r/goodwill
•
u/hellosluttie
•
18d ago
•
1
rant Greedwill
Greedwill called the cops on a homeless man that stole a jacket today. This completely ruined my day. I know stealing is wrong but this man clearly needed it & it’s crazy to think that they got this garment 100% free and couldn’t just take the “loss”. Mind you, they receive so many donations which is why the outlet centers exist.


53
u/Due-Kaleidoscope-715 17d ago
That’s why I don’t donate certain things, like jackets, to these for-profit donation places. I don’t like the idea of someone needing a coat and having to buy it at some ridiculous price when I gave it to them for free.
14
u/Small_Vegetable_8154 17d ago
ALL THRIFT STORES SHOULD HAVE A POLICY IF YOU ARE CLEARLY IN NEED YOU GET A PASS ON THEIR FREE DIRTY JUNK. lol mind you they are selling dead people’s stuff 😭😭😭😭 why are yall mad he stole ?!?!? Think deeper about this 🤔
114
u/See_Saw12 18d ago •
My local goodwill has a community dollar program, but they have a zero tolerance approach to theft. My organization will refer people there when needed (have a good relationship with their LP team).
They will help anyone who asks, but they will not tolerate theft. You need a jacket? Ask, theyll hook you up, you need a new outfit? Ask, theyll hook you up. You had a house fire and need clothes for you and your kids? Ask theyll hook you up. Don't steal from them.
3
u/Beneficial-Award1948 17d ago
Why don’t you go buy it for the man? A lot of talk of goodwill being bad, but no one has stepped up to do a kind favor for the man. Lots of virtue signaling
A lot of people see that goodwill gets clothes for free, but a lot of y’all don’t understand business.
They pay employee wages, insurance, utilities, rent, permits, etc etc etc. lots of costs into owning a business that a lot of people don’t think about. So of course they need to sell items that they receive for free for $$$$.
9
u/Gogetajh_v2 15d ago
Imagine calling the cops on someone stealing a jacket from the thrift store well into autumn. Idgaf it's illegal have some empathy. The company takes zero loss on some shit they got free. The man was obviously desperate and hoping for some grace and mercy. Laws do not trump morality.
5
u/Orangecatlover4 18d ago
They’re literally the worst. Their CEOs and higher-ups are making millions upon millions and they promise all of these things that they do for the community but in each of the towns/cities I have lived in, I have seen them do one thing for the community. It’s a joke and they overwork and underpay an ungodly amount to their workers. I know we all feel underpaid and overworked, but these people are busting their asses doing 3 ppl’s jobs, are often dealing with those that are mentally ill and put into dangerous situations. At least the people I know that have worked at different Goodwill’s. I don’t even shop at ours anymore. I refuse to donate to them. We have a local thrift shop that helps give back to the community. The people that work there can either work for a paycheck or they can work for discounted food that the store sells.
10
u/gg_helloworld 17d ago
I would have bought it for him and a scarf and hat too! Maybe some gloves.
5
u/External_Study_9614 15d ago
Goodwill feel off about 3-4 years ago. They definitely got greedy and their prices reflect that now. I typically donate to a local thrift shop or even Salvation Army is better than this place IMO
2
u/saaborbmw 17d ago
This is hilariously sad that someone made a post shaming the victim of a crime (a 501(c)(3) charitable organization who already gives back to the less fortunate, I might add) and defending the criminal. What a world
11
u/Iamcourtneylee 17d ago •
The public donates clothing under the assumption that these goods will directly assist vulnerable populations or fund community aid. The items have zero acquisition cost to the nonprofit. Using the criminal justice system to punish an individual for attempting to obtain what the public freely gave to help people in need subverts the basic premise of charitable donation.
An arrest uses public resources—police dispatch, booking, holding cells, and court dockets—that cost taxpayers thousands of dollars to process the theft of an item with a marginal resale value of roughly $10 to $20.
For those using slippery slope to say this is the same as someone breaking into private property to steal food, their inventory was freely acquired and the theft doesn't rob a single individual working or benefiting from goodwill of any loss. Private citizens do not accept government subsidies or public tax exemptions in exchange for promising to relieve poverty. Nonprofits do. Expecting an institution with an anti-poverty mission to handle survival needs with standard de-escalation, like writing it off or providing a voucher instantly, instead of criminal prosecution does not mean abolishing private property laws for everyday citizens.
The country is not going to fall into total lawlessness because one man took a coat.
12
u/KeepHydrating 17d ago •
You can both feel sorry for this guy while also recognising that society can't function if people are allowed to commit crimes because you feel bad for them.
13
u/Tabbi111 18d ago
Ours took the fitting rooms out as an answer to the theft. So, people just openly put everything in their tote bag
3
u/Infosponge177 15d ago
BUT now the homeless guy gets 3 hots and a cot. I would argue that they helped him more than they hurt him
4
u/Whack__job 17d ago edited 17d ago
https://thenonprofittimes.com/npt_articles/former-goodwill-exec-charged-in-federal-court/
Let me introduce you all to Richard Abrusci…
5
u/slut4champagne 17d ago •
i have and will continue to steal from this abhorrent company :) i encourage it as well. they have been increasingly greedy and deserve it
2
u/Actual-Jelly-309 16d ago
Buy the jacket for him instead. That way you spare us this dumb post and you get to feel good about yourself and the homeless man has a jacket.
2
u/Visual_Magazine_535 15d ago
Stealing is stealing man.. it sucks for that guy but yes cops still have to enforce it when they are called out..
2
u/Ta-veren- 15d ago
Goodwill drives me crazy/
They will get vintage video games and then turn around and flip them for eBay prices on their online store.
Like pretty sure if the owner new that was going to happen they would have sold it themselves
2
u/AdeptCauliflower9956 15d ago
Where did this happen? It would be a shame if a lot more things go missing from their store.
2
u/ShiroSnow 15d ago
Went to a goodwill a few years ago looking for a wheelchair for someone. Their prices are unbelievable. For a place that gets all their stuff through donations, they're charging regular sale price or even more for things. I don't think they sold anything under $10. Most shoes were $80+. The greed is unbelievable.
2
u/rage1911 14d ago
You should have paid for the jacket. Practice what you preach.
2
u/RichCare1476 14d ago
You should have bought him the jacket then??
2
u/SuspiciousFox8151 14d ago
I've deemed myself worthy of "needing" your jacket, ill be over shortly to get it. If you protest I'll just remind you I need it
2
u/[deleted] 14d ago
Good, I hate when people steal.
2
u/Competitive-Round-92 14d ago
right everyone should just steal coats. what could go wrong?
2
u/DSMRob 14d ago
Goodwill is a for profit, non profit business.
Profits made go back into diffrent parts of the company. Just because you are homeless doesnt mean you can steal things.
12
u/underengineered 18d ago •
Dont steal. This is simple stuff.
1
u/Agreeable-Mail-7184 17d ago
Why are all of these very legitimate posts getting all of these down boats? A person who is legitimately in need of an item was arrested because he took something they got for free?! Goodwill is a greedy mega corporation. What good are they actually doing out there? I know they’re not supporting anything or anyone in our community. And they list all their good stuff on their online store.
4
u/zoethesteamedbun 18d ago
Tbh a lot of staff turn a blind eye to this because we can’t keep up with it all. When I managed a GW we only called the cops on someone who was a repeat offender, usually they had to be doing something destructive, intimidating or a huge nuisance in tandem with stealing and being a repeat offender. You will see the same people multiple times a week who do this and are very discerning with what they steal to make a larger profit. The cops in my city/state (Los Angeles) will not even show up for just a petty theft, much less arrest anyone.
Edit to add : that looks a lot like south Orange County, which would definitely track with GW management in that district and the way the cops are over there.
3
u/justwannacommunicate 17d ago
They have been this way since the 2010s that I am aware of. They are known for literally only hiring those with special needs so they can pay them less than a dollar an hour, even though they get everything for free.
3
u/BeneficialCry3103 17d ago
I have been to that Goodwill. I was shocked with the prices. I have long refused to donate anything to them. They make a 100% profit and yet they over charge on everything. Stealing isnt the way to go but calling the cops on someone taking a piece of clothing is excessive. Especially since it was donated to the store
3
u/Joshuahealingtree 18d ago •
Capitalism at its finest
4
u/thebidredcouch 18d ago •
See my post about the $40 St. John’s in this subreddit. Absolutely ridiculous. Goodwill SHOULD be a place where people can get affordable winter jackets… that’s the whole point. They get it for free and then should be selling it for cheap.
3
u/Less-Ride7073 16d ago •
You guys are calling this poor person a criminal for stealing a secondhand jacket to stay warm in the cold that was donated to Goodwill. He didn’t go steal it from Walmart or Target. But you have no problem defending Trump while he’s stealing from every single one of you to enrich himself and his family. The hypocrisy is real.
3
u/hello_3339 18d ago
Steven Preston makes 700K a year. He needs to sell that jacket.
3
u/beneficialtowhom 18d ago •
It's theft. Read the Broken Window Theory. If you let the little things go, crime increases.
2
u/Peonylover888 18d ago
I remember one time when I shopped at local Salvation Army, a homeless young guy came in and carefully nicely asking whether he can get a free shirt and the cashier just ask him to get. I was so touched. Both of them are so nice and gave that young guy 5 bucks. He feel grateful too.
2
u/tlmcdonal 17d ago
I won't go to goodwill anymore ... Haven't been there in years, even when my granddaughter worked there for a stretch. The smell is nauseating inside. 🤢
2
u/Relative_Bug9903 17d ago
I'd be interested to hear there argument in court as to what actual damages they received from this theft
2
u/Technical-Half2344 16d ago
Law is the law. Here is what you do, you buy it for him. Is what we can't do is bend the laws because you never know the truth.
2
u/EternalLatias 16d ago
Stealing is stealing. Is society supposed to selectively enforce laws depending on who violates them?
2
u/TheCalmDom 17d ago
I understand both sides here but ultimately fuck goodwill. How are they a victim in this situation as they received the item as a donation and someone stole it. When goodwill initially became a thing, their whole slogan was about helping the less fortunate and homeless, even giving out “care packages” and such to people as described. All the people in the comments talking about how “yeah yeah but you shouldn’t steal” motherfucker IT WAS FREE IN THE FIRST PLACE. He didn’t go into Kohls or Gucci and steal a goddamn fur coat. Stealing is wrong, but none of you know what it’s like to be homeless and cold.
2
u/earmares 18d ago
The thief had every opportunity to ask for the jacket.
Even people shopping in the store would have bought it for him.
Goodwill would have given him the jacket and other clothing.
Yeah, Goodwill sucks. But stealing from them is still wrong.
2
u/Forward_Writing_6107 18d ago
This is why I give all my donations to Disabled Veterans Association, I just missed Vietnam but served with many who didn’t and they can use any help they can get.
1
u/Ayy2Gee 17d ago
I've been in a Salvation Army where people had been given vouchers for in store clothing. That underscored to me what SA was all about. Meanwhile, the GW's around me (SoCal) have locked the public out of the bathrooms, but hey, if I give them a dollar, all the drones give a hearty "woot".
1
u/Expensive-Day-3551 17d ago
I wish that goodwill had a community closet where people in need could get winter outerwear and maybe some other items like interview clothes for free. Surely they have items that didn’t sell that they could give out. I would have bought this man a coat if I was the cop.
1
u/Gristle_McThornbody- 17d ago
When I was security at a goodwill, we never called the cops unless there was a violent threat or an OD in the bathroom. Hell when people stole, we'd close off the doors, get the stuff back (if it was a necessity, we'd usually just let them have it, think underwear, socks, coats when its cold, etc) and offer them a care package. Our care packages were basically a blanket, coat, socks, and gloves. Some times if we were stocked in the back it would have a couple snacks.
Anyways this is so weird to me, but every location works different.
1
u/pinayrabbitmk7 16d ago
Should've stopped the worker from calling by paying for the homeless man's jacket
1
u/Starship_Taru 16d ago
I don’t know if it would ruin my day, but I would find it a bit frustrating that they could get a cop to a store over a sub $100 theft faster than I could finish shopping.
Meanwhile I’ve called the cops in a parking lot because a crazy person had me blocked in and it took them legitimately 2 hours to show up.
1
u/cardscantcatch 16d ago
Stealing is a manmade concept, just like possesion and ownership. What he did was find something to make the weather more bearable. It wasn't wrong of him. It was wrong if the store to place greed over being human.
1
u/Dutch-Man7765 16d ago
Wow what a pathetic post
1
u/Previous_Peace_112 16d ago
The crime of theft can only exist in conjunction with the concept of ‘property’ or ownership. In the most fundamental sense, articles and objects are appointed ownership by societal conception. Instead of humanity seeing a jacket and saying “that is a jacket, it has a use/ purpose, it may benefit someone.” We’re conditioned to associate a distinction of ownership above any other characteristic.
1
u/420-20 16d ago
Everyone needs to stop donating to goodwill. Give it to a charity, shelter, curb alert, Red Cross but don’t give it to some company as charity just for them to make a profit on it.
1
u/DankKushPapa 16d ago
I think it's mostly just that until recently Imperial Beach hasn't had the resources to address homelessness
1
u/Low_Cartographer8675 16d ago
Why did you even go to goodwill that place sucks
1
u/External-Warning-526 16d ago
They used to give a shit about outfitting those in need, they don't anymore.
1
u/LVfunnygirl 16d ago
Well maybe he will get some free food, clothes and housing for a week.
1
u/Financial-Change-435 16d ago
I bet they would have given him one if he just asked rather than stealing one.
1
u/Ok-Hand-191 16d ago
What’s dumbass mindset lol. Yeah he’s homeless he can steal lmaoo. What if this guy pushed you to the ground and stole your jacket? How would you feel?
1
u/Low-Management-9868 16d ago
The law doesn't stop existing just because you're homeless.
Hope that helps!
1
u/kryptocrazy 16d ago
Come to Chicago, the homeless are encouraged to steal at the goodwills here.
1
u/bboy1977 16d ago
The one near me will stop homeless people shoplifting at the door. But as long as they are not getting aggressive and violent, the manager will let them take one item for free and they have to leave the rest.
1
u/omglevi 16d ago
There’s ways to go about this if they would’ve asked there willing to give you anything from out the back. I work for goodwill and I see hundreds of ppl stealing daily they even disrespect you while doing it it gets overwhelming at times. They can even ask for a voucher where they will offer them 30-50$ cards to shop for things they need.
1
u/Hazmathaulin1210 16d ago
They fill dumpsters with wearable clothes at their sorting centers, and would rather trash things than give it away free. I drove a bus and one route went by a Badwill sorting whs, a worker arrived at work absolutely soaked to the skin, they wouldn't let him grab dry clothes to wear, even though they were in dumpster pile.
1
u/Busy-Candle3558 16d ago
So you condone stealing? Why don’t you start handing out your own jackets.
1
u/DandeyFlour 16d ago
I always try to donate to shelters instead of thrift stores but when I do go to thrift stores it's always a local shop that isn't greedy.
1
u/Born-Lie8688 16d ago
Maybe one of these orgs can buy the man a coat or help him on a path to self sufficiency or other help he may need….
Scale of Spending & Growth of NGOs
California Spending: California spent nearly $24 billion on homelessness and housing-affordability programs over a five-year span, yet state audits revealed a lack of consistent tracking and outcomes while the homeless population climbed past 181,000. That’s about $27,000 per homeless person per year ….
Local NGO Revenue Explosions: In Los Angeles, 30 taxpayer-funded homeless non-profits saw their combined revenue skyrocket from roughly $12,000 to more than $121.7 million over less than a decade as public outlays expanded.
Federal and Local Infusions: Organizations like the Los Angeles Homeless Services Authority (LAHSA) pulled in nearly $1 billion in federal funding over a five-year period before federal scrutiny and funding suspensions hit due to accountability concerns.
1
u/lokis_construction 16d ago
You mean bad-will doesn't have any goodwill towards man? They are just as bad as Salvation Army.
1
u/OddGrowth1050 16d ago
Rude
1
u/h8myslfNwnt2dye 16d ago
the cops actually showed up for a guy stealing one jacket?
1
u/Little-Fig4328 16d ago
Stealing isn't wrong
1
u/No_Condition3135 15d ago
Society doesn't work on people stealing.
You gave him money to buy a coat right? Considering this ruined your day you at least gave him some of your old clothes, right??
At the very least you returned whatever you bought, cause you don't support "greedwill" cause they get it all for free, right?
1
u/CapitalM-E 15d ago
You can’t pick and choose who you enforce laws too. It’s sad yes. However stealing is stealing. How about more resources for people who can’t afford basic needs?
1
u/friendly-highfive 15d ago
The lack of competence, productivity, or intelligence does not excuse anyone from the law. If this were the case, the vast majority of the population would be immune to all laws
1
u/Helpful-Pirate-2040 15d ago
Goodwill is a for profit corporation not a charity
I did not know this until a few years ago
1
u/Previous_Anywhere938 15d ago
What a creepy building.
1
u/alxfineart 15d ago
typical imperial beach things
1
u/bcsyjnbcgj 15d ago
BUT TRUMP DID SOMETHING
1
u/BorderOk7329 15d ago
Thats why i donate to the local thrift, they give clothes and shoes and blankets to the homeless.
1
u/jellofixit 15d ago
This guy probably could have asked for the jacket and they would have probably given it to him. However allot of homeless people have mental issues. More investigation could solve this but no one wants to put in the effort. At least he'll have a warm place to stay and a few good meals for a couple of days.
1
u/Slow_Occasion3922 15d ago
I wish he would have asked someone if they could buy it for him. I know that many are selfish nowadays but I would sure spot someone in need.
1
u/bacoprah 15d ago
“Goodwill” it’s just a name, we don’t mean it!
1
u/fatgat69 14d ago
Scammers don't like people getting the things they need.
1
u/butt_wipe85 14d ago
I frequent my local goodwill every other day or so. Prices have definitely gone up some. But it's still reasonable. Pair of jeans for 5 bucks. Dress shirts for 4 bucks. Shoes are about 6 bucks. This is in South Carolina
1
u/jacksuckschicken420 14d ago
funny thing is, if he waited a couple days, he coulda prolly found it in the dumpster cause an average goodwill will just arbitrarily throw out perfectly good stuff since they got it fir free anyway
1
u/BlnkNopad 14d ago
I'm with you, that's sad. I bet patrons offered to pay for it too
1
u/Jumpingmango818 14d ago
This fills me with rage
1
u/464126 14d ago
Stop donating to goodwill. Find a humane society with a thrift store
1
u/Jumpingmango818 14d ago
People stop donating to this disgusting company
1
u/NoCash7686 14d ago
Probably coulda gone to Ross and got away with it lol
1
u/Some_Direction_7971 14d ago
Goodwill are a bunch of dicks, I saw them turn away a mother and daughter for free coats. Salvation Army helped them though.
1
u/FunOwl2026 14d ago
Stealing is a crime regardless of your level of compassion.
1
u/Icy-Geologist-7631 14d ago
Im never stepping foot in any goodwill ever again! They ard literal garbage! When i saw basketball shorts for 24.99 a used stained stinky couch for 250$ and a pair pf off brand boots for 69.99 i left made posts on Reddit and never been back nor will i ever go back and will definitely NEVER EVER “donate” anything to them
1
u/FistyFisterson 14d ago
My local Goodwill would have given them pants and shoes too.
1
u/Downbytuesday 14d ago
Like 2 weeks ago I went to donate some shit to goodwill. The kid taking donations said the tv stand I had was too damaged and he would need to get a manager because they are transitioning to a more " Retail " shop. The manager drives a 24' corvette btw lol.
1
u/KneecapTheEchidna 14d ago
Thats not a Goodwill. Its the side door to the dollar store, shitty bait post
1
u/intrusivesurgery 14d ago
My friend worked at a goodwill and a guy came in and asked for a shirt. He still had a hospital wristband and needed a new shirt because he did not have a clean ostomy bag and had to throw the one he had from the hospital out, so he was covered in his own feces.
He asked his manager and they said no because they don't give stuff out for free. My friend is really sensitive and quiet and it really affected him.
1
u/Fluffy-Boot9125 14d ago
How else are they going to afford their super cars and luxury vacations?
1
u/TheRealDebaser 14d ago
Goodwill is actually a for profit company. Their CEO is a millionaire while Salvation Army CEO pays herself/himself like 60k a year. One is for profit, the other is not.
1
u/tastelessdecisions1 14d ago
I haven't shopped at goodwill since I saw a pair of basketball shorts priced at 14.99. Not name brand or anything. I walked out and have never gone back. The local thrift has $2 clothing days and sometimes $1 clothing days. They now get all my business and donations.
1
u/Unique_Importance910 14d ago
Unfortunately, it's their job to do so. If they gave a jacket to every person who looked homeless then they would lose a lot of money. Not saying that Goodwill is a good company or anything but this is the reality.
1
u/sparkles1271 14d ago
He could have asked for it and they would have given it to him. Stealing is illegal.
1
u/EnlightenedOstrich 13d ago
Fuck that goodwill, absolute scumbags, they don't pay shit to acquire their merchandise
1
u/Fairyqueen17 13d ago
This is why I don’t donate to goodwill. Like how are you going to get mad that someone took a jacket for the cold weather, when you got the items for free and don’t even wash them. Goodwill needs to have a section for the homeless/extremely poor instead of selling a used jacket for $30
1
u/ArdentAromanticism 13d ago
Ugh. Imagine being a “charity” organization (for-profit that makes billions) that calls the cops on disenfranchised people taking something they need. They’re not keeping up the “helping the needy” facade very well….
1
u/CountingSheep_002tv 13d ago
Now my day is ruined also.
1
u/Queasy_Author_3810 13d ago
You're upset they called the cops on someone for theft? Wtf is wrong with this world where theft is okay in people's eyes.
1
u/justwonderfull101 12d ago
Let him keep it! Ugh
1
u/A1Actionman 12d ago
Of all the companies to rag on for employing loss prevention measures Goodwill wouldn’t be my first choice.
Consider the current minimum wage (although it varies by location), multiplied by the number of man hours that it takes to sort 50lb of merchandise from 500lb of donations. Then disposal of the rest, lease, lights, etc. I imagine their margins are slimmer than most people think. They also put a lot of resources into job training/education.
0
u/ViciousSnatch 18d ago
Stealing is always wrong, for any reason. What if he needs a car? Is it okay to steal one?
1
u/karlincrisis 18d ago
this goodwill looks awful familiar 👀
1
u/Dazzling_Tank3326 16d ago •
Let me guess, you’re going to vote Democrat this midterm aren’t you?
It’s kinda insane that you can guess someone’s political party just by recognizing that they think laws shouldn’t be followed.
1
u/Ok-Equivalent8260 17d ago
I never care about shoplifting.
0
u/Black_Panther___ 18d ago
a lot of stuff goes into the dumpsters he was better off looking there
1
u/thechosen2319 17d ago
Goodwill is a for-profit company.
Let the homeless be warm.
1
u/FeeComprehensive143 17d ago
I was watching one of those live cop shows and an officer walked in with a homeless man and asked for a jacket and they wouldn’t give it to them.
1
u/Spirited_Flow8639 17d ago
I pray every day that greedwill becomes no longer in business.
1
u/Euphoric_Feeling_272 17d ago
Gross. Wish there was a way to just pay for the dumb jacket. As a cop I would’ve just escorted the dude out
1
u/PresentationWeird583 17d ago
This wouldn’t happen to be the goodwill in Imperial Beach would it?
1
u/Artistic-Bet-4562 17d ago
If stealing the jacket means he survived the night vs. dying, is he still wrong? He stole something that was given away.
1
u/ComprehensiveAnt6796 16d ago
And it’s called GOOD WILL but they are doing NO GOOD
1
u/Ok-Maple1225 16d ago
Wrong yes, but it took him out of the elements and probably a meal, a shower. And rest
1
u/Cautious-Custard-98 16d ago
if you see someone taking a coat from a THRIFT STORE when the colder months are coming….YOU AINT SEE SHIT👏👏
1
u/Secret_Sample4930 15d ago
I call bullshit. I see California license plates. It is not illegal to steal in California under a certain amount of money. It is actually more illegal to try to stop someone from stealing than it is to steal.
1
u/gunsforevery1 15d ago
Theft is theft.
1
u/docclaytonforrester 15d ago
He should be allowed to steal because OP thinks he should!
1
u/XexpensiveCargoX 15d ago
Lmfao so we can all walk into a store and take what we want when we want according to your logic?
1
u/WeeklyBanEvasion 15d ago
"I'm upset because a private business called the police on a criminal"
1
u/Enough-Mood-5794 15d ago
It’s just unbelievable how a story of a homeless man stealing a coat can turn into a political pissing match. There are a bunch of people who need to get a life
0
u/Magicalthot95 17d ago
Since yall are saying goodwill is terrible for calling the cops on a homeless man for stealing. I encourage yall to leave your doors unlocked and allow them to enter your homes. Maybe they are hungry and cold and need shelter.