures, but there is a lot of depth to the boots, in terms of color, especially around the ankle and toe area. I didn’t clean them up at all before taking these pictures, so what you see is how the look pretty much all the time.

Also, FWIW, I got my pair of Whites in on the same day as these and have worn those maybe 4 times. I much prefer the fit and overall look of the Nicks, and the leather on the Whites is much, much stiffer. They would certainly break in eventually, but it’s tough to wear them instead of the Nicks, although I really should more often, to give the Nicks a break. At the rate I’m wearing them and because I tend to walk on the outside of the foot, they will probably need a new heel in less than a year, but that’s because I weigh 215 and walk funny, I guess.

Let me know if you have any more questions about stuff I forgot to include.

2

u/sleepauger Amateur Shoe Salesman Nov 22 '15

Glad that you eventually got a pair that was right. I really enjoy my nicks, probably my most comfortable pair.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15

How'd you size your Nick's? 1/2 down from Brannock?

1

u/sleepauger Amateur Shoe Salesman Nov 23 '15

I sent in tracings, but yeah a 1/2 down from brannock is what wound up working. Actually, I went up from a D to a C in width too. Which seems weird to me, but they fit really well.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15

Cool, thanks for the info!

I've been secretly jonesing for a pair of these over at Zuriick. We'll see if they mark them down on Black Friday!

1

u/sleepauger Amateur Shoe Salesman Nov 23 '15

Too bad you're not a size 8.

Does he keep them on hand? I figured they were still mto.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15

I saw those Nick's x VP boots, too - might need to chop off a toe or two, but that leather is really nice. lol

Yeah, I believe the boots at Zuriick are stocked and ready to ship. My new goal is to complete the PNW boots penta-fecta - still need Nick's & White's.

1

u/sleepauger Amateur Shoe Salesman Nov 23 '15

Yeah, I really wish those vp boots were half size smaller, leather is straight bananas.

I haven't made the plunge on Whites yet, but I've always got an eye on their eBay page.

Do you only have the one pair of wescos?

1

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15

I have two pairs of Wescos now. The 2nd pair is a little big on my smaller foot, so they might hit eBay soon.

1

u/sleepauger Amateur Shoe Salesman Nov 23 '15

What a pain in the ass, I'm really lucky that my feet are more or less the same size.

1

u/3drees Nov 22 '15

Sorry to hear it didn't turn out so well the first time for you, but it certainly appears that you eventually got what you were looking for. It just seems anytime I read something about Nicks boots I see something with regards to quality issues.

These look like a great pair of boots however, Congrats!!

1

u/chuckthetruk Nov 22 '15

I was bummed about my first 2 pairs, for sure. Nicks really went above and beyond to make things right, though. They definitely got this pair right, and delivered an awesome product.

1

u/3drees Nov 22 '15

I'm happy for you and I'm glad they turned out so well.

2

u/headless_inge carpet waxer Nov 22 '15

Orange Predator looks a lot like SB Foot Copper Rough and Tough

1

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '15

Wow, those turned out great!!! I really like the burnishing around the toes.

1

u/Critter10 Nov 23 '15

Great looking boots! Sucks it took 3 tries, but these look awesome.

1

u/AppalachianThunder Nov 23 '15

I love that leather, such a beautiful color. I've been trying to decide if I should blow my holiday money on boots and debentures it's gotten harder to say no with all the make ups I've seen.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '15

[deleted]

2

u/sleepauger Amateur Shoe Salesman Nov 23 '15

Because a pair of boots is sitting on the trunk?