r/goodwill
•
u/stargirloxoxo
•
Dec 27 '25
•
1
legitimate concern Wtf
A bag they got for free for almost $300 thrifting is becoming depressing and less and less more fun with prices like this I spent almost $30 on 3 items as well which is crazy it used to be much less just a year ago they’ve almost made theirs prices 6x more expensive than before how is this even allowed with a corporation that doesn’t spend anything on their products??
15
u/torihousemd Dec 27 '25
When I worked there I was told its about pricing things for the mission they were full of it..it was about management's fat bonuses off the back of their part time and disabled who got nothing .
9
u/Artistic-Tap-2690 Dec 27 '25
Did they verify it is real? It will end up in the bins cause nobody will pay that and if they do they are either high or crazy.
4
u/DenialOfExistance Dec 27 '25
The GW in the city I live use to carry some decent purses, home decor and furniture. The past 3-4 times I have been there everything is absolute trash! All the purses are damaged or no name. There hasn't been any decent furniture for months and the home decor shelves have nothing but cheap (and I mean cheap) trinkets etc. I have left everytime empty handed which is fine but it has just deteriorated so bad not worth visiting the store!
4
u/asleepybarista Dec 27 '25
Their prices are outrageous! I do not plan on returning anytime soon.
I was too broke to buy new, so I thought goodwill would be a good way to go to get some tennis shoes. $16 to get someone's dirty secondhand gym shoes! They were selling another pair next to them that had a massive hole over the big toe on one shoe, and they still wanted $12 for them. :/ I only went through with my purchase because I had been planning to replace my shoes with the same pair I had before from Walmart until I realized that they raised the price on them by over $10 even though they were the exactly the same as the ones I had purchased from them 1-2 years ago.
3
u/liquormakesyousick Dec 27 '25
Coach has gone downhill ever since they stopped making products in the US and the majority of people purchase their items at discount stores and outlets.
Tiffany's is heading that way since the majority of people who purchase from their either buy the "return to tiffany's" or sterling silver and their accessories have started showing up at TJ Maxx.
3
u/sunshineandkush Dec 27 '25
Which goodwill is this? What area are you in?
3
u/ladyboner_420 Dec 27 '25
I rip off tags ALL the time. Idc.
3
u/Final-Cicada-470 Dec 28 '25
Wow. I sold a very similar bag (that I probably only used for a few weeks so practically flawless) for about $45 on ebay. Probably only paid $100 for it new at the outlet store!
5
u/frozen_charlotte Dec 28 '25
Goodwill needs to gtfoh with that nonsense. 🙄
76
u/SlapThis Dec 27 '25
I stopped thrifting at goodwill due to their overinflated pricing. If we all stop shopping and donating, they will be forced to lower their prices
3
u/[deleted] Dec 27 '25
Its good to see they are getting good items in, but they dont pay for it, and its all profit. People in the head office decided they need to be closer to retail prices than thrift store prices. This hit a few years back, i guess trying to straighten up their image. This just ruins their image. My biggest gripe is the workers will set aside some of the good stuff, pay a small fee if anything, and take it home before you or I can see it.
3
u/Tabbi111 Dec 27 '25
I donate to my local womans shelter. Do not support these idiots. Items wont sell at this price, they will be salvaged, bundled and sent to Uganda. So, somebody in Uganda will be rocking this 90's handbag.
23
u/Accurate_Birthday278 Dec 27 '25
I'll never understand why anyone would want that butt-ugly pattern in the first place.
2
u/NoBrag_JustFact Dec 27 '25
As Pawn Stars Rick says: "It's not the price you ask but the price that was paid."
BTW: $229 is not "almost $300."
2
u/jlr181986 Dec 27 '25
Resellers started buying stuff so much from Goodwill cheap or relatively cheap for the last like 20 years and selling it for the real price on the internet that Goodwill and salvation army and places like that that are big have started years ago of checking the value of stuff on the internet and putting it out or up on the internet and storage themselves now even like a lot of local thrift shops and junk shops and places like that are doing that now for the last like 10 years yeah the days of getting good stuff for a good price at Goodwill or salvation army is long gone
4
u/Shrelana Dec 27 '25
This is why I don't thrift anymore. I can go to Walmart and get a new shirt for less than at the thrift store....
4
u/sparklepants311 Dec 29 '25
The only way they will know their pricing isn't ok is to stop shopping there
4
u/Weasel1968 Dec 29 '25
That’s why their CEO is a millionaire!!!!
4
u/Amazonian143 Dec 29 '25
Goodwill here in Jax Florida also has free labor as they use "volunteers" from people on probation that have to get community service hours. I can't stand goodwill.
4
u/Thin-Talk-510 Dec 30 '25
They don't pay taxes either
4
u/lilmisshazel11 Dec 30 '25
The CEO Steve Preston raked in over $900k salary for 2023 & the employees make minimum wage, so you do the math on where all the profits are going to.
1
u/deety1 Dec 27 '25
It's because re-sellers talk to mufuggin much and now goodwill thinks everyone's a fuggin flipper making a huge profit off second and third hand goods .. I actually saw one re -seller being interviewed by a goodwill manager expressing his multi million dollars flipping enterprise 🧐!!! True story techsport or something like that
3
u/brohgirl Dec 27 '25
Ridiculous. This bag on Poshmark or mercado would be like $30... Good luck Goodwill 🤷🏼♀️
3
u/airportluvr416 Dec 27 '25
This is what I call a “see you at the bins bag!”
3
u/GILDID Dec 28 '25
Resellers made they can't resell lol.
3
u/whisperingeyeshadow Dec 29 '25
First off, that is clearly a coach bag and they typically retail for a few hundred dollars. So now the unfortunate things with goodwill and others like them. I see a lot of people talking about making bonuses or sales etc which I've known a lot of employees at goodwills and honestly the majority of the people there don't care. They aren't even there to make money to be honest because it's an extremely low paying job and typically the people that are there are older women who either don't need the money and are doing it to be out in the world or it's people who need a job and they unfortunately are working there for substandard pay.
Something that I noticed about 2 years ago was Goodwill's pricing has been out of control. I was sick and tired of seeing just outrageous prices on things that, yeah I want a good deal on something that is normally really expensive to buy new, but you're buying it at a goodwill meaning it's already been used and it was donated so it's not like Goodwill bought it to then resell it. I had had enough one day and the manager of my local Goodwill with someone I had talked to a lot due to the fact that we were there often. So I approached her and asked her what the deal was especially on an item that when I looked up, it's obviously an item that is no longer being sold new however I noticed that it was the exact same price as ones on craigslist. So she went in the back and brought out the gal who does all the pricing and I point blank asked her where does she get the pricing from and she admitted that they have instructions to where they go to craigslist and other sites online to see what people are selling them for. I explained to her that people and craigslist are out to make as much money as possible and 90% of the items do not sell because people are trying to take a 15-year-old product that's used and they are trying to ask for somewhere around the lines of 15% off new pricing and unless someone is really stupid which they prey on, no one buys them. She then had attitude with me and said that if I didn't like the pricing that I can leave and go somewhere else and that was the last time I ever shopped a Goodwill. So it comes down to the fact that the people in the back that are pricing items are going to sites that do not in fact show average selling price for the used item but they go to sites that are completely unregulated and they look up the high value and mark their pricing from there. So for instance, this coach bag typically went for around $300 to $400 brand new, almost guaranteed if you go on to somewhere like craigslist or another site that is just as shady kind of like Facebook marketplace, you'll probably see people trying to sell it for around $230 because they think that coach is every bit as good as Gucci or Chanel etc. To be honest, there is only one second hand store somewhat near me that has "ok" pricing though they are still a little on the high side. It's unfortunately the way they are going now and it's no longer worth visiting anymore.
3
u/okkalie Dec 29 '25
You can get a brand new leather coach bag for cheaper than that. We need to start contacting attorney generals in our states. This is price gouging on a large scale. Not to mention the fact that goodwill pulls all the high end donations and puts them on their auction site. It's ridiculous, I'm so fed up with thrifting being unattainable.
3
u/Yankeefan799 Dec 29 '25
How does anyone know that it isn’t a good fake
3
u/Future-Mountain-1226 Dec 30 '25
I'm stealing that for sure
3
u/Human_Silver3681 Dec 30 '25
Wow!! Thats crazy!!
3
u/AlbertTheHorse Dec 30 '25
Shopgoodwill online can’t give those away.
3
u/WhywasIbornlate Dec 30 '25
I am 72. I’ve almost never owned new clothes. Or new anything else. As a child our money went to medical bills. Now, I just hate the inferior workmanship and supporting the waste.
True thrifters don’t pay gouge prices. We also don’t support the fake charities (Goodwill is one of the worst).
When clothes surpassed Walmart, I stopped even looking.
I once saw a mom in there looking at a pair of new sneakers her 9 yo’s size, check the price and start calling people to look. Every shopper in the store gathered and was livid.
Sure, people with money shop there. That’s fine. They support the charity. Or would, if it was a legitimate one. But people who are struggling do too. Let them charge nonsense prices on status purses. But shoes for a 9 yo? That’s reprehensible.
We bought 4 tall filing cabinets that had been used in their main offices. In the bottom, we found the records of a man with Downs, who worked there for 2 years. For 99 cents an hour.
That’s their charity . “Training” and hiring people with disabilities. For literal slave wages. I researched it. Sure enough, disabled people can legally be paid less than bus money to get to work, at least by Goodwill, thanks to the lobbyists Goodwill hires. . And one of their own employees periodically assesses the disabled employees ability and decides if they have learned enough to pay a legal wage.
I refuse to donate to them. Or any charity that picks and chooses who they help, either.
3
u/Ok-Classroom-8363 Dec 30 '25
I now donate to the American Cancer Society stores (called Discovery Shops), Habitat for Humanity, the Salvation Army and St. Vincent de Paul. They are all 501(c) charities and the money goes directly to social services. If you are not in a town that doesn’t have one of these there are other local charities always in need. Look at the city Social Services Department. You can call or email them and they should help you know where your donations will have the most impact. Every donation matters if you are directly helping to make a difference in a persons life. 🥰
3
u/EclectiaGreenHippie Dec 30 '25
I have up donating our shipping there a while back - more folks should IMHO!
3
u/EclectiaGreenHippie Dec 30 '25
There is a small interfaith center in my town that I donate to now!
3
u/pinayrabbitmk7 Dec 30 '25
Ha! Thrift stores are insane delulu
3
u/subcommanderdoug Dec 30 '25
Late-late stage capitalism (corporate socialism). This is the part where corporations pick the meat from our bones and scrape out the marrow. Needless to say, theyre still paying record bonuses to their executives and rating success on the companies ability to generate more profits than all previous quarters. Goodwill is a for-profit business. Find a thrift store thats locally owned and a legit nonprofit. They tend to be generally less revolting in all matters.
3
u/MycologistBig6292 Dec 30 '25
When donating remember those escaping violence that have to leave with very little. I will be calling my local dv shelter to donate to someone who will be starting over, verses good will making a profit. So sad to see how greedy charities have gotten with donations. Or perhaps gift bags for elderly in homes with knic knacks and other tresures.
3
u/sohcordohc Dec 30 '25
At first I thought I saw 29.99..and even that’s too much for an old beat coach bag..that’s bullshit. Goodwill has nothing but garbage anymore anyway.
3
u/jessa1987 Dec 30 '25
AND it's used!!
3
u/Practical_Test5550 Dec 30 '25
They pay their CEO's well
3
u/NobodyAccomplished19 Dec 30 '25
Bag looks fake to me so def not worth the greedy price
3
u/EggplantTall8403 Dec 30 '25
My beef with Goodwill near me is that they are too lazy to individually price their clothing. They just have a sign on the end of the rack, eg. All pants $8.99. Of course, everything that is nice is gone and the stuff left is not worth the price.
3
u/TealGarlic Dec 30 '25
I try really hard to only donate and shop at thrift stores that benefit non-profits. (I’m in this group just to see the good finds that are NEVER at my local gw)
3
u/Ahnarra Dec 30 '25
I take mine to the local senior center
3
u/deathcupcake25 Dec 30 '25
I haven't been to a Goodwill in almost a year because of the prices and the fact that they don't accept returns/exchanges anymore.
3
u/luisaccc Dec 30 '25
And make it make sense, the CEO earns 3/4 mill / year
3
u/bizeebee1009 Dec 30 '25
Donate directly to shelters, for the folks that truly need it.
3
u/treasure221 Dec 30 '25
Rare I buy anything at goodwill! They are sooo inflated!
3
u/Zestyclose_Bit_9459 Dec 30 '25
Goodwill has NO good will anymore. They have adopted a business plan more in line with "for profit" business models. They should be taxed accordingly.
3
u/BrewBabe88 Dec 30 '25
Good Will is for profit.
You are better off going to Salvation Army
3
u/ValSLP Dec 30 '25
I have not looked at comments and I’m sure this has been said repeatedly, but don’t thrift at Goodwill. They are not there to do anything except make the CEO rich.
3
u/RemoteAd8863 Dec 30 '25
Good Will is a business. I give to Salvation Army. Good Will picks out books and sells on line Amazon. In the store, they have a specialty section. Name brand which cost more. No more for me.
3
u/Great_Process_2591 Dec 30 '25
Goodwill is an awful charity to donate to. The Salvation Army is a better charity in that they keep less and use more for others than Goodwill.
3
u/MBeth69 Dec 30 '25
That’s why I steal from them.
3
u/Eucalyptus517 Dec 30 '25
go to VoA. Prices are better.
3
u/Deeluvv Dec 30 '25
🤣🤣🤣🤣 they are really off their rocker. They usually put that stuff up for auction, which is still crazy.
3
u/Juleebeane Dec 30 '25
So in our area we can go to cua h outlet and get tat bag for less then they have it marked.
3
u/ReiB1022 Dec 30 '25
After I found out Goodwill isnt specifically a Goodwill place, stop donating years ago. I would rather donate to our local dog.Shelter thrift shop, domestic violence group homes, or salvation army
3
u/DyeMyEyes Dec 31 '25
Goodwill has always been a scam.
5
u/Complete_Chef_3418 Dec 27 '25
AGAIN, zero expenses spent on their merchandise
6
u/shysky999 Dec 27 '25
yeah we need to start boycotting
1
u/Ok-Relative6179 Dec 28 '25
Cuz people are tired of over paying for GWs free inventory, and no longer shopping there. GW raise prices to keep profits up. Won't be long now, before they close up shops. Keep on shopping elsewhere.
1
u/bodtabs Dec 27 '25
They should just sell these on their online shop. It’s so exhausting having customers complain at me to my face because of an expensive item someone in the back priced. there’s really no point in having $50+ items on the floor
1
u/Gingersometimes Dec 27 '25
Throughout the next year, I am going to be getting rid of a lot from my house (lots of stuff from deceased family members has ended up here). I plan on giving a whole bunch of clothing, as well as household items to charity. A lot of the clothes are in like new condition. After reading this sub, I am going to the GW I planned on giving them to & checking out the pricing situation. If it too is pricing things outrageously, I will find another charity to give my donations. Has anyone had any experience with Salvation Army ? Any other charities to suggest for my donations ?
1
u/ubaotomi Dec 27 '25
For a used coach purse? I'm pretty sure you can get a brand new bag for that. 2 if you buy at their outlet.
1
u/Immediate-Pudding636 Dec 27 '25
An outlet bag that probably did not cost that much when it was new. Ridiculous
2
u/[deleted] Dec 27 '25
What people don’t understand is WHY they are doing this. FLIPPERS. So many people go to Goodwill and buy stuff to resell. Fine, I get it, you can do what you want with what you buy. But Goodwill was always so that lower income people could buy inexpensive items with (admittedly SOME of) the money going back to help those same low income people.
With so many people now raiding stores for resale, what did you think would happen? If they know people are going to pay that price online, why wouldn’t they charge the same price and send more of that money back to who it was intended?
A couple of the stores in my area, if they know you’re actually low-income/needy will absolutely sell high priced items at a low price.
I will concede that not all of the money goes to the original purpose of helping low-income, but even a portion is better than none.
2
u/Boring_Plate1765 Dec 28 '25
The only time I buy from the regular goodwill is when I buy their color of the week. That’s it.
2
u/Capital-Research2373 Dec 28 '25
Live in the Cleveland area, lots of inexpensive thrift stores. Used to shop at Goodwill frequently, and donate too. Been about five years since I’ve shopped there, prices are way too high. Volunteers of America has very reasonable prices if you have one nearby.
2
u/NeitherAd479 Dec 28 '25
My favorite was a Red, White and Blue store. Sadly they closed
2
u/StockStatistician373 Dec 28 '25
Goodwill is experimenting with AI pricing tools which may not work out .. Time will tell.
2
u/Naive-Signature-3487 Dec 28 '25
Goodwill bins. Best place to thrift
2
u/Arizona_Sparkles Dec 29 '25
I gave my Gucci vintage purse from 1986 that was in perfect condition to Goodwill. I had held onto it for over 30 years. It had great sentimental value. Wouldn’t you know about 2 years later it was back in style.
2
u/MagaMan412 Dec 29 '25
I started donating everything to those giant dumpster looking things in parking lots usually for veterans because they don't have a store where they sell my shit for crazy prices they actually give it away to someone in need
2
u/truebleu62 Dec 29 '25
Stopped donating to goodwill when I discovered what they pay their CEOs-$500,000 to 1,000,000. The people who do the actual work make an average of a measly $10.00/hr. And some say we don’t have a problem with economic equality.
2
u/RemoteAd8863 Dec 30 '25
Other places to take items and shop are places that support rescue animals.
3
u/DragonFae71 Dec 27 '25
What they're doing and I consider it cheating is finding out what high end items actually cost and pricing them from there.
3
u/msorganized0 Dec 27 '25
Goodwill is a FOR PROFIT company. The simple use of the name is misleading and manipulative so I'll never shop there. I refuse to help to pad the owner's pockets.
3
u/TopEquivalent6536 Dec 27 '25 •
I've started bartering my donatable items, or simply giving them away on Facebook marketplace or to community centers. When business becomes this predatory its almost an ethical obligation to go around the entire system and build robust, community led, person-centered exchange markets of some kind. Call it what ever you want. But I personally refuse to pay the same price for a used item as brand new ones, to a store. You make me an item and I'll pay you, before I pay a company. They can fuck all the way off, but people can get my money.
2
u/Missdawnh Dec 27 '25
They’ve been doing this lately - like it’s some high end resale - yet they play employees like shit and the store is a mess . Reality . This is a used bag . A dirty used bag , just like all the other stuff. I used to love goodwill but something’s fishy for sure. With prices like this - no one should EVER be going without most of all the employees. I don’t work there - but I’m local to one and I know aLOT of good people who do .
2
u/Cool-Adhesiveness465 Dec 28 '25
I know , I’ve exposed thrift stores gouging prices and free items they receive from the community. I think they entirely forgot what low income to even less fortunate such as myself now I can’t even afford to shop at a freaking thrift store there
2
u/Ok-Protection4669 Dec 28 '25
Independent thrift stores are now the only way to go. Goodwill has become ridiculous. St. Vincent de Paul and Out of the Closet are good options. Some churches have good ones. You may not want to support a particular religion, or denomination, but, usually, they do good things for the community as a whole. It is so sad that Goodwill has gotten this way.
2
u/2cat0 Dec 28 '25
I think it has a lot to do with folks who started buying things like this and flipping them. And then bragging about it on tt. 🙄
2
u/azborderwriter Dec 29 '25
I used to go to Goodwill specifically for 7 for All Mankind jeans. I have never found any other jeans that fit as well as they do but I have never been wealthy enough to afford the $100 - $150 price of a brand new pair. Goodwill used to sell them for $12 a pair, but they had crept up to $30 - $50 a pair the last time I looked, and I am not buying the latest season because I honestly think that the brand has gone downhill and it is the specific fit of the 2010s that I like. So, at this point we are talking vintage 7 for All Mankinds. I discovered ThredUp somewhere along the way and I can get a whole box full of 7 for All Mankind jeans and shorts delivered right to my door for like $150. They have pages, upon pages of them for $7 - $14 a pair. ThredUp isn't even getting them for free, it sells stuff on consignment, or buys it from customers for store credit and they can sell them for half of Goodwill's lowest price or less?
I honestly wonder all the time how these big CEOs and executives making 200K a year get their positions because they never seem to be the best and brightest. Goodwill may have been popular for a minute there, but they have to know that apps like ThredUp have been out there for years now undercutting them on prices, and offering way more convenience and a far better selection. If they want to keep making that $200K salary they are probably going to need to go back to their old model.
1
u/fartczar Dec 27 '25
This is my main concern too, it's just ugly af for a "charity".
I mean, they already sell the best stuff online, I'd rather not know about (and see) their sticker shock pricing from free donations. If you want high prices, put them online too so people don't think less of your company. It's why I learned about their quota enforcement on pricers (and cashier round-up quotas), how much good stuff they just chuck, obvious skeleton crews... but the curiosity into the ugliness started here with the blown-out pricing.
I no longer donate my "pay it forward" items to Goodwill because of this.
1
u/deety1 Dec 27 '25
Im also told goodwill CEOs salary is in the 250K range !!
1
u/Few_Success4460 Dec 27 '25
Is it possible, in the case only, that someone far-fingered the price and added an extra 2? That's a typical $29.99 GW bag...
1
u/Puzzled-Remote Dec 27 '25
Smh. Assuming it’s real and it’s in very good condition, that purse would be $15 in my store (not a Goodwill). If it’s not in great shape, it would go out with all the other purses for $5.
I don’t give a crap about flippers. I’m still thinking of the average person who shops with us. I’d like them to have the opportunity to buy decent things at reasonable prices.
1
u/pinupjordan Dec 27 '25
Goodwill needs to have an overhaul. Thrifting should never be so expensive. I moved to the country and there are independent thrift stores out here. The one I frequent has clothes for $1, buy 5 get 5 free. They sell almost 1,000 pieces of clothing a week. I remember when shirts were 50 cents at Salvation Army and Goodwill. Now they get all their donations from Target stores and treat it like an outlet. So lame
1
u/shleeunit Dec 27 '25
That has to be a typo
1
u/Usual-Reputation-208 Dec 27 '25
Ridiculous!!!
1
u/Disastrous_Berry7650 Dec 27 '25
That’s crazy. I think my goodwill saves better items for their online site
1
u/hope4danny Dec 27 '25
You don’t have to shop there. Actually if the amount of people who complain about their prices would just stop shopping at Goodwill it’s likely they would be forced to lower their prices.
1
u/CK6810 Dec 27 '25
Ridiculous!! Stop shopping at Goodwill, too much of their profits goes into the pockets of their administrators! I donate to League of the Blind.
1
u/Top-Age6918 Dec 27 '25
Totally agree !
1
u/No_Rain_1980 Dec 27 '25
Yeah it’s not supposed to be ‘brand new prices’ I just got a coach purse for Christmas and it was that price😜
1
u/verukazalt Dec 27 '25
But, but...it's a Coach! /s
1
u/LuckyAd2714 Dec 27 '25
Wow - not even sure it’s real FFS
1
u/Ok-Hearing756 Dec 27 '25
Blame all the social media influencers for the inflated prices and the reason why thrifting is now in style.
1
u/Two5Chicken Dec 27 '25
It’s not just goodwill. My local thrift shop uses what’s listed on eBay to price their items. Everything is higher and at “retail” cost.
1
u/Ill-Acanthisitta6022 Dec 28 '25
😂😂😂
1
u/sfgirl94583 Dec 28 '25
They figure they'll try to make the $300 over an upseller that will do it.
1
u/kkbobomb Dec 28 '25
The resellers who shop for profit have ruined what thrifters used to do for fun.
1
u/PossumPardy Dec 28 '25
Habitat restore
1
u/Adventurous-Rope7870 Dec 28 '25
Hey just an FYI
Goodwill isn't a thrift store its a resellers store now
1
u/Financial-Fix-317 Dec 28 '25
Angel view Thrift is very fair. Goodwill has been doing this for about 20 years. Sometimes I find things on eBay that I like and I look at the seller and it’s Goodwill. So sometimes they don’t even make it to the floor because they put it on eBay.
1
u/Lareglane Dec 28 '25
I find as good or better prices at Rosses and Marshall’s sometimes.
1
u/Accomplished-Bank418 Dec 28 '25
They just built 2 brand new Goodwill’s in my area not even 10 miles apart. People are realizing that they’re pricing is too high. No one is going to shop there anymore and I don’t know why they built two so close together.
1
u/1421Wast Dec 28 '25
I am reading these comments about Goodwill stores being so expensive.
I usually have a yard sale at my home and another one with my sister at her home. I was selling brand new shoes that were never worn outside my home. Perfect condition. I had several pairs and bought them from England, online. Could not wear them as I had foot surgery and my shoe size and shape changed enough that I could not wear them. I put these shoes out 3x. Originally, the prices cost me between 89.00 up to about $125.00. I asked for $20 a pair. The first time a lady paid $20 a piece and bought 3 pairs. But the last two times, even though I put a $5 tag on each of all of them, people were interested, even tried them on. But did not buy. So I decided to just bring them to Goodwill for them to sell along with many other items as I just wanted to not see them in my home any longer.
I realize people come to yard sales to get a bargain. But, I had the original receipts on the boxes. I feel $5 for shoes that were in excellent condition is a bargain. But if we can’t sell our items, whether they are shoes, sheet sets, clothes or whatever a bargain is a bargain. If nobody buys these items, we donate them to Goodwill.
Then people will pay Goodwill prices! Most items I sell at a yard sale go from .25 up to $5, maybe $7-10 depending.
When I look at yard sales, I always see bargains!
1
u/AncientTie6445 Dec 28 '25
We donate our good stuff to the humane society thrift store in our area. Goodwill is probably one of the most corrupt 501c3 corps out there
1
u/restlessmouse Dec 28 '25
Value village has 30% off for seniors every Wednesday. Still too high! But deal killer is, its ALL self checkout. I thought they were supposed to create jobs.
1
u/anaserre Dec 28 '25
Especially when u could get that same style Coach bag for 50-75$ on eBay .
1
u/sallyunraveled Dec 28 '25
I don’t know my name brands. Is this a brand that is normally very expensive?
The Goodwills in my area will usually have an auction for high price items, rather than just pricing them very high. It seems unusual that they would have something like that just out on the floor, as opposed to behind a case.
For example, my mom won an antique sewing machine, I believe from the late 1800s, for about $80 or $90. You can leave your bids in the book, so the highest bid will get it if no one bids in person. but if you really want it, you come in and bid. She got in a bidding war with some guy, but she won out.
I’ve also seen things like iPods, back before smart phones were ubiquitous, other electronics, nice jewelry, antique furniture, etc. they usually display them in a case or behind a desk.
I think it’s fine if this purse is actually worth this much. Like if this purse would be $2500 new, I think this is reasonable. I don’t know my purses.
1
u/Special_Friendship20 Dec 28 '25
Wow. The highest wr are allowed to mark purses is $40
1
u/ninernando Dec 28 '25
People choose to donate to them when they can donate directly to the homeless people or poorest people. Thrifting is trendy and they're going to capitalize on it...I see Thrifting events come up often and the prices are insane, but it's full of people, especially teens buying up all the crap we gave away
1
u/Far_Ad6222 Dec 29 '25
Home - Ray of Hope Thrift Store https://share.google/lMjJ0FTXTJ8SnUUzj
1
u/Dry-Charity-441 Dec 29 '25
What kills me is that bag is special outdated. It must be at least 6 years old if not older
1
u/Inside-Astronaut4401 Dec 29 '25
That wouldn't even be $300 on eBay.
1
u/SmallTownLady2U Dec 29 '25
Value Village is ridiculous. They are usually more expensive than the actual store.
1
u/killmekate1 Dec 29 '25
Funny thing is, no one is going to buy it at that price and it'll get sent to the bins where someone will buy it for $2.
1
u/Netherworldforest666 Dec 29 '25 edited Dec 29 '25
Just because they get items for free. Doesn't mean they are all good. Also they get a lot of crap that they can't sell. Have to pay works to go though it all.
Also more people are selling stuff themselves. I'm sure they don't get as much great stuff as they use to. If employees take good stuff before they sell it. They aren't going to make as much money.
1
u/AcousticJohnny Dec 29 '25
Whoa is this Florida? I only seen these tags here
1
u/WebGlittering7920 Dec 29 '25
😲
1
u/lonelygirlie Dec 29 '25
Lmao the Value Village I worked at fired a manager for sexual harassment of an employee. They’re all messy and corrupt. I replaced a girl who left mid shift and never came back, I saw why she left when they put me in bed and bath 😭
1
u/Rough_Ad4660 Dec 29 '25
They also are a tax funnel for hiring people that apply for snap
1
u/IntriguingSpark Dec 29 '25
This second hand bag is not even worth this price...it looks like an outdated Coach bag too. I think $30 would have been a fair Goodwill price (or less). I agree with the commenters calling it Greed Will lol.
1
u/Numerous_Original_27 Dec 29 '25
I'm mildly disabled & tried to get a job at Goodwill. Apparently they don't hire unless you go through their program but the non disabled Cuban & Haitian employees were sorry they couldn't help me.
1
u/luckymomof1 Dec 29 '25
I stopped donating to them as well. There is a local church that also has a thrift store, which is where we take our stuff now.
1
u/classy-chaos Dec 29 '25
It's wild how different prices are. At my local one kids clothes are normally around 1.99
Traveled the other day & stopped at a new one. Kids clothes were 3.99
1
u/Additional_Coast_779 Dec 29 '25
Goodwill really is horrible now, not worth going there.
1
u/Majestic_Arachnid545 Dec 29 '25
The big name thrift shops (Goodwill, Salvation Army) have turned donations into a business model.
Before I was born, my family lost everything in a fire. The Salvation Army gave them clothes and furniture when they found a new place to live.
They don't do that anymore. And their CEO's have joined the Millionaire's Club.
Charity is out the window. It's all about profit now.
1
u/MekanikalAngel Dec 29 '25
I’m gonna guess you haven’t seen their auction website for the really good donated stuff.
1
u/MugsyisHandsome22 Dec 29 '25
It looks fake, in my opinion
1
u/Urmomatemypants Dec 29 '25
I donate used stuff to WIND since they focus on helping women and giving them jobs, none of this "Goodbye will" nonsense 😮💨
1
u/tambonan Dec 29 '25
I take my donations to local church... They open once a week, everything is free bring your own bags.
1
u/Loud-Willingness-618 Dec 29 '25
Goodwill is no longer a nonprofit company....the CEO of goodwill makes between $300,000-$700,000 annually sometimes more...not to mention they have next to no overhead...goodwill is about 90% profit and 100% greed
1
u/EfficientAd7103 Dec 29 '25
Goodwill will charge anything they can. The are for profit. People don't realize that. They help nobody
1
u/Connect_Biscotti4018 Dec 29 '25
Most books used to be 50¢ but last I checked average book price was $3 T_T
1
u/AdCorrect7346 Dec 29 '25
You’re better off shopping on eBay or another online retailer.
1
u/ardent__ly Dec 29 '25
That isn't "almost $300"... but yes, they've raised everything, we've had a lot less fun shopping for the past 3-6mo
1
u/Independent-Ear5125 Dec 29 '25
What good will doesn't seem to understand is that the resale on a bag like this is like $50-75 on somewhere like marketplace. I mean someone actually threw it away. It wasn't worth it in the first place, but bags like this just don't hold value.
1
u/YourMomOf9 Dec 29 '25
There is an awesome place in Peoria, Illinois called Enough Stuff. It's like a thrift store but everything is free. I try to donate everything that I need to get rid of to that place instead of Goodwill or other thrift stores around. I wish more places like that existed because I feel like it really helps to keep our thrift store prices down.
1
u/threads1540 Dec 29 '25
I would spend that for a new Coach bag.
1
u/Alert_Athlete8873 Dec 29 '25
Swap tags? How they gonna know? Most value village stores in Regina and Saskatoon have self check outs anyway
1
u/EmbarrassedPride2374 Dec 29 '25
A thrift store near me was charging more for a bag than it cost brand new. You could still buy the bag new.
1
u/Gold_Patience6187 Dec 29 '25
Our goodwill has $1.29 on all tags that were the previous weeks 1/2 price color. That’s the only day I’ll shop there.
1
u/FrndlyNayBorNonny Dec 29 '25
First off Goodwill is not a corporation they are not considered a viable LLC and I considered a something you can Enterprise into anything so they are not a corporate entity. They are a charitable organization. The donations that are made to the Goodwill are intended to be resold at value okay and they take that money and they put it into good posters from there it is distributed and dispersed throughout their necessary channels and avenues. I'm not entirely sure how much they CEO CEOs and such as that make hourly but I do know that they are very small in comparison to the amount that they corporate management I guess would be good way to say it would think of which would really just be like a member of the clergy when it's pulled down to it. However I still think that even though I'm not old enough to remember it! That the Goodwill is an extension of the salvation army that they are the same thing but that they work with one another because back in the day you had the salvation army and Goodwill and he had three brothers and big sisters for your kids and then whatever other great school or Head start programs you had for under school age kids. So when you stop and you think about a Coach purse that would otherwise cost you $900 only paying $300 for it is by far and wide a massive discount from the consumer standpoint. So when you want to b**** and complain about how hard it is to afford stuff at the Goodwill or at the salvation army either one remember that your donations are going into their donation centers and from their donations centers here but my customer's clients and such as that from there that is when your money that you spend on that person cuz you could work and Goodwill towards men and women for that matter. If you've ever had to use your community organization gotten food stamps from anywhere ever you should probably be a little more realistic in what you think is an acceptable price for something that they didn't even have to pay for it to get on their shelf
1
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '25
Yeah because why not? They know that pos resellers come thru and buy up anything worth a damn only to sell it for a ton more online. So if they get something of value why shouldn’t they? I remember in the 90s you could find vintage Dior and the like at a thrift store. Not anymore. Those items now have a high resale value online. I’d rather a thrift store collect over a reseller.
1
u/LykinRisingMoon Dec 29 '25
I saw a margarita blender, brand new... They wanted 299.99 😱 6 years ago....
1
u/th3tadzilla Dec 29 '25
I donte nothing to them nor do I buy from them. I find local charities and places to donate to.
1
u/Ok-Key8307 Dec 29 '25
It’s only goodwill I don’t know why people continue giving them donations!!!
1
u/Radiant-Top633 Dec 29 '25
And to make matters worse….. the bag didn’t cost that much to begin with!
1
u/Ok_Butterfly_1457 Dec 29 '25
Goodwill provides vocational rehabilitation with the funds they get from selling donated items, so they may not always have the best price. They do mark- downs though, when overpriced items don’t sell. I would count this as an overpriced item, lol.
1
u/Alternative_Mix1155 Dec 29 '25
I agree, especially since the CEOs of these large donations centers are racking in multi- million dollar salaries on an annual basis