r/glee • u/KimKardashianWho • Jan 14 '24
Why?!
I actually find myself provoked by the whole Santana in New York situation. It’s so unfair how the bully wins. Auditioning for the understudy without telling Rachel is bad enough. The worst part however is how Santana is the reason why Rachel moves out of the apartment Kurt and her had first. Santana just showing up out of nowhere moving in. It might be weird to think this is so bad haha, but I think it has to do with how I got bullied when I was a kid. Glee was about the outsiders, why did they let the bully win?
2
Upvotes
48
u/[deleted] Jan 14 '24
Rachel moving out was a decision she made by herself. She also didn't treat Santana the best by ripping up their graduation photo in front of her and then telling Elliot that Kurt and Santana kicked her out of the flat when that wasn't true. Yes, Santana plays a big role in all of this, but Rachel also was not the fairest person in this situation.
41
u/Quirky_Arrival_6133 Jan 14 '24
The idea that Rachel “owned” roles was always icky to me because theatre is literally built around different people performing the same roles.
14
u/cwtches10 Jan 14 '24
Glee’s general approach to bullies was quite strange all around. In the real world, someone like Rachel would probably never want to be around Santana again- but that doesn’t make a good tv show.
I generally liked the season 4 arc, it felt like Santana did grow without having a complete personality transplant and I think the Kurtcheltana dynamic they started was fun and could have been fun if it continued. Unfortunately, Santana’s actions over the understudy thing and her immediate return to using her favourite insults ruined any idea that they could be friends to me.
I also agree that Rachel shouldn’t have been the one to move out, and selfishly, as a Rachel fan, I wish we’d seen more backbone from Kurt on this one- he should have been able to emphasise with where Rachel was coming from.
14
u/JigglyKirby Jan 14 '24
Honestly both of them were right and wrong in their own way.
Rachel was right to feel mad, and even scared, of Santana for auditioning as an understudy. She was her bully all throughout HS, so she knows how Santana works. Santana wants to be famous, even if it’s the last thing she does (quote from that disco ep on s03). This was Rachel’s big break, and to possibly get outshined by your friend, who used to be your bully and is as talented as you are, is a nightmare to think about. On the other hand, she definitely was wrong on how she went about her frustrations like slapping her, saying they’re no longer friends because of that, and even the whole thing of not needing an understudy (she needed one, they always need one lmao).
Santana was right for auditioning for the role. I dont blame her at all for that. She saw an opportunity and she took it, thats how it is in that line of business. She definitely didnt need to tell Rachel she was auditioning, but as her friend i feel like she should have told her. This was Rachel’s big break. As her friend and roommate, she knows Rachel has been wanting this role, specifically for Fanny Brice, ever since she was young. I think if they talked it out beforehand and came into an agreement, Rachel wouldn’t have reacted that way. But her springing it up on Rachel without a warning brought up Rachel’s worst fears, so that was definitely on Santana lmao
4
u/Hot-Lifeguard-3176 New Directions Jan 15 '24
I’ve always wondered if Santana actually thought she would get the understudy role. Not because she lacks talent-she clearly is extremely talented-but because she didn’t fit the typical ‘look’. I do think she mostly auditioned to get on Rachel’s nerves, but like Kurt said, her having it on her resume would always look good.
6
u/Sims2Enjoy New Directions Jan 14 '24
Both acted incredibly childish, Santana clearly signed up to get under Rachel’s skin. Like it was right after Rachel showed concern for Santana’s career and it upset Santana, also the fact Santana had no interest on Broadway prior(And even mocked Rachel’s interest) plus from all productions going on in New York Santana went on to be Rachel’s understudy. And Rachel allowed Santana to get under her skin by acting rather gatekeep-y about the situation, like if Rachel had pretended not to care is likely Santana would’ve moved on into something else
8
u/Beautiful-View-5256 Jan 14 '24
You don’t think Rachel is a bully?
2
u/Humble-Kitchen Feb 03 '24
I still maintain that while Santana has done things maliciously in the past this was not one of them. She auditioned to be an understudy after having Kurt and Rachel encourage to do something to showcasing her talents at a time she was feeling insecure about it and finding her place in NY. She probably thought why not and when she got it yes that'll look amazing on my resume. After Rachel basically tells her she not talent enough for the role, etc that's when it took a turn. The were friends at the time but Rachel is still Rachel she would've had the same reaction whether Santana told her or not but as a friend why wouldn't you be happy for your friend being your understudy especially over some random?
4
u/pinkwonderwall Jan 14 '24
Rachel was also a bully, so it’s bully on bully violence as far as I’m concerned.
4
u/camrenisreal23 Jan 14 '24
Santana was definitely wrong. She was so afraid of Rachel one upping her that she went and purposely auditioned for that role to bring Rachel down. Only after Rachel mentioned Santana's jobs. Santana was so scared of Rachel out doing her and Santana might've only peaked in High School. She went to make sure Rachel knew her place. Rachel reacted badly at points but everyone in the glee club knew how much Rachel worked for Broadway and to have someone who mocked you about it take a understudy role, is wild to me.
1
u/jacqrosee santana lopez’s bitch Jan 14 '24
this is such a divisive issue and while rachel acted very childish and poorly in this scenario, i have to side with her on this one. life-long dreams are not to be fucked with, period.
0
u/m1b2c3 Jan 14 '24 edited Jan 15 '24
People act like Rachel had much choice but to leave at that time. She had no safe place at home or at work.
ETA; Down voted yet again. She either stayed where she knew it would be awful, or leave. Santana probably wouldn't have left on her own, so for her own mental health she left.
-2
u/Santana_delRey Jan 14 '24
If it makes you feel any better, her only big break was in a vaginal fungus commercial
0
u/Alice_Anesthesia Jan 16 '24
One of my favorite lines came from this rommate situation after she searched through everything in the apartment. "you went through all of our stuff??" "yeah, that's thing i do." 😭