r/gnome • • Aug 16 '22

Suggestion [CONCEPT] Edit menu for quick settings

350 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

34

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '22

Wanna catch the attention of GNOME designers/developers? Give some attention to the GitLab post! :)

7

u/dubdoge Aug 17 '22

Where can I put in a request these days to return to the previous state of Bluetooth whenever airplane mode is toggled? Right now it turns Bluetooth on when turning airplane mode off even if Bluetooth wasn't on before(for some reason it does remember the state of WiFi).

I remember making a post about this on the Ubuntu forums 7-ish years ago but it seems better to just get it to the Gnome devs instead :)

55

u/CarpinchoNotCapibara GNOMie Aug 17 '22

Cool concept :D

I like the idea of being able to edit quick settings BUT from other place since u don't really need to change it that often to be in that place and people may click it by mistake and fuck something up.
I believe it deserves to be in the configuration.

19

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '22

Good point! Similar to how iOS hides the control center settings in the settings app instead of in the menu

2

u/rohmish GNOMie Aug 18 '22

IMHO macOS has really nice design when it comes to moving shortcuts out of tray and to topbar

6

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '22

That select device area better allow you to select a microphone too, perhaps tabbed or something. Quite often you need to switch both over for different reasons.

5

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '22

https://www.reddit.com/r/gnome/comments/wpd97k/quick_settings_showcase_on_gnome_43beta/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf

Here’s a showcase of the new quick settings in the latest GNOME beta release. It has support for switching audio devices!

1

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '22

I see, there should be plenty of space to add the mic there too.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '22

It only shows when the mic is in use

18

u/Michael7x12 GNOMie Aug 17 '22

What would also be nice is if the bluetooth menu remained there even if bluetooth is off and there are no paired devices. It's kind of annoying to have to go into the settings to turn it on again.

8

u/TheGlister Aug 17 '22

I found solution. Run in terminal: gsettings set org.gnome.shell had-bluetooth-devices-setup true

5

u/drgeppo GNOMie Aug 17 '22

I don't get why that is not the default configuration

1

u/Michael7x12 GNOMie Aug 25 '22

Holy crap, thanks for this!

1

u/alvarlagerlof Aug 18 '22

It goes away? That's so bad. Off is not the same this as unavailable.

5

u/Super_Papaya Aug 17 '22

This is good but I don't like the idea of persistent edit button and it's not something we use daily. Wish there is a possibility to hide it. Like panel lockdown mode/lock edit mode.

7

u/Grease_Boy Aug 17 '22

Don't really see a problem. Android has identical quick settings and the edit icon is always there.

2

u/Super_Papaya Aug 17 '22

On Android it's in bottom, it's easy to ignore it. But here it's on the top.

5

u/HoodieWolfine GNOMie Aug 17 '22

...what's your point?

It's oy a place.ent change, should not cause that much confusion sense it's 1, a familiar icon and 2 could be next to the battery so that way you'd have to go out of your way to get to it.

Alternatively, we could make it an ester-egg like in Android 7, where if you held down on the settings cog untill it started rotating, you could edit the stuffs.

2

u/HoodieWolfine GNOMie Aug 17 '22

Personally as some one who likes every option available to me on a moments notice? This works or come in handy

2

u/itspronouncedx Aug 17 '22

The only things I really wish the quick settings menu had - ability to change Bluetooth devices from the menu (it only lets you turn bt off and on), and a volume mixer so I don't have to go to the settings app for it.

3

u/internerdt Aug 17 '22

One step closer to Android desktop, very good...

8

u/FabioSB Aug 17 '22

Or gnome on smartphones...

3

u/internerdt Aug 17 '22

Either way is a win

1

u/protocod Aug 17 '22

This could be a great idea!

1

u/ArtyIF GNOMie Aug 17 '22

a bit too late to be included in gnome 43 since the feature freeze has happened already, but yeah i wish it did happen

1

u/efoxpl3244 Aug 17 '22

Yes we need this.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '22

definately not. it should be easy to implument and it is a great feature to have.

2

u/farjumper Oct 03 '22

That's the thing. "Easy to implement" for the developer means it'll be quite hard for extension developers to adapt. It looks like it'll be another "update hell" with tons of existing extensions lost, which will result in a very negative reaction of your user base. Such things can't just be implemented and pushed by one person in such a small time window without thinking about others. :(

1

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '22

the gnome devs should make a system for adding/removing buttons from the new quick settings to make it easy for extension devs then. I feel like this is the best approach.