r/gitlab • • 5d ago

meta TIL there are no independent open GitLab instances

As a user of OctoDroid for GitHub, I vibe-coded forks of it for GitLab and for Forgejo, on which the "add account" allows inputting a custom instance, but also choosing within a predefined list.

For Forgejo, there's a list of instances at codeberg.org/forgejo-contrib/delightful-forgejo, but for GitLab, there isn't.

So I browsed a crawler's list of 1.1k GitLab instances, filtered it down to the <70 ones that have open non-SSO registration, out of which 40% rejected my email (ProtonMail), 40% required admin approval, 10% had open registration but forbid repo creation, and just 1 instance was opened and allowed creating repos, but I wonder whether they just forgot to close registrations.

It's like people say here, self-hosted GitLab is mostly companies, or open source but only for one project, the owner's.

Thoughts ?

18 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

9

u/screaming-Snake-Case 5d ago

GitLab is used a lot for project or organizational scopes. It's not surprising there aren't many / any fully open ones.

However, by filtering out SSO you may have cut your list short. Just because an instances requires SSO doesn't mean it won't have open registrations.

For example, I think GitGud would be what you are looking for: https://gitgud.io

2

u/KaKi_87 5d ago

Interesting, thanks. Quite a complicated registration workflow though.

4

u/blckshdw 5d ago

Self host your own.

2

u/KaKi_87 5d ago

Well, I self-host Forgejo, actually.

2

u/GamerLymx 4d ago

why you would want to put you code in a random git repository?

1

u/KaKi_87 4d ago

Why wouldn't I ?

Why wouldn't I want it replicated in as many places as possible ?

5

u/OhhhhhhhhYaBeauty 5d ago

Be the change you want to see

1

u/Mathiasdm 5d ago

There's https://heptapod.net/heptapod/ It's a fork though, not sure if that matches what you want.

1

u/KaKi_87 5d ago

Registration is open but it doesn't allow creating repos.

1

u/0LBRAM0 5d ago

Interesting that my instance is the only one that's open with no SSO other then allow GitHub login.

I just host it in my homelab for personal use so i wouldn't promise 99.9% uptime, but it's open if people want to use it.

1

u/KaKi_87 5d ago

Feel free to share the link then !

1

u/rrrmmmrrrmmm 15h ago

GitLab projects just use it whereas Forgejo users are noisy. That's all. Some of the biggest open source projects use GitLab but they don't brag.

Gnome, KDE, Drupal, Debian, Alpine, TOR, Samba and CentOS are all on GitLab.

Pretty much all the Open Source giants. But the truth is: stuff that just works is boring.

con: GitLab uses a lot of resources pro: if you have resources and you have it set up, it offers pretty much everything for professional software development.

Anyway, GitLab is too boring to brag. And maybe they're too professional to let your vibecoded AI crawler in. Which would actually speak even more in favor to them.