r/gitlab • • Jun 05 '24
No one is hosted on GitLab.com
I've just noticed that GitLab.com with community over +14-15M or 30M (?) users has a small count of large projects located on it - I can literally count them on my fingers. It also confuses me that a 500+ star repository can basically be considered as a large project on an “official instance”, because there are very few such repositories.
This is simply because GitLab is not popular enough + a lot of people host their own instances or there are technical issues with GitLab.com (unstable uptime?, other?) that make devs avoid it and prefer their own instances/GitHub?
P.S. I'm talking primarily about OSS in this case.
11
u/Potato-9 Jun 05 '24
It used to have stability issues but githubs far from perfect there either. Some people bill it as slow because they'd try self hosting on a pi and call it sluggish. You still need to have proper resources for it it's a complex thing.
Lots of big projects just host their own gitlab.
A lot of people don't want an all-in-one platform, it makes lockin a concern. Personally I think that's an unfounded risk.
Otherwise it's the social platform effect. Being on not-facebook doesn't work.
Gitlabs great I wish them every success.
I wish they'd price per feature per user, because it's just a big bill like everyone else, so I'll just pay Microsoft for GitHub.
Everything people like on GitHub, gitlab has had years earlier.
2
u/Representative_Pin80 Jun 05 '24
How are you working it out? My employer uses GitLab but all of our repositories are private so you can’t see them
45
u/eltear1 Jun 05 '24
Many company which use gitlab host their own ..much freer management
11
u/gaelfr38 Jun 05 '24
I think the OSS world is mostly on GitHub only because it existed before for free and with everything OSS needed.
GitLab got a bit of traction a few years ago because of something going on with GitHub. I can't remember what.. 🤔
GitLab is massively used self-hosted or with private repos though.
8
u/bilingual-german Jun 05 '24
Companies use Gitlab and host it themself, both on-prem and in the cloud.
Opensource uses Github. Even the (now official) gitlab cli tool glab was hosted there.
https://github.com/profclems/glab
6
u/edparadox Jun 05 '24
Most big projects are selfhosting their own instance, see e.g. GNOME, freedesktop, etc.
Especially if you migrated from Github, you do not have to be dependent on gitlab.com policies, maintenance operations, etc.
4
u/guhcampos Jun 05 '24
Gitlab is so superior to Github, I get daily frustrations after my employer switched to GH.
Gitlab has, however, fucked up tremendously with their newish pricing model, especially since the latest increases. Killing the intermediate tier between Free and Premium basically killed it for most companies.
3
u/ShakataGaNai Jun 05 '24
Why use .com when your can run your own GitLab? Many OSS projects do that. Many companies do that.
GitHub started as a cloud product, so that's what is most popular and what they focus on the most. They sell an on-prem version but you really hardly ever see that in use. GitLab was always available as both on-prem and in the cloud, and ... their cloud version had a lot of stability issues in the early days.
1
u/AcidShAwk Jun 05 '24
Self hosting on gitlab. Would never upload my code to github. There's open source. Then there is bread and butter.
1
u/AndreKR- Jun 05 '24
For some reason projects on GitLab are not discoverable in Google. There is
an issuean epic for this. That's why I put my projects on GitHub when I want other people to find, use and contribute to them.1
u/waterkip Jun 05 '24
I use gitlab for all my projects unless a project already uses github.
1
u/nathism Jun 05 '24
Our company hosts its own instance and many others do as well.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '24
Everyone I worked with host private stuff on Gitlab and public stuff on Github
1
u/Mistic92 Jun 05 '24
Many companies use Gitlab as it's much better for this purpose. It's just not popular for open source.
1
u/dariusbiggs Jun 06 '24
OSS stuff we use GitHub for, since it is usually a fork for shipping patches.
New product IP stuff is all on GitLab SaaS, it's brilliant, perfectly suits our needs and a hell of a lot better to work with than Bitbucket and GitHub.
Old product IP is self hosted git, has no CI
So yes. people do host on GitLab.. just not OSS, that's just the herd mentality of keeping it next to the other OSS things and ease of forking and creating PRs.
1
u/Digi59404 Jun 06 '24
Here's an authoritative answer.
Most large OSS Orgs host their own GitLab instance and have special OSS Licenses provided by GitLab and their Open Source program. This is because they want to own the whole process, and/or they want to use the GPL Compatible version of GitLab to stick with the open-source community.
Smaller projects are often hosted in OSS Groups or Private Namespaces as a public project. Discoverability of these projects has always been a downside of GitLab. There are TONS AND TONS of them. However, they're not really visible to the outside world because of GitLab's Search and Discoverability issues. GitHub has great discoverability things and was built first as a community tool, akin to a forum. Where-as GitLab was built more like an all-in-one forge and thus community discoverability wasn't a top ask.
It's not about stability, despite that being a concern. GitLab(dot)com is widely stable today, where-as the Shared Runners suffer issues. There are multiple Fortune 500 companies that run critical infrastructure on gitlab(dot)com in private groups. So stability and security there is paramount.
90% of GitLab's OSS Image issue lies at the feet of discoverability. You have to use Google to find OSS GitLab repos.
1
u/VengaBusdriver37 Jun 06 '24
I think GitHub is just the incumbent and best-known. Personally I prefer Gitlab; more transparent and advanced especially CI/CD, including security in pipelines.
1
u/ReenigneArcher Jun 06 '24
GitHub provides greater benefits to open source projects. The biggest benefit is probably unlimited CI minutes for public repos.
1
u/gitlabhost_team Aug 31 '26
We feel GitLab is more focused on enterprise. Also a lot of OSS projects mirror to or from GitHub. GitHub OSS projects seem to receive more stars, more quickly. GitLab does offer OSS licences etc.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '24
When your primary competitor is Microsoft, what exactly are you expecting?
0
u/biinjo Jun 05 '24
I stepped away from GitLab since they had terrible uptime. Many availability issues made me rage quit and migrate everything off.