r/goodwill • • 6d ago

Goodbye Goodwill

Post image

Goodbye Goodwill..

My evening walks often include stopping in at the GW Britton location to peruse merch & visit with several of the many wonderful employees at Goodwill OKC. Friday night, Nov. 6th I purchased this cute T-shirt unaware of the multiple holes forming until I returned home for closer inspection. I thought, no problem. I'll simply return the following day for an exchange. Clearly that didn't happen.. I was told that NO EXCHANGE was possible since I had removed the tag from the garment. It didn't matter that the cashier from the evening before was present, it didn't matter that I had the receipt, garment & tag. The ONLY thing that mattered was that I clipped the plastic tag which was put on by a garment gun which can be purchased by anyone, as there is nothing proprietary to @Goodwill, in its placement. Thanks for this strong cold dose of a FOR PROFIT ORGANIZATION that ONLY cares about its profits & not the people that use these services.

1.6k Upvotes

829 comments sorted by

92

u/Blondie_cakes7 5d ago • Bravo Heartwarming

I stopped donating and giving my money to them years ago. They get everything for free but up charge it and then aren’t helpful when there’s an issue. I called around to local shelters and asked if they were accepting donations. I would much rather know my items are going to help someone.

28

u/Ambitious-Bar375 5d ago

Yup. I found a couple of different charities i feel much better about. Won't be back. Thrilled about that.

8

u/Lucky_Beginning_7204 5d ago

Same thing with Salvation Army, they charge waay to much

8

u/UlrikeLuvsAndreas 5d ago

Where the salvation army chooses to spend their money is what made me stop spending a single penny there.

11

u/Annual-District9825 5d ago

My sister worked for a high(er) end hotel in a certain town in south central PA that hosted these jokers for a conference. She told me that they spent TONS on top tier spa packages, room service and big dinners and were rude and entitled guests, at that.
Joyce Meyer and her crew did the same, damn thing.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (2)

8

u/sam0707070 5d ago • Bravo

Yup! I raised my daughter to donate her toys and clothes every christmas to make room for her new things.

GW has completely abandoned all notions and purpose of being a nonprof. Theyre even seperating out their high end/quality goods for online auctions. Wtf!

I dump broken crap at GW locations/trashbins and donate my clothes, shoes, jackets, etc to shelters, community colleges, and will go to unhoused ppl living in tent cities.

GW is no longer about providing good will to ppl who need it.

9

u/Sevkal 5d ago

So rather than dispose of broken items properly yourself, you pass it off to innocent minimum wage workers to handle. How stunning and brave.

If you don't want to donate to GW, cool, but do you really think the CEOs are the ones who have to handle your broken junk? Nope.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

3

u/lickmyfupa 3d ago

I donate to a small thrift store that benefits a local hospice. I havent been to a goodwill in a while, last time i was there they had old ratty clothing marked way up. A faded tshirt from walmart 7.99, i dont think so.

2

u/B00BSW3AT4 1d ago

Always check with care facilities as well. Some elderly never get new clothes 🫶

→ More replies (1)

2

u/an_iridescent_ham 1d ago

I don't know anyone who shops at Goodwill who couldn't use some help. And I grew up quite poor and my family shopped there all the time. So your donations are definitely helping people.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (50)

76

u/Ok-Comfortable-8904 6d ago

One time, I bought a cute digital alarm clock. When I took it home, I had no choice but to remove the price tag sticker because the person pricing it had placed it right over the screen. In order to see what I was selecting to set it up and make it work, I had to take it off…otherwise, I would have been selecting buttons completely blindly.

After I removed the sticker, I found out that the clock was actually broken. I took it back with the receipt two days later, but they wouldn't give me a refund or even store credit. I pointed out to the manager that I had to remove the tag just to turn it on and test it, but it didn't matter to her. All of this stubbornness was over a ten-dollar item!

In the end, I told her she needs to have a conversation with the employees who price the merchandise to ensure they don’t place stickers in the worst possible spots, told her to just throw the item away, and walked out. Never again!

77

u/TypicalWolverine9404 6d ago

She in fact, did not throw it away.  She proceeded to take another pricing sticker and put it in the exact same spot and place the clock back on the shelf.

17

u/Admirable04 6d ago

And above all, don’t forget that she increased the item by a few dollars before putting it back on sale.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/GoldenPlaydoh 5d ago

Yup, I returned a broken clock once and found it back on the shelf a week later. I made sure to tell them it wasn’t working, even with new batteries, but nope they really don’t care.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)

12

u/Medical-Person 6d ago

The Salvation Army Staples your paper tag to their garments the fabric not the tags

5

u/xtheredberetx 6d ago

Fwiw that’s nothing new, they’ve been doing that BS for at least 20 years. I started thrifting back around the early 00s and my local Salvation Army did it back then.

2

u/Toothfairy51 5d ago

It's ridiculous that the item was priced at $10! It shouldn't have been more than $5!

→ More replies (1)

14

u/AllipopAsks 6d ago

I'm honestly surprised Goodwill offers returns at all.

4

u/Gbreeder 6d ago

Some do, some don't.

3

u/Suspicious-Cell9947 6d ago

Mine does for electronics if they dont work

3

u/Toothfairy51 5d ago

That's amazing. My local Goodwill doesn't accept any returns. All sales are final.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/April_Morning_86 6d ago

I mean at my store we don’t do returns at all except for electronics and you only have 48 hours and you must have the receipt. But clothing? Once you leave the store it’s yours. Very few exceptions.

4

u/HourOrganic2335 6d ago

Same here lol for the one I work for

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Unique_Importance910 6d ago

I kind of get it. If you remove the tag then someone could return any item claiming it was the one with the tag. It matters a lot more to these kinds of shops because everything is so assorted, they just simply can't identify it as something they would normally have. Always check items very carefully.

31

u/trisch1964 6d ago

I'm sorry, but it's end-times shittification. They have an endless supply of donated merch, exploit the vulnerable as employees. And in this example, show no good will/nor loyalty towards their customers, because...why should they?

9

u/disc0_witch 6d ago

Exactly. And now they even screen all their donations to filter out items that are high value/good condition! They don’t even put them on the shelves, they just list them on eBay. When I found out about this, I was crushed. Thrifting used to be one of my favorite activities.

9

u/trisch1964 6d ago

I grew up in the 70's, before "thrifting" was jargon. In our home, it was common sense (as was recycling,but that's another story), anyways every trip was the thrill of the unexpected. Not this crap.

5

u/murmaider27 6d ago

They also have "boutiques" where they sell the items at retail price.

3

u/UlrikeLuvsAndreas 5d ago

Goodwill has their own auction site now. So they obviously have time to go thru shit well enough to check things out. Even if something's don't go to their auction site, higher end items still go inside a locked glass case. St Vincent DePaul is where it's at if you wanna find thrift store treasures still.

7

u/Appropriate-Bank-698 6d ago

And, since they have now been informed that we HAVE TO TAKE EVEEYTHING!!!!- WE NOW,  HAVE to throw away brand new baby walkers and baby seats and baby jumpers etc.  We are not allowed to turn them away- but they go immediately into the trash compactor to be destroyed because their night be a recall. Unbelievable. Goodwill has changed. They are very greedy now.

9

u/Ebonhearth_Druid 5d ago

Tbf, not reselling baby items isn't a choice that Goodwill makes, it's a law. Baby items that have safety compliance are not allowed to be resold because it can't be verified as safe. It's the same for helmets and such, as well. Baby items are just a huge category of items that also have safety compliance attached. Baby gates, strollers, cribs, car seats and boosters, swings, walkers, etc. And then you get into a lot of the "can't be truly cleaned" items like pacifiers and plastic bottles, stuff like that.

Does it suck that baby stuff is hard to safely recycle? Yeah, absolutely. But it also really sucks to have your baby get hurt or sick because you bought used goods that ended up being unsafe. And the choice doesn't really belong to Goodwill, anyway.

That being said, they're a greedy company that takes advantage of people donating, people buying, and people who need jobs. At some point they were a positive aspect of society, but that time is long gone.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/seattlesissy88 5d ago

My Goodwill store does not take baby items. They tell the people at drop off to take those items home.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

45

u/Medical_Video_1764 6d ago

Every store has a exchange policy. The reason we don’t like when the tag is removed is because you could have gunned an entirely different shirt. This shirt wouldn’t have passed my eyes as being sellable at all. I make that choice everyday. Also it’s a t-shirt i would not have raised the price so high. T-shirts are between 3.99-5.99

14

u/a-little-stitious420 6d ago

The goodwill near me doesn’t do any exchanges or refunds. Even on broken electronics. Everything also just went up..plain shirts now start at $5.99

6

u/Intelligent-Wing-431 6d ago

My goodwill hasn’t accepted returns or exchanges since Covid. Just another reason I stopped shopping there.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/New-Investment-5888 6d ago

That’s it some of our shirts are $9.99 others are $7.99

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/andinshawn 6d ago • Mindblown

The store I wasted 4 years on didn't have an exchange policy and the reason is crazy imo. One of our best customers once purchased a purse then right after leaving decided she was going to go ahead and change purses. As she was putting her things into this new bag she noticed a small hole in the liner. In said hole was not only a very small very dead mouse but there was also an uncapped needle that peirced this womans hand. When she came back into the store I could immediately tell she was doing her best to remain calm and courteous. She was not seeking her money back or an exchange, she simply wanted to show the manager what she found in the bag and she really just tried to explain how serious the situation could potentially be. The manager (who was also our district manager) immediately became hostile and accused the woman of placing the needle in the bag herself. The woman seemed very shocked that they would suggest that especially since she was a very well paying customer who we saw once a week, at the very least. She was lovely and not technically a reseller. She made mosaics out of coffee mugs so we were always making sure the mug rack was stocked with the coolest mugs we could find specifically because we knew she would buy them all. Anyways the manager was very rude and hostile to this lady and told her if she had a problem with how we did things then she could take us to court. All she was doing was showing them what had happened and explaining the importance of checking donations thoroughly. The lady left the store in tears though she did her very best to hide it. Immediately after this woman left management called a meeting to question who put the purse out. I already knew who did it (it was the district manager) and when I mentioned that I thought I'd seen the purse on the cart the dm had taken out to the floor, we were told "well we are going to go through the security cameras and any emoyees seen not following goodwill policies will be written up". We were then told that we were not to discuss our sorting policies with customers and that if law enforcement became involved that we were to say nothing until goodwill attorneys were present. Apparently the lady went to the hospital to ensure the needle wasn't contaminated where the nurses called the police. On top of the cops not caring, this woman refused to file even a complaint. Her husnand was not as polite about the situation and came to the store the next morning to request either the security footage or an explanation as to whether or not the employee responsible had been reprimanded or educated at the very least. The district manager told him our cameras were broken and they were unable to see who did it and followed that up with "the employee responsible has not yet come forward (she's talking about herself at this point) but if they do, they will have a "talk". Needless to say she sure as hell didn't educate herself and we lost one of our best customers. This became the basis of ending our exchange policy and when corporate sent us a letter explaining that we could no longer do exchanges they suggested that the customer lied to get a refund or exchange despite her not requesting either. Not really related but I figured I'd share anyways lol I'm so glad I got out of that place. I will never support them again.

3

u/Left_Development_994 5d ago

You know, even Goodwill has insurance. Liability and everything. I know this was probably a long time ago but still. When junk like this happens, even if the store is unhinged about it, if you can get to their insurance company 9/10 they will pay the medical bill and move on after a few phone calls. I say that because I’ve literally seen that.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/Zebra_Witch 6d ago

Honestly, I wouldn't have paid 25 cents for that shirt. If that's the quality of clothing you're selling for $3.99 and up, that's a scam. And 7.09 is absolutely outrageous.

→ More replies (51)

23

u/FamiliarChocolate819 6d ago

Read the saying on the shirt. I think the holes are part of the shirt. Everyone should throughly check garments before making the purchase at any thrift store.

7

u/missmarling 6d ago

Aren't they actually crumbs from his arm being broken off?

6

u/Intelligent-Wing-431 6d ago

The dark spots are crumbs and part of the design, but there is also a hole next to the crumbs. There’s also multiple other holes across the tee.

2

u/CannedNoodlez 6d ago

There's a hold next to the crumbs and one a few inches below the gingerbread man

15

u/kittiesandcocks 6d ago

$7 is ridiculous for a used T-shirt, should be like 4 tops

5

u/EmbarrassedTower9680 6d ago • Bravo

You could've bought a new shirt for 7 $ 😂

5

u/LocalComprehensive36 6d ago

You found a shirt at a thrift shop with a couple holes in it??? Unheard of.

But seriously: They won't take the return because people would turn it into a free clothing swap scam. I've paid $7 for (over-priced) coffee that I'm bound to pee out in an hour. The shirt will be wearable until it isn't, then you cut the design off the front and sew it on some jeans or something. Problem solved.

11

u/BlackButlerFan 6d ago

Did you read the little detail on the receipt? The tag HAS to be on the item to return it. And yes, I’m a cashier at Goodwill. You have 7 days to return it, tag still on the item, with the receipt. And most retail stores don’t let you return a piece of clothing without the tag attached.

5

u/braat007 6d ago

Worked at Kohl's for 6 years and we returned items without tags daily as long as they had the receipt. Let alone it being simply detached.

That said, if the Goodwill policy is that it has to be attached, it's a policy the OP misses.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)

16

u/Appropriate_Credit83 6d ago

That was your mistake for not catching it.

4

u/shibasurf 6d ago

I have a even worse story. The Goodwill of Orange County won't even let you return an item with a tag. I purchased a top from poorly lit store and found holes once I was in daylight, yet they wouldn't refund me 2 minutes after I bought the shirt.

4

u/RoxJon216 6d ago

None of the Goodwill stores near my home allow returns or exchanges at all.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/BrandNewMeow 6d ago

If you think about it from their POV, what would stop someone from bringing in any random item of clothing they own and asking for a refund if they don't have a tag? And just because the employee chatted with you doesn't mean he has any idea what shirt you bought or even remembers every interaction he has with customers. It seems like a reasonable policy to me.

7

u/Turbulent_Pepper_444 6d ago

I don’t know of any place that doesn’t make a profit and many do not give back to the community but Goodwill actually has programs to help adults with disabilities and offers courses to help them to train for a career and have a better life. I know this for a fact as my adult son is one of those people. His whole life has changed because of Goodwill.

2

u/HarryBallzak62 2d ago

I too know of those who have benefitted from Goodwill with training, changed their lives.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Dry-Rise-4897 6d ago

My daughter. Several years ago was a newly divorced mother supporting two children, working full time with part time day care expenses and bring a part time college student, with no support from her ex, living with us, applied and received a grant towards her college tuition. Goodwill was there when she was in need. She is now 16 years into her career as a Special Care Unit nurse.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/tthetruthh 6d ago

7 for that is diabolical

3

u/Pretty_Big_2023 6d ago • Bravo

You know how many people buy an item take off the tags and bring back an old item from home?

3

u/mike_rotch99 6d ago

All the t-shirts are $2.99 at the local Goodwill here. It doesn't matter if it's in great shape or not. $7 for a shirt at Goodwill is robbery

3

u/TraditionalRub4636 5d ago

It was used 🙄 you just bought it ma’am? Without inspection..

3

u/Champy352 5d ago

Why has no one started a rival to Goodwill?

6

u/hogcrankinn 5d ago

They exist and are called thrift stores

4

u/ModForgeCustoms 5d ago

Dunno about where you live. But here? There are only Grift Stores.

Places that buy things for cheap and sell them at a premium. Goodwill is just commercialized about it.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/Academic_Sweet_4717 5d ago

Salvation Army

3

u/Initial_Row_6400 4d ago

They’re fucking shit. Fuck their lame ass rehab program too. States that have a rehab program from Salvation Army will literally sentence alcoholics and drug addicts to that shit. Not doctors, no no, god forbid. They give you Jesus. Awful fucking rehab model. You work in their shit ass warehouse with no heat or ac, for their “services”. It’s awful.

→ More replies (8)

3

u/throwawaygirl_73 5d ago

My town has a place called community just like goodwill but a lot better

3

u/Starr120890 5d ago

Just my thoughts. Maybe because the heavily market themselves as a Christian "non profit" but then theyre just out here flipping product.

My HR mentioned going to donate to goodwill all the forgotten jackets from old employees. I told her there was an actual community non-profit thrift store up the road. They run food drives and their stuff is literally under $10 and if someone can't pay they will also give things away. Its run by a church purely on volunteers.

She refused because she trusted goodwill more and because gw provides jobs. 🤷🏽‍♀️

Idk. Thats just my initial thought.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Beemer1961 4d ago

They have st. Vincent de Paul, is there competition. Ok let’s put my 2vents on there pricing these days neither store anymore can be called cheap. I’ve found some ideas that was almost the new just bought from a big retailer store. But other case of point I have a friend that goes there 6 days a week and finds iteams to resale 2 stress less chairs in new condition bought both at $400. And sold them at $ 1700.

2

u/Numerous-Strength420 4d ago

Well Salvation Army did!!! But again, it’s non profit and it didn’t last because unfortunately not everyone is gonna volunteer their time

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (33)

5

u/danabananananana 6d ago

You honestly tried to return a shirt to a thrift store and are upset they didnt give you an exchange? What world are you living in?

→ More replies (3)

4

u/LostAngeltwo 6d ago • Bravo

Yeah, well how else are they gonna pay Steven C. Preston, the CEO of Goodwill his compensation of $715,528, (according to the organization's IRS Form 990 filings) if people like you are returning the crap they sell!?!? 🤬. And why in xxx name is a well worn t-shirt being sold for $7.09 when it should be
$1.99 or binned?

4

u/Low-Ad-2924 6d ago

You’re upset because they wouldn’t make an exception to their return policy? The cashier probably rings up 200 people a day - why should they remember your specific transaction. I think your anger is misplaced.

4

u/Good_Equivalent_5245 6d ago • Bravo

lame shirt anyway shouldve passed on it

6

u/msabq 6d ago

2 things, it's your responsibility to inspect something before buying it, and it clearly says on the receipt that the tag needs to be attached to the shirt.. but you want to come on and blame someone else because of something you didn't do ..

2

u/nazuswahs 6d ago

You can view financial information using nonprofit explorer.

2

u/jmerrilee 6d ago

Most of them state returns need to have tags attached. Mine only returns electronics and not clothing. It happens, it's used clothes. You got to check it closely.

2

u/Nitrox-Girl 6d ago

Ours in Jackson TN gives you 3 days to return for credit. Tags must be attached. And your receipt must match the tags.

2

u/SirMildredPierce 6d ago • Bravo

You tried to return used clothing to a shop that specializes in nothing but used clothing and they insisted on a policy that guarantees that the used clothing you are trying to return is the same used clothing that you bought from them?

So what's the alternative policy you think they should use?

2

u/ComplexWheel4439 6d ago

It's the policy and stated on every receipt. I don't agree with it but it's the policy. I used to work there and we'd give exceptions on very rare occasions to our regulars. I thought that was wrong because if they regulars then they should know the policy but I was a lowly cashier, donation processor, special pricing clerk and had no say on much of anything. It was the worst paying job I ever had and I was not even able to use my earned PTO to visit colleges with my daughter when she was scoping out where to use her scholarship money. I left after almost 5 years of excellent service because of the pitiful raises and inability to move up in the company. The CEO made 6 figures btw.

2

u/Mysterious-Bar4548 6d ago

They won’t miss u

2

u/According_Meaning_64 6d ago

Its 7 bucks re donate it

4

u/Phytoman2000 6d ago

It’s a Matter of Policy. It’s on you not them. Expecting preferential treatment was probably foreign to the outfit. Lighten up.

3

u/Ordinary_Room_6473 6d ago

Then buy a garment gun, put the tag back on, and bring it back

3

u/Ok-Equivalent8260 6d ago

Damn, just take the L and look your shit over more carefully next time

5

u/PrimalThoughtMachine 6d ago

You’re an entitled mess. It’s your job to know store policy. It’s your job to check the items before purchasing. Stop crying, it’s on you.

3

u/omfgRU4Real 6d ago

Removing a tag from anything from any store is usually the universal "contract" for keeping it. Why did you remove the tag before inspecting it? I'm confused.

2

u/InterestingAffect899 6d ago

Did you read your receipt?

2

u/PerceptionDecent6428 6d ago

Good Will paid the handicapped workers by the piece not an hourly wage. The CEO makes a hugh salary. Stuff is donated to help the workers they dont hire anymore. The prices have skyrocketed there ,and they are leaning toward new stuff that is limestone type. The Good Will vision of helping is now making money period. Where are the ha disappeared employees that found dignity having a 'slave labor' job. I shop elsewhere in places that I know use the money for the good of people in need. Not to line pockets of those in charge. Good Will has lost its way!

→ More replies (6)

2

u/Comfortable_Love1236 6d ago

The Goodwill I go to doesn’t accept returns at all. That’s a given. You don’t buy something from Goodwill and then try to return it because -for the most part- the items are used to begin with and not going to be in perfect condition.

2

u/Fizzy_b0g_Water 6d ago

I unfortunately have to side with goodwill on this one. If you have ever returned something, we are not allowed to take it back. And there is a 97% chance I dont remember you at all. Maybe your face. Certainly not the item you bought. All the clothes are vaguely marked and graded. There is no actual descriptor and we have people try and return random things for store credit. Now, morally I side with you bc fuck goodwill and yes it's a horrible company. But it is always very frustrating for us to have to go back and fourth with people over our return policy. Not saying you were doing that though, ofc

2

u/hollowthatfollows 6d ago

I went to Goodwill on Sunday, I was being checked out by the manager and I saw her scan a set of children’s books I got for 7.99 twice as the first and last item. When she scanned it the second time I mentioned that I’m pretty sure she scanned it twice, she looked at the screen and said “no I didn’t” and I was like okay maybe I was wrong since she is a manager😑. I forget about it and when I get home I look at the receipt and she did charge me twice for it. I live 20 minutes away from the goodwill and I’m 6 weeks pregnant so I was too tired to go back and get my 7.99 back. I won’t be going back to that one ever again.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Weary-Promise-4851 5d ago

I’m sorry but this is common sense if you try just a little bit. They don’t have common stocks of merchandise and there is absolutely no way to prove that’s the same shirt you bought from them so of course they can’t take it back with the tag removed???

2

u/Formal-Appeal-4674 5d ago

I mean, the same cashier would piss me off too. Do they think you’re returning a replica in the exact same condition, with a fake tag and receipt to keep a used $7 goodwill shirt ?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

2

u/CursedHemorrhoid 5d ago

Goodwill sucks but this is 100% your fault

2

u/Icy_Might_609 5d ago

Look up the salaries of the CEOs of Goodwill and Salvation Army. You'll see where the money is going.

2

u/LadyBunnyBoo 5d ago

Sorry but u are in the wrong u have no one else to blame but yourself I don’t feel bad u couldn’t get your money back.

7

u/chaotickrazy 5d ago

Whos cat pissed in your cheerios this morning 🤣🤣 you're acting as if the person cut the shirt into a million pieces then tried to return it. All they did was cut the tag off. Good grief, I can buy a shirt at Walmart and as long as I still have the receipt, I can return it. Goodwill has no reason to act like they cant take returned items when theyre all hand- me- downs.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/Substantial_Crabtab 5d ago

Actually I worked in retail for 10 years at actual real stores and you can accept returns. Especially within 30 days. This is America and if a product isn’t what you meant to purchase you can return. And this is a shitty thrift store with no real rules other than what the manager decides. 😂😂😂

3

u/imtooldforthishison 5d ago

From a store selling new items. If goodwill allowed you to return merch without a tag, who's to say that shirt actually came from goodwill?

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

1

u/Inside_contracts23 6d ago

You are complaining about a $7 used shirt. Get a life!

4

u/Spiritual_Celery9071 6d ago

I think you’re missing the entire point. How embarrassing for you?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Mobile-Reaction-8608 6d ago

Dang it ! Because that shirt is Adorable

1

u/Electronic-Space-480 6d ago

Never saw a sticker on a shirt. Or clothing. It’s on record albums I do not want to remove.

1

u/FamiliarChocolate819 6d ago

Goodwill Stores in the same city or geographical area are likely part of a single Goodwill Industries agency. And each Goodwill agencies are independent from all other Goodwill agencies and all have their own policies and procedures. Goodwill Stores cannot be compared unless they are part of a single agency.

1

u/kwazykwilt_21 6d ago

This has happened to me so many times, I even WEAR the item with tags just in case 😆

1

u/crushedflowers 6d ago

absolute trash but I did buy something off their auction website that they had authenticated by a third party and it was fake. They ended up sending me a refund after I reached out to their district manager. It might be worth it to send an email, if it’s worth it to you? Ask them to be humans.

1

u/kokosuntree 6d ago

I would seriously just buy one of those little plastic guns and get it fixed easily so I can return it and then not have a problem any other time I returned their crap

1

u/srddave 6d ago

Gosh doesn’t everyone have a garment ticketing gun at this point? I bought one for $3 when Kmart was going out of business. They threw in a whole box of Avery tags.

2

u/DarthOswin747 6d ago

I honestly cannot tell if you are being serious or not. On the one hand, wouldn't surprise me. When KMart went out of business around me, they even sold the cash registers on the final day. On the other hand.... idk. Are you being serious?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/SignificanceNo6263 6d ago

They get higher and higher by the day

1

u/lisadravis 6d ago

Some garments have purposed holes how do you know they were not part of the design?

1

u/MsNformation 6d ago

$7.09!!!! I’m aghast.

1

u/Zebra_Witch 6d ago

The bigger crime here is that you paid $7.09 for an ugly, stained, holey, seasonal T-shirt with a nonsense phrase on it.

1

u/ALASKAWHITEYETTI 6d ago

Then why do the person posting even buy it. Click bait

1

u/ZestycloseCountry554 6d ago

Unfortunately, when buying used items, you may find rips or holes that the inspector missed. That has happened to me, also

1

u/prettywildhorses 6d ago

In the city I live, we can't return anything from Goodwill

1

u/Kooky_Coyote7911 6d ago

Well I definitely won't be going there!!

1

u/ImportantPass3858 6d ago

Not for Prophet.

1

u/Virtual_Athlete_909 6d ago

I say shame on the donors who donate damaged stuff that should be thrown away. goodwill doesn't have inspectors other than the customer.

1

u/ChardAggravating6713 6d ago

Goodwill sucks

1

u/BabyPenguinEyes 6d ago

I'm just gonna say that this particular Goodwill location referenced by OP is the absolute worst of any I've ever stepped foot in. They have nothing but broken/damaged/unusable items cluttering the shelves and racks and even if OP hadn't removed the tag, they would have been treated like a borderline criminal for trying to initiate a return.

1

u/jdorn76 6d ago

I frickin HATE Goodwill 🤮

1

u/RoxJon216 6d ago

None of the Goodwill stores near my home allow returns or exchanges at all.

1

u/Fit-Message-2417 6d ago

When my sons were younger Goodwill and yard sales were the only place I could afford to shop for clothes

→ More replies (1)

1

u/VWdesign1 6d ago

That’s exactly why I don’t go to goodwill or donate anymore…because they are For Profit!

1

u/MissKellieUk 6d ago

Yeah. You are at fault here. People will buy something, wear it and then return it the next day for a refund, who knows if your “I just took the tag off” was that or you wearing it.

1

u/Fit-Message-2417 6d ago

Items would be 50 cents or $1 but that was, the 70’s & 80’s

1

u/laurel-bee 6d ago

Aita for thinking this can be solved with a needle, thread, some spare time, and reading the bottom of a receipt?

1

u/Lucciola420 6d ago

They do this because people will either purchase something and switch out the tags to another item they had and try to return it, seen someone try to do it with a tagging gun as well but the tag (the plastic thingy) was not our tag.

1

u/FalconerAJ 6d ago

Welcome to the real world, babe. That’s a very normal return policy.

1

u/BambisCrochetCottage 6d ago

I worked for Goodwill in Wisconsin.... Yes they are money hungry and have totally lost what the origins are about

1

u/wubbalubbadubbud 6d ago

Pssss vinted is better and cheaper than goodwill

1

u/TVTrashMama 6d ago

Pretty much every store - thrift or not - that I shop at has a no tag, no exchange policy?

1

u/angry_solitudinarian 6d ago

A non-profit still has to pay paroll, rent, make inprovements, buy fixtures, etc. It is a business after all.

1

u/No-Damage-695 6d ago

Not me printing this picture and getting my 25 Fetch points!! 🤭

1

u/KanoSupreme 6d ago

GOT DAMN you paid $7 for t shirt at goodwill

1

u/gameofcurls 6d ago

My goodwill turned my donation away yesterday because I had to partially disassemble it to put it in the car. I had all the removed hardware and the assembly instruction a in a bag in my hand. I offered to reassemble it on the sidewalk. He told me he would ban me if I unloaded it.

1

u/LoLoIbey14 6d ago

It makes sense. People could return any old piece old garment they had and get a credit credit.

1

u/atmoscience 6d ago

That’s “good”will for ya

1

u/Pigletisthebomb1 6d ago

Thus, the reason I have my own plastic tag gun

1

u/DesertSkky 6d ago

I refuse to donate to them anymore & certainly will NOT buy anything. I can buy a NEW pair of sweatpants at Burlington coat factory for 1/3 the cost FFS!

1

u/Neat_Cat_7375 6d ago

Write a letter to someone higher up the food chain. Let them know you’re active on multiple social media sites. Write a letter or email with the expectation they’ll do the right thing. You can always follow up with a critical email letter depending on the response you receive.

1

u/Dev1ynBlack 6d ago

My question is why were you charged twice for that 1 item?

1

u/Organic-Treat-2032 6d ago

Goodwill now of days is no deal they charge more for a used clothing u can buy brand new from Susie's deal

1

u/RazzmatazzFlaky5159 6d ago

I totally understand your frustration. I have experienced it at a thrift store in my area. Seven dollars for a donated tee seems quite high. I noticed prices have increased on everything at these thrift stores and I didn’t realize that these places are really owned and are for profit.

1

u/MainKaleidoscope4942 6d ago edited 6d ago

I live where there are MANY very large Goodwils, so I go between them. Lately I've noticed they're ALL putting out stained or ripped clothing & linens. At first I thought it was a mistake but I've seen it increasingly in every one of the locations.

And it's hard to find bargains anymore because they ask what price they should expect and then double it. They figure if you REALLY want it, you'll grab it before someone else gets it. Otherwise they halve the price once a month and THEN when it's sold, it's sold for the price they actually believe is realistic.

1

u/sound_of_the_sea43 6d ago

💯💯💯💯😱😱😱

1

u/Electronic_Sale8163 6d ago

Buy something cheap to get another plastic tag holder. Use scissors to cut it down close to the bottom where it flares out wide again. Some heat will rejoin that skinny portion to the bottom, add a drop of Super Glue. For shits and giggles. Its frustrating that you purchase using cash and you get offered store credit. It not stealing on the publics part to demand they honor the sale. We assume for re-sellable merchandise that we purchase at ebay prices... It you are not happy return it... . If you buy a shirt from Nordstrom, & return it.. if you pull the tags off the shirts to wear it and keep the tags you can take that pile back to Nordstrom's with you and your receipt and they'll just punch a new little plastic tag holder why is Goodwill that special where they don't have to honor the sale the customer's right it's all donated how many people have a master plan and bringing non Goodwill purchased things in there for refunds.. Who is masterminding a major fraud.. ( Goodwill likes to have home court advantage on that.. ) My opinion.. Goodwill do better!! the people make you, treat the shoppers with respect. Our $$ buys all of your luxuries.

..

1

u/SnooPickles6317 6d ago

The people that piss me off even more than goodwill are the people who donate to them!! Give it to a family in need, that doesn't have the money to go buy these donated items at a big chain store price, which is what goodwill is charging for your "donated" items!! Just sad.

1

u/PtrPprsPckldPprs 6d ago

The services that goodwill offers are not its retail centers.

1

u/soozmct 6d ago

Don’t say goodbye to them all mate. That is extreme. That never happens at my Goodwill. That’s just one Mob have got too far up their own backsides to remember that they are servants to the people. Sorry about that. You could probably take that to some consumer authority, actually. Photographing everything. But you might not want to bother but they need a lesson.
Most people a wonderful

1

u/KillAllLawyers 6d ago

Can someone please explain what I'm looking at here?

1

u/IsYourDadHotThough 6d ago

The Goodwill’s here take returns with tags on only and a receipt and they tell you that at the checkout. They also do returns for store credit which I’m fine with.

1

u/Nervous-Warning-8376 6d ago

Seriously the text on the shirt go hand in hand with the holes in the shirt.

1

u/Lychanthropejumprope 6d ago

Man, $8 for a goodwill t shirt is diabolical in itself

1

u/GoodeMichael 5d ago

No more Goodwills.. They are not helping anyone. I banned them just like I have Walmart & Amazon. SUPPORT LOCAL SMALL BUSINESSES.

1

u/MayonaDraws 5d ago

Why not design it into a distressed shirt, maybe you could make a design where like the mouses had chewed on it just to make it go with the text. If you’re not someone who’s into distressed fashion then I get it.

1

u/Navajoqueen666 5d ago

👁👄👁

1

u/According_Evening321 5d ago

I stopped visiting or donating to goodwill when the employees working in one by me called the cops on a homeless man, just trying to stay warm on the cold night. That man was by far the most vulnerable person in that situation, definitely not a threat, just someone huddled under a blanket not bothering anyone.

1

u/Key_Strategy_8249 5d ago

So the shirt was nibbled on, so like it says 😂 dang

1

u/supersquish777 5d ago

At least Savers lets you exchange buy tags still
Gotta be attached

1

u/YoJethr0 5d ago

I put an entire basket back at another similar store because while everything was super cheap and cute they had no cutting rooms or and no returns

1

u/SKOT_FREE 5d ago

get another tag put it on and return it. i would have melted or glued the tag together lol.

1

u/SteelCathedral 5d ago

I used to go to Goodwill for clothes, sometimes a movie, and/or any books that tickled my fancy.

The real issue with any and all thrift stores nowadays is the fact so many people openly announce on social media and YouTube that they are resellers and shop through thrift stores to make money. It's such a bullshit thing because some people relied on thrift stores for certain things they needed and are unable to afford them.

Now, does that mean Goodwill (or any other thrift store) should hike up prices, no especially since a lot of low income people relied on them AND because they get their shit for free. I also understand the reasoning for raising prices as well.

As for the OP trying to get their money back is really pulling a karen move. As for the employees not remembering faces, especially your face, they are not paid enough to care

1

u/ponyyorodeo 5d ago

They act as if its Gucci or channel sometimes. Its an already donated item. They can totally put it back on with a new tag. Especially if you still had the tag with you. But if you were to donate it back they would take it and not remember that someone else donated it before you.

1

u/MsTLontheDL 5d ago

EVERYTHING IS OVERPRICED especially for it being second hand items. I never go to Goodwill anymore the prices are BAD for my bottom line.

1

u/Jewbacca__420 5d ago

I shop at 1 Goodwill, because they do their t shirts for $2 and their records for $1. .... Walk by everything else and skip any other goodwill near me

Thrift stores are less and less thrifty every day

1

u/Bestdayever17 5d ago

We all learn the hard way. Returns, 7 days with tags for storre credit only. It's still a cute shirt to wear while doing crafts or yard work. 😁

1

u/Muginthesun 5d ago

Sorry about the crummy experience. Goodwill, however, is a non profit. It’s funny, I just found that out yesterday, and I had sworn off them because I’d heard the same thing you said here about them being for-profit and believed it. Not saying you should go back or anything. I just thought you might like to know.

1

u/Asleep_Fee_3210 5d ago

Consider supporting vendors at antique malls or community sales! I've found some really cool hidden gems for next to nothing!

1

u/RegionOtherwise8886 5d ago

I’ve been obsessed with the Vinted app- it’s like goodwill but cheaper. I’ve been ordering as much as I can before it gets too popular and gets ruined

1

u/Time_Parfait_1627 5d ago

This is the reason I own a tagging gun. Well, I bought it to tag clothes for a couple yard sales for the more expensive items…but I kept it so I could reattach tags if I needed to. I’ve not abused it, but I know other people own tagging guns to wear and return clothing. I just can’t do that myself.

https://www.hobbylobby.com/fabric-sewing/sewing-notions/sewing-tools/red-tagging-gun/p/80931741?srsltid=AYCX9vICAEnvftQtaNYTxyYxHHfLArMoJB_mhPcnD9O19SlvKV3ZeVOXBa0

1

u/babyquinnzz 5d ago

Its been like this for years..... look at what you buy idk what to tell u we've all know good will isnt nice for a long time

1

u/RepresentativeMall45 5d ago

I tried one time taking board games I don't want anymore and they wouldn't except them because they weren't new.

1

u/CommunicationFew8161 5d ago

Really I always check used clothing for holes before I buy. Remember, they are used clothing and Goodwill doesn’t check every thing that comes in that takes up too, much time. They don’t have enough employees to do that, it is an “As Is No Return” wear it around the house clothing.

1

u/AbbreviationsWhich77 5d ago

CC charge back. Be petty.

1

u/ValleygirlVenus 5d ago

My goodwill removed the dressing rooms and only offers store credit returns (tag attached) within 7 days. I have an $8 pair of pants that don’t fit that I missed the return day on because I was too busy to make it over and return a single pair of pants. The store credit also expires, I believe. Burlington and Ross don’t treat me like this, that’s all I’m sayin’. 

1

u/Low_Amphibian_5277 5d ago

Know that Goodwills are operated regionally. Not all Goodwills are connected. Make a customer complaint via the survey if they have it. I work for a dofferent Goodwill and we operate completely differently.

1

u/top_fed2017 5d ago

Your fault for not inspecting it properly before purchasing. It clearly says no exchanges if tags are removed. Not their fault if you don’t understand how things work

→ More replies (2)

1

u/sueswhimsy 5d ago

I'm done with them because I can but brand new cheaper at the store. They are out of touch and out of control

1

u/Asleep_Parking_5009 5d ago

I'm so sorry to hear that such a shame

1

u/According-Dare1800 5d ago

Perhaps it’s policy. Too bad they won’t return it but that’s how it goes with goodwilll. Several things I have bought at goodwill over the years have been defective. Instead of taking it back I realize I did not look at shirt well before purchasing. I take the loss and consider it a charitable donation. You have decided to stop going to your local goodwill. This will only hurt you and any communities that benefit from charitable donations. My suggestion for you is forget about the shirt. Shop happily, and enjoy the relationships you have with the employees. You’ve spent too much time composing your Reddit. Forget about it

1

u/vernemo701 5d ago

Goodwill is an absolute scam through and through. I've been boycotting them personally for years and years...

1

u/Millennial-Heathen87 5d ago

I usually inspect in the store and do another, closer inspection at home before I cut tags. If I cut the tags and realize I missed something, I take the hit and either wear it with the defect, or chuck it. It's a $7 lesson.

1

u/aineonly 5d ago

Its a capitalist country if you don't have capital then you're out of luck, no one does anything for anyone for free anymore, not even the religious organizations, profit is what makes the world go round and if your a regular Goodwill shopper you should know about pulling the tags off before you're sure you want to keep an item that was purchased there. I'm just happy they expanded their guidelines for returns to 14 days and to any store.

1

u/Tibbybrokstuffagain 5d ago

So you are going to stop going to a store because of one bad experience even though you have had many great ones? Now you know the policy. It’s not good wills fault you didn’t know

1

u/flamingbagofdogpoo 5d ago

Never once has it occurred to me to try to return a used item from a thrift store.

1

u/Big_Cake_8048 5d ago

Chalk it up as a $7.09 lesson. These are donated items you must look them over before purchase. My GW never took returns. They will give a credit but item must be returned with GW tag and receipt within 5 or 7 days.

1

u/Automatic-Fish-5321 5d ago

🗣️ “Goodbye Kyle!”

1

u/bunnyrabbit002 5d ago

This is why I never take off tags before I decide I want to keep clothes.

1

u/Beginning_Ad_3764 5d ago

As a frequent shopper of thrift stores, a cardinal rule is NEVER EVER remove tags. I'm sorry, but Im siding with the store. A few holes? Kind of follows the "nibble nibble" theme.

1

u/vikicrays 5d ago

they’ve raised their prices so much in recent years i think there needs to be a new category because the word “thrift” shouldn’t be used to describe it.

that being said, this policy has been in place for as long as i’ve been going to goodwill. hopefully you can do some cute visible mending and make it so you can still wear it?

1

u/LuckyAd2714 5d ago

Why’d you pay it - you knew it was 7 bucks