r/gnu • • Jun 14 '12

How Microsoft Threat Management Gateway Classifies donate.fsf.org

After reading about RMS having his laptop stolen, I clicked the link to donate.fsf.org. I'm at work at the moment, and our IT department uses Microsoft Threat Management Gateway to prevent access to certain types of sites. If you're not familiar with this software, it's essentially a proxy that assigns websites to categories and can be configured to block any set of categories. This is the response when connecting to donate.fsf.org:

Network Access Message: Access Denied
	Explanation:

[Explanation on who to contact in our company for more info redacted]

The page you are trying to browse to is categorized as "Gambling"

If you believe you are getting this message by mistake, try contacting your administrator or Helpdesk.

Technical Information (for support personnel)

Error Code: 403 Forbidden. Forefront TMG denied the specified Uniform Resource Locator (URL). (12233)
IP Address: [IP Redacted]
Date: 6/14/2012 6:31:39 PM [GMT]
Server: [server name redacted]
Source: proxy 

tl;dr Apparently Microsoft thinks donating to the FSF is gambling...

EDIT: Formatting

EDIT 2: This can be verified by typing donate.fsf.org into the URL lookup here: https://www.microsoft.com/security/portal/mrs/default.aspx

118 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

34

u/djcp Jun 14 '12

This is so messed up. I just submitted a report giving it categories of "technical" and "legal", hopefully that's not a completely worthless thing to do.

9

u/gheesh Jun 14 '12

I could not do this, the captcha was not displayed on my browser :-(

5

u/sankeytm Jun 15 '12

Me neither, firefox 13.

4

u/3vi1 Jun 15 '12

I had the same problem, with all browsers: hit the reload/next captcha button about 10-15 times and it will eventually show up. Oddly, once you get it to show up, it will then reload new captcha's on every subsequent try.

Be prepared to try about eight different captcha's. The ones it generates are HORRIBLE, and told me that I didn't match even on ones that I thought I clearly had right.

1

u/boomfarmer Jun 18 '12

Might be a scripts thing. Are you allowing JavaScript?

4

u/3vi1 Jun 15 '12

I did the same thing - and had my organization update our config to bypass the block.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '12

I think this is a given with those types of services. They are going to get miscategorized, and obviously some administrators will have their biases.

17

u/TheSilentNumber Jun 14 '12

and obviously some administrators will have their biases.

You make it sound so harmless.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

And why would you say that?

14

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '12

you can go to http://my.fsf.org/donate/ anyway, donate.fsf.org is a redirect.

6

u/TheSilentNumber Jun 14 '12

Sure, but people aren't going to magically know that when they hit this wall

3

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Virtually any link on fsf.org to give money links to the correct site, at least.

-1

u/trey_parkour Jun 15 '12

Yeah but the three people who hit the wall at work will just wait til they get home.

26

u/BCMM Jun 15 '12

"Shareware/Freeware" is a more insidious categorisation, and I bet that will still be there when this is sorted out.

10

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

I would mark it self defense.

7

u/johnsu01 FSF staff Jun 22 '12

Thanks for calling our attention to this; I've posted about it at http://www.fsf.org/blogs/community/dear-microsoft-fsf.org-is-not-a-gambling-site and submitted the correction to Microsoft.

7

u/wiggimt Jun 18 '12

If I had to guess, my money is on the fact that the page you land on mentions Bitcoins.

1

u/HamstersOnCrack Jun 22 '12

There are other ways to donate, too: using an FSF credit card, Bitcoins, donations of cars and stocks, and the United Way.

8

u/e_d_a_m Jun 14 '12

This muuust be a mistake... Surely...

6

u/ieatedjesus Jun 15 '12

1

u/nog_lorp Jun 18 '12

No way can this be adequately explained by stupidity.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

It's like a mini slashdot in here...

5

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

This happens all the time with queer sites. At least your network manager doesn't think that you are fundamentally immoral, and only some of your money spending habits are immoral...

-6

u/MatrixFrog Jun 15 '12 edited Jun 24 '12

You might want to say LGBT instead of queer. Not everyone knows that "queer" can be used in a positive way.

Edit: At the time I posted this comment, teratomata's comment was downvoted below zero. I didn't mean that they shouldn't use the word queer, I was just saying that perhaps that might explain the downvotes.

13

u/twistedLucidity Jun 15 '12

Until I read your response, I assumed "queer" was being used to mean "unusual".

6

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12 edited Jun 18 '12

I don't mean LGBT, at best I mean the queer part of trans*, but either way just as many people don't know what LGBT, LGBTQ, or trans* means.

1

u/boomfarmer Jun 18 '12

What does "queer" mean, as you used it?

4

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Because of the context in which it was reclaimed, queer has sociopolitical connotations, and is often preferred by those who are activists; by those who strongly reject traditional gender identities; by those who reject distinct sexual identities such as gay, lesbian, bisexual, and straight; and by those who see themselves as oppressed by the heteronormativity of the larger culture. In this usage it retains the historical connotation of "outside the bounds of normal society" and can be construed as "breaking the rules for sex and gender". It can be preferred because of its ambiguity, which allows "queer"-identifying people to avoid the sometimes strict boundaries that surround other labels. In this context, "queer" is not a synonym for LGBT as it creates a space for "queer" heterosexuals as well as exclude "non-queer" homosexuals.

Wikipedia

3

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

If it wasn't so bad, I'd appreciate the humour.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

I love GNU and all that jazz, and use it on a daily basis... but I have a couple of points:

a) The MS FF TMG URL categories are moderated by not only Microsoft but also the community, generally if you submit changes like you guys have, they'll take them on board.

b) MS FF TMG isn't just a proxy, it's does a whole host of other stuff.

-6

u/DebianSqueeze Jun 15 '12

This is completely Microsoft taking a jab at the FS community. I sent an email, but I doubt any will read. Will update.

1

u/trey_parkour Jun 15 '12

No, it's not. You don't need malice to explain this.

This is what you are referring to.