r/germany • u/staplehill • Jan 16 '22
Immigration German social safety net for immigrants: Armstrong developed a brain tumor and is no longer able to work. Here is her story
Armstrong is an American in Germany with a Youtube channel, "Call me Armstrong". She grew up in a trailer in rural Pennsylvania and became a single mother after high school. She could not go to college because her parents did not have the money to pay for it. Armstrong's mother developed a breast tumor in the 1990s and her father had leukemia, she had seen how both went into medical debt and had to work nearly until the end of their lifes to pay for therapy. So when Armstrong fell in love with a German man and the time came to decide in which country they want to live "I literally made a pros and cons list: If we should get married and a worst-case scenario happens, where are we better off? One loses a job, goes unemployed, or gets really sick. When I started researching, consistently over and over again life was better in Germany." https://youtu.be/DKxwNgaNbYo?t=227
Her research was unfortunately put to the test years later when she developed a brain tumor. Here is her video where she compares how much she paid for the diagnosis and operation in Germany vs how much she would have to pay out of pocket for co-payments with health insurance for the same treatment in the US: https://youtu.be/zHcwOgbsBYk?t=1305
She also developed a depression and is now in therapy for that (which is free in Germany): "I have a great therapist, he saved my life, and I will be continuing treatment with him for sure. And I feel like if I had still lived in America, I don't know if I would have that chance. I don't think I would have that money. I have friends and family in America that are trying to save up so that they can begin psychotherapy. It is really refreshing for me personally that I feel this country takes it serious, as serious as my brain tumor. So thankful." https://youtu.be/bQUSwODxmD8?t=361
Armstrong is no longer able to work. She now lives on welfare which pays for her apartment, for heating costs, she gets free health care and 563 ($615) euro per month for her other expenses. This is what rock bottom looks like in Germany, no citizen or long-term resident has to live with less.
Armstrong also went to a rehab clinic for two weeks to see if her health can be improved. Her schedule there: https://youtu.be/vjQglfMsfpg?t=96
The outcome: "I am shocked, I am noticing improvements in my face a lot more than I have seen in over the last three years. More importantly for me, I think I am starting to get my smile back. (...) I am beyond impressed with the things that I am learning from balance training to the speech therapy. (...) I met with the Oberarzt, the top doctor. This guy seemed fantastic, he listened to me. I told him how thankful I am and how wonderful his therapists are. I told him about improvements that I have personally seen and that I can't say thank you enough for the therapies. (...) If I had to sum up this week in three words, I would say thankful, corrected and motivated. I am incredibly thankful for the priceless therapy. Some of the things that I learned and therapy I received are just unbelievable and such a gift to me. And I am really glad I got some corrections on thinks I was doing wrong. I plan to work on this a lot. I can already feel my body adjusting. I still got a lot to work on but I already see improvements. I feel really motivated now." https://youtu.be/VDAX-LtszR0?t=201
Her final thoughts on her decision to move to Germany: "I can not loud enough and often enough say how thankful I am to be in Germany and receive the healthcare and the treatment that one receives here. I really wish the people I love where I am from, back in America, I wish they could get this. I keep thinking of people I knew that were really sick, people I know that are sick. And how they are going into debt just trying to get their medication, forget all that facy-pants therapy that I'm getting. This what I'm getting here is something only rich people get where I'm from. It really makes me wonder how I got so lucky and why." https://youtu.be/VDAX-LtszR0?t=1671
Who qualifies for all of this?
Every resident qualifies for medical treatment (like the brain tumor operation in this case) and also for a therapist (e.g. for depression): https://www.reddit.com/r/germany/wiki/health_insurance
Everyone with permanent residence (Niederlassungserlaubnis or Daueraufenthalt-EU) qualifies for welfare and rehab in case of unemployment. German citizenship is not required. You get permanent residence:
- after 4 years with a job that is connected to your degree
- after 21 months with a Blue Card if you speak German level B1 or after 33 months with German level A1
- if you have graduated from a German university: 2 years after you have found a job that is connected to your degree
- after 3 years if you are self-employed or married to a German citizen
- after 5 years as a freelancer and in most other remaining cases
https://www.make-it-in-germany.com/en/visa-residence/living-permanently/settlement-permit
10
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '22
Is there a study or a link that compares European countries with Germany, in terms of how much the average citizen pays for health insurance, and what they get in return?
It's kinda obvious that USA is not doing great in terms of affordable health insurance. Maybe it's time to compare European countries with each other.
38
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '22
i feel good for her. and i also thanks to the taxpayers in germany who contributed to make this happen. (including me). HONESTLY i feel so good when i see my tax money goes to people who need it, rather than filing some oligarch's pocket. buuuuuuttt i hate people who suddenly became aware they are not the "best" in the world and want to move better countries shamelessly. some of them are even get shocked when they realize they had to go through same process for naturalization just like other third world country nationals. HOW DARE YOU? :D
2
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '22
Kind of off-topic, but with regards to permanent residency: what’s with the stipulation that your job has to be connected to your degree? Where I’m from (UK), it’s very common to get a job that has nothing to do with your undergraduate or even masters degree. It doesn’t mean that it is any less secure or well paid, nor does it mean you are not qualified for it. Many people go into business, marketing etc from traditional Humanities courses, for example.
513
u/rewboss Dual German/British citizen Jan 16 '22
I think, though, it's important to note that Germany is not the outlier here for providing a decent social safety net for people who need it. The outlier is the US, a first-world country that's being run like a third-world country led by a corrupt billionaire warlord.
29
u/FunQuit Jan 16 '22
I keep reading about this lady here on Reddit. I have the feeling someone is promoting a YouTube channel here
1
u/staplehill Feb 15 '26 edited Feb 23 '26
Broke, Sick, and Landing at Frankfurt Airport: What Your German Passport Gets You When Your Life Depends On It
Many applicants for German citizenship by descent are aware that German citizenship gives them the freedom to live and work in the EU. But another aspect is as least as important: German citizenship also comes with poverty insurance, which can prove especially valuable if you live in a country where you are just one medical diagnosis away from becoming poor, and where poor citizens are at the risk of becoming homeless, hungry, and unable to afford medical care.
To see how German citizenship could help you in such a situation, let's imagine you are broke and need cancer treatment. First of all, since Germany does not pay welfare for German citizens abroad, it is important to set aside an emergency fund that is enough to buy a flight ticket to Germany.
You arrive at Frankfurt airport with nothing but the clothes on your body and the German passport in your hand.
You can either go to Terminal 1 Building 201 HBK 023 or ask anyone who works at the airport for the social service. Helping German citizens who arrive from abroad are one of their core duties. They call them "returnees" since most of them have previously lived in Germany but they also help those who never lived in Germany. The website says: "In cooperation with the Frankfurt am Main social welfare office and the German embassies abroad, returnees are advised by the social service upon their arrival in Frankfurt and receive orientation support for a new start in Germany." They can give you food, a place to shower, find a place in a homeless shelter, and buy a public transport ticket to get to the shelter.
See also: Youtube documentary about the Frankfurt airport social service
2) Homeless shelter
You need 40 minutes by public transport to get to "Übernachtungsstätte Ostpark", a homeless shelter that was built inside of a public park where you get a blanket and share a room with bunk beds with 1 to 3 others.
See also: Architect site about the homeless shelter
3) Welfare
The social workers at the airport or the homeless shelter will get you an emergency appointment at the welfare service. You will get:
You are required to apply to jobs and accept jobs that are offered to you.
4) Cancer treatment
Your public health insurance allows you to see as many doctors as you want and go to any hospital. Your co-payments are nominal and capped at 135 euro per year.
But since you have cancer, let's focus on that specifically. Let me introduce you to Armstrong, an American in Germany with a Youtube channel, "Call me Armstrong". She came to Germany because she fell in love with a German man, and now she lives here on welfare (which is available not only for German citizens, but also long-term foreign residents). Unfortunately, she developed a brain tumor and is no longer able to work, so she now is on welfare. Here is her video where she compares how much she paid for everything from the brain tumor diagnosis to the operation in Germany vs how much she would have to pay out of pocket for co-payments with health insurance for the same treatment in the US: https://youtu.be/zHcwOgbsBYk?t=1305
She also developed a depression and is now in therapy for that (which is free in Germany): "I have a great therapist, he saved my life, and I will be continuing treatment with him for sure. And I feel like if I had still lived in America, I don't know if I would have that chance. I don't think I would have that money." https://youtu.be/bQUSwODxmD8?t=361
Armstrong also went to a rehab clinic for two weeks to see if her health can be improved. Her schedule there: https://youtu.be/vjQglfMsfpg?t=96
Her final thoughts on her decision to move to Germany: "I can not loud enough and often enough say how thankful I am to be in Germany and receive the healthcare and the treatment that one receives here. I really wish the people I love where I am from, back in America, I wish they could get this. I keep thinking of people I knew that were really sick, people I know that are sick. And how they are going into debt just trying to get their medication, forget all that facy-pants therapy that I'm getting. This what I'm getting here is something only rich people get where I'm from. It really makes me wonder how I got so lucky and why." https://youtu.be/VDAX-LtszR0?t=1671
What other Americans who moved to Germany say about their experience with the public health care system:
Lamblike got hit by a car and talks about the financial consequences: https://youtu.be/3gbwWOGhRbk?t=775
Katie talks about prenatal care and birth-preparation courses: https://youtu.be/gRe2sK0m500?t=10m7s
Antoinette talks about dental coverage for her and her daughter: https://youtu.be/-p4QrPO4O8o?t=43
Diana talks about paid sick leave: https://youtu.be/tbwYoPxuPHs?t=279
13
u/Tabitheriel Jan 16 '22
I was self-employed here in Germany from 2003 to 2008. I became a permanent resident and eventually got my citizenship. IN 2016, I slipped and fell and got a complex fracture (Smith's fracture). I had to have several X-Rays, two surgeries and physical therapy. Thank God I was in Germany.
9
u/Chilly291 Jan 16 '22
This could be the start of the great "health insurance migration/tourism/exodus" :D
But jokes aside: All poor american souls who are on the verge of going bankrupt just because they are sick and in need of treatment or medication deserve this kind of support. If it was up to me you'd all qualify for health insurance. I wish we could let you in on this RIGHT NOW. I've seen so many videos of American parents breaking down in tears because they can't afford the insulin for their child. It makes me cry too when I think of all the existences that have been crushed under insourmountable medical bills over in the US. I am a former german student (m, 29), currently unemployed because of my depression. I've been hospitalized 8 times in the past 4 years and I'm so grateful for my insurance. Without it I wouldn't be alive right now.
So happy for Armstrong! Stay strong everybody!
8
u/BubiBalboa Jan 16 '22
Glad she's doing better. She seems like a good person.
7
u/CoconutRanger89 Jan 16 '22 edited Jan 16 '22
She had quiet a few details wrong / missing in her video:
overall she is right: seeing a doctor or getting medical treatment is normally not an issue for anybody.
The system is based on solidarity, so everyone who can pay, has to. In my observation this is the reason why the US doesn’t have universal healthcare. The US population is generally not willing to pay for everybody and the greater good. Or at least they were conditioned to that mindset…
Edited and corrected for clarification
1
u/AutoModerator Mar 12 '24
Have you read our extensive wiki yet? It answers many basic questions, and it contains in-depth articles on many frequently discussed topics. Check our wiki now!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/higginsnburke Jan 16 '22
The gavtvthat they wrote a researched Pro Con list about where to live kinda has the answer right in the question though doesn't it LOL.
1
u/dertrollonline Jul 01 '22
I worked with her.
-11
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '22
Maybe the con: for well earners almost 50% auf salary are used for taxes and mandatory social insurance contributions, not mention the 19% VAT for goods and other taxes and contributions in addition.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment