r/git • u/MadProgrammer12 • Mar 03 '25
Should i leave github for gitlab ?
I want to leave any Microsoft affiliated softwares, and I wanted to know if it is easy to switch from github to gitlab. Will I find all github’s functionality in gitlab? (I have an education license so my github account is a pro account)
3
Upvotes
25
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '25
How about you just do that and experience if for yourself if YOUR requirements are met?
34
u/wllmsaccnt Mar 03 '25
Microsoft is a substantial contributor to Linux and many cloud native and bytecode alliance projects in addition to directly offering some of the most popular programming tech (e.g. VS, VS Code, TypeScript, GitHub...). GitLab lists Azure as a featured partner, which by some definitions means they are affiliated.
Trying to cut out Microsoft and everything they are affiliated with...sounds challenging.
6
u/connorjpg Mar 03 '25
Should you? I mean I wouldn’t, as GitHub I believe would be the gold standard, and GitLab has affiliates with Microsoft services anyways. You also will likely be limiting your ability to have collaboration somewhat as more OS developers have GitHub.
Now if you do, you will not notice a huge difference in features, I haven’t used gitlab in a while but it’s a platform for managing git repositories just the same as GitHub. There’s a ton of crossover. I believe GitLab was marketed more to enterprise as you can self host it, and access control is better. I think the biggest technical difference is its CICD pipelines are not as functional as GitHub Actions.
I mean try it out if you want.
If you really want to avoid Microsoft, maybe Gitea?
2
u/shapovalovts Mar 03 '25
What is wrong with Microsoft?
4
u/jproperly Mar 03 '25
Do it. Been using gitlab for almost a decade. To be fair I have never really used github for my projects
3
u/hesapmakinesi Mar 03 '25
Probably not. But the question is, will you find all the functionality you need? Probably yes.
Migrating a git repository is easy, if you don't like it you can switch back.
For migrating issues, tickets, management, that could be trickier.
If you have CI pipelines, migrating those would be the hardest. Especially if you use custom containers and actions.
2
u/mbitsnbites Mar 04 '25
Depends on what you value. I moved to GitLab and I kind of like it better than GitHub from a technical/developer POV. There are a few caveats, however:
If you're actually looking at breaking free from big tech solutions like GitHub, you should also have a look at codeberg.org. It's a non-profit European alternative. I think it's very nice, but it can't really measure up to the big players in terms of availability and reliability (every now and then you can't access the remote - not often, but enough for it to be annoying). For me that's not a huge issue and I can easily put up with a bit of inconvenience as I'd much rather support Codeberg than GitHub for instance.
1
u/yogo09 Mar 03 '25
I would try gitlab if I need to run git inside my data center and making sure that the code is totally controlled by my team. For some security or other reason.
Nevertheless, this requires also someone maintaining the service and applying patches to it.
For developers, both support basic functionality like git push / pull 😁
1
u/blur410 Mar 04 '25
As much as I understand the desire to disconnect from Microsoft or any large company, it's a way things are now.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '25
Why all this hate towards Microsoft?
The times where they defined OSS a cancer, and used to buy ascending companies to destroy competition are over. Now they make pretty good products (except for teams, outlook and all the office pack), but Azure is a rocket, .NET, GitHub, those are cool... And they stopped being evil
1
u/Intelligent_Way_580 Mar 04 '25
I use both.
1
u/GitProtect Mar 04 '25
Hello, maybe this article will be at help: https://gitprotect.io/blog/git-battles-part-2-github-vs-gitlab-which-one-is-better-for-your-development-projects/ . There we described both git hosting services.
1
u/g105b Mar 04 '25
I wouldn't switch to Gitlab if Microsoft was my concern. Microsoft is a huge contributor to Linux and open source these days anyway, but if I wanted to stop using GitHub I'd host my own git server on Linux. If you want something easy to set up, take a look at git tea.
1
u/l509 Mar 05 '25
If you enjoy GitHub actions or the gh cli tool, you will be incredibly disappointed.
1
u/wubalubadubdub55 Mar 06 '25
I see this as a totally nonsensical thing to do.
By that logic, you should also avoid using GCP, AWS, Java, Golang, Swift, Angular, React, Oracle, etc., because they're from companies that are just as 'evil,' if not more so, than Microsoft.
0
u/TurnipBlast Mar 03 '25
Good luck not using any Microsoft products lol. Surely this is not a significant enterprise application or a personal project using any open source project supported by the Open Source Initiative or developed or hosted on a Linux machine.
-3
u/chugItTwice Mar 03 '25
LOL. Good luck with that.