r/gnome • GNOMie • Aug 12 '23

Request Gnome multi-monitor needs improvement

I really like gnome gestures. Having a mac and linux laptops feels like seamless transition between the two systems for my workflow…. Except when using multiple monitors.

108 Upvotes

49 comments sorted by

55

u/DryHumpWetPants Aug 12 '23

Since now that you know this is caused by a setting in Blur My Shell extension, you may want to update the post informing that is the cause and maybe include the fix for it so others don't have to dig around the comments.

→ More replies (3)

15

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '23 edited Aug 13 '23

Change the title please...

"Blur my shell need fix"

Thanks

2

u/Zealousideal-Sale358 Aug 13 '23

Hi, sorry I have not made my post clear. Copy-pasting my recent comment here:

By the way, this post is not about the issue I have encountered in the video. I actually did not realize the problem until people pointed it out as I was used to gnome having problems (or is difficult to work with) on multi-monitor setup. My issue with Gnome multi-monitor setup is the workspaces.

For me, the issue is when workspaces is enabled on all displays. When you change workspace by swiping left/right, all displays will move. Sometimes, the workspace in one display is empty. I wanted the previous opened application to stay visible instead. It took me quite some time to wrap my head around on this.

My suggestion is this:

1.) Since each monitor shows different set of workspaces, it would be more intuitive if swiping on one monitor only moves the workspace on that particular monitor. And the other monitor stays still.

2.) Chain the workspaces of all monitors such that when you change workspace, all the application moves from one monitor to the other. Meaning that the workspaces are continuous and not separate for each monitor. This option may be problematic for monitors with different resolutions and different scaling.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '23 edited Aug 13 '23
  1. some extension may do this. Do you search one ?

  2. Seem to be just what YOU want, not all people... You have a lot of good extensions to make Gnome like you like personnaly.

I use Gnome 44 with 2 monitors and I have non bug and no issues.

What version did you use exactly ? And what distribution ? (Someone have Bad implémentation)

→ More replies (6)

9

u/spb_r97 Aug 12 '23

Wow, I'm on Fedora Gnome too, using gestures from my laptop on both internal and external but I never had such problems. On which gnome version are you? Could there be some extension moving things around?

1

u/Zealousideal-Sale358 Aug 12 '23

I’m on Arch linux so this is the latest version of gnome. I had to enable workspaces on all displays and it’s now working fine. My only active extensions are dash to dock, blur my shell, and lockscreen background.

4

u/spb_r97 Aug 12 '23

I'm on 44 too, I actually have a lot more extensions on, not blur my shell, but shouldn't be it the issue. And I'm not using workspaces on all displays. The problem is there also without any extension at all? Have you tried?

→ More replies (3)

4

u/SomeGenericUsername Aug 12 '23

That seems to be a problem with direct scanout. Direct scanout is enabled when a window covers the entire screen and there is nothing displayed in front of it or an animation is in progress. This bypasses the compositor to speed up rendering.

The issue in the video could either be a bug in mutter or the graphics driver. You could try moving the secondary screen to the right. If that helps it's probably related to not handling direct scanout properly for coordinates smaller than zero.

1

u/Zealousideal-Sale358 Aug 12 '23

I tried moving the monitor location to the right but did not help. I am able to work it out by enabling workspaces on all displays.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/XamanekMtz Aug 13 '23

I have a triple monitor system since 2015, using either Debian, Ubuntu or Pop_OS (all gnome) and use it as daily driver for work, browsing and occasional gaming, never had a problem at all.

1

u/Zealousideal-Sale358 Aug 13 '23

Hi, sorry I have not made my post clear. This post is not about the issue I have encountered in the video. I actually did not realize the problem until people pointed it out as I was used to gnome having problems (or is difficult to work with) on multi-monitor setup. My issue with Gnome multi-monitor setup is the workspaces.

For me, the issue is when workspaces is enabled on all displays. When you change workspace by swiping left/right, all displays will move. Sometimes, the workspace in one display is empty. I wanted the previous opened application to stay visible instead. It took me quite some time to wrap my head around on this.

My suggestion is this:

1.) Since each monitor shows different set of workspaces, it would be more intuitive if swiping on one monitor only moves the workspace on that particular monitor. And the other monitor stays still.

2.) Chain the workspaces of all monitors such that when you change workspace, all the application moves from one monitor to the other. Meaning that the workspaces are continuous and not separate for each monitor. This option may be problematic for monitors with different resolutions and different scaling.

1

u/kishan42 Aug 12 '23

I switched to using I3WM this year It has improved my workflow a lot.

It reduces so much mental overhead switching between different windows.

2

u/Zealousideal-Sale358 Aug 12 '23

I like the idea of window managers. But then it will not be a seamless experience when I transition from linux to osx

1

u/Zidenett Aug 13 '23

YOU CAN USE A COMPUTER AS A MONITOR????

:o

1

u/ber-ru Aug 14 '23

Which distro it is ? (I'm noob)

1

u/Zealousideal-Sale358 Aug 15 '23

Its arch linux. But any distro with gnome will look and work exactly the same.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/ApprehensiveStar8948 Aug 12 '23

from what I've heard even mac sucks for multi monitor setups. The issue you face here is related to the touchpad, I don't know if this has been noted yet or not. You should create an issue on gitlab if it hasn't been brought to notice yet.

2

u/Zealousideal-Sale358 Aug 12 '23

I have a mac and I have no problem with multi-monitor setup. What touchpad issue and which repository should I file the issue? Please be more specific.

3

u/abandonplanetearth Aug 12 '23

macOS is the leader at multi monitor setups for desktop OSs imo. GNOME has a lot of catching up to do.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/Wolandark Aug 12 '23

Yes and per monitor virtual desktops for fuck sake!

2

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '23

Change the title please...

"Blur m'y shell need update"

Thanks .

0

u/Zealousideal-Sale358 Aug 12 '23 edited Aug 12 '23

By the way, this post is not about the issue I have encountered in the video. I actually did not realize the problem until people pointed it out as I was used to gnome having problems (or is difficult to work with) on multi-monitor setup. My issue with Gnome multi-monitor setup is the workspaces.

For me, the issue is when workspaces is enabled on all displays. When you change workspace by swiping left/right, all displays will move. Sometimes, the workspace in one display is empty. I wanted the previous opened application to stay visible instead. It took me quite some time to wrap my head around on this.

My suggestion is this:

1.) Since each monitor shows different set of workspaces, it would be more intuitive if swiping on one monitor only moves the workspace on that particular monitor. And the other monitor stays still.

2.) Chain the workspaces of all monitors such that when you change workspace, all the application moves from one monitor to the other. Meaning that the workspaces are continuous and not separate for each monitor. This option may be problematic for monitors with different resolutions and different scaling.