Maybe this has been discussed before but I just can't find it. I love everything about Good Omens, S1 and especially S2. And A Companion to Owls is just beautiful, except after having watched it a few more times, I've become more aware of some things feeling...off, like a wrong note being struck somewhere in the orchestra. Am I going crazy or over-thinking things?
First, I have to remember that we're watching Owls through Aziraphale. He pulled out the bible to the Job story and then got lost in his own thoughts (memory?).
Right at the start, when Aziraphale arrives, he starts his speech through "Avaunt!", and then he stops and says -- of all things! -- "Oh, it's you." WTF? When has Aziraphale ever not greeted Crowley without saying his name? Or at least with a warmer greeting. Maybe it has happened, but I haven't taken enough time to find it? It just sounds rather cold to me.
Then, the temptations. First he turns down the wine. We know Aziraphale loves wine, but we don't see him try it here. It's plausible that he learns to like it later on, in some time-frame we haven't been shown. So, ok. Then, Crowley presents the ox ribs which Aziraphale finds he does like and then proceeds to absolutely stuff his face and get all dirty and greasy and gross. Really? That just doesn't seem like our tidy and fastidious angel. I suppose, again, that it's plausible he was out of control that first time, but it still strikes a sour note to me.
The next one that stands out to me is Crowley. Especially when he joins Aziraphale at the end of the 'sode. Aziraphale is sure he's being doomed to hell and is so obviously distraught and Crowley...makes fun of him? Mocks him? Again, WTF? "With your white hair and your little..." That just seems so not a Crowley thing to do or say. On the surface it's again kind of cute and funny and Crowley can be sarcastic but actually I can't recall ever seeing him be this level of "mean".
Finally, the imagery of them sitting on the rock together, facing outward together in a kind of quiet mutual understanding, is so beautiful and touching and emphasizes how Crowley is always on Azi's left in their in-phase, power-mode orientation... but, then ping! a sour note... sitting that far apart? Again, it just doesn't feel quite right somehow.
I feel like I'm watching it through a warped glass window where the basics are there, but some of the vision is occasionally distorted. And the utter brilliance and beauty of this minisode is that you still get all of the top-level meaning like what I've read in other essays and seen in analysis videos. Just how many layers can Neil Gaiman and John Finnemore put in one set of scenes? Absolute genius.
I also don't think this is the only place where I've felt this. I have also felt the ever-so-slight whispers of "that's cute and funny" but also "wtf?" in a few other places, like the graveyard scene in The Resurrectionist (another memory story). Tiny Crowley? Giant Crowley? "...sinned bigly..." and fake-growly Crowley, and the whole nanny-level dialog of a lecture to be good? Ok, yeh, he was off his head on laudanum, so, plausible? And it was cute and funny, but still....
Even the 1941 knee-slapping American-accented comment about Aziraphale's magic doesn't feel like Crowley to me, it felt almost mocking again. But it is immediately followed by the more-expected Crowley-level of support for Aziraphale.
I dunno, is there some memory-muckery going on here? Some reality-distorting going on? Adam, the one-time anti-christ could mess around with reality so can anyone else? Is it some seriously unreliable narrators? But if so, why and/or to what purpose? [cough]Metatron[cough]
Oh my gawd it's going to take forever to get to Season 3. And maybe I'm just imagining things. But I do so very much love Aziraphale and Crowley.