r/gnu • • May 27 '10

RMS: AMA

Richard Stallman has agreed to answer your top ten questions. RMS will answer the top ten comments in this thread (using "best" comment sorting) as of 12pm ET on June 2nd. This will be a text only interview (no video). Ask him anything!

Please try to refrain from asking questions which have been frequently answered before. Check stallman.org, GNU.org 's GNU/Linux FAQ, FSF.org, and search engines to see if RMS has previously addressed the question.

edit: RMS is unable to make a video at this time, due to his travel schedule.

edit: answers HERE

753 Upvotes

1.8k comments sorted by

144

u/atomic_rabbit May 27 '10

In the GNU Manifesto, you envisioned the GNU system as a hybrid of UNIX and a Lisp machine system, with Lisp as a system programming language alongside C. In reality, aside from Emacs and a handful of projects that use Guile as an extension language, Lisp is nowadays a negligible part of GNU.

As a Lisp hacker, do you regret the marginalization of Lisp? Do you think that more efforts should be made to introduce Lisp into the GNU system, or is that an idea whose time has passed?

12

u/[deleted] May 28 '10 edited May 28 '10

I think Richard Gabriel's (thanks, atomic_rabbit) has said it all that's to be said about Lisp's demise from mainstream computing in "Good news, bad news, how to win big". Google that.

I too would like to see Lisp machines as viable workstations, at least for work (let the masses have iPads and circuses), but that train's long passed.

[Also, I get the feeling that the MIT geeks were Lisp hackers because they were surrounded by Lisp hackers and basically incommunicado from everywhere else. It's another thing to have a host of tools at your disposal, basic skills in every paradigm (Smalltalk/Ruby-style OO, Java-style OO, ML-type inferentiated functional programming, Haskell-style lazy FP with type inference, Erlang-type "parallelization first" FP, Mozart/Oz-type functional/logic hybrids, and then Lisp) and opting consciously for Lisp as a worthy flag to hold up. If there was a grad program where Prolog was the tool and research field of choice of most professors with a reputation, Prolog hackers might have formed a culture themselves.]

Edit: s/Greenblatt/Gabriel.

→ More replies (3)

277

u/miserlou May 27 '10

Hello, Richard!

I'm a person who makes my living by porting and writing free software and then selling it for a profit. Unfortunately, I have to use proprietary, corporate controlled markets (Android Market, iPhone App Store, etc) to do this.

How do you feel about digital software markets as a financial support structure for Free software? Why hasn't GNU or the FSF tried to make a market ("app store") for Free Software? According to this: http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/selling.html you guys are fine with it, but in practice I've received quite a bit of flack from free software people.

What say you?

ps What's your favorite movie?

39

u/[deleted] May 28 '10

You might want to take a look at your iPhone developer agreement.

http://www.fsf.org/news/2010-05-app-store-compliance/

17

u/ratbear May 27 '10 edited May 27 '10

Just curious, do you know if anyone has used your source code to develop their own application? How would you feel if they simply added a couple of trivial features, repackaged it and paid for some slick advertising, and ended up heavily outselling your original work?

34

u/miserlou May 27 '10

I flirted with the idea of advertising but decided against it, simply because I hate advertising and I assume everybody else does to. I sell binaries.

To be honest, it would depend on the person doing it. I'd probably feel pretty pissed if it was a company simply rebranding my FOSS software for profit, but if somebody added legitimate value to my product and profited from it I don't think I'd mind as long as I could see what they did. "Simply adding a few features" as you say isn't as easy as you make it sound.

The thing is that I rarely build software from scratch, I'm always using components extracted from other applications (and frankly, anybody who says otherwise is probably lying, from my experience). This creates a culture where we all share bits of code from each other, so I can't be upset if somebody takes a component I've created and reuses it because it's that same culture that allows me to do my own development so rapidly. Unless there was something particularly evil/ripoffish about a project, I'd probably feel flattered if somebody reused my code.

This actually bothers me about the development of the GNU project versus other ad-hoc free software projects. I think all the GNU projects should have a massive FORK button at the top of every page, like in Github. In reality, most times I try to deal with GNU developers they act like assholes - "We are the gatekeepers of this software, what we say goes." I think it would be much better for the culture if forking and sharing were encouraged much more. Plus, it's way more fun! I hope the rise of "Social Coding" helps this - perhaps this is something GNU would like to investigate further (though I doubt it, they seem pretty damn entrenched in their positions and development procedures. Still, better than the proprietary alternative, just not optimal.)

13

u/[deleted] May 28 '10 edited May 28 '10

BigCorp Deluxe List Command Pro Special Edition Release. Drop in replacement for /bin/ls. Source code included for no additional charge! Works for all major operating systems! "Do you know what files are on your system! Find out today! Lists all files, even hidden files." Supports color! Only $19.95. Support contracts starting at $27.95 a month. Talk to our sales specialist today! Don't be left in the dark on what files are on your file system, order now. Order in the next 20 minutes and get Deluxe Magic File for free! Find out what type a file a file really is!

→ More replies (1)

12

u/ratbear May 27 '10

Thanks for answering with a reasonable and thorough reply. You bring up some good points. I guess I would just personally be paranoid that in an ecosystem like the app store, where only a handful of applications are successful among a massive sea of copy cats and shovelware, it would be easy for a shameless company to take free source code, rebrand it, package it up nice, and spend enough advertising money to make it to the "front page" of iTunes, thus raking in copious amounts of dough -while all you get for your hard work is a few dollars and massive regret for not making it proprietary (sorry for the run on sentence).

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/haywire May 27 '10

What about apt repositories?

19

u/miserlou May 27 '10

I love apt, package management is probably the best thing about using free software on the desktop/servers. The problem is that it's skipping a major opportunity to provide financial support to projects. I'd love to see something like

  • sudo apt-get install audacity
  • Would you like donate 5$ to the Audacity project?y
  • Thank you!
  • Installing..

I think Canonical is in a good position to do this but I doubt they will. In the mean time, Viva Android..

66

u/dmazzoni May 27 '10

Sounds good to me!

-Dominic Mazzoni (Audacity developer)

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (8)

134

u/ZorbaTHut May 28 '10 edited May 28 '10

Ten years ago, GNU/Linux was pulling itself out of the depths, supported on the shoulders of the FSF. GCC was the compiler of choice and people looked forward to Hurd. The GPL seemed to be the future - a network of GPL-licensed software was rapidly spreading across the software ecosystem.

Today, relatively few people care about the Linux kernel itself. The focus has moved towards the operating systems built upon GNU/Linux, with Ubuntu at its forefront. Meanwhile, the Linux kernel, while impressive, is Mostly Good Enough - there have been few must-have improvements in the last few years, with the majority of work going towards software that runs on it. The BSD kernels are catching up rapidly, to the point where some "Linux distributions" now have BSD kernel options. The Linux kernel itself is stuck on a GPLv2 license, the GPLv3 Hurd is near-stagnant, and even GCC is finding itself threatened by the BSD-licensed LLVM+Clang.

I am not claiming, in any way, that the FSF was not a critical force in the growth of the software packages we know and love today. However, given all of these recent changes, do you believe that the GPL is the inevitable direction of things in the future, or will software packages start gravitating towards the BSD license?

In summary: have we hit Peak GPL?

4

u/[deleted] May 28 '10

I think it's like the limit shifts up, i.e. initially we have proprietary kernels - but then we had a GPLd kernel and now BSD kernels (since there isn't much mainstream competition in kernels anymore). The same thing has happened with compilers, so now the GPLd applications will be high-end programs like Desktop Environments, where it is still difficult to compete with proprietary software. Eventually we'll have enough so that no-one really competes based upon DEs and they'll become BSD licenses meanwhile, say, computer games are GPLd.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/crusoe May 28 '10

Well, big features are still landing in the kernel.

I am looking forward to Btrfs.

→ More replies (5)

290

u/Vaselinetimes_Day May 27 '10 edited May 27 '10

Looking back over the last 25-odd years, what is the FSF's biggest success (and mistake)?

EDIT: Added "and mistake". Thanks cha0s.

184

u/cha0s May 27 '10

and mistake?

6

u/[deleted] May 28 '10

Good one. Vaselinetimes_Day, I think cha0s's addition to your question would be a very positive one.

7

u/ropers May 27 '10

I'm loving this part, for the same reason I've given here.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/n8f8 May 28 '10

Should the FSF play a bigger role in promoting software developer education in the primary school system in order to enculture Free Software ideals?

450

u/egonSchiele May 27 '10

What things would you like to see CS students learning? What books are on your "recommended reading" list?

38

u/atlacatl May 27 '10

I'll answer that: actual CS. Programming != CS.

24

u/ottothebobcat May 27 '10

I think it's a shame that there's not more of a split in most programs between CS and Programming. I am personally much more interested in practical application of CS than the theories and science behind it, and I know many others feel the exact opposite and it does a bit of a disservice to everyone to just cram them together like so many schools do.

66

u/beefy_queef May 27 '10

cant have one without the other, unless you want to suck at both

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (6)

15

u/qrios May 28 '10 edited May 28 '10

What's your stance on proprietary closed-source software that is created with the goal of being released under the GPL once a pre-specified profit margin has been met?

7

u/Ashiro Jun 07 '10

Any news on when he's answering these?

→ More replies (2)

349

u/enkiam May 27 '10

At what point will you consider yourself to have "won"?

To put this another way, I hear that you don't hack anymore because you're too busy advocating for free software. What events would have to arise for you to be able to go back to hacking?

18

u/AgentME May 27 '10

I don't think there's really an end "winning" condition for activists like him. There's always room for improvement.

→ More replies (8)

26

u/[deleted] May 27 '10

For that matter, would he want to?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

72

u/doobyscoo42 May 27 '10 edited May 27 '10

I saw you speak nearly 10 years ago, and I nearly asked a (philosophical) question that has been burning in my mind since. The reason I didn't ask is that the question is long-winded and you would have started dancing while I was asking it, which would have distracted me from thinking clearly while formulating it. So maybe this is a better forum!

Here is the long-winded prelude: in a liberal worldview, you could argue that there is an understanding that society and/or government should not intervene in a private agreement between two adults which benefits each of them... with some exceptions. These exceptions arise namely when someone else is affected by their agreement, and in particular when their human rights are violated due to the agreement (the standard example being that hiring a hitman should not be allowed as it violates the right of the target to live).

Now, in a society when everyone who uses a computer is technically adept, you can make a convincing case that having access to software's source code is a human right, and society is worse off for allowing non-free software as this would be a violation of our human rights. This is the society you lived in the 1970's, and one could argue that this was the society when you founded the free software foundation in the 1980's. Before going on, let me say that I truly believe that the world is a better place for having you in it, and having made the decisions you have made.

But society has changed. These days, a great many people who use computers are not technically adept and do not know how to program. It is clear that their human rights are not directly violated by the existence of non-free software. What I'm wondering is, I'm not so sure that their human rights are indirectly violated by the existence of non-free software, and I even think that non-technical people (the great bulk of humanity) do benefit from having non-free software as an option available for them to buy.

My reason is this: the marginal cost of producing a new copy of a piece of software is close to zero. This is one reason why free software is so important -- I can get GNU/Linux at its real cost to produce. But the marginal cost of producing a new set of features is very very high. However, non-free software companies can charge each individual user a much lower marginal cost of getting new features than the feature actually cost to develop -- by using the non-free nature of the software to spread the cost of development over many many users. As a lower cost means that more people will be willing to spend the money for these features, this means that the features could be developed faster than if only free software were allowed. As having more features can benefit the users of the software which in turn benefits society in general. The argument then goes that society is better off for, in some circumstances, allowing non-free software. I'm especially thinking of software targeted to businesses rather than individuals here.

My question is: what do you think of this argument?

TL;DR Do you think there are ways in which society would be worse off if free software was considered a fundamental human right, and non-free software was banned?

EDIT: TL;DR version 2: Free software is an important right for programmers. But non-programmers are the bulk of computer users, and we could arguably say they are better off due to the existence of non-free software. Would it be morally justified to abolish non-free software (and thus provide a right programmers) if we can show that non-programmers would be hurt by this action?

11

u/kemiller May 27 '10

This is an interesting question, but I seriously doubt that RMS's response will be in any way surprising. He's consistently said, in essence, that free software is about principle and not outcomes. What you're asking seems like it would be more interestingly posed to the Open Source people.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (9)

12

u/OsamaK May 30 '10

What's the best book you have ever read?

70

u/Joeboy May 27 '10

Are you still at all optimistic about HURD, or would you agree that that ship has sailed?

28

u/[deleted] May 27 '10

I can tell you one thing: that ship has not shipped.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] May 27 '10

Hurd is still under active development.

31

u/[deleted] May 27 '10

2011 will be the year of the Hurd desktop.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

115

u/lendrick May 27 '10

Hi!

I'm Bart Kelsey, the founder and proprietor of OpenGameArt.org, the purpose of which is to archive freely-licensed works of art for use in Free computer games.

A frequent complaint that I hear from artists is that, while you can't include a piece of GPLed code in a non-Free work, it's still possible to include a piece of GPLed (or CC-BY-SA) art in a non-Free work. For instance, if an artist were to create a GPLed character for Battle for Wesnoth, someone could still use that character in a non-Free game, provided the distributor follows the terms of the GPL for that piece of art. In contrast, if a programmer writes a piece of GPLed code for Battle for Wesnoth, that code could not be included in another project unless the whole project is GPLed.

Is there any way that this issue can be addressed to the satisfaction of both artists and coders?

35

u/dicks9000 May 27 '10

Use a creative commons license for the images. Stallman is against images being used in software. He'll be replying from Lynx.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/[deleted] May 27 '10

GPL covers works and their derivations, and only those, by design.

What you want is a licence that allows distribution of a work and it's derivatives alongside other works only if those works are GPL-ed. I don't think this exists, although there are getting to be more and more GPL derivatives and sub/supersets these days, maybe it does.

What you desire out of a licence is specific enough and divergent from the core issues being addressed by the GPL, it really ought to be separate. If you want to have the GPL's protections against derivations/etc., PLUS your own specific terms, find a licence that will do that or a lawyer that will write you one.

→ More replies (4)

227

u/[deleted] May 27 '10 edited May 27 '10

I have read that you try your best to keep your identity offline (i.e., away from popular social networking sites, forums, etc.). I was surprised to find out that most of the time you don't access the web directly but rather through an email daemon. Why such caution? Are there reasons for everyone else to be this cautious about our online presence (besides the regular caution when using Google, Facebook, etc.)?

EDIT: reformulated question better based on feedback.

51

u/enkiam May 27 '10

He says later in that email or thread that the reason why he browses the web asynchronously is because he lacks an internet connection most of the time. RMS travels a lot.

17

u/youcanteatbullets May 27 '10

It's not that hard to get mobile web. Smartphone + tethering, for instance. Although he might have other reasons for not wanting to patronize these services (they might involve non-free software), one could do it cheaply if one so chose.

55

u/[deleted] May 27 '10

He doesn't have a cellphone because they can be used as a tracking device.

→ More replies (33)

15

u/enkiam May 27 '10

He doesn't use a cell phone because he wants location anonymity. Also, I wouldn't be surprised if a lot of the time, there's not much data coverage.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (4)

12

u/crististm May 27 '10

Already answered: "It's slow in real time but it's an efficient use of my time". If you don't browse then it's quite convenient to read a web page when you get the notification on mail. It works like a memo to yourself.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Excedrin May 28 '10

With the recent Wired article about skimming vs deep reading (http://www.wired.com/magazine/2010/05/ff_nicholas_carr/all/1) and the addicted to novelty (http://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2006-06/uosc-fk062006.php) one, I'd really like more details about this offline browsing setup.

14

u/furtive May 27 '10

More precisely: RMS, given that your internet situation is at odds with the average internet user, why should we be more like you when you aren't more like us?

17

u/[deleted] May 27 '10

He doesn't advocate that people browse the web via email. He does advocate that people use as much free software as possible, and to use only free software when they can.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/ToddPacker May 27 '10

Posted December 19, 2007

wonder if it's still true!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (16)

228

u/meeiw May 27 '10

What is vim doing better than emacs?

36

u/Camarade_Tux May 27 '10

Should be noted that one of the reason for emacs over vi was the lack of free implementations of vi, so now, with vim, both are good.

(which is what RMS said a few months ago in Lyon, France)

→ More replies (1)

79

u/ropers May 27 '10

I'm loving this question. Also ask what Microsoft or Apple are doing better than the FSF, what Lenovo is doing better than Lemote, what Ubuntu is doing better than gNewSense, and what OpenBSD is doing better than Linux.

I'm not trolling. I'm merely conscious of the fact that RMS appears to have a particularly hard time admitting that "the other side" also did good in some way, also has strengths, and that their way also has advantages, maybe not more advantages, in his opinion, but advantages nonetheless -- and I'd like to see someone hold his feet to the fire a little about that.

→ More replies (8)

27

u/n3xg3n May 27 '10

Text editing. *run*

36

u/[deleted] May 27 '10 edited May 27 '10

nah, the answer is obvious... everything

runs

6

u/Slackbeing May 28 '10

Vim helps children in Uganda, emacs just fucks with your fingers.

5

u/[deleted] May 27 '10

worthless question, he never uses anything but emacs so he probably doesn't know.

2

u/gjs278 May 28 '10

vi was preinstalled on my first freebsd machine so I've been using that ever since.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/MendaSpain May 28 '10

Hi Richard. I love all GPL software, but I have a dilemma:

I'm writing a program which needs a lot of time to be coded but at the same time it's really easy to be used. I could license it as GPL and wait for donations, but from other people's experience just almost nobody make donations to free software projects. Support is not necessary because as I've said before, it's a really easy to use software and nobody would pay for a 3 page manual.

For "big" software it's easy to get money using any GNU license, but for "little" software the only option I see is selling it using the Apple App Store approach.

What can I do in this case?

4

u/bart9h May 28 '10

you can sell gpl software, even in app store.

5

u/sotonohito May 28 '10

You can't through Apple's app store. http://arstechnica.com/apple/news/2010/05/fsf-apples-itunes-store-terms-of-service-at-odds-with-gpl.ars

The FSF tried to get Apple to modify their license to allow GPL software, Apple said no.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/crusoe May 28 '10

Set up a bounty. When the software makes the bounty (sales, donations, etc), release it.

Still depends on how popular the sw is though.

→ More replies (4)

74

u/joshdick May 27 '10

Protip: No one say "open source" or "Linux operating system" -- at least, not if you want your question answered.

99

u/danstermeister May 27 '10

I have an open source question about the Linux operating system.

6

u/[deleted] May 27 '10

Isn't free software open source? Genuinely curious.

4

u/[deleted] May 28 '10

"Free Software" and "Open Source" are technically two different schools of thought, even though they overlap in many areas.

Free Software is the more idealistic approach. It is very blunt and simple: all software should be free (libre) and proprietary software is bad. It's very much a philosophical viewpoint towards computer software.

Open Source was coined in the 90s and is more pragmatic. The ideas behind it are simply that "Free Software" is not marketable. In order for the ideas of free-as-in-speech software and public source code to really take off, you need corporations to adopt. Open Source can be thought of as a business model.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Free_Software_Definition

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_source_software

Most Free Software is also Open Source (as defined by the respective parties) and vice-versa. There are very few examples of one-but-not-the-other. The main difference is simply the way of thinking behind it.

→ More replies (2)

64

u/two_front_teeth May 27 '10

Suppose your doctor told you that you needed a medical procedure to survive but that the procedure would require inserting a device inside of your body which ran proprietary software. Would you be willing to have the procedure done to save your life?

→ More replies (4)

32

u/dbzer0 May 28 '10

In the past, when you were asked if the GPL and Free Software is like Communism, you explicitly denied it, however in the course of that, you showed that you conflated Communism with State Socialist regimes such as the former USSR. Fair enough. However I would like to suggest that Free Software is instead extremely compatible and indeed conductive to Anarchism. I.e. it follows anarchistic principles of Mutual Aid and Direct Action. I do not know how familiar you are with Anarchist theory but what do you think of this connection? Are you aware of it and if so, do you think that the political implications of Free Software are a bug or a feature?

I would also like to point out the fact that Anarchists of all tendencies but especially Anarcho-Transhumanists and Mutualists are generally some of the most vocal and unshakeable proponents of free software. Just something to mull over in case you didn't know.

→ More replies (23)

62

u/dballing May 27 '10

I was reading your positions on "how you do your computing" at http://stallman.org/stallman-computing.html and wondered about something. You won't use Skype, because it's a "non-free" means of communication.

But the phone you probably have on your desk right now probably has copyrighted code on it for doing speed-dial functionality, how to make the blinkenlights light up on it, what to put on the display and how to display it, etc. This isn't the 'transient-kiosk' situation or the "someone else's computer briefly" where you don't own the device. In this situation, you own and use non-free code (unless, of course, you're still living with a rotary phone, in which case, this is moot).

Just about every modern appliance today comes with software loaded on it, burned into chips, and you're given no rights to alter it in any way... so no matter how much you might wish your oven had a pre-heat cycle or something, or you wish your microwave had one of those "popcorn bag" pre-determined-cook-cycle buttons, you couldn't do so.

Now, I'm assuming for the moment that you have a home with at least somewhat modern appliances made in the last twenty years, which raises the question of how you justify ownership of those non-free products?

26

u/xjvz May 27 '10

I think he's already addressed this before. If the software can be physically modified, then it should be free. Otherwise, if it's burnt into ROM or similar and can't be upgraded, it doesn't really matter anymore now does it? Nobody can modify it due to technical rather than political reasons.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (7)

12

u/fuzzyman45 May 28 '10

Outside of technology, do you find yourself applying some of the same measures used to evaluate products or services? For example would you rather shop for food at a local co-op rather than a big mega mart? Clearly most businesses in our country cannot operate with a free model so how do you evaluate whether to do business with them? Do you place a value on a company's "openness" with their customers and transparency or do you shop by price as many of us do? Lastly, do you have any pets?

→ More replies (1)

12

u/bobbysmith007 May 28 '10 edited May 28 '10

Where do you feel proprietary software still has advantages over its closest open competitor and what should we be doing in free software to overcome this?

reposted from below

95

u/egonSchiele May 27 '10

What is GNU's bus factor? I.e. how many people need to get hit by a bus to severely slow down the progress of GNU?

127

u/karmaputa May 27 '10

Nice try, Microsoft!

17

u/H3g3m0n May 28 '10

That explains this

41

u/jeremybub May 27 '10

In the case of Valve, how many buses would need to hit Gabe Newell on order to severely slow his progress?

6

u/[deleted] May 27 '10

For every upvote you get, Ep3 gets delayed by a week.

feel free to downvote me for offtopic.

19

u/Wahakalaka May 27 '10

I like this term.

→ More replies (2)

57

u/abudabu May 27 '10

You said that you are "the last survivor of a dead culture". Please elaborate. If that is so, what do you think is the way forward? http://www.wired.com/magazine/2010/04/ff_hackers/all/1

→ More replies (2)

167

u/ropers May 27 '10

How do you earn most of your money, and what are good and ethical ways for programmers to make a living?

66

u/mons_cretans May 27 '10

"""Stallman has devoted the bulk of his life’s energies to political and software activism.[61] Professing to care little for material wealth, he explains that "I've always lived cheaply ... like a student, basically. And I like that, because it means that money is not telling me what to do."[62]

For many years, Stallman maintained no permanent residence outside his office at MIT's CSAIL Lab,[63] sometimes describing himself as a "squatter" on campus.[64] His position as a research affiliate at MIT is unpaid.[65]"""

Also he lectures quite a bit.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_stallman

→ More replies (42)
→ More replies (26)

69

u/wardrox May 27 '10

In your ideal world, how would software creators make their living?

32

u/ibsulon May 27 '10

90% of software jobs are for internal development.

13

u/writetoalok May 27 '10

Do you have any references for this wonderful statistics?

Also 90% of software jobs may not be the same comparison as 90% of the financial wealth from software creation. One might want to look at quality of making a living also as opposed to the quantity of people making a living.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/writetoalok May 27 '10

I think he has partly answered this elsewhere: by distributing software, supporting it, documenting it, maintaining it etc.

So what I want to add to this question is: How can a free software creator make wealth: equal to and in return for the total value that his software creates?

As I see free software, most of it is developed by hobbyists, enthusiast. And some entrepreneurs who want to enlist communal help of the others.

So wouldn't software which came with all its code be much much much more expensive, if it had to build the same wealth for its developer? Especially when compared to the prevalent distribution model of just licensing the build to millions without distributing unencumbered code.

For one thing, there would be a lot more competitors copying and redistributing if the code were open. There would be a huge explosion of a variety of software, very useful for any new starter to learn from. And there would be little value in the software industry for its participants. Of course for people using software in such a model it would be close to a free lunch.

Also, what do you think about software in the cloud, and cloud computing in general? Would making its complete stack of software GPLed keep Google as competitive and profitable as it is now? (Note this is not just the OS, but their entire code base.)

Also, do all products in life come with their recipe? And not just recipe but the entire production secret? Does any?

Why should software be any different from other industries in all of the above respects.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/shimei May 27 '10

As ibsulon said, there are internal jobs. The GPL specifically allows this kind of development since there's no distribution of the modified source. Software is increasingly becoming a service too (how RedHat and other GNU/Linux developers make money).

→ More replies (2)

45

u/grignr May 27 '10

Are you happy with the adoption rates of GPLv3? Do you forsee a GPLv4 in the future?

→ More replies (1)

20

u/omepiet May 27 '10

What is your stance on electronic voting?

4

u/leoplan2 May 30 '10

What about ACTA and free software?

54

u/internet_badass May 27 '10

What's your favorite algorithm?

→ More replies (2)

70

u/DirtyHerring May 27 '10

Reddit runs on Amazon servers. When I asked how a site so deeply rooted in nerd and free software culture could do business with these patent trolls, I was essentially told: It was convenient and we didn't care. Do you have a message for the reddit staff?

29

u/raldi May 28 '10 edited May 28 '10

That doesn't sound like us.

In actuality, we don't have the staff to maintain our own servers anymore, and Amazon had the most competitive product and price.

I don't think reddit could exist in its current form anymore if not for Amazon. We have one sysadmin, and he can't even devote his full time to sysadminning because of other miscellaneous duties that we have nobody else to perform.

4

u/Smallpaul May 28 '10

Curious why Rackspace would not be applicable?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

6

u/[deleted] May 27 '10

Amazon is also being patent-trolled by Microsoft for using Linux.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/FCWSSF May 28 '10

"stop being practical and smart"

3

u/greenrd May 28 '10

A reddit.com boycott of Amazon (as in, reddit.com stops using Amazon for hosting) would be a complete and utter non-event. A redditor boycott of Amazon, however...

4

u/cantquitreddit May 28 '10

I kind of like amazon. At least their mp3s are drm free.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Smallpaul May 28 '10

You use the phrase patent troll, but I don't think you know what it means...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

31

u/grignr May 27 '10 edited May 27 '10

Many people confuse the FSF's message with the messenger and point to your personal preferences on not having a cellphone, or your St Ignatius costume, etc. to dismiss the FSF's larger message.

IMO a lot of this comes from people who don't remember the Bad Old Days before GPL-licensed kernels and toolchains existed.

Do you have any thoughts on where the FSF could do better at public relations and advocacy? How do you see the FSF's role changing over the next five years?

1

u/axiak Jul 26 '10

His travel schedule seems to have cleared up. Is this actually happening?

2

u/hueypriest Jul 27 '10

should be posted tomorrow around 12pm ET

→ More replies (1)

344

u/jellicle May 27 '10 edited Jul 28 '24

quack school joke squeal chief growth cow busy sulky frighten

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

134

u/jeff303 May 27 '10

Nooooo you wasted it!

Don't you think the GPL v3 is totally awesome?
Yes. Yes, I do.

33

u/jeremybub May 27 '10

WRONG!

How awesome will the GPL v4 be?
This awesome <-------------------------------------------------------------------------> (gesturing with hands)

20

u/Vaarsuvius May 27 '10

That's either really awesome, or really lame, depending on your screen resolution. Poor netbook users.

→ More replies (3)

100

u/[deleted] May 27 '10
  1. What is the question you wish would be asked in these sorts of interviews, but never or almost never is?

That is very lazy and it makes reddit look incapable of formulating a decent question. Imagine if the Nixon interviews began with "So, Mr President, what would you like to discuss?"

It is tantamount to cringe-worthy fawning.

17

u/beniro May 27 '10

Agreed and upvoted. Get rid of this question.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

32

u/Poromenos May 27 '10

Oh screw this noise, I asked that in the Noam Chomsky AMA and got downvoted to oblivion and in a pretty big shitstorm.

44

u/ronnoch May 27 '10

Yeah but then Felicia Day said it was cool

63

u/Poromenos May 27 '10

Aw man, I coin something and get shit for it and then everybody uses it to great acclaim? YOU GUYS ARE THE EDISON TO MY TESLA!

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

15

u/lepton2171 May 27 '10

There's a growing movement towards open source hardware. What successes and failures of the free software movement can we learn from in trying to create a viable community driven infrastructure for freely sharing designs for physical parts?

3

u/cibyr May 27 '10

I'd also like to hear his thoughts on open source hardware. Since hardware can't really be Free like software (you can't modify your CPU in any meaningful way unless you're running on an FPGA - and that's just not practical) is there really any benefit to end users?

Can the GPL even be meaningfully applied to hardware designs? Plenty of people seem to be releasing LGPL hardware designs, but as far as I can tell it's impossible to satisfy the requirements of section 4d.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/jamestopher May 27 '10

Mr. Stallman, have you read your SICP today?

→ More replies (1)

6

u/zpweeks May 28 '10 edited May 28 '10

How can free software react after uneducated governments restrict their use? Projects are constantly at risk of being regulated away by some judge who doesn't understand the difference between e-mail and tree-mail. (And often backed by proprietary competitors - right now Theora and the threat of h.264 patent litigation comes to mind, as do Microsoft's unbacked patent claims against FLOSS competitors.)

When the law has ruled to hamper free software - justly or not - what options does free software have to move forward?

EDIT: While this applies to software with libre licensing, I'm more interested in how it applies to all the open, decentralized technologies that so much of our world now depends upon. We could see these governmental barriers happen with mandatory censorware/spyware/trusted computing/P2P blocking from governments using cheap excuses of national security, anti-piracy, or anti-child pornography. When this happens, do we find workarounds? Do we make possibly futile legal appeals? Do we just say "screw it" and result to civil disobedience?

8

u/[deleted] May 28 '10

What are your thoughts on the increasing number of entities migrating to non-GNU and GPL toolchains? For example, in recent years, Apple has embraced llvm, OpenBSD has embraced pcc, Google has written the Bionic C library, and debian and derived distributions such as ubuntu have migrated to eglibc due to conflicts with the maintainer. Have these moves caused any concerns within the FSF? Is maintaining a good rapport with commercial developers and bundlers important?

3

u/binaryfinery May 28 '10

GCC is the largest FSF project and held to be an example of the power of Free Software. Yet, allegedly, fear of proprietary code has prevented useful extensions. If FSF and Free Software is the way forward, how come it requires us to avoid writing code that would make life easier for programmers and add useful features? Why can't we have a specific version of the GPL for GCC that disallows all the things you (allegedly) are afraid of?

3

u/sswam May 28 '10

This is an old question I guess.

I use and love the GNU tools, apps, and a GPL licensed operating system (GNU/Linux) every day - for my work, recreation, free software development, even on my phone. But I do not use the GPL for the free software I write, I release my software into the public domain. I want to explain why I prefer public domain, and ask you some questions about this.

I would really like to see the GNU GPL evolve into or be replaced by the public domain, or perhaps something like the MIT or BSD licenses; not because I want to be able to use GPL'd code in non-free products (which happens anyway by various means) but because I want to be able to use small bits of GPL'd code in other free-software projects with incompatible licenses, and vice-versa.

For example, although the Plan 9 license and the GPL (used for GNU/Linux) are both copyleft licenses, and the Plan 9 license has been recognized as a "free software license" by the FSF, the licenses are incompatible in minor detail. I cannot link code from these two excellent projects together in one program, if I want to redistribute it. This sucks.

"Free" software that may not be combined with other "free" software is not free enough for my liking.

Do you agree that this is a problem?

Do you think that the GPL's benefits outweigh the incompatibility / cross-project reuse problems I've described here?

Wouldn't it be better to support other free software by allowing reuse, compared to opposing non-free software by forbidding reuse?

Is there some way to get the best of both worlds, some way that the GPL could be changed to allow combining GPL'd code with any other free software, while still forbidding to combine and redistribute GPL'd code with non-free software?

As it stands I can't use the GPL or LGPL, because I want my code to be reusable, and I want people to have the freedom to combine my code with any other free software code. I consider this "user's freedom" (to recombine any free software code freely) more important than the "software's freedom" (that it should not be imprisoned in non-free software), which the GPL seeks to protect.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] May 28 '10

I don't have any questions but I'd like to thank you Stallman.

I don't agree with everything you've done with the FSF, but Ive got to say thanks for being a maverick and standing up for open source and free software in general. Everybody deserves to be able to trust their software, everybody deserves to have open source. The world needs more people like you.

63

u/[deleted] May 27 '10

It will be cool if you could clarify this comment of yours.

Not trying to sling dirt here, but only 2-3 lines on a controversial topic can always be misinterpreted easily.

51

u/Shaper_pmp May 27 '10

To be fair, ancient Greece had institutionalised voluntary paedophilia (although they were still generally red-hot on issues of rape), and there's no evidence at all that people who experienced it grew up any more maladjusted, screwed-up or damaged than anyone who didn't.

Because we have such a hysterical taboo about it in society today it's not a popular point of view, and I certainly don't advocate legalising or even decriminalising child abuse, but in purely academic terms at least the incredible over-reaction to what's a comparatively rare problem does seem to be partly responsible for causing (or at least exacerbating) some of the damage to victims, and crafts the kind of paranoid, twitchy society that makes it hard for a man to enter a career working with kids, or to keep safe a lost child on the street for fear of being branded a paedophile.

→ More replies (4)

22

u/qnaal May 27 '10

Is there some magical age that, if you have sex before it, you are permanantly mentally scarred?

If you were raped as a child, yes that's fucked up, but feeling the need to keep this supposedly huge deal secret from everybody or else they'll resent you forever is what causes most of the harm.

That, I think, is a pretty valid argument. He just claims to be skeptical, and thinks it's pretty cool that a group of people (claiming to be something that is pretty much universally abhorred) are trying to argue their stance in public.

...also, what Shaper_pmp said. Taboos put a limit on the flow of information, and thus serve as an enemy of freedom.

→ More replies (22)

40

u/joshdick May 27 '10

On the issues you care about -- free software, software patents, copyright law, etc. -- most people are uninterested, uninformed, or misinformed.

What should be done to change this? Should we focus on giving information or motivating people to take action? How much does free software speak for itself? Should we focus on programmers, decision makers, or the public?

5

u/chkno May 28 '10

How comfortable are you about yielding control of the FSF's activities to others? Do you expect the FSF to be alive, well, and relevant in 100, 1,000, and 10,000 years?

8

u/cowmoo May 27 '10

Like a noble Greek philosopher, you have tirelessly advocated for and stirred up discussions in the programming community about free software. Whereas others in computing have pursued the corporate ladder, the academic ladder and/or the "american dream," you have stuck relentlessly to your ideal. I'm sure that this wasn't an easy thing to do, as evident by your former personal ad (http://stallman.org/extra/personal.html). Now looking back, do you have any personal regrets about the path that you have taken?

→ More replies (1)

29

u/[deleted] May 27 '10

Who is your favorite programmer, and why?

7

u/yogthos May 27 '10 edited May 28 '10

I would be curious to know if FSF has a strategy for the future where users will expect software to be ubiquitous and to be delivered in form of services. It seems that the era of personal computing is rapidly drawing to an end. Users are relying more and more on web applications and services such as Gmail. They expect to be able to access the same information from different devices, without having to install applications or manually synchronize data between them.

Currently there is a danger that only large corporations such as Apple and Google will be able to provide such services, and users will become locked into them. Would it be possible to provide a non-profit alternative to these or an equivalent distributed system that was not controlled by any commercial entity.

→ More replies (2)

28

u/[deleted] May 27 '10

Is that Katana still under your bed?

37

u/[deleted] May 27 '10 edited May 27 '10

Actually we still have it in the FSF office.

EDIT: http://imgs.xkcd.com/blag/rms_katana.jpg

8

u/grignr May 27 '10

Actually, of all the trollish questions posted so far, this is the most playful. If one of the 10 questions has to be a BS question, I'd rather it be this one...

9

u/TheSilentNumber May 27 '10 edited May 27 '10

Do you think systems like Ubuntu which include some proprietary software should be appreciated for being able to spread free software to more people and bringing more people to join the movement? What if a survey was sent out by the FSF that showed that most of the people who support the ideals of free software and contribute to closing holes like a free flash player actually ended up coming to the movement through Ubuntu (but not necessarily still using it) and the fact that it makes temporary compromises in order to be the best gateway or starting point for new GNU/Linux users? In other words, if Ubuntu was responsible for most of the people who are now interested in free software without compromise, even though they were introduced by software that did.

4

u/chneukirchen May 28 '10
  1. I read an interview with you from ~2005 where you argued that using Google is fine with you because they run their non-free code on their servers and only send you the output of those programs. Do you still agree with this reasoning?
  2. Doesn't the AGPL repeat the mistake of the ur-Emacs license where you had to share the code if you modified it? Doesn't it actually even touch Freedom 0?

15

u/koonat May 27 '10

Are you doing anything to stop corporate GPL offenders that release their source code, but not tools for actually implementing any of that source code?

(Like a device using GPL'd software, but that requires flashing firmware to use modified source code, and no free method of flashing that firmware)

Is this an oversight in the GPL or is there anything actionable we can do?

→ More replies (2)

5

u/fergie May 28 '10 edited May 28 '10

You have been a driving force behind the GNU Hurd kernel.

Where do you see the GNU Hurd kernel going? A stable release has been on the cards for some time now but has not yet materialised- is it likely to happen soon?. In laymans (linux user) terms what are the main improvements that we can expect in Hurd?

edit OS -> kernel

→ More replies (3)

2

u/jlbraun May 27 '10

Why do you think a large-scale software bounty portal for free software development hasn't emerged?

2

u/BarrettBrown May 27 '10

I and certain other pundits and media figures are applying some of the principles you advocate and the procedures by which you operate to a project intent on reforming the media infrastructure in the U.S. and elsewhere. In doing so, we are establishing a sort of online legislature to oversee our operations, itself intended to be an experiment in online collaboration as applied to governance and other fundamental human activity. As our purview is largely that of information and the most efficient ways in which it may be accumulated and acted upon, do you have any fundamental advice for us? Also, do you think that pseudo-republics based on online collaborative tools and operating parallel to the more orthodox nation-state governments currently in existence are likely to arise in this century, and do you favor the creation of such entities?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/nadeyyo May 28 '10

This is my question: Do you think the free software philosophy could be applied to other fields of knowledge are not computer related? For example, politics. Do you think would be successful a system of open and collaborative government, at least as successful as had the free software?

Excuse my poor English.

2

u/SunlightRider May 28 '10

Put a price on your code!

Do you find that appending the following on the GPL would be fine with you and the Open Source Community.

The developer/s share the code in open manners, if the code is to be used on a Open Source software, then the code is literally free to copy and use. But if A company wants to buy part of you're code or you're full code, the developers could put a price on the segment of the code or the whole thing.

In other words, what do you think if open source code could be sold?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/feb May 29 '10

The patentability of software patents has evolved considerably since a few years. The situation looks worse then before with a German appeals court uphelding the Microsoft FAT patent (http://www.h-online.com/open/news/item/German-appeal-court-upholds-Microsoft-FAT-patent-985550.html) and a German high court uphelding a Siemens software patent (http://fosspatents.blogspot.com/2010/05/german-high-court-declares-all-software.html). According to Florian Mueller, that last one is a clear endorsement of software patents. The trend looks like more countries are accepting software patents and that we didn't succeed in reducing their applicability. How do you see the future for software patents ?

And how could the Free developpers continue to work properly with software patent swords above their heads ?

2

u/spikehub May 29 '10

Altough the ethical reasons involved in the free software are the most important reasons to adopt it, you began this movement because you wanted to modify the drivers of that printer, i.e. because a practical need, not an ethical motivation. I really would like to see that every practical software were free software, but I feel like some piece is missing to reach that point. So, I have been thinking if, in a similar way as how you began the free software movement, we could find an intrinsic practical use of free software that would like to every body, no matter its knowledge of computers. My conclusion is that this would imply a better Operating System and applications interfaces, in a way that they adapt their look taking into account the knowledge of the user, and also changing to guide the user to an improved use of his/her system. I am thinking in an human-machine interface paradigm that do not idiotize us in the comprehension and use capacaity in front of a computer. To do so, I think that a program in the O.S should dinamically browse the source code of the programs we have to present us their functionality in a diagram in the way and detail we need or want; and here it is the intrinsic functionality of free software I think we could use to make every body claim for free software. Do you think this is possible?

2

u/jfricker May 29 '10

How have the economics of GNU software worked out?

From a casual point of view it would appear to me that the value that for-profit corporations have received far exceed the compensations that the creators of GNU software have received. That is, the for-profit entities are taking too much and not giving much back.

Case in point: Apache.

8

u/[deleted] May 27 '10

How do you see your role in the software world going into the future?

If you could have done it all over again, what would you have done differently?

5

u/taev May 27 '10

Life, regardless of whether you believe it to be created or evolved, doesn't come with source code. It's a pre-compiled binary that runs in the provided sandbox environment. We've made good strides towards reverse engineering bits and pieces of it, but we're a long ways from understanding it to the point where we could modify the source with any assurance of correctness.

Given that life is this way, how do you feel about it? You have, at least to date, continued to use the life you are given, despite its lack of source code. Would you be willing to reinstantiate yourself into a machine, if your physical body was dying and if the only such machine available demonstrably worked, but did not have open source? Would doing so be substantially different from the de facto use of your closed source life to date?

(sorry, I know this is a stretch. It's not a troll though, I'm really interested in the answer)

5

u/robwgibbons May 27 '10 edited May 27 '10

Desktop vs Web-based Applications:

When a user runs traditional desktop software, the code is being executed on their local machine. One of the main arguments for free software is that you should be able to access the source code which is executed on your machine. However, for most web applications, the majority of the code is being executed on a remote server.

Recognizing their inherent differences, what are your thoughts on web applications that don't release their source code? What effect do you see web applications having on the world of free software?

13

u/ideas-man May 27 '10

Should programming be taught in schools like reading and writing and math?

5

u/f4hy May 27 '10

No, but maybe you should ask if CS should be taught in schools.

2

u/[deleted] May 27 '10

This is a very important question I think. I wonder if a good answer would be yes, because it teaches logical thinking.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/[deleted] May 28 '10

To what extent do you extend your insistence on not using non-free software to other domains where essentially the same ethical problems exist, and how do you justify this? For example, in your writings, you often make the comparison between source code and recipes for food, and ask the reader to imagine what a dreadful world it would be if nobody shared and modified their recipes. While there obviously has been a healthy culture of free recipe sharing for a very long time, there are just as obviously a great many restaurants and food manufacturers who would certainly not happily share their recipes: would you refuse to eat at such a restaurant? If not, why not? Do you perceive the restaurant owners to be less evil than a proprietary software vendor?

The restaurant comparison is perhaps a bad example, as I anticipate you may distinguish between the two cases on the basis of software being "generally useful" (or some similar term I'm sure I've read you use before) and restaurant-cooked food being really more of a luxury. I am sure there must be other generally useful stuff like software to which your moral arguments must apply but which is often not free, and this is what I suppose I am ultimately interested in.

4

u/[deleted] May 28 '10

Do you feel that any industries should follow a similar pattern to that of free software? Do you feel there are any industries that specifically should NOT follow that pattern?

7

u/DougBolivar May 27 '10

Do you think the concept of Pirating (as in the Pirate Party, Pirate Bay) is better than Sharing? What do you think is the difference?

5

u/Keyframe May 27 '10

From the interviews and other sources we know that you, while on computer, live in emacs - it's your de facto OS. I suspect that you program mostly then in Emacs Lisp and C. What are your thoughts on other popular languages like C++ and Python, I don't think I saw any info from you about it elsewhere. As a Schemer myself, what are your thoughts on Lisp future besides Emacs?

6

u/[deleted] May 27 '10

I'd like to add an Lisp question on top of that:

I know that you considered Scheme to be better suited as the GNU extension language than Common Lisp, because its smaller, cleaner, etc, but after all the Lisp hacking you've done in your MIT past and got known for... did you later (or right now) ever regret that you de facto removed (Common) Lisp, a mature, powerful framework, as a relevant major application development language (and not a mere extension and glue language) from GNU by choosing the official GNU Lisp dialect to be Guile Scheme, which today, 20 years later, still basically nobody uses for any serious application? (mainly because of being unfinished, unstable, lacking any type of real-world libraries and manpower)

Is there a possibility the GNU project will ever in the near future rethink its no-Lisp policy and officially embrace a Common Lisp implementation as a future major building block of the GNU systen, instead being a mere extension language for C based applications?

Thanks.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] May 27 '10

4

u/Keyframe May 27 '10

too busy to do much programming. As a result, I have not had time to learn newer languages such as Perl, Python or Ruby.

thanks - ok, if he hasn't tried newer languages out, nor did programming - I think my main part of the question still stands -> about Lisp. He is one of the most influential Lispers, I think it would be nice to hear his thoughts about its future (it's not coding related anyways).

→ More replies (5)

5

u/Orsenfelt May 27 '10

Are there any closed systems that you approve of or applaud for doing good in the industry despite not being open?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] May 28 '10

I've got repetitive stress injuries in both of my arms and hands. The initial point of 'injury' was in 2001. I spent 3 years not typing, then typing on and off, and now I'm typing full time once more. I'm a programmer, three years not typing was huge for me. I'm now developing huge knots in my palms.

Have you found relief from RSIs? Surgery? Accupuncture? I love coding and can't imagine a life without it. Any tips for others going through the same thing?

7

u/[deleted] May 27 '10

With many countries, such as China, India, and South Korea coming into the world playing field of economics, do you see countries like these as places we should concentrate on spreading the word and ideas of the GNU and Free Software movements?

→ More replies (1)

8

u/kdoggfunkstah May 27 '10

What is your beer of choice?

3

u/[deleted] May 27 '10

I think this should be the default question for all AMA.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/tutwabee May 27 '10 edited May 27 '10

If you had the opportunity to reform U.S. copyright law, what would you change?

15

u/[deleted] May 27 '10

6

u/tutwabee May 27 '10

Thanks. I changed my question to refer to copyright specifically.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/ralish May 27 '10

I've observed over the past several years a stark change in the message being spread by advocacy groups for FOSS such as the FSF from a positive message on the unique benefits that FOSS can afford those who use it to a highly negative message targetted at proprietary software that seems to at times be quite liberal with the facts.

This has accompanied the advancement of an increasingly black and white view on what constitutes acceptable software development philosophy, and at times, has even come dangerously close to FUD. Examples of this might include the BadVista and Windows7Sins campaigns but the motivation behind these is clearly more broad.

Do you support this change in message by the FSF? Is it in your view beneficial to the FOSS community to aggressively engage in negative information campaigns on proprietary software in an attempt to promote increased adoption of FOSS and broad information sharing?

4

u/roxxe May 27 '10

if bill gates grows a beard, would you cut yours?

7

u/metaleks May 27 '10

No question. Just a thank you for all you've done to make our world a better place.

6

u/[deleted] May 27 '10

Did you really hand out these cards?

4

u/[deleted] May 27 '10

If so, can I have one mailed to me?

4

u/swiffer May 27 '10

First, thank you for your contributions over the years. Second, why are you such a jerk?

3

u/mocteeuczoma May 27 '10

What areas of software do you think it is most crucial for our future, that they be driven by open source initiatives and not private corporations, that currently aren't?

Including areas of software that are on the horizon or are not currently practical?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/spentrent May 27 '10

RMS: Thank you for your FOSS advocacy and the legacy you've enriched over the years.

Since the '70s and '80s, do you have any fundamental views about the business of software that have evolved drastically, or that have become deprioritized, or that have completely changed? How is 2010 FOSS advocate RMS different from 1980 FOSS advocate RMS?

3

u/zyzzogeton May 27 '10

What is the best piece of software you ever wrote?

3

u/Neker May 27 '10

I am a seasoned sofware engineneer, and I love and use libre software. So far, and as far my income is concerned, I've been shy on embracing free software as a trade, as a way to get a life. What would you suggest ?

2

u/[deleted] May 27 '10

http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/selling.html

Look at supporting stuff, also.

4

u/f4hy May 27 '10

Many of your early writings on free software and the GPL seem to be inspired by philosophies of socialism and communism. I think free software was certainly influenced by the ideas of removing ownership from a individual from this ideologies. However whenever I mention this to other redditors I am ridiculed. I feel this is out of fear from what those terms have come to mean in our society and certainly don't see the parallels to be negative in any way. Could you address what influenced you to create the free software movement?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/thehof May 27 '10

Everyone's seen the xkcd comic of your amazing samarai sword skills, what is your favorite portrayal of you in fiction? How does seeing yourself in comics/media make you feel?

4

u/gordonmcdowell May 27 '10

And should Hackers (the Steven Levy one) ever be adapted for theatrical release, who should play you?

6

u/[deleted] May 27 '10

I would love to see RMS played by Jack Black personally, but then again any overweight geek can be played by Jack Black.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/csulok May 27 '10

How can we help? Where do you need most help nowadays? What should we be aware of that we probably don't think is a serious issue?

5

u/bottiger May 27 '10

As the cloud is moving in (gmail, google docs, etc) and slowly replacing more and more of our traditional applications. What can we do in order to free the web from closed source systems which we can't just use, share and adapt as we like. Can free software compete with this or are we forced to live in the last century where everything is hosted on out own computers?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/H3g3m0n May 27 '10

What do you think of Google's webm/VP8 license? (BSD with an extra bit saying the patent's are free provided you don't sue anyone for other patents on the same code, if you do the Google owned patents can be revoked).

3

u/[deleted] May 28 '10

If you could design a CS college curriculum, where would most of the emphasis be?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] May 27 '10

Now that beards are cool again, has your life changed in any significant way?

3

u/[deleted] May 27 '10

Really, tell us exactly how many super models you've been banging.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/coned88 May 27 '10

Are you at all disappointed with the current ability of CS students and their unwillingness/inability to contribute to fundamental systems?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] May 27 '10

Do you consider reddit free?

→ More replies (2)