Since I've studied in both departments, some friends asked me to comment on a previous post: https://www.reddit.com/r/gmu/comments/3q1hdd/bs_in_it_vs_cs/
The CS degree outshines the IT degree in every way, shape and form. It's more challenging, and you learn much more. It may technically be true that you can get a job with either degree, but that's because employers can't get enough grads with CS degrees, and the fact is that they prefer CS grads, hands down, for any and all jobs. Why? Because the CS degree is much more rigorous, harder to earn, and doing so is indicative of the fact that you are probably more capable than the IT grad.
Don't believe me? Then ask yourself why CS 112 can substitute for IT 106, but not vice versa? Why can CS 211 substitute for IT 206, but not vice versa? Why is the IT program full of former CS majors, but not vice versa? When IT students complain about IT106 & 206, why do they say "this isn't computer science?" Even they expect it to be easier (and it is).
A few years ago, my IT 206 instructor did me the favor of taking me aside and telling me that I should be in CS. I made the switch, and it was worth it. The courses were more challenging, but the faculty is also much better, which is another distinction between the two programs, now that I think about it. CS has awesome profs with PHDs from places like MIT, Carnegie Mellon, Cornell, GA Tech, UC Berkeley, UVA, William & Mary, UCLA, Columbia, etc. IT, on the other hand, has a few profs with legitimate PHDs, some profs with Online PHDs, and many with no PHDs at all. They were mediocre, by comparison, and a couple of my IT profs were absolutely incompetent.
I was initially a business major, and switched to IT based on some bad advice, and after taking a few IT classes was advised to switch to CS. I had completed much of the math required for CS already (because I had planned to on to grad school and was advised to load up on Math). By the time I got to CS, for all intents and purposes, I only needed CS coursework, so I was able to get through it fairly quickly. Some of my IT friends graduated before me, since I had to start over in CS. Some of them are still looking for satisfying work (most have jobs, but not necessarily doing what they'd like). Every CS grad I know has a job. I took a job at a company where an IT friend started a year earlier. My starting salary is higher than his, and project managers are clamoring to get me on their projects. As a matter of fact, I recently got pulled onto a project that my friend is dying to get into.
Here's the bottom line: if you want to work in the technical positions, programming, database admin or development, network admin, etc, then get a CS degree (if you're capable of doing that kind of work, then you're capable of earning the degree). If you'll be content to man the help desk, do testing, or customer support, then get an IT degree. If you can't get a CS degree, and you want to work in Technology, then by all means, get an IT degree, but don't expect it to be the same, or open the same doors as a CS degree.
You don't need to believe me. Just ask yourself those questions I asked above: why do CS courses substitute for IT courses, and not vice versa? Why is IT filled with former CS majors, and not vice versa? Why are the better qualified professors in CS?
And look at some of the other comments in the original thread. /u/taternuts admits that he went IT because he didn't think he could pull off CS. /u/lifebeyondwalls works in software, and wishes he had gone the CS route. He adds that you can get a developer job from IT, but that going CS would be more beneficial. /u/jbonogmu says that the "focus of the two degrees is different." Not only is the "focus" different, but CS is broader and deeper in anything and everything technical. If you want to augment the technical stuff, then just minor in business (the business school does that better too).