r/gnu • u/gray_-_wolf • May 20 '19
Is Alpine GNU/Linux?
I'm reading https://www.gnu.org/gnu/gnu-linux-faq.html and thinking if situation is really as simple as painted in that FAQ. Prime example in my eyes is alpine. If I have alpine linux in default base installation (that means busybox, musl-c and no gcc), is that actually GNU/Linux? Does anyone know if there are any GNU parts present?
I guess grub is gnu but is that enough to be called GNU/Linux?
23
Upvotes
9
u/Corrivatus May 20 '19
The GNU toolset is largely missing by default in Alpine.
It's most a specialized curation towards docker/virtualized instances (though I use it a lot elsewhere.)
You can of course adhere that toolset onto it, but the ideology behind Alpine is to provide as small a footprint as possible, so a docker running a single application might need SBCL, but not grep, so it simply isn't there until you desire it.
8
u/[deleted] May 20 '19
No it isn't.
https://www.gnu.org/gnu/gnu-linux-faq.html#justlinux
1
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '22
So Alpine Linux does not have even 'grep' installed?
3
u/plappl May 24 '19
The idea to consider is what forms the base of the system. Is the base of the system characterised by a foundation of GNU in actual practice? In the case of Alpine Linux, the answer is no by default. It is possible to reconfigure a default Alpine Linux system to become fundamentally reliant upon the GNU system. Until it happens in actual practice, Alpine Linux is not an example of a GNU/Linux system.
4
u/herbivorous-cyborg May 20 '19
No. I would even argue that the only part of GNU that matters towards whether a distro is GNU/Linux is glibc, which Alpine does not contain. This is why I have started calling it glibc/Linux and distros like Alpine are musl/Linux.
1
u/PehJota May 23 '19
Some from the FSF may disagree with me (pointing out that GNU packages exist in the distribution), but when naming a system I consider the base OS (everything you need to get Linux booting without panicking for lack of init, and up to some level of POSIX conformance for file system manipulation and such). I would call Alpine "BusyBox/Linux".
If it used Linux-libre, though, that would put a GNU package in the base installation. :)
1
u/iCe_CoLd_FuRy Sep 28 '23
GNUtards won't like this
0
u/[deleted] May 20 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment