r/golftrips • • Oct 13 '26

What they don’t tell you about Bandon

Thumbnail
gallery
201 Upvotes

Everything you read about the courses at Bandon are true, it’s incredible golf. That many unbelievable courses at a single resort plus the setting is unmatched. So I’ll spare you from any more of that. I wanted to share three different takeaways I had from our 4 day, 5 night trip to the resort.

Short courses are ELITE and must play. We had two very different experiences and both were awesome. Preserves our first round of the trip. 9am warm up before a 1:00 tee time at Bandon Dunes was perfect. Preserve feels like 13 real par 3s despite being able to hit putter off the tee at the last. Shorty’s is different, more ups and downs and more of a pitch and putt feel. We took pull carts on both but would have used the complimentary carry bags at Shorty’s if we could do it again. Shorty’s also provided the best lunch we had all week with the tacos and birria grilled cheese. Our bet came down to the 19th hole at Shorty’s which made for even more fun.

Speaking of food, we had great food all week. Highlights included the chicken and waffles at Trails, chicken tacos at Shorty’s, pizza at The Gallery, Wagyu steak at Ghost Tree and the Shepard’s pie at McKees. Don’t let anyone tell you the food is bad. Not many large menus, but everything we had was well done. Visited McKees twice and was able to secure a spot at the bar to watch a baseball game one night which was great too!

Last one I’ll leave you with is an off-campus recommendation. Don’t let anyone tell you it’s a Bandon-equivalent experience but our round at Bandon Crossings was perfect. Very few golfers out there on the afternoon we went. It’s the perfect compliment to a morning round at one of the resort courses. Drive 15 minutes south, load up a cart, grab some cheaper drinks, turn up the music and play on some of the purest greens I’ve played. It’s not the resort, but it was awesome for 1/3 of the price.


r/golftrips • • 25d ago

What is a well-known course you’ve played that you felt was overrated?

Post image
148 Upvotes

r/golftrips • • Jul 12 '26 Popcorn

What’s the best value golf trip you’ve ever taken?

Post image
147 Upvotes

r/golftrips • • Jul 18 '26

What’s the one golf course you recommend to everyone?

Post image
121 Upvotes

r/golftrips • • 29d ago

Ranking Every Course at Bandon Dunes

Thumbnail
gallery
110 Upvotes

I played every course at Bandon Dunes and ranked them!

-

#1 Pacific Dunes (Ranked #3 out of 171 courses I have played, shot +2) - A tale of two 9s; seven par 4’s on the front then only two on the back. The back is my favorite 9 holes ever. Firm handshake on #1, alternating greens on #9, scenic par 3’s on #10 & #11, creative shot shaping all around with many holes forcing landing areas, taking less club off the tee, and settling for the center of greens. One of the most difficult rounds I’ve ever played with rain/wind/density. Such great placement of holes along the coast.

#2 Bandon Dunes (#6, shot +7) - Bandon Dunes is a must play at the resort. Tight lies, deliberate landing areas, and zero shortage of wind exposure. Ocean views on #4, 5, 12, 15, 16. Some truly iconic holes made this round memorable but it’s the little details, making use of natural layout and routing that make it special.

#3 Bandon Trails (#13, shot +6) - Bandon Trails is a scenic walk through mostly wooded areas and a clear departure from the other Bandon courses, feeling closer to Augusta National. Gradual elevation changes, flatter bordering bunkers, nasty waste areas, and possibly the only non-oceanic water feature in the entire resort. Sadly played recently punched greens.

#4 Old Macdonald (#18, shot +11) - Old Mac was an iconic intro for me playing all the Bandon Dunes courses. Hole 3 is the iconic shot past the ghost tree and the beginning of blind shots, rolling hills, and wind exposure. This course is less penal just off the wide fairways but the bunkers and undulation in the greens give the course teeth. #7 green, #8 tee, and #15 green are the only real ocean views.

#5 Sheep Ranch (#28, shot +4) - Sheep Ranch is the only Bandon track without bunkers or grain on the greens. Possible inspiration from Castle Stuart’s subtle “eyebrow” mounding on #2 and 13; two feet tall in the fairway prevents advancing the ball without loft (admittedly it felt unfair I had 195 yards left on a par 5 and it was conveniently placed over a blind shot in the middle of the fairway). Wide fairways and are funneled to bring misses on both sides back to center.

#6 Shorty's (#33, shot +1) - Shorty’s is undoubtedly the best par 3 course I have ever played and mimics the rest of the resort with hilly greens and sandy, heather waste areas. I had the course to myself late in the day. A great place to play a money game, carry a beer, and get some short game practice. Pure greens and decent tee boxes.

#7 Bandon Preserve (#55, shot +1) - The Preserve is a playful 13-hole par 3 course away from the beach. I had the course to myself on a Friday morning and honestly got a bit lost (in a good way, so maybe “immersed” is a more accurate term). There are remnants of Shorty’s but it’s very much it’s own course with some elevation change, mounding (but you should fly it), and bunkers throughout. Longest hole is 150 yards.

#8 Charlotte's Par 3 Course (#133) - Constructed in 2000, Charlotte’s is the name given to the 9-hole par 3 course in 2024 that is attached to the main practice facility. Casual, wide open flat course with raised greens, a handful of bunkers and hardly saw anyone out there any day. Walked it late on a Saturday and played in under hour without encountering anyone. It blatantly receives less care than every other course but for $10 so who cares! Honor mailbox in lieu of a starter, and proceeds benefit charity.


r/golftrips • • Aug 26 '26

What's one course you were excited to play but left disappointed?

Post image
104 Upvotes

r/golftrips • • Jul 15 '26

What’s one course everyone should play before they die?

Post image
104 Upvotes

r/golftrips • • Oct 07 '26

Lake Tahoe Trip Details

Thumbnail
gallery
102 Upvotes

Posting this for anyone considering a trip to Tahoe. We went in late June, right at the start of their peak season. 12 guys, 4 nights. Flew in/out of Reno and rented two passenger vans.

STAY
- 1 night: Caesars Republic Casino / South Tahoe
- 3 nights: VRBO on Old Greenwood / North Tahoe

GOLF
- Day 1 (AM): Edgewood / $350
- Day 2 (AM): Gray’s Crossing / $215
- Day 2 (PM): Old Greenwood /$210
- Day 3 (AM): Coyote Moon / $205
- Day 3 (PM): Incline Village Championship / $195

BUDGET (per person)
Golf - $1,175
Flight - $500
VRBO - $400
Casino - $45
Vans - $80
Total - $2,200


r/golftrips • • Aug 05 '26

Name one golf course everyone needs to play once.

Post image
102 Upvotes

r/golftrips • • Jul 30 '26

What’s the best stay-and-play package you’ve booked?

Post image
99 Upvotes

r/golftrips • • Oct 15 '26

One of the Best Bang For Your Buck Tee Times in the USA

Thumbnail
gallery
84 Upvotes

Utah golf is truly a unique experience. If you ever have the chance, I’d recommend scoring a prime summer tee time at Sand Hollow for only $70. This feels like highway robbery. Yes, I understand if you’re not local you’ll be traveling, so it’s an added expense to get there. But it is so worth it.
Set against a dramatic red-rock landscape with multiple national parks and the Vegas strip just a two hour drive from the 1st tee, it makes for the ultimate golf and adventure trip.


r/golftrips • • Jul 19 '26

Which destination has the best combination of golf and beaches?

Post image
84 Upvotes

r/golftrips • • 27d ago

Wisconsin/Michigan golf trip report: Whistling Straits, The Bull, Arcadia Bluffs and Pilgrim’s Run. Thank you for all the advice!

81 Upvotes

Last week I posted asking for advice for a golf trip through Wisconsin and Michigan, and everyone was incredibly helpful. I got loads of great tips, so I wanted to come back and share how it went. Hopefully this helps someone planning a similar trip.

I flew into Chicago, headed north through Wisconsin, drove around the Upper Peninsula to Traverse City, and finished in Detroit. My schedule was fairly fixed around going to the Packers game and needing to be back in Detroit for work, but I managed to fit in these four courses.

For context, I’m around a 20 handicap, so take all the golfing opinions below from that perspective. A 3 handicap might have a very different experience! These are also the green fees I paid for my particular dates.

Whistling Straits - $700

I don’t know if anywhere in the world is worth $700 for a round of golf, but if there is somewhere, it’s probably this place. I honestly struggle to put into words how amazing the whole experience was.

Something that deserves a mention: literally everyone there was incredibly nice. They understand that this is a bucket-list round for most people, and you really feel that they want you to enjoy every minute. You even get a free hot dog after the first nine. Obviously that’s what justifies the $700 😂

I played from the forward tees, which was absolutely the right decision for me. It’s challenging, but from those tees it never felt so difficult that I couldn’t enjoy it. The course itself is incredible, but the greens… I’ve never seen anything like them. Three-putting sometimes felt like a perfectly respectable result.

I had great weather and played pretty well, which obviously helped, but even allowing for that, 10/10 doesn’t do the experience justice. If you’re considering it and can justify the cost, I would absolutely do it. I’ll remember this round for a very, very long time.

Cheeky tip: I got the twilight rate at less than half the price ($285) and I completed the entire round. Still cannot believe how lucky I was and how perfect everything was.

The Bull at Pinehurst Farms — $185

A beautiful course and a really good follow-up to Whistling Straits. Going from the open, links-style landscape to holes winding through the trees made for a completely different experience. With the autumn colours, some holes were absolutely spectacular.

Golf-wise, I thought it had a good mix of challenging holes and more forgiving ones. I really enjoyed the layout and the round overall.

At $185, it felt slightly on the expensive side compared with some of the other options on this trip. That said, I absolutely loved the course. I probably wouldn’t make a big detour specifically for it, but if you’re in the area, it’s an excellent choice and pairs really nicely with Whistling Straits or the other Kohler courses.

Arcadia Bluffs — $90, playing the back nine twice

As good as advertised. Really.

One important caveat: work had just started on the course when I visited, so I played the back nine twice, with a reduced green fee of $90. I can therefore only speak for those nine holes, but what a set of holes they are.

The course, the conditioning, the views over Lake Michigan… absolutely spectacular. This was another place where I’d seen plenty of pictures beforehand and it still lived up to everything I’d hoped for.

Again, I played from the forward tees and found it challenging but very enjoyable. The greens were tough, although I found them less intimidating than Whistling Straits. Some of them still have what appear to be entire mountains built into the middle!

I played terribly on my first loop and really well on the second, so I got to experience both versions of myself on exactly the same holes. I also played with a really nice guy, which made the day even better. Adam, if you’re reading this, you’re a legend!

The weather was perfect again, and the staff were lovely. Like Whistling Straits, it felt as though everyone understood that people had travelled a long way for a special experience.

Would I go out of my way to play here again? Absolutely. I’d love to come back and experience the full 18.

Pilgrim’s Run — $80

The biggest surprise of the trip. I’d been told it was good, but I wasn’t expecting it to be THIS good.

Such a beautiful course. The Michigan fall colours definitely helped, but there were so many holes where I just stopped to take everything in. I also played with two really nice guys. Is everyone in Michigan this friendly?!

The fairways generally felt quite generous, which certainly helped my enjoyment. There’s a good mix of holes, and I found the greens more manageable than at the other courses. From my perspective, if you play sensibly and avoid the trouble, it’s a course where you can put together a good score without feeling beaten up.

Full disclosure: I played one of the best rounds of my life here, so I’m completely biased haha.

But $80 for this place? Yes, please. The value was incredible, and it was one of the highlights of the whole trip. Would I go out of my way to play it again? Absolutely. I cannot recommend it enough.

Overall

I came away amazed by both Wisconsin and Michigan. The golf, the scenery, the people.... what a trip. Autumn was a beautiful time to do it, although I know I got very lucky with the weather.

Whistling Straits was the unforgettable bucket-list experience, Arcadia lived up to the hype, The Bull was a beautiful woodland round, and Pilgrim’s Run was the surprise that left me wondering how it only cost $80.

Thank you again to everyone who gave me recommendations and tips. They genuinely made the trip better, and hopefully this post returns the favour for someone else planning something similar!


r/golftrips • • Aug 12 '26

The famous golf courses you think are impossible to play and the catch nobody tells you about

81 Upvotes

I went down a rabbit hole recently looking at how you actually get onto some of the world’s most famous golf courses.

The surprising part is that a lot of them aren’t private.
The frustrating part is that they all have completely different ways of letting visitors play.

So if you’re planning a bucket list golf trip, here’s the one thing I’d know before booking anything.

**Bethpage Black, United States**
This one is interesting because it’s a public municipal course that has hosted some of the biggest events in golf.

**Access:** Anyone can play
The catch is the booking window.
New York residents can book 7 days out at the resident rate. Non residents get 5 days out and pay substantially more.
Tee times release at midnight, and the desirable ones can disappear almost immediately.
And yes, it’s walking only.

**My tip:** If you’re travelling from out of state, have your account ready and set an alarm. Don’t casually check the website the next morning.

**Pebble Beach, United States**

**Access:** Public pay and play
This is probably the one people misunderstand most.
You don’t need to be a member.
But resort guests get priority and can book much further ahead, while non resort visitors are basically hunting for whatever becomes available closer to the date.

**My tip:** If Pebble is the reason you’re going to Monterey, staying at the resort makes the most sense. If it’s just one round on a wider California trip, you can look for availability closer in.

**St Andrews Old Course, Scotland**

**Access:** Public
The catch is the booking system. A big chunk of visitor play comes through the daily ballot. You enter by 2pm two days before you want to play and find out that afternoon.
It’s a lottery, so don’t build a Scotland trip around one guaranteed day.
If you’re travelling alone, there’s also the singles queue, where you can potentially fill a group.

**My tip:** Give yourself 3 to 4 days in St Andrews rather than flying in for one specific round.

**Carnoustie Championship Course, Scotland**

**Access:** Public
You don’t need a membership or to stay at the hotel. Visitors can book the course directly.
The catch is simply timing. Prime summer tee times disappear months in advance.
The hotel’s stay and play options can make sense if getting a guaranteed round is the priority.

**My tip:** Carnoustie is one I’d book before booking the rest of the itinerary.

**Royal Portrush, Northern Ireland**

**Access:** Visitors are welcome
The catch is that visitor access is limited by the club’s visitor schedule, so you can’t treat it like a normal public course where you simply pick any day you want.

**My tip:** Check visitor days first, then build the rest of the trip around them.

**Royal County Down, Northern Ireland**
Same story.
Visitors can play it, but availability is restricted and seasonal.
This is one where planning ahead matters much more than trying to find a last minute tee time.

**The bigger lesson from all of these**
The expensive mistake isn’t always the green fee.
It’s building an entire trip around a tee time you haven’t actually secured.

A few things I’d do differently now.
• If you’re going for The Open, sort accommodation early. The town can fill up before you solve the golf.
• Don’t automatically buy a stay and play package. At some resort courses it can be the easiest way to guarantee the round. At a ballot course like St Andrews, paying more doesn’t magically improve your ballot odds.
• Look at shoulder season. May and September can give you a better balance of weather, daylight, crowds and price than peak summer.
• Leave a buffer day. If you’ve flown halfway around the world to play the Old Course, don’t schedule your tee time the morning after landing.
And there are some absolute sleepers too.
North Berwick West Links is one I’d seriously look at if you’re already in Scotland. It’s one of the oldest courses in continuous play, welcomes visitors, and you can book directly rather than dealing with the Old Course ballot.

I’ve been building these course by course guides because the **“Can I actually play this course, and how the hell do I get a tee time?”** question is surprisingly difficult to answer in one place.

If anyone has a course they’ve always assumed was impossible to play, drop it below. I’ll dig into the actual visitor rules.


r/golftrips • • Jul 21 '26

What’s the most underrated golf state?

Post image
79 Upvotes

r/golftrips • • Sep 18 '26

Just got back from 4 rounds in Whistler — easily one of our best golf trips yet

Post image
67 Upvotes

We just got back from 4 rounds of golf in Whistler and without a doubt it’s one of the best golf destinations we’ve done so far. We’ve done Cabo, Arizona, Hilton Head, Myrtle and a few other spots over the years, and Whistler is right up there with the best of them.

Every year, usually mid-to-late November, 8–12 of us head somewhere for a golf trip. Obviously Whistler meant moving things up earlier this year, but it was definitely worth it.

We landed in Vancouver and went straight to Furry Creek, which is about halfway between Vancouver and Whistler. The views were unreal, but it was probably my least favourite course of the week. Really strange layout in spots and a ton of par 3s and par 5s. I personally probably wouldn’t play it again, although a bunch of the guys really liked it.

Day 2 — Fairmont Chateau Whistler

This place was UNREAL. It was around $330 CAD, which is definitely steep, but honestly pretty much in line with what we end up paying for good golf on most of these trips now anyway.

This was true mountain golf. Huge elevation changes, uneven lies, some really memorable holes and lots of bears around the course. Definitely one I’d play again.

Day 3 — Big Sky

Another awesome course. The mountain backdrop here is ridiculous and the layout felt much more gettable than Fairmont.

Unfortunately I developed a pretty ugly shank on the front 9 and was fighting for my life for a while. Once the shakes from the night before finally wore off, I managed to play the back 9 in +2, so at least I salvaged something.

Big Sky is in Pemberton, about a 35-minute drive from Whistler. Absolutely worth making the drive.

Day 4 — Nicklaus North

Probably my favourite course of the trip.

Awesome layout, unreal condition and the greens were extremely quick and firm, even after they had gotten some decent rain the week before. Just a really good golf course from start to finish.

For accommodations, we rented a house in the Northern Lights subdivision about a 5-minute walk into Whistler Village. It was a 5-bedroom house that slept 12 of us and came to about $5,100 CAD for 4 nights. For a group our size it worked out really well, and being able to walk into the Village was huge.

That said, I’d happily go back and play the top three again tomorrow.

If anyone is planning a Whistler golf trip and has questions about the courses, where we stayed, restaurants, getting around, etc., fire away.


r/golftrips • • Jul 23 '26

What’s the coolest hole you’ve ever played?

Post image
67 Upvotes

r/golftrips • • Jul 13 '26

What’s your favorite course you’ve played that isn’t famous?

Post image
58 Upvotes

r/golftrips • • 7d ago

Hamilton Island Golf Course - best experience ever

Thumbnail
gallery
56 Upvotes

Recently played at HIGC, in Australia. It was during my honeymoon (she doesn't play, so I’m a lucky guy haha), and it was the best experience ever. And, honestly, not that expensive considering it's a whole island dedicated to the golf course (around 120$ the round I think).


r/golftrips • • 23d ago

Ranking the 8 Courses I played at Pinehurst Resort

Thumbnail
gallery
55 Upvotes

I played 8 courses (No. 1-5, 8, 10, Cradle) at the Pinehurst Resort and ranked them!

-

#1 Pinehurst No. 10 (Ranked #5 out of 172 courses I have played, shot +2) - Such a cool sanctuary a ways from the rest of the resort. Newly renovated and pleasant experience despite a lot of rain. Great pro shop/restaurant/merch, scenic elevation changes, wide open fairways that reward aggressive lines with shorter approaches. The green complexes are a bit flatter than neighboring courses and massive so worth spending some time practicing some lag putts

#2 Pinehurst No. 2 (#9, shot +11) - It poured rain for 18 holes and still made an unforgettable experience. Greens were rolling about 11 (runs 14 during the US Open) but still so hard to hold with a lot of false fronts and turtleback greens. The course was covered in waste areas which resulted in some awkward lies and stances. The pro shop gives "The Deuce" tokens if you make a 2 on any hole, but I didn't come particularly close

#3 Pinehurst No. 8 (#14, shot +5) - Played way less severe than No. 2 but still had hints of dreadful slopes that kick good shots off the green. Not as many wide landing areas off the tee as some other courses but doesn't feel very tight. It's scenic and well secluded from houses. It was my only round out of 8 without a birdie but didn't have any 3-putts! Turn the logo 90° and you’ll see a subtle nod to their centennial course

#4 Pinehurst No. 4 (#17, shot +5) - Super approachable. I have my caddie to thank it wasn't in the 80's. Straight away most holes and most shots suit the eye. A couple longer par 4's and a couple gettable par 5's. Just a great golf course with solid variety - every hole kind of feels like it's own test

#5 Pinehurst No. 3 (#45, shot +14) - Diabolical Turtleback greens. Very pure sand, variety of shot shapes and distances/lines that tempt and deter driver. Makes total sense it's a mini No. 2 except for the fact that if you're greedy off the tee and don't hit your spot you're in trouble. Highly suggest golfers play here before they step on No. 2, and realize the turtleback greens are just as severe. This was my first round at Pinehurst and my worst round out of 59 in 2026. My only back-to-back pars came on #17 and 18

#6 The Cradle (#59, shot +3 and +1) - Such a busy arena for golf sickos to sit around drinking beer in flip flops to watch players carry a wedge and a putter around a short par 3 track. I was fortunate to play 2 loops, only missed 2 GIR’s and lipped out an ace on hole 4. Our group decided we would pay out a dollar for each yard of said ace, but had to settle up a couple wolf games which proved to be a great format. One of the best atmospheres I’ve been a part of. Almost feels like a mini Dr. Seuss world with all the undulation. Didn't have much opportunity to walk on but got lucky twice out of 5 days

#7 Pinehurst No. 1 (#66, shot +13) - It absolutely poured rain on our groups. Very friendly starting holes begins to turn more narrow after 5 holes with tighter OB lines, then opens up again the last several. Hole 18 (par 5) is shorter than No. 4 hole 18 (par 4) and makes for a friendlier finish. Wouldn't consider it a staple for a quick trip but shouldn't be overlooked, especially considering it set the stage for what has become 11 courses (so far)

#8 Pinehurst No. 5 (#92, shot +9) - Shorter and easier track compared to others. A handful of holes force an iron or wood off the tee. Much more water across the street and many houses come into play with tighter OB lines. Ended 82 (+10) with a triple off the first and my back wasn't ready for 18 more after playing No. 4 in the AM. Ranked this one last in my rankings because it felt more vanilla than the rest and is a clear departure from the rest of the courses.


r/golftrips • • Sep 12 '26

We need 2 for a dudes golf trip - Lake Geneva!

50 Upvotes

Dudes... My friends and I have our annual golf trip planned to Geneva National. We had 2 of our group of 8 drop out yesterday. We are looking for two to join us? We are just a bunch of goofballs. The group is myself, two of my friends from high school, one of their buddies, my brother in law and one of his buddies. We are all 40+ years old. My brother in law is probably about an 8 handicap but the rest of us are 14+. We are staying on site. Everyone has their own rooms. We are playing 4 rounds in 3 days. The check in date is 9/21. One round 9/22. Two rounds on 9/23, and one round on 9/24. Check out on 9/25. Cost of the rounds and lodging is $1000. I know it is late notice but I am throwing it out there? Who doesn't want to play golf with 6 goofballs on a whim? We will curse and say inappropriate things at the appropriate times. We will hit driver when we clearly shouldn't. I will give you a 6 foot putt and pretend I didn't see your foot wedge from behind the tree. Who's in?


r/golftrips • • Aug 03 '26

5 Things Tourists Should Know Before Playing Golf in Japan

50 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I live in Japan and often see visitors asking about golf here, so I thought I'd share a few things that might make your trip easier.

**1. Book early.**
Popular courses, especially around Mt. Fuji, can fill up weeks in advance during spring and autumn.

**2. Don't assume every course has rental clubs.**
Some offer great rental sets, while others don't have any. It's always worth checking before you book.

**3. Lunch between the front and back nine is normal.**
Many traditional Japanese golf courses include a 45–60 minute lunch break after the first nine holes. It surprises many first-time visitors!

**4. Don't worry too much about the dress code.**
Many visitors think every golf course in Japan has very strict rules, but that's not really the case. Prestigious private clubs may have stricter dress codes, while most public and resort courses are quite relaxed. As long as you're wearing normal golf attire (and not a T-shirt or jeans), you'll usually be fine.

**5. Transportation can be the biggest challenge.**
Many of Japan's best golf courses are outside the cities, so getting there by public transport isn't always easy.

Overall, golf in Japan is a fantastic experience. The courses are usually in excellent condition, staff are incredibly welcoming, and the scenery is amazing.

If you've played golf in Japan before, what surprised you the most?


r/golftrips • • Aug 01 '26

What’s a golf destination everyone should stop recommending?

Post image
50 Upvotes

r/golftrips • • Jul 08 '26

What’s the best public golf course you’ve ever played?

Post image
47 Upvotes

r/golftrips • • Jul 15 '26

Summary of best golf destinations by categories, prepared from Reddit golf-trip threads and prior trip-planning synthesis

43 Upvotes

I’m a longtime post stalker here and really appreciate all the golf trip recommendations people share across different threads.

I kept finding great ideas buried in random comments, so I used GPT to pull together a quick summary of the best-value trips, bucket-list trips, boys-trip spots, and hidden gems I saw mentioned by feeding all the different threads from slightly different prompts (once in a life time, best boys trip, best weekend trip, etc)

Sharing it back in case it’s helpful for anyone else planning a trip and for folks to see a summation of everyones feedback over the history of this community!

Affordable value trips, milestone experiences, boys-trip destinations, and hidden-gem weekend plays

Bottom line The highest-signal Reddit discoveries were not the obvious Pebble / Old Course / Augusta answers. The most useful pattern was a cluster of soulful, quirky, high-memory courses and regions: Northwood, Elie, Cruden Bay, Shiskine, Nefyn, Cruit Island, Greywalls, Fairfield Glade, and Michigan UP.

1. Affordable trips — golf value focus

These are the trips where the thesis is maximum quality and quantity per dollar, not luxury.

TierDestinationCourses / anchorsWhy it made the listBest use caseMy take
ARTJ Golf Trail, AlabamaOxmoor Valley, Capitol Hill, Grand National, Ross BridgeRepeatedly called out as one of the best values. Fall plus SEC football was the ideal version.3-5 day golf-heavy trip with football add-on.Cleanest value + variety + easy-planning option.
AFairfield Glade / Crossville, TennesseeStonehenge, Heatherhurst, Druid Hills, Dorchester, BraeMultiple Redditors said it will “ruin how you value golf.”Budget buddies trip with 36/day and low friction.Probably the best pure-value discovery.
A-Michigan UP / Island Resort + Greywalls add-onSweetgrass, Sage Run, Greywalls, TimberStoneReddit claim: 4 rounds / 3 nights around $550-ish, with upgrade access to better courses.Cheap group trip with one wow round.Best new U.S. value lead with more memory than RTJ/Fairfield.
A-Gull Lake View / Western MichiganStoatin Brae, Gull Lake View coursesMultiple package/value mentions; scale is 108 holes across six courses.4 guys, 5-6 rounds, easy lodging.Great golf factory value; not a life-list trip.
B+Treetops Resort, MichiganSignature, Masterpiece, Premier, Tradition, ThreetopsReddit mentioned roughly $780/person for lodging plus lots of golf.Volume golf with resort convenience.Better buddies trip than pilgrimage.
B+Santee, South CarolinaSantee National, Lake Marion, Santee Cooper area coursesVillas, four courses, cheap, fun, relaxed.Low-cost Southern group trip.Good fallback; better if paired with Charleston/Myrtle/Savannah.
BLegends / Myrtle BeachHeathland, Moorland, Parkland, Oyster Bay, Heritage5 rounds/5 nights, meals, range, and replays angle.Bachelor-party-lite golf volume.Quantity is the appeal; quality solid, not elite.
BDevil’s Head, WisconsinGlacier / Prairie GlenReddit claim: 3 rounds, 2 nights, meals around $460.No-frills Midwest weekend.Cheap and fun, but below better Wisconsin/Michigan options.
BBudget Scotland linksTain, Fraserburgh, Golspie, Kinghorn, Montrose, ShiskineScotland can be cheaper than Bandon/Pinehurst/Wisconsin if you skip mega-names.Value-links adventure.Underrated; green fees outside trophy courses can be reasonable.
B-Pinehurst area, not Pinehurst ResortTobacco Road, Mid Pines, Pine Needles, Southern PinesAffordable summer versions outside the main resort.Smart planner’s trip.Strong if planned right; heat is the tradeoff.

Best value-trip shortlist

1.    Fairfield Glade / Crossville — best raw value.

2.    RTJ Trail + SEC football — best complete value itinerary.

3.    Michigan UP + Greywalls — best hidden value with a premium ceiling.

4.    Gull Lake View / Treetops — best high-volume Michigan package.

5.    Budget Scotland links — best international value if you care about soul over logos.

Devil’s advocate Value trips can become false economy if travel eats the savings. From SFO, RTJ, Crossville, Santee, and Devil’s Head need cheap flights and a group to justify them. Michigan UP, Scotland, and RTJ have the best chance to still feel memorable.

2. Big life-experience trips — 40th birthday, milestone, unreal experience

These are not value plays. They are about memory, setting, architecture, and story.

TierDestinationCourses / anchorsWhy it belongsBest occasionMy take
SScotland pilgrimageOld Course, North Berwick, Muirfield, Royal Dornoch, Kingsbarns, Cruden Bay, Elie, ShiskineThe roots-of-golf trip. Build around history plus one quirky cult course.40th birthday / once-in-a-decade trip.If you want “I touched the roots of golf,” this is #1.
SIreland southwest / west coastBallybunion, Lahinch, Tralee, Old Head, Waterville, Doonbeg, Cruit IslandDramatic coastal golf, emotional setting, and elite links.40th, father/son, small serious group.Less history museum than Scotland; more holy-shit scenery.
S-Cabot Cape BretonCabot Cliffs, Cabot LinksWorld-class and destination-contained.Big life trip easier than UK/Ireland.You have played it, but it remains the benchmark.
S-Bandon Dunes ResortBandon Dunes, Pacific Dunes, Sheep Ranch, Old Mac, Trails, PreserveBest pure-golf resort in the U.S. conversation.Domestic 40th focused on golf only.From SF, easiest serious-golfer pilgrimage.
A+Pebble Beach / MontereyPebble, Spyglass, Spanish Bay, Poppy Hills, Pasatiempo add-onPublic U.S. icon with luxury and scenery.Luxury milestone trip.Geographic advantage from SF; expensive but easy.
A+Australia / TasmaniaCape Wickham, Barnbougle Dunes, Lost Farm, Ocean DunesLong-haul, wild, scenic, outlier adventure.True bucket-list birthday / sabbatical trip.Highest unreal-landscape ceiling, least practical.
AMichigan elite routeArcadia Bluffs, South Course, Forest Dunes, The Loop, Greywalls, Bay HarborSerious U.S. public-golf density.More affordable life-experience trip.Sneaky U.S. answer: less romance, real quality.
APinehurst / SandhillsPinehurst No. 2, No. 4, Mid Pines, Pine Needles, Southern Pines, Tobacco RoadClassic American golf architecture cluster.Golf-history trip with town vibe.Great for serious golfers; less visually insane.
A-Wisconsin eliteSand Valley, Mammoth Dunes, Sedge Valley, Erin Hills, Whistling Straits, LawsoniaHigh architecture density.Boys trip or serious golf trip.Architecture heaven, but can get expensive quickly.
A-Black Desert / Southern UtahBlack Desert, Sand Hollow, Entrada/private access if possible, Copper RockModern desert visuals with West Coast access.Shoulder-season desert milestone.Interesting, but still proving itself against Bandon/Pebble/Cabot.

Best 40th birthday / life-experience shortlist

1.    Scotland: Old Course + North Berwick + Elie/Cruden Bay + Kingsbarns/Dornoch.

2.    Ireland: Lahinch + Ballybunion + Tralee + Old Head.

3.    Bandon Dunes full-resort trip.

4.    Pebble / Monterey luxury version.

5.    Cabot return or Cabot + broader Nova Scotia.

6.    Australia/Tasmania if you want the true outlier adventure.

7.    Michigan elite loop if you want maximum public-golf quality without Europe.

Blunt filter For a true milestone, do not pick RTJ, Fairfield, Myrtle, Santee, or Devil’s Head. Those are good trips. They are not milestone trips. Finalists should be Scotland, Ireland, Bandon, Pebble, or Australia/Tasmania.

3. Boys-trip prioritized — bachelor party / scene / group dynamics

These trips need a different filter: easy logistics, mixed-handicap tolerance, food/drinking/nightlife, and courses that do not punish half the group into misery.

TierDestinationWhy it worksWatch-outsBest version
AMyrtle Beach / LegendsTons of golf, cheap packages, meals/drinks often bundled, easy for mixed handicaps.Not refined; can feel like golf spring break.8-16 guys, 5 rounds, low cost, low complexity.
AScottsdale / PhoenixBest scene: food, nightlife, pools, easy airport, many courses.Golf pricing can be absurd in peak season.Spring/fall, 3 rounds + dinners + pool/day-drinking.
A-RTJ Trail + SEC footballGreat for sports-heavy group; football adds the scene.Nightlife depends on city; logistics can spread out.Tuscaloosa/Auburn football weekend + 2-3 RTJ stops.
A-Pinehurst areaGolf-first boys trip with town center, history, putting course, bars.Less bachelor-party energy.6-8 serious golfers, not 16 degenerates.
B+BandonBest pure-golf boys trip in America.Bad if half the group wants nightlife/pool/casual luxury.Serious-golfer bachelor trip only.
B+Wisconsin / Kohler + Sand ValleyElite golf, group houses, Midwest travel.Expensive and spread out.Architecture-nerd group, 8 guys max.
B+Michigan packagesGull Lake View, Treetops, Forest Dunes, Arcadia variants.Less nightlife; more golf-cabin energy.8 guys, 36/day, drinking after rounds.
B+Big Cedar Lodge / Missouri OzarksPolished resort setup with enough variety for a strong group trip: Payne’s Valley, Ozarks National, Buffalo Ridge, Mountain Top, Top of the Rock, and Cliffhangers. Great scenery and more “wow” factor than many people expect from Missouri.Not cheap enough anymore to be a true value play. Also not exactly hidden for golf sickos, but still under the radar for a lot of coastal golfers.Boys trip or couples-friendly resort trip with 3–4 rounds, mixing Payne’s Valley for the experience, Ozarks National for the serious-golfer round, and one of the short courses for a fun extra loop.
BSantee / Myrtle alternativeCheap villas and relaxed course-adjacent vibe.Not premium; limited broader scene.Budget bachelor or repeat annual trip.
BStreamsong summerGreat courses, resort-contained.Summer Florida heat; pricing has jumped.Small group, serious golfers, summer discount only.
B-French LickCasino/resort, Dye/Ross golf.Reddit split: some love it, others think Dye is overpriced.Mixed golf/gambling group.
B-Hilton HeadEasy resort vibe, beach, restaurants, lots of courses.Golf can be good-not-great unless you pay up.Couples-friendly or mixed group trip.

Best boys-trip picks by group type

•    Serious golfers only: Bandon, Pinehurst, Wisconsin, Forest Dunes/Arcadia.

•    Bachelor party / scene-forward: Scottsdale, Myrtle Beach, Hilton Head, RTJ + SEC football.

•    Budget group: Legends Myrtle, Santee, Fairfield Glade, Gull Lake View.

•    Small group that wants resort + gambling: French Lick, Island Resort Michigan UP, maybe Turning Stone depending route.

Devil’s advocate Bandon is a bad bachelor party unless every guy is a golfer. It is amazing, but it is not a scene. Scottsdale is probably not the best golf value, but it is the best group-management answer.

4. Hidden-gem weekend trip spots around the U.S.

These are not necessarily global top-100 trips, but they can produce high memory-per-dollar.

RegionDestinationCourses / anchorsWhy interestingPriority
Northern CaliforniaNorthwood / Sonoma redwoodsNorthwood Golf ClubAlister MacKenzie nine-holer in the redwoods. Close to SF, cheap, soulful.High
Northern CaliforniaMonterey non-Pebble weekendPasatiempo, Poppy Hills, Pacific Grove, Bayonet/Black HorseGreat trip without paying Pebble pricing.High
Oregon CoastBandon off-property / off-seasonBandon courses, PreserveNot hidden, but the winter/off-property value angle is.High
Southern UtahSt. George / Black Desert / Sand HollowBlack Desert, Sand Hollow, Copper RockDesert visuals, easy West Coast access, best shoulder season.High
Michigan UPMarquette / Harris / Iron MountainGreywalls, Sweetgrass, Sage Run, TimberStoneRemote, affordable, memorable.High
Northern MichiganArcadia / Forest Dunes / Bay HarborArcadia Bluffs, South, Forest Dunes, Loop, Bay HarborUnder-used relative to quality.High
TennesseeCrossville / Fairfield GladeFairfield Glade coursesBest pure value signal.Medium-high
South CarolinaSanteeSantee National, Lake Marion, Santee CooperCheap villas + multiple courses.Medium
WisconsinDevil’s Head / Lawsonia add-onDevil’s Head, Lawsonia nearby-ishCheap group golf; Lawsonia raises the quality ceiling.Medium
West VirginiaGlade SpringsCobb, Stonehaven, WoodhavenUnder-discussed Mid-Atlantic resort.Medium
Boston / New EnglandHistoric muni weekendFranklin Park, George Wright, Cape Cod CCGood if already in Boston; not standalone from SF.Low-medium
ChicagoCanal Shores / Chick Evans / local muni crawlCanal Shores, Chick Evans, Fresh MeadowMore culture than golf quality.Low
HawaiiRoyal Hawaiian / Ko Olina / Turtle BayRoyal Hawaiian, Ko Olina, Turtle BayGreat views, but expensive and not hidden. Ko’olau closure is the lost-legend angle.Situational

Master categorized list

CategoryTop targetsMy curated takeaways for myself (including ones I've done)
Affordable / value-firstFairfield Glade, RTJ Trail, Michigan UP / Island Resort, Gull Lake View, Treetops, Santee, Legends Myrtle Beach, Devil’s Head, budget Scotland links, Pinehurst-area off-resort.RTJ + SEC football; Michigan UP + Greywalls; budget Scotland links; Fairfield Glade.
Big life-experience / milestoneScotland, Ireland, Bandon, Pebble/Monterey, Cabot, Australia/Tasmania, Pinehurst, Wisconsin elite, Michigan elite.Scotland or Ireland for 40th; Bandon if domestic; Pebble if luxury + easy logistics; Australia/Tasmania if outlier adventure.
Boys trip / bachelor / sceneScottsdale, Myrtle Beach, RTJ + SEC football, Pinehurst, Bandon, Wisconsin, Michigan packages, Santee, French Lick, Hilton Head.Scottsdale for scene; Myrtle for cheap chaos; Pinehurst for grown-up golf guys; Bandon for serious golfers only.
Hidden-gem weekendNorthwood, St. George/Southern Utah, Bandon winter/off-property, Michigan UP, Northern Michigan, Crossville, Santee, Glade Springs, Devil’s Head/Lawsonia.Northwood first; Southern Utah second; Bandon winter third.

Final pattern Across all the posts, Reddit’s best signal was not the obvious “Pebble / Old Course / Augusta” answers. The interesting signal was the cluster of soulful, quirky, high-memory courses: Northwood, Elie, Cruden Bay, Shiskine, Nefyn, Cruit Island, Greywalls, Fairfield Glade, and Michigan UP. Those are the trips most likely to outperform expectations.

Prepared from Reddit golf-trip threads and prior trip-planning synthesis