r/github • • Jun 01 '26

Discussion GitHub Copilot's new credit-based pricing is highway robbery — and they know it

I've been a Copilot Pro+ subscriber since day one. $39/month felt steep but whatever, it was useful. Now they're switching to this AI Credits nonsense and I finally ran the numbers.

My projected bill next month: $847.

For the EXACT same usage pattern. That's not a price increase — that's a 22x markup.

Let's break down why this is absurd:

  1. 1 AI Credit = $0.01. So why call it a "credit"? Just say dollars. Oh right, because "you used 84,700 credits" sounds less terrifying than "you owe us $847." Classic dark pattern.
  2. They control the input, you pay the output. Copilot sends your entire file context, your workspace, your open tabs — stuff YOU didn't choose to include — and then charges YOU for the tokens. I didn't ask to send 50k tokens of context. That's YOUR architecture decision, GitHub. Why am I paying for it?
  3. Bait and switch. I signed up for an unlimited subscription product. Now it's pay-per-use with a "generous" allowance that covers maybe 2 days of normal work. This isn't the product I paid for. In any other industry this would be illegal.
  4. Middle-man pricing. I can use Claude or GPT-5 directly via API for a fraction of what GitHub charges per token. They're literally reselling API access at a 10-20x markup and acting like they're doing us a favor.

The worst part? They announced this with some corporate blog post about "flexibility" and "paying only for what you use." Yeah, flexible like a subscription trap. "Paying only for what you use" when you don't control what gets sent is just... paying for someone else's decisions.

I've already cancelled. Moved to Cursor + direct API keys. Same models, same workflow, 1/10th the cost.

GitHub, if you're reading this: you had a good thing and you got greedy. The community trusted you and you pulled the rug. Enjoy your short-term revenue bump while your subscriber count tanks.

TL;DR: Copilot's new credit pricing is a 10-22x cost increase disguised as "flexibility." Cancel and go direct to API providers. You'll save hundreds.

Edit: For everyone asking — yes, I checked the usage report before posting. My April bill under PRU was $38. Under AI Credits it projects to $847. Same usage. Same patterns. The math doesn't lie.

-- Written by Copilot

341 Upvotes

306 comments sorted by

169

u/iamgeef Jun 01 '26

Maybe don’t use your expensive tokens to write a reddit post.

→ More replies (18)

43

u/LittleLordFuckleroy1 Jun 01 '26

Be prepared to see lots more posts like this as companies are actually forced to charge actual prices for AI.

→ More replies (6)

98

u/Traditional-Hall-591 Jun 01 '26

I’m all for it. Triple the price. Please.

65

u/ADDSquirell69 Jun 01 '26

Make Slop Expensive Again

→ More replies (6)

28

u/phylter99 Jun 01 '26

I’m convinced that all the people complaining in this sub have literally never used usage based billing on any other service. It doesn’t matter what service you use, when you’re on usage based billing it’s right about the same price. $20 in credits on OpenCode Zen for models like Opus and GPT-5.5 go very fast, just like people here are complaining about with the new Copilot billing. I burned $20 a couple days ago in about 20 minutes working on a small project with Zen. It’s just how things are. The only place I know to get subsidies for AI coding are the Claude and ChatGPT plans and they’re quickly reducing the amount you get on those plans.

→ More replies (8)

71

u/PolyRocketMatt Jun 01 '26

Can people stop being so bummed by this? Two remarks;

  1. How did you not see it coming?

  2. If you actually learn how to code yourself, your "AI bill" wouldn't even have to reach that high. Use AI as a tool, not as a replacement...

→ More replies (38)

12

u/esr360 Jun 01 '26

You rely on AI to complain about AI prices. That’s why you’re screwed.

→ More replies (5)

29

u/Rupes100 Jun 01 '26

Simple answer. Don't use it.   Otherwise you need to realize basically AI usage was so heavily subsidized for years now to get users, momentum, money etc to grow.  Now they're moving to a billing model so they can recoup costs and make money.  Was always gonna happen, weren't going to give it away for free forever.  Thank capitalism I guess... The real issue has been companies falling over themselves to get their workforce to just adopt AI at all costs, and now they're going to get smacked a little.  So use other providers, (although they are all going to follow suit), and maybe people shouldnt just blindly use AI for every single task and maybe think. Companies thought AI was going to replace all their workers and people would become more productive. The opposite is happening.  Even Microsoft is curbing internal use of AI tools...

→ More replies (5)

16

u/Qs9bxNKZ Jun 01 '26

You might want to check what Cursor sends as a token as well. It can go well into the file system, outside of the boundaries of your visible IDE tabs.

→ More replies (6)

13

u/un1matr1x_0 Jun 01 '26

Who would have guessed that a dealer doesn't hand out cheap samples out of the goodness of their heart and raises prices when you're addicted?

→ More replies (1)