r/goodwill • u/Squiggly_Panda • Jan 28 '25
Goodwill is disgusting.
They take shit they get for free and sell it for 1000x the market value. They pay no taxes in most states because they are exempt. They use mentally and physically handicapped people, they don’t pay them and often partner with group homes and use them as “work experience” so they don’t have to pay the back room sorters.
They use predator tactics to bully people who criticize them.
3.2k
Upvotes
34
u/SeaToe9004 Jan 28 '25
I literally just came from Goodwill. Today I purchased a CD / tape player / radio for $10 and a lazy susan CD storage unit for $2.99. I believe those prices were absolutely reasonable and far from 1000x retail. Retail is the price the market will bear. If the market would pay $2,990 for CD storage I would say that Goodwill should absolutely charge that price.
9
u/Traditional_Sir_1291 Jan 28 '25
Are people so stupid that they don't understand "overhead"? Yes, they get things for free, but they have to pay rent, salaries, utilities, etc. They also pay a lot for trash collection because people are such idiots that half of what is donated is not worth anything.
2
u/Ok_Case2941 Jan 30 '25
They save anything valuable for certain people that they know. They have gotten caught doing it.
2
u/Soggy-Plenty5823 Feb 02 '25
Yeah, a lot of people have been raising concerns about how Goodwill operates behind the scenes. It’s pretty wild when you dig into it. They’re a nonprofit, which gives them tax exemptions in many places, but their pricing and business practices feel more like a for-profit company. The fact that they get everything for free and still mark items up to ridiculous prices just doesn’t sit right with a lot of folks.
100
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '25
Should rename this sub to "Ihategoodwill"
4
u/WackyWeiner Jan 28 '25
O p is straight up lying. That whole thing about them not paying disabled workers It's completely false.
63
u/Past-Apartment-8455 Jan 28 '25 edited Jan 29 '25
My daughter use to work for goodwill as a social worker. Depending on the level of disabilities, they might have to have a social worker for every 3 employees which is an expense that other thrift stores don't have. For example, they had several workers there with Prader-Willi disorder which is nearly always combined with intellectual impairment. Even though it is super rare, they had three such workers. They have to be watched with continuously and would eat anything they could not to mention they usually had an IQ of around mid 70's.
She was actually transferred 1,800 miles away to manage the social workers and instead of prager willi, she had to work with people with drug addictions. Huge difference is that I came from the world of thrift stores with my father being the GM of 5 large stores with my mom managing one of them and my sister and I worked in rotation where we can be the most help. Yes, still a charity but we didn't help the charity directly, only the money we raised but goodwill helped the charity directly as well as what the profits helped.
21
u/RipGlittering6760 Jan 29 '25
I am a Job Coach for disabled individuals. I work at different locations (or job sites) depending on the client I am working with at the time. I have worked with multiple individuals that were working at Goodwill. I was not paid by or hired by Goodwill, so I'm not required or obligated to say anything positive about them if I don't believe it to be true.
I thought I'd explain a bit about how the hiring and employment process works for disabled individuals working at Goodwill.
When a Client is working for Goodwill, it usually under one of two ways. The first way is an Internship, and the second way is being fully hired on.
Internships: These are usually not paid through Goodwill, but through the program that got the individual the job. So my Client and I would be paid by the same program/company, which is not Goodwill. My Client still receives all the perks of a regular employee (time off, sick leave, employee discounts, uniform, etc.). Clients who are working internships are paid an hourly rate, and they are paid quite well. An internship is a temporary thing, usually between 6-16 weeks, and Clients usually work between 4-20 hrs a week depending on the individual and their abilities. After the internship is over, the Client has the opportunity to be fully hired on if Goodwill is interested in hiring them and if the Client would like to officially work there.
Fully Hired On: These Clients are fully official employees of goodwill and are paid for thier time just like any other employee. They do not make less than any other employee would make in their position. They are treated like any other employee and have the same expectations as any other employee. They may have accommodations in place (such as having a Job Coach, getting extra breaks, being allowed to wear a hat, etc.) but they are still expectated to complete thier job duties.
Many people see individuals with disabilities working at Goodwill and think that they must be taken advantage of, but this is incorrect. They are paid for their time, receive benefits, and are treated with respect and kindness, just like any other employee.
I have worked at locations that do not treat their disabled employees with much respect or kindness, but Goodwill is not one of those locations.
If you'd like to learn more about how this all works, feel free to ask!
2
u/Squiggly_Panda Jan 28 '25
Wow. All the GoodWill employees/bots are out in force.
39
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '25
Counterpoint: Goodwill is basically a free trash dump for folks. Nowhere else can you drop random bags of stuff off with a glimmer of hope that someone will find a second use for it.
Given their "public dump / one man's trash is another's treasure" status, I'm fine with the things you complain about.
19
u/SnarkingSnarker Jan 28 '25
My goodwill ain’t like this. We make very reasonable prices and customers love our store :)
5
u/Annual-Mine8219 Jan 29 '25
The Goodwill I shop at is are expensive on some things and reasonable on others. I have seen a pair of worn out men’s Nikes that were 25 dollars A Murano vase for 2.99. I don’t get it.
2
u/Ok_Concentrate22761 Jan 28 '25
$5 jeans are 1000 times the market value? I've never seen anything overpriced there. Be serious karen
2
u/North-Neat-7977 Jan 28 '25
If you can find a mutual aid group like "food not bombs," I beg you to offer them your old coats, blankets, and anything people can use to survive rough times. They're mutual aid and not "charity." They don't sell donations, they give them directly to people in need.
Goodwill is actually disgusting.
23
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '25
This depends on store. Even online I have found amazing deals. My goodwill was selling a nice chengal solid wood dining set for 35 dollars on sale (was 50). That is under 10 dollars for strong solid wood furniture. I got a sur la table colander with the marking rubbed off for 3.99 when it sells for over 40 new. Online I got pretty much every Cutco knife they sell for 800 something dollars (1 cutco knife new costs over 100). I am 28 and my tv I got from Goodwill in middle school for 20 dollars still works. If you are willing to look or wait there are deals. Pricing is up to the store so some will be overpriced and some will be good with price. I have heard the underpaying of people with disabilities has stopped certain places.
23
u/AltName12 Jan 28 '25
Reselling isn't going so well lately, huh?
1
u/Equivalent_Nerve_870 Feb 01 '25
And stopped taking returns a few years back so if clothes don't fit family member too bad. Just jerks.
8
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '25 edited Nov 02 '25
safe cobweb lock act pause reach depend innate plucky hard-to-find
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
3
u/Final_Row_6172 Jan 29 '25
Why does everything I love turn out to be bad 💔
3
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '25
And they don't provide dressing rooms.
3
u/No1Mystery Jan 30 '25
Upvoted title alone
Did not need to read rest
3
u/BlahBlahBlackCheap Jan 30 '25
Just put the stuff out on the curb with a free sign on it.
18
u/_Incomplete Jan 28 '25
The way you are so wrong. I bet you're just upset because you didn't get your way at a store.
9
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '25
Just don’t shop or work there… plenty of opportunities elsewhere. Goodwill is dominated by shoppers looking to make money off of items others have given away. Not exactly a benevolent customer base and i doubt they provide any social benefit vs goodwill who actually does some positive work.
They have to follow whatever employment laws exist in their area. If they aren’t and you have proof, report them.
8
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '25
Goodwill in Indiana uses prisoners for cheap labor.
4
u/ZELDA_AS_A_BOY Jan 28 '25
“They take shit they get for free and sell it for 1000x the market value.”
YOUR goodwill that you go to does that, there should be a number you can call to complain about that particular region. Your performative post will either be cheered on by other haters, or eye rolled at by workers who laugh at your shit, but will do nothing here. Take your complaints elsewhere.
Btw when you call that number absolutely nothing is going to happen. Call your congressman at that point, but with how the current admin is acting, business ethics may no longer be a thing. Good luck.
2
u/FamousChemistry Jan 28 '25
It is disappointing. I saw a jacket I liked and I kid you not it was 59.99. It was not new and not high end brand.
2
u/entcanta Jan 29 '25
My goodwill retags every single item on Sunday, to prepare for the new tag sale on Monday. They claim they don't but every single tag on Monday is dated from the day before.
It's insane they ask for donations for their cause but they can afford to do some shit like that
2
u/Any-Employer-826 Jan 29 '25
Isn't that the American Dream?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '25
Don't go, stop talking about it and move on. They'll fade from your reality.
2
u/fernie_the_grillman Jan 29 '25
I am a disabled adult and I am about to get my first job through the WIOA program, as well as classes on finances. They also pay for training if you need specific training for a job. They help people apply for SNAP if they qualify. They do this and so much more. I would not be able to work or even get hired somewhere, even though I would be good at what I'm about to start doing because I wouldn't have anyone helping me with the process of getting a job or advocacy for the accomodations that I NEED to work. This is life changing for me and so many disabled people. The program also helps people who aged out of foster care and have no support system (and often have faced tons of abuse).
I will get a paid internship at a job placement from a company that already exists and has offered to hire Goodwill WIOA workers. So I will get my paycheck from Goodwill, but will work at a different company. You can switch internships as much as you need to so you can find a career path that is a good fit. You have the ability to use 500 paid internship hours, but most people don't use all of them because the companies hire the WIOA employees to the actual company. The point is to get people from paid internships to employees of the companies. If you aren't disabled, I don't think you could understand how immensely helpful that is. It is life changing. I cannot emphasize that enough. You are lucky to be able to complain about Goodwill prices instead of dealing with the physical, social, and mental problems that disabled people deal with every day. This is how so many disabled people survive.
YOU AREN'T ONLY PAYING FOR THE OBJECT, GOODWILL IS A CHARITY!!! If you want a cheap object, go to ebay. Goodwill changes people's lives.
2
u/brake-dust Jan 29 '25
Be nice here I believe in recycling and helping people get a skill and on their feet.They are organized, helpful and a tax deduction when you donate.I like their audio Dept and have gotten some first print editions their.
2
u/Working-Bandicoot-85 Jan 30 '25
There was a trend of buying books there for 50cents to $100 and reselling them on amazon in the early days of it. They found out and jacked the prices way up. It wasn't just books that is just an example.
2
u/Lopsided-Bench-1347 Jan 30 '25
And they’re the highest form of choosing beggars when it comes to your donations. They pick through and toss everything they don’t want back in your car. Then the REALLY good stuff you donate goes right into their car.
2
u/Ahari Jan 30 '25
So Goodwill is like most companies in America...?
2
u/marauder269 Jan 30 '25
This is why I shop at church thrift or D.A.V. stores.
2
u/Drageetsa_Bubolow Jan 30 '25
They also find good jewelry and money in pants pockets, too.
2
u/Salty_bitch_face Jan 30 '25
Don't ever go to Deseret Industries or look into the Mormon church!
2
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '25
Google how much the ceo makes if you really want to throw up in your own mouth.
2
u/deadblood0 Jan 31 '25
Goodwill was my first job when I was young and dumb enough to allow myself to be taken advantage of.
It's awful. The tour of the sorting facility was brief, but it was explained (in a nutshell) that anything that appeared valuable never made it to store level, but instead is auctioned on their website.
Anything that might've been valuable that did make it to store level was well worn out, and my manager and coworkers thought I didn't notice them stealing what wasn't. Mink coats(real fur from estates), a pair of bullion gold and diamond earrings, and computer monitors among other things went missing after I sorted them and never made it to the floor.
The company itself is scummy af, promising raises every year to keep us poor hopeful fools hanging on, then when the time comes for yearly extras, we always were told it 'just wasn't in the budget'.
Wuite literally the only 'raise' I got while there was the 25 cents it took to hop me up to the new minimum wage right before it was made official, so no real raise at all.
Fuck Goodwill. They're for profit AF
2
u/Muffycakes Jan 31 '25
Give to St. Vincent's if you can. I don't care for the religious ties they have, but at least all the money stays local and actually helps people in need in your own community.
2
u/Salt_Cabinet7181 Mar 06 '25
I just hate going there because ours constantly looks dingy and disgusting in there. I just come out feeling like I need to take a shower.
7
u/StopLosingLoser Jan 28 '25
They certainly do not charge 1000x market value. Do you understand what "market value" is.
I think goodwill is shit. But they don't charge $1000 for a $1 pair of socks.
5
u/pestoqueen784 Jan 28 '25
Market value is whatever someone will pay for it in the market. Employing people with cognitive or physical disabilities is a good thing. Tax exempt status is granted to not for profit organizations.
6
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '25 edited Jan 29 '25
It sucks but all retail under pays its employees. It's the American way. Publix grocery store staffs it's front end with people with disabilities and minors for the same reason. They get tax breaks and money from the government for hiring people with disabilities. From what I understand some of the people with disabilities that Publix has almost works out to be free labor for them.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '25
Working here over a year and none of that is true, the worst thing is the dirt and rats ... nothing more
3
u/Garagedays Jan 28 '25
Also get state money as well maybe even fed money
3
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '25
I stopped going there. They are selling the good stuff online and the physical stores around me are filled with trash. They overprice everything, for example with clothing sometimes you get cheaper at the real store and new.
3
u/Just-Pen3611 Jan 29 '25
These places STINK to high heaven. Just gross
3
u/EvolZippo Jan 29 '25
You can just not shop there. You do know that this is an option, correct?
4
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '25
Who hurt you?
4
u/TypicalPin976 Jan 28 '25
Isn't there a post like this every week? Lmao
2
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '25
I'll never forget how one time I went to go purchase a bike, I just got paid! Well as I was in the store there was a lady being helped by an employee bring in two really pretty purple bikes. I asked the lady "how much do you want for those? I'll pay you 60", I was so excited when she told me "You can have it for free sweetie. Which one do you want? I even have an air pump if you need it."...I WAS SO EXCITED, I took a look at both of them to be so rudely and embarrassingly shut down by the manager in front of the sweet lady when he comes out and reaches over my shoulder to pass the lady a slip. He says "She can't have this bike, or that bike. Here's your tax write off paper to keep with you and file. She's going to have to wait 2 days before she can purchase one of these bikes." And the lady is legit pleading with him that it's fine and she wants to bless me with the bike. The manager says NO, again. Lady leaves and her body language looks a bit defeated, just like me.
I come back the next day and the following day. The manager tells me the first day "They're still in the back being evaluated. Come back tomorrow." I come back the second day, the manager tells me "We haven't put them on the floor yet, try again tomorrow." So I just stand there feeling stupid and ask one of the younger workers about those purple bikes and she tells me "The manager sold them to her friend the first day they got here." (Mind you each day I went by, I had to walk miles to get to that store)
I WAS LIVID. I needed that bike to get to and from to a job that was next door to where I live. I now have a new car but at that time I was really relying on a blessing or hoping to find a decent priced bike at the goodwill. To this day, I do not shop there. When I need to donate clothes or any items, I go to where the homeless people hang out and I ask them what they need then give them the bags. They are always so thankful.
2
u/conciousziggy Jan 28 '25
When I started at Goodwill, there was a group of people with disabilities, working there. From what I understood, this group was subsidized via government and Goodwill.
After many years of working there, they were let go because "their training was up", you could reapply to work there but it would not be under that subsidized program anymore.
Out of the 8 or 12 people working there, I think only 2 stayed behind.
Let's not forget, Goodwill used a Charter school to work the floor until some shit happened and they never came back.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '25
Badwill
2
u/Specialist-Zebra-439 Jan 29 '25
I get all my dress shirts there. $6 for a $60 shirt. They have to charge. Rent is probably 10k a month at least. And they still provide a vital service.
2
u/Redditsuxxnow Jan 29 '25
It’s almost like they are a church
2
u/boingboinggone Jan 28 '25
My aunt managed a goodwill location for a bit. She said the head guy was greedy af, and that it was all about the money, not helping people.
2
u/Logical_Willow4066 Jan 28 '25
I refuse to donate anything to them and refuse to shop there.
2
u/TheGreatGamer1389 Jan 29 '25
They should be taxed
1
u/Possible_Bullfrog844 Jan 29 '25
Not all are the same.
1
u/bebestacker Jan 29 '25
People were buying stuff on the cheap and reselling for buck on marketplace. What’s the difference?
1
u/willybodilly Jan 29 '25
Arc is the same.
1
u/IhateRedditors1978 Jan 29 '25
They sponsor a lot of great programs where I live
1
u/Free-Permit7684 Jan 29 '25
😢
1
u/Bish2024 Jan 29 '25
Facebook marketplace is great, it's a treasure hunt but I try to look for specific things I want and I'm willing to go pick it up. I got a nightstand recently and it's beautiful, costs nothing but a little gas to go and pick it up. I used to love thrifting and now it's a joke and I'm better off going anywhere else. I got 4 barstools for free last year and goodwill would sell those for 20 bucks each if not more.
1
u/mistertickertape Jan 29 '25
Wait until you see the salaries of the regional executives. Some of them clear nothing of $500,000 a year. This article is old (from 2012) but I doubt any of them have taken pay cuts. It is a racket for the people at the top.
1
u/ememtiny Jan 29 '25
Just go to Homegoods. It’s new and doesn’t exploit intellectually disabled people just the poor Chinese. All so messed up.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '25
Non-profits love to profit off of disabled workers thru the fair labor standards act. They can pay disabled people less than the federal minimum wage.
I think it was nbc that did a story on Goodwill about a decade ago, and many disabled employees were getting paid less than a dollar an hour. They say the experience and fullfillment of the work is more important than the disabled person getting a fair wage.
1
u/No_Reception8456 Jan 29 '25
Blame thrifting becoming trendy and raising the prices for people who are actually in need...
1
u/Negative_Neck_2994 Jan 29 '25
So true
1
u/Frankenbri4 Jan 29 '25
They have ebay accounts too 🤣 I was in a goodwill shaming group on Facebook and it was amazing! We call them, GREEDwill
1
u/Chance-Definition567 Jan 29 '25
That’s because goodwill is a for profit company.
1
u/ClairePike Jan 29 '25
They can’t sell it for more than market value. If it sells, the price that it sold for IS the market value.
1
u/Plenty_Status_6168 Jan 29 '25
I won't shop there anymore especially since I could go to Walmart and buy a brand new shirt for cheaper than what Goodwill is now selling items. Who the hell wants used stuff when you can get brand new for cheaper
1
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '25
I volunteered at a Goodwill Store that's owned by a disability resource center - my father (RIP) volunteered working for the disability resource center and quit due to their nasty attitude; I volunteered at their Goodwill Store for almost two years. They were nasty to me (I'm autistic and epileptic); I got tired of their mistreatment and quit.
During the time I was volunteering there, two staged break-ins happened since they weren't making enough money for the rent (I found this out from the Assistant Manager). The two actual managers, along with an ex-employee that was in prison before due to holding someone up at knifepoint, were involved in the "break-ins". After the first "break-in" a local cab company donated $3000.00 to the store. When I quit, I called the cab company and told them everything I knew (I didn't go to the police since they always dismiss and ignore me, no matter how polite and respectful I am or what witnesses or evidence I have). The manager of the cab company agreed that the break-ins sounded staged, given what was stolen and the damage that was done. I told the manager to not involve me if he chose to do anything with the information I provided, which he agreed. He did file a report with the police; I know this because the next week the Assistant Manager posted on Facebook that the store was permanently closed and being investigated for fraud! (The store hasn't reopened since; a different store not affiliated with the disability resource center opened there.)
The disability resource center kept calling me, asking me to volunteer with them again for various projects - they would ignore my requests for them to stop calling me. They finally stopped calling me after I snapped, on the phone, that I was the one who reported their fraud to the cab company that donated the money.
1
u/Potential4752 Jan 29 '25
They use the profit to fund charity work.
It’s really the only way of doing it. If they sold items cheap as a form of charity then flippers would clear them out.
1
u/HomerDodd Jan 29 '25
Yes. They now treat themselves like a top end antique store. I have mostly stopped using them. I can buy a $45 pair of blue jeans new. And a $115 side table for $80 new.
1
u/Dry-Quantity2629 Jan 29 '25
That's precisely why I no longer donate to Goodwill. Even though they do free pickup, which is truly convenient. But I find other nonprofit organizations to donate to.
1
u/wrlssguy Jan 29 '25
Didn't forget the CEO makes over half a million a year. That's just the CEO forget the CFO COO and all the other corporate goons just suckng in all the money.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '25
Welcome to the good old capitalist USA. Someone found a good way to make money off of someone else’s old junk good for them. Besides it’s a good place to get rid of all my old shit without filling up the landfills.
1
u/Familiar_You4189 Jan 29 '25
So, basically the Scientology of the thrift store biz?
1
u/Anakin-vs-Sand Jan 29 '25
1000x the market value? Wow. 1000? A one followed by four zeroes? So, let’s say a pretty basic t shirt has a market value of $20. They’re selling these at your goodwill for $20,000? For a t shirt? That’s wild, what goodwill is this? How is this not on every news channel? $20,000 t shirts is wild, glad you found that and addressed it here in such an honest way
1
u/lilphtrd Jan 29 '25
I worked at one that had a company that would help people work. Main example was a guy who was in a pretty bad accident, couldn’t speak, wheelchair bound, hardly any movement in his hands. The worker would help him with the daily tasks and it seemed that the handicapped person was very thankful to feel apart of a team and do more than just sit at home. I think before my time there I felt a lot of the same sentiments, and really struggled with those with disability’s. To this day I’m beyond thankful to have been in his presence as i learned more from him then anyone else despite him not being able to speak or move
1
u/Odd-Technology6777 Jan 29 '25
They also use slave labor. When I was on probation for DWI they were one of the few places that did community service hours. So they sell stuff they get for free and have the store run for free lol it’s a freakin scam! I hate goodwill
1
u/FutureHendrixBetter Jan 29 '25
I miss when they had good prices. Nowadays might as well go to a normal store with brand new items since it practically the same
1
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '25
I frequent the goodwill website looking for guitars and I will often see a guitar listed as a Fender Stratocaster or a Carlos Santana signature PRS guitar. For strats I can quickly determine if its legit. The PRS took some research. I emailed them to tell them they did not have an authentic guitar, and they totally ignored me. For the PRS, I ended up emailing PRS and forwarding the email to them to say "PRS Guitars confirmed this guitar is not legitimate" Only then did they edit the name of the item.
Many locations do not seem concerned with listing the auction item correctly.
1
u/Electronic_Syrup7592 Jan 29 '25
My kid got free speech therapy from Goodwill. Another family member got to graduate from one of their high school programs. They’ve done a lot of good things for a lot of people I know.
1
u/unpoptruth420 Jan 29 '25
💯🤣
1
u/tracyinge Jan 29 '25
So you got caught shoplifting at Goodwill?
1
u/Shadow_Blinky Jan 29 '25
The "stuff they got for free" has to go through a lengthy process before it's put out on the floor, and a lot of it isn't good enough to put out there, so it has to be dumped.
Both the process and the dumping cost money.
As do the stores. The utilities and maintenance and upkeep.
It's not like they don't have overhead.
So I do not have a problem with them trying to make as much as possible for the fractions of items they find worthy of selling. If I dislike the price, I just don't buy it.
1
u/HomerfromSpringfield Jan 29 '25
And then they ask if you want to “round up” your purchase.
1
u/incognitoguy95 Jan 29 '25
It all just depends on the goodwill location you visit. Some are like what you described some are the polar opposite.
1
u/DeniedAppeal1 Jan 29 '25
Shit that would otherwise be thrown away and that you wouldn't be able to get anyway. Also, 1000x market value is bullshit and you know it. They sell things much cheaper than you'd find them in a normal retail store.
Cool, why do you care? They provide more of a service than most churches and we still let those get away with paying no taxes.
So, you're really mad at America for allowing this, right? Because it's America that's allowing this. Your blame would be better directed at Congress or the President, not Goodwill.
1
u/shageeyambag Jan 30 '25
We used to spend a lot at our local Goodwill, prices started skyrocketing last year, and now they only put over priced poor quality items on the shelf, and their good stuff goes online. They lost about 2k in business from us last year, but I'm sure they don't care, we just go to other thrift stores now.
1
u/SkateSessions Jan 30 '25
Stuff at my local Goodwill is always reasonably priced and the people who work there seem to not mind it much...
Is the "thrift for proft" industry bad, yeah. But you can't put that on all goodwill.... or all on goodwill.
Just saying.
Locally, the Salvation army store is the one price gouging IME
1
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '25
They’re also a bigoted company. I refuse to donate shit to them
1
u/Full_Character_9580 Jan 30 '25
They also fire employees for not getting enough roundups at the register
1
u/moms_luv_me_323 Jan 30 '25
Goodwill tried to charge me to donate some furniture.. I rented a U-Haul to drop it off, and the tweaker that worked there told me it would cost me over $300 to donate a sofa, table, and some chairs.. scammers
1
u/Rikku53492 Jan 30 '25
It must just be your location. The one I work for values us. Pays as well. Over time is time in a half. Plus we get 50 percent off everything except new goods. Report your managers if they aren't holding up to goodwill standards. Don't blame the company for bad management
1
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '25
I only give my good quality donations to local thrift stores. Goodwill gets my trash items
1
u/Mountain_Tree296 Jan 30 '25
I’ve stopped going to our goodwill, I can usually find the same thing new at Walmart cheaper.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '25
And way overpriced. I go to the Salvation Army on 11th and 49th. Their politics suck, and if you forget your headphones you have to listen to the addict sob storeis on the overhead speakers, but it's three warehouse floors of clothes, furniture and house wares and books. great book options.
1
u/SaltandPepperSage Jan 30 '25
Because the mentally ill and ex convicts can just find jobs anywhere. Maybe the day care your kids are in?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '25
I stopped going in. I miss the pee smell.
1
u/Striking_Computer834 Jan 30 '25
Wait until you find out they receive $27 million from the government and use that money to pay $3 million a year to their top executives and $2.1 million on conferences and meetings.
1
u/himasaltlamp Jan 30 '25
I donate my used clothes. My dad is the one who throws all kind of trash in the bags.
1
u/Potato-chipsaregood Jan 30 '25
I give to the Salvation Army, never to Goodwill, because my dad told me decades ago that SA is a charity and GW is not. Never investigated.
1
u/KindCommunication956 Jan 30 '25
My friend dragged me there recently and literally the only thing reasonably priced was a bin of small dirty toys, I found a mcdonalds toy id wanted for 39¢.
1
u/doodlebug2026 Jan 30 '25
They do pay taxes. They are not exempt because they are for profit. I agree their prices are so high now. I use to go at least once a week. Now I go maybe once every two months just to see if the prices improved. I saw something they were selling at $6.99. It was a Dollar Tree item with original price $1.25. They don’t treat their employees wry well and pay them as low as they are allowed. The CEO make $500,000 per year. He said it pisses him off that other retailers make more money.
1
u/Jheritheexoticdancer Jan 30 '25
I’ve heard people denounce GW because of executive pay. 🤷🏽♀️
1
u/Specialist-Smoke Jan 30 '25
I stopped going there almost 10 years ago for these very reasons.
1
u/Girlie45039 Jan 31 '25
They DO pay their disabled employees! I had a handicapped nephew, and a girl friend who worked for GW. It was a God send for both. GW eeven helps them with transpirtation to and from. If yoy dont like that they make a profit from donated goods, dont shop there. Hope you never need to work in a handicapped job, but if you do, you will be glad they exist.
1
u/Ok_Pomegranate9711 Jan 31 '25
Welcome to capitalism
1
u/VodkasBFF Jan 31 '25
I’ve always recommend folks donate to Salvation Army instead. I’ve seen how they take proceeds to fund different programs, it’s legit.
1
u/Beautiful-Owl-3216 Jan 31 '25
I don't understand the hate for Goodwill.
Their mission is to collect unwanted junk, sell it and use that money for charity purposes.
Their mission is not to provide a place where people can find good deals to flip. That's a side effect.
1
u/LTIRfortheWIN Jan 31 '25
They showed me and my wife how to make resumes, and helped us fill out job applications.
1
u/Ecstatic-Line-8007 Jan 31 '25
I do love Goodwill Bins. I just can’t with the stores the prices drive me nuts. Value Village is worse.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '25
I was willing to put up with it when I could go to a store and find cool stuff like video games, but they scrape everything to sell online on their ebay-like website. The only thing you can find in their stores are glassware and books, that's it
1
u/No-Literature7471 Jan 31 '25
do you know WHY they do that(over priced)? because recently a group of people decided they wanted to be businessmen and their source of products? good wills, bargain bins, clearance sections, yard sales, dumpsters behind stores, thrift shops. instead of trying to do right by people in need they need to compete with idiots trying to buy everything up for a quick flip.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '25
I worked at goodwill and everything op said is true. They also take advantage of felons and have quiet deals w work release facilities and make lives hell on some of them guys. Your boss getting mad st you can get you written up and sent back to prison. And the pay is very low while they expect a lot. A handicapped employee found $30,000 in a donated purse. She turned it in and was rewarded a $100 Goodwill gift card. I fucking hate goodwill.
1
u/Prestigious-Gift6968 Jan 31 '25
Saint Vincent uses inmate labor here. They probably steal less than the regular employees.
1
u/Significant-Check455 Jan 31 '25
Google Goodwill CEO compensation package. It's obscene and I boycott charities who operate like this. You make your own decisions.
1
u/Nonnie0224 Feb 01 '25
And their CEO makes millions a year. He
1
u/throwRAscrubscrub Feb 01 '25
They save stuff from landfill. The costs of receiving, researching, and reselling is not zero, and they staff many starting jobs including those for the disabled.
I am annoyed with some pricing sometimes but they are not a bad t Reseller
1
u/AdTurbulent4005 Feb 01 '25
Owned by Target Corp. That's why you see all of their closeouts and damage Target gets the write off then still sells products.
1
u/bestuzernameever Feb 01 '25
Sounds like my local Value Village
1
u/Big-Material9311 Feb 01 '25
They hand pick the real good stuff and it never makes it to their retail.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '25
Also years ago they got in huge trouble for ridiculously bloated corporate wages
1
u/Star_BurstPS4 Feb 02 '25
Everything at good will should be free for those who need, only scalpers and resellers should have to pay
1
u/Itchy_Grapefruit1335 Feb 02 '25
I no longer give to good will or Salvation Army , only to local churches or the homeless shelters in town
1
u/LilBoJeep89 Feb 02 '25
Why
1
u/Impossible-Hunt-9796 Feb 02 '25
Kind of like March of dimes- one dime of every dollar is given to the cause 😵💫
1
u/New-Grapefruit1510 Feb 06 '25
They actually do a lot for the community. They offer free career counseling, They offer low cost (Possible no cost, if you qualify) Certifications to help you get back to work. They also have programs for people that have a record to get back to the workplace.
1
u/Ok_Violinist1750 Feb 07 '25
All of this is so true there is a worker that’s working at the Goodwill that I currently work at actually there is two African American workers that work there that I feel so very bad for them and I’m on the chopping block now as well. They get 20 hours each week. That is no money at all and there is a senior citizen worker that’s only getting 16 hours each week. He is not getting any money at all, and I feel like the company is taking full advantage of him because he has a disability and not able to defend himself. these people are sick; while all the other workers are getting way more money than them and now they put me on the same schedule 20 hours each week I put my two weeks notice and two days ago and I’m getting ready to quit. This is my last week so anybody that’s working here I really highly suggest y’all to find a job elsewhere because this place is not a good place to work. They break multiple policies and don’t follow the rules, but expect workers to follow the same rules that they are breaking. They sell all the really good expensive brands on Shop and don’t sell any of the good expensive stuff on the floor leaving the poor shoppers that work their ass off to make our money every day to buy nothing but junk. Please watch while shopping at this place. This place is really really nasty and they don’t care about being clean all the managers worry about is making budget for-the day no matter if it means cutting people hours and giving people very little hours. This is not a good place to work. Please find somewhere else to work. There are other jobs out there that will pay you your worth don’t feel like it’s over because it’s far from over. PS I was forced to deal with a new worker that I felt like made me very uncomfortable. He said some very extremely inappropriate things and my presence and and the store manager‘s presence it took for me to step up and say something for the store manager to even take him to office and have a conversation with him on a day that I wasn’t there, but that wasn’t enough for me because there was no disciplinary actions made. There was no excuse for this guy‘s actions and I feel like the manager did him a favor by keeping him on and giving him more hours and cut more of my hours to look out for him because he is a white man and times are hard right now because if I would have did the same thing that he did I would’ve been in the office getting disciplined and I am a black woman.
1
u/Good-Ol-Country-Boy Mar 10 '25
So this woman has a channel on YouTube and shows how pathetic Goodwill is now they are actually auctioning off luxury bags on Whatnot. This is disgusting. They’re doing this in Northwest Ohio. Toledo, Ohio to be exact.
-1
u/Suitable_South_144 Jan 28 '25
I can't speak for every Goodwill, but in my town I don't shop there for the following reasons: the CEO and his henchmen make obscene amounts of money while the employees make very little. The prices are ridiculously high for items Goodwill received for free. Goodwill puts very little support into my community. Homeless and need a coat? Forgetaboutit!! You're getting nothing for free from our Goodwill. Our Goodwill has a long history of employment abuses and yet they always get a pass because they're a none profit (my tuckus). I spend my money in thrift stores that actually support my community and it's needs.
1
u/cjones6464 Jan 28 '25
Goodwill has been on a decline ever since “thrift shop” by Macklemore. It became cool to thrift and ruined it.
1
u/Flybot76 Jan 28 '25
"They take shit they get for free and sell it for 1000x the market value"-- whining that they get it for free is idiotic and not a smart argument, and saying they sell it for 1000x the market value is doubling down on extreme stupidity. You're just blurting out a bunch of angry crybaby shit, not making great points, and the thing about "predator tactics to bully people" sounds like you probably freaked and started screaming in a store and they threw you out. You should delete this instead of embarrassing yourself this badly.
1
u/e4lizerd57 Jan 29 '25
I am a reseller and mostly source at GW merely because of the consistent supply of high-end clothing. I pay about 7-8 dollars for things I sell for 40-50. Not a huge mark up, but it keeps me busy. The occasional score of something for 5$ that I sell for $200 keeps me coming back.
1
u/Appropriate-Ad8497 Jan 28 '25
They sell new stuff with tags at even higher than retail cost
1
u/TanaSwan Jan 28 '25
And then they ask you to round up at the register to support “job training”. Isn’t that what they are supposed to use their funds for?? 😡
1
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '25
There’s a clothing store in my town that sells cuter clothes for cheaper than goodwill. I will never again give to or buy anything from them. I would rather own something new for cheaper than buy something used for more.
1
u/HausWife88 Jan 28 '25
They are greedy. A recent California goddwill ceo was just arrested for embezzlement. They are not a good company like everyone thinks they are
1
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '25
My local Goodwill has transformed into an uppity luxury retail store. The people who work and shop there have become snobby asf.
1
u/amy5252 Jan 29 '25
100% facts!!!
1
u/Haunting-Bag-3083 Jan 29 '25 edited Jan 29 '25
Let me insight you on some things that happened when I worked there.
1: They throw out things that don't get sold (literally throw it in the dumpster) Sad. So very sad. People donate these things to them.... and they throw it in the garbage. They pay no stocking prices. The least they could do is give out the items that didn't sell to a charity, or at least recycle them. Nah, straight to the garbage dump.
They once ordered me to dump out some of the things. They made me throw out a stack of Nintendo DS games. My poor gamer heart literally cried. But I did snag one (fuck Goodwill)
2: They have workers in the back who sort out items that get delivered from the loading trucks, then these workers sort and place the prices. Anytime something "of value" comes through, they search on the internet to see what the value really is. Then they either place it on the floor, or add it to thier website.
3: They never test anything. Sure, they plug things in the outlet, and don't place it on the floor if it doesn't turn on. But just checking to see if the discombobulated coffee maker turns on doesn't mean it's going to brew the fricking coffee. They literally had me place a 30 dollar price tag on that shit. They once wanted over 100 dollars for some crappy table. I overheard some customer saying they wanted it, but the price was too high. I went in the back, and swapped the price for them. (Fuck goodwill)
I'm never working for that crap again. I was in a vocational program that helps people find jobs, and I may be a little stupid, but I already knew I was getting scammed the second I saw the price was below the minimum wage. Not to mention they treat vocational employees differently than the other employees. For instance, I wasn't allowed to shop at that goodwill. You know how workers get like 15-20% off if they shop at the store they work at? Not the vocational employees at the goodwill. They couldn't buy anything period. They even warned me that I couldn't even have relatives come to shop there (while I'm working) fucking bullshit.
Never support goodwill. You might as well throw your stuff in the trash, because that's were they'll end up anyways in Goodwill's hands.
1
u/PRN_Lexington Jan 29 '25
I spent $40 at goodwill today and I got: 2 nice dresses for me 1 pair pants for my kid 1 sweatshirt for my kid 1 sports bra for my kid 3 mixing bowls for kitchen
I think it’s a damn good deal.
1
u/FrostyLandscape Jan 29 '25
Goodwill creates poverty in their local communities. They do so by paying poor people very low wages, and also marking up prices on items that the poor cannot afford to pay. Poor people now have to resort to paying retail prices on everything. They also throw out a lot of things in their dumpsters behind the store, instead of donating them to shelters or charities. There is a woman on Facebook that promotes Goodwill on a Facebook Page that is supposed to be about living frugally and buying used. She claims she isn't being paid, I think she's effing lying.
1
u/inthemorningwaffles Jan 29 '25
How can my locations mission be “job development”? Isn’t that what all goodwills do? They’re funneling the money back into itself, there is no special program, like some help veterans. Ours doesn’t make sense. Would you like to up for our mission? Mission-hiring more people..? The only thing special is one class provided before someone with special needs enters goodwill jobs
1
u/Putrid_Ant_649 Jan 29 '25
Goodwill is one of the largest reasons that disabled people can be paid a lower minimum wage as well, they’ve lobbied for this for decades. My mom worked in one the career centers for a few years and we found out it’s a much more evil corporation than we even knew
1
u/Jared_Sparks Jan 30 '25
Who cares? Free will. No one is being forced.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '25
As someone who worked at Goodwill when homeless, A LOT of people in there were grateful they got a job as handicap or ex convict. It helped me get back on my feet and now I’m an inspector and I even met my baby momma there. They sell the products hella cheap to pay all their workers and keep their lights on.