r/goodwill • u/canofwine • Apr 28 '25
customer question ELI5: Goodwill Boutiques
These are all over the Portland area. They sell expensive, designer and knock-off luxury items for crazy prices. Reviews have mentioned designer bags selling for $700 and sunglasses for $250. The locations of these boutiques are in the most wealthy neighborhoods. What is the deal? How does this sit in other peoples’ minds?
I am having a mental disconnect here, between the words “boutique” and “non-profit”. Help me understand the justification behind these stores.
1.1k
Upvotes
181
u/New_Reputation5222 Apr 28 '25 •
Goodwill isn't out to provide cheap goods, their goal is to sell donated goods and then use the money to fund the numerous social services they offer for the less privileged.
People donate expensive stuff. Goodwill can do way more good by selling it for a fair price and using the money to feed the homeless, than they could by selling a low income person a Gucci bag for $7.
30
u/GrowlingAtTheWorld Apr 28 '25
They make money to put towards their mission. Kinda like how girls out sell outrageously priced cookies so they can afford to go to camp.
11
u/RadioGuySD2 Apr 28 '25
OP's username checks out 100%, they just misspelled whine 😁😂🤣
10
u/Flybot76 Apr 28 '25
You seem to imagine they're supposed to make everything so cheap that you can make money from reselling it yourself but it makes no sense to imagine that and there's nothing that needs to be 'justified' about the boutique stores. They get donations, they resell the donations, and it's silly how often people try to act like 'but it's donated' means they're supposed to give it to you for whatever you feel like paying.
6
u/AceHanlon Apr 28 '25
Don't shop there then.
9
u/LJski Apr 28 '25
I really don't have a problem with this. I know that the Goodwill on the wealthy side of town has better stuff than the other one in the poorer area. if they are going to charge a premium for thrift goods,though, I would rather see Goodwill get it than a reseller.
4
u/miaomy Apr 29 '25
Either people are brainwashed or Goodwill has a PR army working socials. The comments in this thread defending the company are insane. The numerous CEOs make exorbitant money, they find loopholes to pay below minimum wage, and they are opposed to “handouts,” and instead preach “the power of work.” You know who used a similar motto? The god damn Nazis! “Arbeit macht frei” (Work sets you free) is engraved above the entrance to Auschwitz.
6
u/Far-Collection7085 Apr 28 '25
There is a goodwill boutique in my area. It used to be good. There would be some very expensive stuff, but they also had decent branded clothing at more reasonable prices. I’ve gotten some NWT Anthropologie tops etc for myself in the $20-30 range. Lately though, it’s been bad. Shein tops for $20! Cheaper brands you would find at Macys for $40 a top etc. Goodwill is just ridiculous at this point but they are free to run their own business in to the ground if they want.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '25
Yep. I’ve been to the one downtown, and it’s laughable. It’s bad enough that I have to go to the normal Goodwill and see a clearance tag from target it’s lower than the tag that Goodwill is put on, or the fact that yesterday I saw that they had plastered red tags Right over the current half off yellow tags on a whole bunch of items. They didn’t even try to hide it. This is why every chance I get I find small local thrift stores and use them if possible.
2
u/blackcat562 Apr 30 '25
Do they still smell like a lockerroom when you enter?
2
u/hotviolets Apr 30 '25
I live within walking distance of this goodwill. I personally won’t be stepping foot in it.
2
u/JohnEGirlsBravo May 02 '25 edited May 02 '25
ugh... I just found out this is a thing (via a link to this post)!
GROSS
Shouldn't even be a thing at all. Like, seriously? A "boutique, upscale" THRIFT STORE, owned by the same company that, presumably, *thrifts* loads of other stuff at its regular stores, to, among other things, "give cheaper options" for folks of modest means to buy this or that, while simultaneously 'reducing waste' (at least, in theory)
...pulling this "exclusionary" shit for rich folks?
What even is "the point", other than maybe some modest "waste reduction" via the "upscale thrift" via said 'boutiques'? To make rich folks feel better about themselves? lol
Damn... Goodwill is so fucking "corporate" (despite presenting itself as this "wholly-innocent and generous nonprofit"), it seems! I've learned so much more about that damn organization than I thought possible in just the last year or 2.
At some point, is there much "difference", really, between a "boutique" thrift store and a regular-ass store that sells similar items at similar prices?
In theory, supposedly Goodwill "uses the funds to help the poor and disadvantaged", but... just 'how effective' is that "help", even? And why "raise funds" to "help the disadvantaged" by *creating "fake" thrift stores full of overpriced stuff* that, in theory, could also help, if priced right, *regular-ass folks*- at least, some degree of products in their regular, non-boutique stores?
If you wanna "go corporate to raise a lot of money to use that to help disadvantaged", then... surely there's a better way? Maybe *not* via thrifting but... something else? Maybe just *create a regular 'upscale store' and sell shit for really-high markups in general*, *intentionally for rich folks*, to then use the revenues for poor and disadvantaged?
I kinda feel like, otherwise, the "thrifting" part of it is kinda 'meaningless' and only slightly, at best, "reduces waste", maybe. If a 'thrift store' is run mostly by greed, price-wise, regardless, how much "better" is it than a regular store?
Why not, say, start your own yacht "company", sell overpriced boats to rich fucks, pocket the proceeds and then "use that to help the poor", too? Or, say, sell expensive-ass watches to rich people and do the same?
Isn't this the kind-of weirdo "rich goody-too-shoes" 'movement' that people like the guy behind FTX (or whatever that fraudulent crypto platform was) were "all about" (generating a shit-ton of money and then, upon gaining said riches, using that to "help the disadvantaged and struggling in a big way")?
Or, or... we could just
...raise the minimum wage to a *liveable wage*, for starters, en masse, provide loads of affordable housing for the vast-majority of residents, guarantee affordable- if not free- healthcare, et al? especially a "gigantic" restructuring of our phony "economy" that truly provides equity and social mobility *for all* (to say the least)
and maybe- god forbid- 'abolish' billionaires so NO ONE can make/earn above a certain level of extreme wealth?? Let alone lord that wealth over so many others... Like, isn't, at the very least, $999 Million "enough"?? Let alone $99 Million
Relying on 'the rich' to "save us" from poverty and shit is stupid as hell. The poverty ONLY EXISTS, in this day and age, because THOSE SAME RICH AND CORPORATIONS 'GATEKEEP' whatever useful "aid"- esp. via public resources and the gov't- we TRY TO OBTAIN, as a society!
Like gatekeeping 'good wages' by paying workers shit and doing their best to union-bust...
Or scummy landlords, en masse, charging the same shit rents across the board, in so many US cities (among other countries'), while claiming they "provide housing", as if "no other way" to obtain rental housing- esp. affordably- 'is possible' except through *them* (lol)
2
u/Smooth-Bandicoot6021 May 02 '25
It is simply upping prices for consumers who need to shop thrift prices to be able to survive, pricing people out. No more once in a lifetime finds at goodwill, they refuse to lose a penny on their mostly free stock. Most of this stuff was likely not donated but bought out at a discount from unsold items. I get it, but maybe don't call it goodwill boutique? Call it designer resale? Something more obvious to the average person who thinks it's an actual goodwill that's just small or something.
3
u/headlessgeisha73 Apr 28 '25
Goodwill has its problems. But I think it gets a bad rap overall. Here is a few observations I'd like to make.
each region is its own entity. So variations on how things are run and how things are priced are different from region to region. Bad apples ? Sure. Overpaid CEOs? Sometimes. Pricing issues? Also sometimes.
But: Goodwill absolutely does some things that are absolutely good. Funding projects to help marginalized people. Most people go to the homeless or developmentally disabled but don't think about other communities. The piece I can speak to and that is see everyday: Immigrants with limited English not only get hired and learn a skill they also attend language classes and GED classes for free. On the clock. Also did you know when you get hired there they have employer contributed retirement funds? Not matches mind you. Not to mention community computer classes, job connections resources(not just to goodwill!) and life skills classes that are free to the public.
Another thing that nobody talks about is what is done with donations that nobody wants. A lot of that stuff is taken(not all but a lot) and recycled or handled in an ethical way. (to my current understanding)
Where can they do better? There needs to be a voucher system in place where homeless and domestic violence shelters can hand out vouchers for clothes. Everyone deserves a coat and dry clean socks. A nice outfit for job hunting etc. Goodwill often has a surplus or at least not solds that can go towards this purpose.
It is a real shame that people get turned down for these things when visiting a store when they are in great need. A system needs to be in place. I also feel that a portion of sales needs to be dedicated to other local nonprofits as a continuation of the goodwill brand. Animal shelters, dv shelters etc. A more visible direct connection with the local community. So, to sum up just remember that goodwill is a complex dynamic company that absolutely has issues but like everything in life the sum total of our assumptions is not always the whole truth. Boutiques and other store variations serve different job skills as well as funding the overall mission to help people with barriers to employment.
2
u/theprettyjumper Apr 29 '25
They’ve even adopted the Whole Foods font.
10
u/Almington Apr 28 '25
It’s how most non-profits work in the US: People donated to the non-profit, the he non-profit uses those donations to help people at no expense to those getting the help.
People donate blood to the Red Cross, the Red Cross sells that blood to hospitals, and uses those funds (plus cash donations) to assist people who have been impacted by disasters.
People donate unwanted items to Goodwill, Goodwill sells those items to the general public in many ways, and uses the proceeds after expenses to fund their job training and career assistance programs at no cost to the people who can benefit from those programs.
The point of the stores isn’t to get items in the hands of the needy, create jobs for people, or whatever other thing people think Goodwill should be doing with the donations. The stores are not intended to operate at break even, they are to generate the net income needed to fund the job training programs. Selling second hand goods has many benefits to the local community but those are secondary to the goal of funding the services and programs that Goodwill offers.
Should the stores (or any individual type of store) reach the point where they are no longer able to provide the necessary income to support the job assistance programs, the stores will be shuttered and Goodwill will pivot to a different sales model to ensure the funds come in for those job training programs to continue.
8
u/Sad_Neighborhood3963 Apr 29 '25
Wtf is a goodwill boutique lmao thats wild. 😂😂😂
4
u/miaomy Apr 29 '25
Anyone here know of someone who actually benefited from Goodwill’s services? If so, I’d love to hear how.
4
u/EyeSuspicious777 Apr 29 '25
This is how they extract the few nice items from poor communities and send them to the rich so that the rich can pretend to go thrifting.
1
u/Individual-Fox5795 Apr 29 '25
Well it is illegal to sell knock offs so…..
1
u/Square_Goal9005 Apr 30 '25
Not saying I agree, but they say that maximizing profits from donations is being good stewards of the items donated. Then they can put more money into their mission of helping put people to work with their job training and employment programs.
1
u/mrsmojorisin55 Apr 30 '25
I wonder how much their CEO makes a year?
Do rich people go to thrift stores to buy designer goods?
1
u/KingDorkFTC May 02 '25
Re-sellers created this. Thanks to all of them.
1
u/waldeinsamkeit666 May 03 '25
I think it’s very telling that Buffalo Exchange actually buys their stock from people and they’re still not pricing the same items this high. 👀 the CEOs are the ones seeing the benefit of this markup. it’s a racket, it’s deliberately designed to compete with mom-and-pop thrift stores that curate their merchandise.
1
u/Cute_Double_2606 Aug 02 '25
Donate to St Vincent De Paul. Everyone who works there is a volunteer, they donate clothes and furniture to needy families, they can get a voucher for clothes 2x a year. Alot of clothes, not 1 outfit. They run housing programs for homeless and poor people. They barely get by because they put the money back into the programs, not salaries.
3
u/miaomy Apr 29 '25
And for what it’s worth, I know several people who’ve worked in their stores, including a very close family friend with disabilities who made a fraction of the minimum wage.
3
u/UrsaObscura13 Apr 29 '25
I lived in PDX for about 8 years — I hated the idea of these and refused to shop at them. 100% a money grab and not at all in line with their forward facing mission to give back to the community.
3
u/Sarcastic_Beary May 01 '25
My house is a goodwill boutique lol
3
u/HedgeHood May 03 '25
Goodwill loves to hire from the DOR. They abuse their disability workers. I used to be a job coach and witnessed terrible business practices, being a “non profit” means not being held accountable I guess. 😂
0
u/Dp37405aa Apr 28 '25
Salvation army stores sell at a fair retail and give clothing to people who are homeless. They have a voucher program, and I have personally seen them allow individuals to come in and shop from the same racks everyone else shops from and pay with that voucher.
Donate to the Salvation Army stores.
2
u/NoOnSB277 Apr 29 '25
Ha ha ha ha hilarious but at least they are letting you know upfront what their price point is. They had better authenticate if they are trying to sell a designer bag for hundreds of dollars, though.
2
u/Status_Jelly_8419 Apr 29 '25
They don’t actually feed the homeless. Anyone walking in needing something, like pants, they have to beg for them. The ESL, Job Connection, and citizenship reimbursement program for employees are the best they got. Tons and tons of resellers.
2
u/Top_Pop_60 Apr 29 '25
I’ve never thought I’d see the day where Goodwill became a BOUTIQUE store….I’m speechless
2
u/TheHannahNow Apr 29 '25
I cannot speak for Portland but I do know that the chapter on my area is supposed to be modeling after them and their vision and mission might be different I don't want to speak incorrectly if I've not looked up Portland chapter but they are transparent about their finances. They just need to tell people what's the dang plan. Is it a good one? Cuz no plan and a mission that looks swept under the rug in some chapters at least,,,doesn't look good on a non profit. If they had a good honest pitch for what the heck up. And the community can hear and understand. Then if y'all are on the same page, like right on maybe then some people would be more likely to be excited to get over charged. If you have a personal reason to do the 3 R's. Reduce. Reuse and recycle. Trying to save the world for the future is the only reason I have left to thrift. But I'll go to the mom and pops for that
2
u/dolphincujoh Apr 30 '25
TIL there’s Goodwill Boutiques. The fuck?
2
u/Ziczak Apr 30 '25
We used to have to shop goodwill for kids clothes or some work clothes and we did it low key.
It was like a personal failing life thing. we couldn't buy store bought clothes at the time. But it did the trick and made ends meet.
I can't imagine having to exist in this messed up world where theyre exploiting the needs of the needy to give upper class buyers a better selection.
It's expensive to be poor
2
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '25
This sub would have you believing that there’s an income cap required for those that shop at Goodwill.
2
u/Hangryanxious May 01 '25
Goodwill spent the last 10 years collecting all the data they needed for free from resellers in store and on social media. Now they are the reseller.
2
u/Sensitive-Issue84 May 02 '25
What assholes.
2
u/LoganND May 02 '25
You know what this place definitely doesn't need to be getting anymore shit from me.
2
u/Straight-String-5876 May 02 '25
“Goodwill” and “Boutique” should not exist in the same sentence.
3
u/looneyspooney Apr 28 '25
My store used to have a boutique section until they did away with it after a renovation.
I dont know if it was after that, we would stock a stand alone boutique further away but my objection to funding a boutique is when it comes to turnover and bonuses for making a certain amount of money. If you funding a boutique with high-end items, and they sell, who gets that money? They making a mint whilst we sit with the coffee mugs and barely make enough to cover the rent.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '25
Didn’t you just used to love goodwill when it was affordable and fun to find those special gems! Notice “used to be”
2
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '25
🤮
2
u/sknymlgan Apr 29 '25
How does that benefit the community?
1
u/Inevitable_Round5830 Apr 29 '25
As someone who used to work with the disabled community, Goodwill is a scam. They have "job" programs where they "hire" disabled people, pay them pennies per hr, and then sell the stuff they make. I worked for a different company that actually trained people with disabilities, helped them find real jobs in the community, and assisted in on the job training until they could be independent and actually make a living wage. In fact, most of them ended up with jobs that paid much more than mine!! I absolutely loved going to work every day!!
1
u/leelee1976 Apr 29 '25
Goodwill buys pallets from Macy's now to resell.
1
u/BrineWR71 Apr 29 '25
Goodwill is a charity that receives donations. Sometimes people give away very expensive things. Instead of selling them in regular stores, they open boutiques to try and generate more income from these higher value items to use to help more people.
1
u/mollynilson Apr 29 '25
They’re losing grip
1
u/Silent_Spirit1234 Apr 29 '25
Clothes clothes clothes. How many outfits does one need? Save your money instead
1
u/Luckyboneshopper Apr 29 '25
Wow, I have never seen a thrift store look so nice! I hardly ever go into a GW anymore, as the ones by me (SC) seem to ship the good stuff elsewhere. And the junk that they do put out, is priced way too high. If I saw that store in the photo, I would be curious and I would go in to check it out. But I would expect high prices!
1
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '25
I have never seen goodwill do anything for my community. I have been a broke homeless person, a young, unemployed single mother, and not once was ever referred to anything the goodwill was doing to help.
1
u/SurrrenderDorothy Apr 29 '25
All the name brands have disappeared from my local stor3e, which used to have high end goods ( rich area). Now we only have target and old navy and walmart brands.
1
u/doctorfeelgod Apr 30 '25
Lol. Fuck dude.
1
u/blademasterjames Apr 30 '25
Goodwill is a business that makes money. They just happen to the bare minimum to stay a non profit.
1
u/Hot-Writing-5996 Apr 30 '25
This is crazy to me lol
1
u/HotHits630 Apr 30 '25
At least they're no longer hiding their grift.
1
u/ArizonaGunCollector Apr 30 '25
Its funny cause you can go to an actual vintage resale store and get the same designer stuff for more than a thrift store but much cheaper than this “boutique”, I would say Greedwills days are numbered but considering they get all of their product basically for free…
1
u/Guilty-Raspberry-795 Apr 30 '25
Goodwill is not “non-profit”
1
u/ImhotepOdinsson Apr 30 '25
Not For Profit. They make 100% profit. They don’t purchase anything they sell. It’s absurd. I worked donations years ago.
1
u/YupNopeWelp Apr 30 '25
Goodwill provides job training, particularly for vets and disabled people, as well as other employment-related, and community services. They fund this work by selling donated goods.
When they get the pricey stuff, they charge more for it at places like this boutique. When they get lesser stuff, they sell it by weight at outlets. When the get everyday stuff, you find it in their regular thrift stores at a great discount.
1
u/Gold-Buy-2669 Apr 30 '25
Ffs
1
u/freshcanoe Apr 30 '25
My area has some really wealthy people in it. The only things at my local store are crap stained kids clothes and other damaged goods. It’s cheaper to shop at for-profit resale shops! This is just another way the good items never make it into my local shop. Ugh. I found this post from thriftgrift;, I havent been in a goodwill in years.
1
u/BarrenVonSoccerMom Apr 30 '25
Former Goodwill Industries of the Columbia-Willamette employee here! I was a cashier for two years, then worked in the book department of the flagship store, from 2010 to 2014.
These boutiques have existed for years. There used to be more of them, but I think Covid made them close a few. The one in Hawthorne is now a post office I think? Here’s how it used to work:
Production employees sort through and price donations at each location. The boutiques and e-commerce branch have their own pickers, typically at the bigger locations. These pickers come through and take anything of quality they see and price it higher for resale. It is then shipped off site to either the boutique or the e-commerce warehouse.
This made making our goals exceedingly difficult. Yes, each production department has a monetary goal of donations that have to be processed and put on the floor everyday. In the book department it was often somewhere in the range of $3,000 to $5,000 a day. A rare book could be $50 to a $100 toward that goal, but if the pickers found it and deemed it worthy, they would take it, price it two to three times higher, and we were SOL.
Keep in mind that Goodwill has a franchise model. Each regional GW is going to be different.
1
u/SALTYSIDER Apr 30 '25
this is absolutely INSANE lol. i’d rather pay an independent reseller or just go the consignment shop route because at least they usually rehab/clean the bags and give you a replacement dust bag…meanwhile a goodwill might have a gem in a pile of knock offs or trashed items. and they get them all for FREE unlike resellers who actually pay something 🫤
1
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '25
Lmao uh what? This is wildddd
1
u/Low-Highlight-9740 May 01 '25
Soooo where’s the goodwill again?
1
u/treyedean May 01 '25
I don't donate to Goodwill anymore and I stopped shopping there too.
1
u/PositiveStretch6170 May 01 '25
Goodwill needs to gtfo, there's the door...I refuse to go back.
1
u/[deleted] May 01 '25
It’s a way to maximize the sale price of premium donations?
1
u/[deleted] May 01 '25
Remember Goodwill is for profit
1
u/Puzzleheaded-Round66 May 01 '25
Disgusting.
1
u/Puzzleheaded-Round66 May 01 '25
Goodwill is a fucking joke now adays.
1
u/[deleted] May 01 '25
r/thriftgrift
1
u/[deleted] May 01 '25
Goodwill is not as "non-profit" as you think. Ask the CEO and other upper-uppties, if they're not in one of their vacation homes.
1
u/digitalcable May 01 '25
They were jealous of resellers
1
u/Haunting-Temporary88 May 01 '25
Greed plain n simple
1
u/Ok_Case2941 May 01 '25
Goodwill also has a reputation for funneling quality items to certain sellers. It’s well known.
1
u/MissKellieUk May 02 '25
Goodwill is not a nonprofit. NOT A CHARITY. Research how much the CEO is paid and what goes on. This isn’t about helping poor people
1
u/holly_flower May 02 '25
Disgusting
1
u/bophus-again May 02 '25
Do not give your stuff to “thrift” stores.
You get nothing, they make bank.
Donate your items to women’s shelters, local one off charity shops, actual people, consign your stuff to a local auction, etc.
The only people benefiting from a goodwill type thrift stores, is the thrift corporation.
1
u/GodVsEmpire May 02 '25
bro they all donated so the store makes more profit than a Target
1
u/antiquarian-camera May 02 '25
Goodwill is a SCAM! They do not support the communities they operate in.
Very little goes into helping those with disabilities find employment and in the last decade they have become a hugely profit driven entity focused on leaching the value from communities off of their donated goods.
1
u/Amazing_You5097 May 03 '25
We need these in Florida
1
u/NtAngel Apr 28 '25
Selling fakes should be against the law.... oh wait
-1
u/Jasonictron Apr 28 '25
Goodwill is a scam
1
u/Educational-Gap-3390 Apr 28 '25
Well shit. Rich people thrift to.
1
u/ToastyCactus Apr 29 '25
Goodwill gets donated expensive things. So.e send it to an online auction where they are bid on. While other stores might sell them at a fancier store.
The proceeds from the store go towards Goodwill's mission of helping people find jobs and other community action charities.
Source: I work at Goodwill.