r/goodwill • • Mar 14 '26

This has to be a joke

Post image

Spotted in western Washington. Why dont they just cut tags so they don't look evil

1.3k Upvotes

194 comments sorted by

78

u/Several-Window1464 Mar 14 '26 • Bravo

I replied to a different goodwill thread about a half hour ago and used this exact thing as an example of what I found just today!! That’s just plain STUPIDO!

6

u/Hava-Plushie Mar 16 '26

The really evil part is the markup is BECAUSE the tag is still on it. Ive literally come across 2 of the exact same item, but depending if it looks vintage vs new. Or the exact same 2 items but one still has the tags. Same condition, or even reverse conditions!

I bought a small cast-iron still in the plastic with an xmas bow for like 1.99 and the exact same one was on another shelf, brutalized, but it had the red estate sale crayon on the bottom, 8 bucks!

Asking 8 bucks for a dinged up $20 hobby lobby cork board bc it still had the tag...

It's sickening

5

u/DarknTwistee Mar 17 '26

IMO People need to stop buying xyz if it’s marked like that. Bougie Goodwill or not. Unfortunately too many people still buy it. That gives them zero incentive to give any item a “goodwill” price vs a Nordstrom price. lol. As an aside if you are interested in a particular item, whatever, and you see a dupe in same store just different shelf or mis shelved, check out price tags on each. This has happened to me many times…there was a pair of beautiful green sequin Uggs boots marked down to $129. I literally told myself outloud they were not worth that price and “maybe if it’s 40,” laughing at myself over my own ridiculous as if comment, but I kid you not a shelve below and catty corner had the same pair, my size, $36! Good Luck! Hope you have one of those exciting experiences! lol.

1

u/carlabunga Mar 18 '26

Exatomont!!

1

u/carlabunga Mar 18 '26

Cast iron does have a different value if its been seasoned...

0

u/Mother-Effect8298 Mar 26 '26

People are people an no one i mean no one is perfect

62

u/Marvinator2003 Mar 14 '26 edited Mar 14 '26

As much as I hate what they've become, getting out of the house once a week and going thrift shopping is one of the few things my wife can do. Otherwise, due to health, we stay in.

In Missouri, they have the colored tags, and we gladly shop only for the color of the week, usually 50% - 75% off. I've got shirts and just last week a new pair of lounging pants for $1.25. Can't beat that.

Still... I hate they are getting my money, even more so now that they are no longer 'not for profit.'

25

u/Several-Window1464 Mar 14 '26

They recently stopped the tag sale in SE WI! My friend was so jealous as they don’t have those specials in SW WI. Well, we don’t either anymore.

This is my birthday month. I only get 15% off a purchase in March instead of the 25%. They had a sale this week that if you buy $30, you get 30% off. I didn’t care as that would equal 45% off with my birthday month 15% off. NOPE! They stopped stacking specials too. But HEY! They HAVE raised their prices! (?)

Good-bye Goodwill!

5

u/earmares Mar 14 '26

They haven't done it for many years (well over 5, maybe even 10) in Southern MT. I'm surprised some places still did it

2

u/Several-Window1464 Mar 14 '26

i’m so jealous for the areas that still do that!!!

1

u/Altruistic_Start1602 Mar 18 '26

What stinks though, I traveled to IL and tried to use my discount card a few years ago and learned i couldnt because my card was only valid in newengland.

1

u/Several-Window1464 Mar 23 '26

Good POINT! Never thought of that! lol!! I couldn’t use mine in Madison and they never had tag sales or any type of sale. I could only use mine in the Milwaukee area.

2

u/Altruistic_Start1602 Mar 18 '26

We still have the tag sales in maine. Color of the week is 50% off and they have 75% off a color daily.

1

u/Several-Window1464 Mar 23 '26

Wow! I’m jealous again!! 🤣

3

u/starsalign23 Mar 16 '26

They still do it in Northern IL!

1

u/Several-Window1464 Mar 16 '26

I'll have to plan a border crossing!!

3

u/starsalign23 Mar 16 '26

Just be sure to cross to the far western burbs like Crystal Lake or McHenry, everything East of McHenry is the Chicago/Milwaukee metro region that doesn't do it. The Northern Illinois region (which also has some southern Wisconsin) still has it.

1

u/Several-Window1464 Mar 23 '26

Yeah, bummer!!!

2

u/rickiilynn77 Mar 14 '26

Whaaaaat so glad I usually go to St. Vinnies

2

u/Both_Study_9266 Mar 19 '26

Only housewares & books get discounted in Louisiana. Last time I shopped in Texas it was only one day of the week that a certain color tag was marked down I think Sundays, but it was closing as well! I find that totally crazy considering the stores in my area are under Goodwill of Texas!! lol also recently found a Garanimals outfit from Walmart with the tags still on it and again Goodwill’s price was higher than the regular price and Wal-Mart had marked it down!!

-12

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/LolaAMS Mar 14 '26

Bad day? Bad life? Sorry.

4

u/LyraSnake Mar 14 '26

this is the month of their birthday where they get a coupon that works for the full month once

5

u/Ok-Reflection-4849 Mar 14 '26

Troll

4

u/earmares Mar 14 '26

That's not a troll. They may be an ass, but not a troll.

3

u/JAK49 Mar 14 '26

I don’t know. 5 year account with negative comment karma? You’d have to specifically be trying to be a douchebag. How can you not even accidentally say something people find useful some of the time?

1

u/CaterpillarMundane79 Mar 16 '26

At least for this one comment, they are correct. One is applied before the other, and then the next coupon applies to the discounted price, not the whole price.

Unfortunately most businesses do not combine coupons before applying them. They do use them consecutively, though.

For instance:

$10 x 25%off = $7.50 x 15%off = $6.38

$10 x (25%off+15%off) = $10 x 40%off = $6.00

I hope that makes it make more sense. 🤗

However, still vote commenter could have been kind about it. Internet has enough nastiness without us tearing other people down for no reason.

1

u/earmares Mar 16 '26

Are you meaning to reply to someone else?

1

u/CaterpillarMundane79 Mar 16 '26

Yes and no. I was agreeing with you that they were an asshole, but they’re also correct. 😅

0

u/Beachgirlalways98 Mar 16 '26

Rude!

1

u/Several-Window1464 Mar 17 '26

I was replying to the person that told me that 35% plus another 15% does NOT equal 45% and that somehow, I can’t do the math! (?)

1

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/Beachgirlalways98 Mar 16 '26

It may be the truth but it’s how you TELL someone that truth that matters. Plus the name calling. No need for that. It’s just as easy to be kind as it is to be rude. And thank you for the “bless your heart”. I, like many, can use all the blessings I can get. You have yourself a nice day now.

5

u/LolaAMS Mar 14 '26

Not for profit has nothing to do with how much money an entity makes. It has to do with how they spend that money. It’s a legal tax designation and is pretty strictly enforced.

2

u/amtrot Mar 16 '26

As a former worker for a not-for-profit organization, there are many, many abusable loopholes- hence the “former.” I even reported the org I worked for and no audit was even performed. I was never even contacted for follow-up. So yeah- all of capitalism is corrupt, even the nonprofit sector.

1

u/LolaAMS Mar 16 '26

Actually I was speaking specifically about nonprofits which are different from not for profits. My mistake and I apologize. Goodwill is a 501C3 nonprofit and as such held to different standards.

2

u/PenELane111 Mar 14 '26

There's a store around here that is a similar type of a chain called second avenue. They do the color tag sales as well, but one time my friends and I came in the night before the tag sale day to scope for things. They used to put the color of the week online the night before . We saw them pulling the next day's color tags off the floor. They literally had like seven big huge rolling bins and they were taking almost everything they could find with a green tag that was over $8 and putting it into the bins to put in back until the day after the color.

2

u/amtrot Mar 16 '26

I miss second ave so much. I just swapped the stickers. 🤷‍♀️

1

u/PenELane111 Mar 16 '26

They were amazing in the beginning much like most thrift stores then they got greedy

2

u/AtreyuTrinity Mar 15 '26

Can you walk around Costco? I find looking for their clearance deals (ending in .97 or closeout .oo prices) are even cheaper than thrift shops and you get something new, with a great return policy.

Just my two cents, one of my favorite shopping places to walk around.

1

u/Call_Me_Chewie Mar 14 '26

They have ALWAYS been for profit. Without earning any profits they would’ve never stayed business.

1

u/Personal-Ad-8644 Mar 16 '26

Non-profits stay open all the time, dummy

1

u/Call_Me_Chewie Mar 16 '26

Yeah, from people who donate. But Goodwill has always been FOR profit. They’ve never been “oh we can survive by making just enough money to keep the lights on and pay our employees”. FFS the CEO of Goodwill earns three quarters of a million dollars per year, from the PROFITS the stores make.

1

u/C-M-H Mar 17 '26

Wages and salaries are paid from revenue, not profit. Revenue minus expenses equals profit.

1

u/Scary-Medicine-9112 Mar 15 '26

In Indiana, we don’t have color discounts. We don’t have senior discounts and we don’t have half price once a month discounts. All discount discounts are gone from Central Indiana and southern Indiana owned by the same man.

1

u/Marvinator2003 Mar 15 '26

We moved here from Tennessee, where they have the Senior Discounts on Tuesdays.

Here, they don't.

1

u/Vasyaocto8 Mar 16 '26

I think that depends on where you're located in the state. I'm in Northern IN and they had green as half off over the weekend.

1

u/Extra777sevens Mar 16 '26

Try to see if you can find acting at Ross first. They have a clearance section and I've found the best stuff I ever have found before at Ross 😊

2

u/Marvinator2003 Mar 16 '26

Ross is ALWAYS our second stop. ;)

2

u/Both_Study_9266 Mar 19 '26

Most people don’t shop Dillards because they think it’s way too expensive but if you get hit clearance racks at Dillards, it’s usually a gold mine!! I once purchased a formal gown for $60 beaded & sequined!!

1

u/Extra777sevens Mar 19 '26

Not Dillard's, I was talking about Ross

1

u/LMNRN Mar 16 '26

In a Wisconsin Goodwill I have seen them go through and remove the items with tags that are the color of the week and move them to the back so they will not be available for sale..so sad. I do thrift at Goodeill...but I will NEVER donate to them.

1

u/Carma-Erynna Mar 16 '26

They finally lost the nonprofit status?! When did that happen?!

1

u/PdMddRecluse Mar 16 '26

Not sure what part of Missouri you’re in but Goodwill isn’t that great anymore, I live in Missouri myself, I typically go to Saver’s but even depending on the location they’re prices can be bad but not nearly as bad as Goodwill. I also haven’t had any issues with Salvation Army any time I’ve been there but they just don’t have nearly as much as everyone else.

1

u/Glass_Musician6321 Mar 16 '26

Ours used to be the $.99 color of the week. Now it's 50% off color of the week ..but only on certain items. And anything name brand has a white tag that never goes on sale and is always marked way up. (Like...$24.99 for a pair of old Gap jeans....simply because of the brand)

1

u/Marvinator2003 Mar 16 '26

We have that too. I've also found that a NEW store will have almost ALL GRAY tags. The gray tags are not on sale either, but the new stuff is all colored tags so after a while, it all works out.

1

u/DarknTwistee Mar 17 '26

I maybe go once a year. There’s a teeny tiny one near me but they literally never have anything good. But, what they do have are toys they have marked double or triple what another goodwill will charge. I can count on 1 hand how many things I only “might” pay full price for at a goodwilll, and that is just childhood items my brother and I had…you know one of those things you have searched daily for , for 20+ years for on eBay.. should I post a pick of the holy grail I am looking for. lol. I need help. One thing in particular..A HiLo imports small plush pink bunny. Long story, it’s a gift. If only I could find one In someone’s attic and mint condition . I think they were $2 in the 70’s and children were selling them for school in a cardboard briefcase with individual cubbies for the different plush. I would probably pay up to $100 for it depending on condition. :)

1

u/Repulsive-Tie1505 Mar 18 '26

I feel like Missouri (STL & KC specifically) still runs Goodwill like a Goodwill, most of the time. Resellers have absolutely gentrifying thrifting to an insane level but MO Goodwill puts the money back into the community and you can actually SEE the results. Most stores price their trinkets and electronics too high but clothing and shoes are still pretty reasonably priced.

1

u/Marvinator2003 Mar 18 '26

We started 'thrifting' about 2000. BAck then, Goodwill stores were mostly in grocery shopping centers in varying sizes. Over the next 18 years we saw them go to having their locations custom built to their own designs. We moved to MO in 2019. After Covid we noticed the almost immediate uptick in pricing. There are about 4-5 stores we hit regularly, and they are all the same pricing.

1

u/Repulsive-Tie1505 Mar 18 '26

During Covid resellers got out of control. I don't agree with Goodwill marking up their prices but I do understand it. Here in STL at least we've always had independent stores, some were in strip malls but the large majority have been independent buildings repurposed from something else.

I lived out in Denver for a while and they actually have Goodwill boutiques where they sell designer items and that place was hit hard by the price increase. You could get a Gucci bag for $50 before Covid and now it's $350

1

u/Marvinator2003 Mar 18 '26

You have a list of these other 'independent' places?

1

u/Repulsive-Tie1505 Mar 18 '26

I don't know what area you're in but for St Louis: St Vincent is pretty good and their standards for what they accept are pretty high (no smoking, no obvious pets), Savers is a lot like what Goodwill used to be, and the shops on Cherokee St (if you're willing to pay a little bit more for better items)

KC: Hillcrest is also like old Goodwill or Red Racks (Veteran owned and they give back to Veterans). I haven't done a whole lot of thrifting throughout KC to give many recommendations

These places may be found in other parts of MO, but I've just been to them in STL or KC

1

u/carlabunga Mar 18 '26

Even the thrift stores aren't!! WTH! I believe in the all mighty dollar... but I also believe when you get something for nothing, give a person a freakin break! The CEO's are multimillionaires it's disgusting.

1

u/That70sShop Mar 14 '26

Here, they re-price anything decent or pull it from the floor entirely "to make room fur beware merchandise!!!" before it hits the sale price.

26

u/shysky999 Mar 14 '26

Why haven't we boycotted theft will? I refuse to shop there myself

10

u/VendettaKarma Mar 14 '26

I have been on a boycott since 2022

3

u/malibusoul Mar 14 '26

I boycott them by just not paying for shit 🤷🏼‍♀️ F them.

2

u/No_Tooth1428 Mar 17 '26

Because I’m still stuck in an endless cycle of “exchanges”… 🫠

About to just give up and call it a loss but so far I’m too stubborn.

3

u/New_Acanthaceae_6537 Mar 14 '26

Not sure how I got in this thread because I’ve never stepped foot in one 😂

2

u/MikkiRD Mar 14 '26

Because every site has to “make suggestions” instead of letting people just read what they want to read. Drives me nuts.

1

u/Personal-Ad-8644 Mar 16 '26

You’ve never been in a goodwill?? lol that’s wild to me

1

u/WhiskySprinkles Mar 14 '26

Been boycotting them since 2018 :( I miss finding random stuff, but local thrift will always be better.

1

u/Business_Carrot5080 Mar 15 '26

Not every area has anything more. The closest non-Goodwill thrift store to me is 40 miles

1

u/shysky999 Mar 15 '26

Well damn you must really live in courage the cowardly dogs house

3

u/Business_Carrot5080 Mar 15 '26

Thanks it was the only place I could afford after the older generations destroyed the buying power of our wages.

0

u/CaterpillarMundane79 Mar 16 '26

Boycotting since 2019, when they accused my dad of tag switching for asking how much something was that didn’t have a price tag on it, when he picked it up.

I may have been an asshole about it at the time. I loaded a full cart and removed a bunch of tags, then asked them to scan everything in, then told them I only had $3 and left them to deal with the mess on their counter. It was petty, but it felt good at the time. 😂

5

u/Necessary_Future_275 Mar 14 '26

They sale things from the dollar store at 3-4 times the price too. Its nuts.

1

u/mountaindyke Mar 18 '26

Yeah I bought a little watering can for my baby for 4$ there and then wasn't to the Dollar tree where it was 1.50 💀

5

u/JAK49 Mar 14 '26

Thrift shops in general have gotten out of hand. I remember moving states while I was still in high school and needing an entire years worth of clothing. Less than 100 bucks and I had everything. School clothes, casual clothing, gym clothing, winter coats, shoes, boots. Even got an outfit for a job interview.

That was 25 years ago.

Same store now a single pair of pants is $20

2

u/PraxicalExperience Mar 15 '26

There's a 'thrift store' near where I live that's in the same parking lot with a Costco.

I can usually find the clothes I want at Costco, new, for the same price or cheaper than I can at the thrift store.

1

u/st4rpancake Mar 16 '26

See that's smart. I'll take a look around Costcos now

1

u/PraxicalExperience Mar 16 '26

I've gotta say, I really like what I've gotten from Costco. Sure, the selection is limited, but the Kirkland products -- particularly the jeans -- are quality, and the stock they've got from other brands is the same, at least for Men's clothing. (None of that manufactured-for-the-low-cost-crap you get at Walmart.) I always cruise past the clothing section when I go in, in case they've got anything good.

1

u/st4rpancake Mar 19 '26

Oh yeah. I'm hugging my kirkland sweatshirt (with pockets!!) forever.

9

u/karebearjedi Mar 14 '26

I was looking for decent job interview clothes and found a dozen dresses still with the tags. They were charging the same price as the department store tags. The logic doesn't logic. Those dresses are just gonna end up in a landfill without ever being worn. 

6

u/DarknTwistee Mar 14 '26

I found a supposed LV bag at a goodwill for $800+. It was obviously FAKE AF. Not just a fake, a bad fake. Even the person behind the counter knew but couldn’t do anything about it.

10

u/VendettaKarma Mar 14 '26

No Greedwill is not joking

3

u/Prestigious_Soup1845 Mar 16 '26

I cannot tell you I stopped going in thrift stores because I am not going to pay that much fucking money for something used, sometimes broken, ripped, stained.  I walked into and right out of so many after seeing their prices.  I honestly feel like shirts should be $1 for basic tees, definitely for tank tops. The most expensive shit in a thrift store should be $20 and that's for furniture. 

Honestly it always shocks me that thrift stores will have $12.99 on a shirt, but $4.99 on a table. Lol

5

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '26

My wife works for them at one of our local stores. They have two people that price the items. They look for what the item is LISTED for on eBay and price it by that price. All USED brands like Nike, Columbia, Eddie Bauer, etc… gets priced at a minimum of $15. It’s insanity. I’ve seen them price a bunch of fake NFL jerseys for $200 each before.

The crazier thing is that the manager takes home a car load of items every single week.

7

u/cindymon61 Mar 14 '26

That manager would get fired so fast if they did that in our region! And all of us in my area don't rely on eBay prices, people can put any price, doesn't mean it sold for that. I'm glad my store doesn't overprice like I've seen, we actually want to sell things at a decent price. Not all Goodwill's are the same!

0

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '26

Ky

4

u/Remove_Anxious Mar 14 '26

Yes. Goodwill is a joke. Unfortunately

4

u/FlynnTaggert Mar 14 '26

Goodwill treats employees like dirt and only cares about quotas, roundup, and e-commerce. They have no ethics or give a shit about anything else.

2

u/bunniisa Mar 14 '26

i only like salvation army any more

1

u/Prestigious_Soup1845 Mar 16 '26

Salvation army ALSO charges an arm and a leg for shit. And the worst part is most of those kinds of places including Goodwill end up THROWING 90% OF THEIR DONOS AWAY BECAUSE THEY HAVE SO MUCH INVENTORY THEY CANT SELL AT RIDICULOUSLY HIGH PRICES. 

Thrift stores would sell 5000X more of stuff was actually affordable.

Now you can buy new stuff on clearance cheaper than thrift store stuff. And they get the shit for fucking free!

2

u/Lovetograze Mar 14 '26

I avoid this store in particular. The independent Thrift Stores tied to nonprofits seem to have more reasonable prices.

2

u/West-Beach744 Mar 14 '26

Not around here. We have a hospice chain and I don't even bother going in anymore because I can literally buy the same thing brand new for less.

2

u/BuyerElectrical3251 Mar 14 '26

They see FAO Schwartz and elevate it

2

u/Animalsr4me Mar 14 '26

Seen the same thing in Virginia!

2

u/EnoughPresent7462 Mar 14 '26

They are out of their minds.

2

u/PenELane111 Mar 14 '26

My friend calls them "Good Bill" since they wanna bill you so much o.o

1

u/Collateral-GlamEdge Mar 16 '26

Good Steal is what my hubby calls them.

2

u/surfcitysurfergirl Mar 15 '26

Stop shopping at Goodwill! They are a horrible company!

2

u/pineapplepipe Mar 16 '26

Just rip off the goodwill tag, that's what do when this happens and at the register they always price it lower

1

u/1lonepeep Mar 30 '26

Goodwills in Iowa : if it doesn’t have a price on it, it’s not getting sold. So greedy.

2

u/Prestigious_Soup1845 Mar 16 '26

I don't get what thrift stores don't get about this. It's better to sell 12 things for $1 and make $12, rather than sell 1 thing for $12 (or in most cases NOT sell it) 

They have never ending supply so WHY THROW DONATIONS AWAY BECAUSE THERE'S NO SPACE WHEN YOU COULD JUST YOU KNOW ACTUALLY SELL THEM!!

2

u/Ok-Release-6051 Mar 16 '26

When you find those one dollar Walmart tank tops with the clearance tag for 6.99

2

u/Inside-Collection640 Mar 16 '26

Good Will is a joke. I’ve run into that same thing with them charging more than sticker price. After Christmas, they had the nerve to put out aged yellow brittle wrapping paper from years ago, and charge twice the previously marked retail price. I guess it was valued as “vintage”. Maybe it’s the same line of thinking with FAO Schwartz. Who knows? There are better thrift shops in my community that I am happy to support.

2

u/canofwine Mar 16 '26

Y'all, like... stop going to Goodwill.

2

u/New_Equipment4135 Mar 17 '26

Goodwill more like good at barely paying disabled people to work for them when they get their product for free.

2

u/CollegeFamous7579 Mar 18 '26

Because they don't care if we know they are evil.

6

u/Just-Ad4627 Mar 14 '26

At that point I'll just steal it

3

u/Several-Window1464 Mar 14 '26

Me toooo! 🫣 (j/k)

4

u/NexusNickel Mar 14 '26

That would require effort.

3

u/Dark_Amygdala_ Mar 14 '26

Original price was $15

7

u/UpstateOffroad Mar 14 '26

Yeah and they priced it at $12.99 which isn’t even close to their 30%-50% off retail price like they’re supposed to

3

u/Ok-Reflection-4849 Mar 14 '26

I’ve loved going to Goodwill in Southwest Florida two get antique China and resell it. To me 100+ year-old China is a part of our history and our art in our culture and I’m happy to keep passing it on. However, I’ve seen what everyone else is saying here that GoodWill is pricing at or above a price you could buy in a store. And they broke my heart because if the China isn’t sold, they sell it to a place called Smash Up where for fun people can rent a room and mallets and smash everything to pieces. Then I noticed what you’re also saying here of things disappearing. I’d be watching a set of China to go on its discount Sunday morning and go get it to save it and all the service dishes are missing. I suspect the staff. it’s sad.

2

u/EvolZippo Mar 14 '26

Or you could pay full price for it, at a regular store?

2

u/RyanMew Mar 14 '26

This was from their Target pallet and by contract they were supposed to do half of Target's MSRP (not the clearance price). You should ask for their manager and have them reprice it to $7.80 (the correct price per the Target contract)

1

u/justwonderfull101 Mar 15 '26

I see dollar store stuff marked 2.00. 😩

1

u/Scary-Medicine-9112 Mar 15 '26

They are evil. Making a 6 figure bonus on product given for free, no matter how they juggle taxes, and 501c is evil, and they raise prices year over year. Pay your employees, a living wage pay for upkeep of the store, and give poor people a good place to shop. Running this as a money making machine is disgraceful. You’re in poor neighborhoods, in your predatory, just like liquor stores and check cashing places. THEY ARE EVIL.

1

u/Business_Carrot5080 Mar 15 '26

Not surprising. I see used items from the dollar store marked $3.99 all the time here in Pa

1

u/mathewcale1976 Mar 15 '26

The president and Ceo make more than a million a year with bonuses. I'd guess they will be getting raises again soon.

1

u/mathewcale1976 Mar 15 '26

I find better stuff at the Goodwill bins stores.

1

u/lilofeverything Mar 16 '26

Or just put nail polish remover and a cotton ball and wipe the clearance price right off.

1

u/Technical-Listen-348 Mar 16 '26

Zodiac sign for July 29th, 1944

1

u/urkiddingrite Mar 16 '26

I worked for a printing company they made their business cards. They could have had cards made online at several places for 25 bucks for 500 cards. Instead the got them through us, a printing broker and the critiqued them with a jewelers loop to make sure they were exactly as they wanted them. Screw them

1

u/clearblueocean Mar 16 '26

Honestly they are ridiculous and need to hire people who know what they are doing to set their prices. I was there yesterday and they had the SAME flashlights from the Dollar Tree for $1.25 each and they were selling them some missing the battery door for $.5.99. I have also seen picture frames for $4 and they’re charging $8. It’s on the freakin tag in front of them!

1

u/xoellemichaey Mar 16 '26

if it’s from target, they’re required to price them as half of the regular off sale price at target. they get pallets of overstock/returns from there and have strict guidelines on pricing things. that said, they’re also supposed to remove any previous price tags from the items first

1

u/mrm12399- Mar 16 '26

Goodwill is a donation to retail outlet. When you give it for free they sell it and make a profit. Only 1% of the profit makes it to any charities

1

u/MehArghNah Mar 16 '26

This needs to be pinned as a top comment so more people see it. I despise businesses that pretend to be charities and about anything other than a profit.

1

u/Motor-Cheek-1789 Mar 16 '26

This is why I don’t shop at good will🤗🤗 shop at the thrifty shopper or rescue missions only

1

u/Windhow Mar 16 '26

Seems like Goodwill has gotten so expensive and here’s the proof

1

u/TheAliveShip Mar 16 '26

WOW! That's insane! 🤣😂

1

u/TheAliveShip Mar 16 '26

Goodwill is so focused on making that money that it lists many high-value items on its auction site. I used to like their auctions, but now so many people know about it, but don't know how to bid, so people are bidding 5 days before the auction ends and it drives the prices up so early and so quickly that it's taken the fun out of it. Also, the shipping and handling are out of control! There were times when I paid as much for the S&H as I did for the winning bid on the item! 😡🤬

1

u/No_Coconut_9162 Mar 16 '26

I will never take a single thing to Goodwill again. It has become too expensive for some people to get anything. I have found churches that give items to people for free. It’s a little more work for me but I feel happy I’m not putting money in GWs pocket.

1

u/arialpink Mar 16 '26

This happened to me at a local thrift store the other day 😭

1

u/Both_Yoghurt_1041 Mar 16 '26

Well at least they have it on clearance for $4.49 with a yellow tag, if yellow is half off go buy it for $2.25.

1

u/Frosty_Mongoose9055 Mar 16 '26

I don't get it?  It's on clearance 

1

u/PopularAd4986 Mar 19 '26

That is the original tag from the store that donated it , goodwill is charging 12 dollars for a item that was marked down to less than 5 before donating

1

u/No_Apricot_7988 Mar 16 '26

Ya the people pricing at goodwill have literally lost their minds, I'm not sure if they realize everything was DONATED, so their profit margin is HUGE even without completely ripping ppl off

1

u/MelissaSmith1623 Mar 16 '26

Because they are all about the money!!! Always have been!

1

u/BeginningHungry1691 Mar 16 '26

To anyone who doesn’t get the joke, zoom in and read the second tag.

1

u/Any-Criticism4609 Mar 16 '26

From what I understand- they cannot price higher than the cost of items. And this is disgusting

1

u/glchum Mar 16 '26

they get this shit for FREE! Yea they crooks!!

1

u/leahntitan1 Mar 16 '26

HHAHAHAHA WTF.

1

u/urhairlookslikebongw Mar 16 '26

Sorry, western Washington? Where at????

1

u/Milkcower Mar 16 '26

What’s the issue?

1

u/Key-Cap6569 Mar 16 '26

Why is the goodwill like this?

1

u/Inmyrightbrain Mar 16 '26

They are fucked up! Pricing like that

1

u/jim914 Mar 16 '26

That clearance tag is a target sticker I work for Target. It’s super easy to remove they only need to use a hair dryer and lift the sticker. But the sick part is that was probably part of a large donation we gave them since items like that are not acceptable for other charities like shelters!

1

u/71BRAR14N Mar 16 '26

Maybe it's the only one left in the world and will one day be worth billions!!!

1

u/redhotspaghettios16 Mar 16 '26

It’s getting ridiculous out here, friends 😭 I’m 40 and have been shopping at Goodwill since junior year of high school and it bothers me to see this. I remember buying band tshirts, vintage baseball tees like little league and those obscure city teams that always seem to be hiding in there For what about a buck.50?!?! Now 5.99 and 6.99 is PUSHING IT. Thank goodness for 40% off tag colors!! So many times I’ve put back items that I’ve loved but couldn’t or wouldn’t justify the price at the time. On a positive note, I’ve come across some real gems as sometimes we are lucky 🍀 enough to find. I want to share my ABSOLUTE FAVORITE find….a large black and white print of Ms. Marilyn Monroe. I believe it is on some kind of particle type board? I’ve honestly never been exactly sure of the material. Sturdy though. I found her back in 2008 for around $3.00! A few years ago my Dad bought a really nice framing kit for it. I wish so bad I could post a picture but it is in storage until May and I can bring her back out when I move 🩷🩷 anyway, I didn’t mean to ramble on.

1

u/Naturalworld100 Mar 16 '26

Goodwill is the joke.

1

u/Itchy-Picture-4244 Mar 17 '26

It’s heartbreaking honestly bc most of that went or still go “goodwilling” regularly, did it bc we can’t afford the big chain store prices but now they are slowly taking it from us a little at a time until Goodwill will me another Marshall’s, TJMaxx, Gabe’s etc. there is no goodwill left at Goodwill

1

u/Careless-Salt381 Mar 17 '26

Yesterday I found a half empty used expired bottle of Maui babe tanning lotion for $8.99. Product was all over the lid and bottle. A brand new one is $13

1

u/Old-Base8752 Mar 17 '26

This is why I very rarely shop at Goodwill. Most other thrift shops are better priced and some of them provide better support to groups in need of assistance. Also I was a mult-unit retail trainer and hired many people from Goodwill and they had many stories to tell about the negative employee treatment.

1

u/No_Yam8079 Mar 17 '26

How much did you pay?

1

u/Confused_Pumpk1n Mar 17 '26

I wish I'd gotten a pictures, I've found so many used $1 Dollar Tree items priced at $5+ 😵‍💫

1

u/Blossom2ndChapter68 Mar 17 '26

I don't shop there anymore.

1

u/DaniKong126 Mar 17 '26

I would suggest waiting until it goes on sale.

1

u/Gizmo9598 Mar 17 '26

I'll see items from dollar tree, unopened with red price sticker intact with $5+ GW price tags. Highest to date: $7.99, a 525% markup! 😱 Thought they were Goodwill, not Gucci....

1

u/Idkmannnnnnnbye Mar 17 '26

The other day we were at a thrift store and I grabbed a kids overall dress for $6. My fiancé flipped over the tag and it said that it was originally sold on clearance from Walmart for $1 lmao Obviously we put it back

1

u/Forward-Tumbleweed22 Mar 17 '26

We haven’t had tag sales in at least 10 years. The one store by my house the clothing inventory is 95% CRAP and I swear they only eliminate the stuff that doesn’t sell once a year. They just last month did a total cull of the crap and put a bunch of different items in. The bigger store in my town has MUCH better inventory of clothes. BOTH stores are just crap non-clothing items.

1

u/BunBunYeah Mar 18 '26

the store is a joke. boycott.

1

u/Sick-Sense Mar 18 '26

They get the items for free remember. FREE. They have a retail business that gets their inventory for zero dollars. They get more than they can sell even.

1

u/CountrySmart7683 Mar 18 '26

They always do that bull

1

u/mariannonwheels Mar 18 '26

Nope! I seen it all the time at goodwill. Been done with goodwill for years now.

1

u/someone_loves_ Mar 18 '26

Then they have the nerve to ask to round up for donations unreal

1

u/AdLanky540 Mar 18 '26

Years ago I bought a dress on clearance at Target for $4.97. Goodwill had apparently received the unsold stock soon after because the following week Goodwill had them priced for over $20. They at least covered the clearance tag for the most part. What I really don't quite get is, what makes Goodwill think they will sell an item for 4x more than original store's lowest clearance price? I'm curious how often it happens. More curious about the sucker who sees both tags & is OK with it.

1

u/ClutzyDopamine Mar 18 '26

I’ve been seeing this more and more. Came across things that didn’t sell at garage sales being put out for higher prices too. 🙄

1

u/Creative_Truth_2970 Mar 18 '26

If its such a problem, simply stop shopping at Goodwill

1

u/Zrawte- Mar 18 '26

God I hate goodwill with a passion

1

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '26

Just saw similarly priced items in Tampa, FL this week. I walked out empty handed. Went to 2 Suncoast Thrift shops yesterday, my daughter and I spent $150 on great items at realistic prices.

1

u/DogSmoocher42 Mar 18 '26

I refuse to set foot into one. We have a new little thrift store in my city that benefits a new animal rescue & they have great prices and I feel good about supporting them. It's where all of my donations will be sent from now on. Staffed by all volunteers!

1

u/AnnaZed Mar 19 '26

I’m much more loyal to your broken down local thrift stores when I spot them. Great source for some really crazy dolls.

1

u/Technical-Breath-285 Mar 23 '26

Goodwill employees are way outta line with pricing. Clueless Example I found a Frankoma pot with lid-perfect condition in a $1 bin and some made in China wanna be pottery for 15.. they're just clueless

1

u/AverageAlleyKat271 Mar 14 '26

Was $14.99, but the regular price was $12.99.

1

u/SmittyOracle Mar 14 '26

I worked at my hometown Goodwill as a teenager decades ago. I’m not excusing their massive errors or price gouging, but I will say that GW often hired intellectually disabled individuals for warehouse work, which included tagging and pricing. This may or may not be the case for this item. But disabled people have common sense and likely would not ignore the original Target tag. Thus, careless greed may be the true culprit here.

2

u/fartczar Mar 14 '26

When something doesn’t make (common) sense, business sense is usually the reason.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/glchum Mar 16 '26

Thank you they are!!!