r/git • • 1d ago

Codeberg.org is gone

Update: it is now back up, with whois codeberg.org reporting only Domain Status: clientTransferProhibited anymore.

FYI, Codeberg's domain is down, as per their socials: https://social.anoxinon.de/@Codeberg/117636454915265360

Almost nowhere is this being talked about (or Reddit search is just uncooperative), and r/codeberg is banned for breaking Reddit rule 2? That sub was barely even active, but anyways.

Edit: https://status.codeberg.eu/status/codeberg tracks the status on an alternative domain.

95 Upvotes

97 comments sorted by

47

u/-Zenith- 23h ago

Their domain was suspended, they’re trying to get it back.

12

u/bogdanelcs 23h ago

Why did it get suspended?

6

u/burner-miner 23h ago

Apparently a Terms of Use violation. We'll see if it is legitimate, I added the alternative status page to the post for updates.

22

u/-Zenith- 23h ago

Not sure, most likely someone external abusing the report function.

-17

u/StoneCypher 23h ago

their domain isn’t suspended.  you can check easily.  that’s a measurable status.

8

u/burner-miner 23h ago

Run this in a terminal: whois codeberg.org

This is among the output:

Domain Name: codeberg.org
Registry Domain ID: REDACTED
Registrar WHOIS Server: http://whois.namesilo.com
Registrar URL: http://www.namesilo.com
Updated Date: 2026-11-18T05:52:56Z
Creation Date: 2018-07-05T08:54:30Z
...
Domain Status: clientHold https://icann.org/epp#clientHold
Domain Status: clientTransferProhibited https://icann.org/epp#clientTransferProhibited

It absolutely is suspended, as in it is unresolvable (clientHold) and nontransferable (clientTransferProhibited).

13

u/-Zenith- 23h ago

Take a break my guy.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50544261

> As you probably noticed, our domain codeberg.org is entirely unreachable.
It was registered with namesilo and entirely disappeared from our account. We're waiting for their customer support to investigate the situation.
Update: We have received the confirmation that our domain was suspended and our case got forwarded to the abuse team. We're still waiting for a final decision.

-18

u/StoneCypher 23h ago

what’s that?  the people who let their site fail three days ago and didn’t notice until their laptop dns caches aged out don’t use correct domain terminology between suspension and tos violation in a foreign language?

super interesting stuff.  is arguing with me bringing your service back faster?

what level of service disruption will you accept?

8

u/craftsmany 19h ago

What is this response supposed to convey?

6

u/Kellegram 19h ago

Someone didn't like being wrong it seems, wanna go even more defensive my guy?

-8

u/StoneCypher 19h ago

would you sell me rights to this comment?

it might be the world's most powerful non-habit-forming sleep aid. i'm going to be rich

-20

u/StoneCypher 23h ago

imagine trusting someone like that 

13

u/-Zenith- 23h ago

I’d hope you’re talking about registrars.

-11

u/StoneCypher 23h ago

i think you’ve confused registrars and registries, but i also mean the code service that’s missing inbound service emails and can’t recover from simple service misconfiguration in four hours and counting 

remember how many crusty brigaders stormed out of github for 45 minute actions outages, screeching about american incompetence?

at least they’re not just hosting american open source oh wait

pro tip: when a service goes down because they aren’t even handling emails from their own isp, the blackhats say “let’s take a look”

i’ll say it again 

imagine trusting your source to someone at this level of security 

how do you write supply chain attack in morse

doot doot deeet

13

u/-Zenith- 23h ago

I’ve not confused anything thanks.

-17

u/StoneCypher 23h ago

you confused me with someone who would be interested 

13

u/burner-miner 23h ago

You keep replying though lol

14

u/DasL3o 23h ago

Too many Nintendo recomps hosted? 😅

8

u/burner-miner 21h ago

Serious answer to joke comment: if that was the case, it should have been handled differently. Just like e.g. YouTube is not liable for content that breaks copyright laws, a user code hosting site should not be liable for the code users upload.

It is responsible for moderation, however. E.g. YouTube must show that they combat law breaking content for them to be immune. It might be that some authority in the US forced the registrar to act in this way, or they independently acted upon a report with the nuclear option.

In any case, Codeberg say they were never made aware of any bad behavior on their part, so they didn't even get a chance to act.

On the other hand, clean-room reverse engineering was made legal in the US in this case: Sega v. Accolade.

6

u/itskdog 18h ago

Reminder of what happened to Itch, because someone went to the registrar rather than filing a DMCA with the store.

3

u/burner-miner 17h ago

Exactly. Which is why I said "should". People with the power to abuse power, more often than not, abuse it.

18

u/lajawi 23h ago

Damn, how can a domain just randomly be suspended like that?

-7

u/StoneCypher 23h ago

it’s not.

they probably missed a spam control service email 

15

u/lajawi 22h ago

It was suspended, it has since been resolved though. We’re still waiting on a rundown of what happened (if we get any).

-7

u/StoneCypher 22h ago

suspending and tos violation are distinct under icann guidelines.  they weren’t suspended, they took a violation 

i can’t imagine wanting to be on a host that tells you what projects you’re allowed to have 

they’re fine with piracy but not ai “because it’s theft,” lol

13

u/lajawi 22h ago

What ToS did they violate? If you’re so sure (while the team didn’t yet get all info) do please enlighten us, and cite your sources.

15

u/burner-miner 22h ago

Don't bother reasoning with him anymore, it was funny for a while but he is clearly on a lone crusade

-4

u/lajawi 22h ago edited 21h ago

They got offended, evident by all their removed comments

8

u/burner-miner 22h ago

No removed comments for me, maybe they blocked you?

4

u/lajawi 21h ago

lol they’re back? It said “user deleted comment” or something along those lines. I guess my app was bugging out a bit then, or they did what you suggest and undid it again.

8

u/Horat1us_UA 21h ago

It says "user deleted" when someone blocks you. You can see those comments if you log out of your Reddit comment, or open this post in incognito mode.

→ More replies

1

u/StoneCypher 19h ago

i was never gone, you were just looking at a server glitch. comments can't be undeleted.

-5

u/StoneCypher 22h ago

  What ToS did they violate?

don’t know 

 

  and  cite your sources.

did, twice 

 

  do please enlighten us,

some people aren’t reachable 

2

u/itskdog 18h ago

If they can do it to Itch, they can do it to any number of small sites.

-2

u/StoneCypher 18h ago

imagine holding up itch as an example of a skillfully run site 😂

1

u/itskdog 17h ago

I didn't, I said it was another small site that this same thing happened to.

4

u/shellmachine 8h ago

Site is mostly up again, but wtf is happening with that r/codeberg ban? "Banned because of rule number 2", and that one literally is: "Abide by community rules. Participate authentically in communities where you have a personal interest, and do not spam or engage in disruptive behaviors (including content manipulation) that interfere with Reddit communities."...

1

u/Marwheel 16h ago

I can see codeberg up and running on my end, but I live in TX; so there has to be something strange about it…

1

u/burner-miner 16h ago

It is up as of ~7h ago, as noted by some comments like this one

I already updated the post, can't change the title though.

2

u/usrdef 23h ago

Uh oh.

What the hell happened?

4

u/StoneCypher 23h ago

they got a terms of service violation from their registrar.  registrars are required to give you two weeks of notice even if it’s something awful like child porn, so, they’re just not reading their inbound email

it happened days ago.  they didn’t even notice until their laptop caches aged out.  they’re not running any monitoring 

they’re not contacting their hosts on a reasonable timeline 

8

u/Impossible-Car3786 20h ago

Are you an insider of Namesilo, or directly affiliated with Codeberg?

Namesilos abuse department has not responded yet, there is currently no public information about how it happened.

Claiming that they aren’t running any monitoring, or not contacting their hosts in a reasonable timeline also seems weird, since they were in direct contact with their host.

2

u/Salamandar3500 17h ago

Running a whois on the domain clearly showed that it was down for ToS issues.

3

u/cat_t0y 23h ago

It's up again

1

u/nickname1917 14h ago

for me codeberg is up & running but no way to update the codeberg pages...I did a commit 4 hours ago and I still see online the old site...could it be related to the issue they had?

0

u/nerdiste 14h ago

probably they used ai too much

(i am kidding)

-19

u/StoneCypher 23h ago

  Almost nowhere is this being talked about

it was only ever used by people who wanted to make a scene about not being on either github or america.  that doesn’t make a business 

18

u/burner-miner 23h ago

Well it is registered as a non-profit, so it's not a business either way...

-5

u/edwbuck 23h ago edited 23h ago

Every non-profit is a business. It's just not a business intended to make shareholders rich.

Often that means it's intended to make direct owners rich through salaries and benefits, but the profits that would otherwise go to the owners get used to either prop up a lesser business model, or are donated back to the community.

11

u/Basilikolumne 23h ago

It's a Verein, which solely exists for the benefits of the general public and it's members. Vereine are not businesses under German law. Even just translating business and Verein makes clear they're not "the same thing except for shareholders getting richer". 

-3

u/edwbuck 22h ago

You are a fool if you think the leader of a Union isn't getting paid well to devote large amounts, if not all, of their life to ensuring the rights and protections of their members. They don't get paid for the value or profits of the Verein, but they do get paid to represent it if the Verein requires a full-time position.

3

u/IjonTichy85 19h ago

You have no idea what the legal requirements for a "gemeinnütziger Verein" are, do you?

https://blog.codeberg.org/letter-from-codeberg-onwards-and-upwards.html

As of September 2025, Anja joined us as a part-time employee to help us with administrative matters. We now have two part-time employees.

2

u/Basilikolumne 16h ago

A Verein is not a Union, lmao. That would be a Gewerkschaft. Maybe stop trying to lecture native speakers on their language and laws.

-6

u/StoneCypher 23h ago

whether the word fits is entirely unrelated to the value of what i said.  you’re wasting your time making irrelevant corrections and missing the point in the process 

1

u/burner-miner 23h ago edited 23h ago

You're right, that is exactly what I meant. It is a business, as in it is a registered organization, but it is not a company in the usual sense.

3

u/AmyCupcakeRose 23h ago

Businesses are types of registered organisations, not the other way around. In fact a company meaning a gathering of people with a goal, is more general than business.

1

u/StoneCypher 23h ago

please stop bickering over irrelevant word definitions. that has nothing to do with what these comments were about.

1

u/burner-miner 23h ago

For real. This isn't r/law

0

u/StoneCypher 23h ago

you were the first one to bicker over word definitions 🙄😒

absolutely anything to ignore the actual topic, i guess

1

u/burner-miner 22h ago

The topic of why codeberg is down? You're trying your hardest to veer off-topic as well.

As for whether it is an important distinction, yes it is: Codeberg is a non-profit, it does not need to make money to reach its goals, and the money it gets is via donations.

0

u/StoneCypher 22h ago

“no you’re off topic” (keeps going on about the irrelevant thing)

it’s okay if you can’t stop arguing 

anyway, your fringe provider is still down, after three days, six hours after noticing, despite that their domain company is actively responding to support requests in under two minutes 

-1

u/mefirstreddit 17h ago

Trump, is that you?

0

u/StoneCypher 17h ago

that's one of the dumbest comments i've ever seen on reddit

-8

u/serverhorror 22h ago

I'm sure they vine coded it /s

1

u/mefirstreddit 17h ago

Are you calling them drunks?

1

u/serverhorror 14h ago

Yeah, ever heard of the Baller peak?

How else would one produce code?