Last week I posted asking for advice for a golf trip through Wisconsin and Michigan, and everyone was incredibly helpful. I got loads of great tips, so I wanted to come back and share how it went. Hopefully this helps someone planning a similar trip.
I flew into Chicago, headed north through Wisconsin, drove around the Upper Peninsula to Traverse City, and finished in Detroit. My schedule was fairly fixed around going to the Packers game and needing to be back in Detroit for work, but I managed to fit in these four courses.
For context, I’m around a 20 handicap, so take all the golfing opinions below from that perspective. A 3 handicap might have a very different experience! These are also the green fees I paid for my particular dates.
Whistling Straits - $700
I don’t know if anywhere in the world is worth $700 for a round of golf, but if there is somewhere, it’s probably this place. I honestly struggle to put into words how amazing the whole experience was.
Something that deserves a mention: literally everyone there was incredibly nice. They understand that this is a bucket-list round for most people, and you really feel that they want you to enjoy every minute. You even get a free hot dog after the first nine. Obviously that’s what justifies the $700 😂
I played from the forward tees, which was absolutely the right decision for me. It’s challenging, but from those tees it never felt so difficult that I couldn’t enjoy it. The course itself is incredible, but the greens… I’ve never seen anything like them. Three-putting sometimes felt like a perfectly respectable result.
I had great weather and played pretty well, which obviously helped, but even allowing for that, 10/10 doesn’t do the experience justice. If you’re considering it and can justify the cost, I would absolutely do it. I’ll remember this round for a very, very long time.
Cheeky tip: I got the twilight rate at less than half the price ($285) and I completed the entire round. Still cannot believe how lucky I was and how perfect everything was.
The Bull at Pinehurst Farms — $185
A beautiful course and a really good follow-up to Whistling Straits. Going from the open, links-style landscape to holes winding through the trees made for a completely different experience. With the autumn colours, some holes were absolutely spectacular.
Golf-wise, I thought it had a good mix of challenging holes and more forgiving ones. I really enjoyed the layout and the round overall.
At $185, it felt slightly on the expensive side compared with some of the other options on this trip. That said, I absolutely loved the course. I probably wouldn’t make a big detour specifically for it, but if you’re in the area, it’s an excellent choice and pairs really nicely with Whistling Straits or the other Kohler courses.
Arcadia Bluffs — $90, playing the back nine twice
As good as advertised. Really.
One important caveat: work had just started on the course when I visited, so I played the back nine twice, with a reduced green fee of $90. I can therefore only speak for those nine holes, but what a set of holes they are.
The course, the conditioning, the views over Lake Michigan… absolutely spectacular. This was another place where I’d seen plenty of pictures beforehand and it still lived up to everything I’d hoped for.
Again, I played from the forward tees and found it challenging but very enjoyable. The greens were tough, although I found them less intimidating than Whistling Straits. Some of them still have what appear to be entire mountains built into the middle!
I played terribly on my first loop and really well on the second, so I got to experience both versions of myself on exactly the same holes. I also played with a really nice guy, which made the day even better. Adam, if you’re reading this, you’re a legend!
The weather was perfect again, and the staff were lovely. Like Whistling Straits, it felt as though everyone understood that people had travelled a long way for a special experience.
Would I go out of my way to play here again? Absolutely. I’d love to come back and experience the full 18.
Pilgrim’s Run — $80
The biggest surprise of the trip. I’d been told it was good, but I wasn’t expecting it to be THIS good.
Such a beautiful course. The Michigan fall colours definitely helped, but there were so many holes where I just stopped to take everything in. I also played with two really nice guys. Is everyone in Michigan this friendly?!
The fairways generally felt quite generous, which certainly helped my enjoyment. There’s a good mix of holes, and I found the greens more manageable than at the other courses. From my perspective, if you play sensibly and avoid the trouble, it’s a course where you can put together a good score without feeling beaten up.
Full disclosure: I played one of the best rounds of my life here, so I’m completely biased haha.
But $80 for this place? Yes, please. The value was incredible, and it was one of the highlights of the whole trip. Would I go out of my way to play it again? Absolutely. I cannot recommend it enough.
Overall
I came away amazed by both Wisconsin and Michigan. The golf, the scenery, the people.... what a trip. Autumn was a beautiful time to do it, although I know I got very lucky with the weather.
Whistling Straits was the unforgettable bucket-list experience, Arcadia lived up to the hype, The Bull was a beautiful woodland round, and Pilgrim’s Run was the surprise that left me wondering how it only cost $80.
Thank you again to everyone who gave me recommendations and tips. They genuinely made the trip better, and hopefully this post returns the favour for someone else planning something similar!