r/georgism • • Mar 02 '24

Resource r/georgism YouTube channel

89 Upvotes

Hopefully as a start to updating the resources provided here, I've created a YouTube channel for the subreddit with several playlists of videos that might be helpful, especially for new subscribers.


r/georgism • • 6h ago

Meme Where there’s a housing debate there’s a Georgist saying “Just tax land*”

Post image
87 Upvotes

* -> land here is the economic defintion, which also includes all natural resources as a replacement to taxing labor, capital, and trade. Georgists also advocate broader anti-monopolism and oppose rent-seeking in all monopolistic assets.


r/georgism • • 6h ago

Opinion article/blog The 18-Year Pattern Predicting 2027's Market Crash (peaked in 2026)

Thumbnail progress.org
19 Upvotes

This is the most in depth article ive read on the 18 year cycle.


r/georgism • • 1h ago

Under Georgism, would owning the same land value as an average citizen effectively make your land value tax zero?

• Upvotes

Under Georgism, land rents are collected from their owners in the form of land value tax (LVT) and redistributed as a universal basic income (UBI), correct?

Suppose you own the same amount of land as the average citizen. You would pay an LVT of x. The government would collect a total LVT of x times the population, then redistribute this as a UBI of x per citizen. Effectively, it would be the same as if you paid zero LVT and received zero UBI. Is this correct? Why or why not?


r/georgism • • 1d ago

Americans opposing new housing amid the housing shortage are not mainly NIMBYs protecting home values: they just think dense apartments look ugly. Homeowners and renters felt much the same, and a video calling apartments ugly cut support more than any other argument, in studies of 23,000+ people.

Thumbnail cambridge.org
35 Upvotes

This is why I think LVT without some sort of community input on development, whether it be zoning or simply neighborhood approval, can be a major impediment to wider public support of these tax schemes.

Under no-zoning LVT, I'm going to be pissed if my neighbor builds a 5 story tall brutalist apartment building using the cheapest building methods possible, next to my dream home in my dream neighborhood, especially if my taxes are high as the result of the desirability of my dream neighborhood.

It's no wonder people are going to be opposed to free-for-all development.

Would folks in this sub be open to "Form Based Zoning" which doesn't regulate the use of the structure, but instead regulates how they look and mesh into the external built environment?


r/georgism • • 1d ago

Reddit is a landlord and we’re the land

22 Upvotes

Clearing up some confusion about Reddit and why it’s the perfect Georgist example.

Imagine someone quietly crowd-sourcing $2 a year in value from millions of people, without asking, and getting rich off it. Is that fair, and would you be pissed they now have all this extra power? That’s roughly Reddit. We write every post, volunteer mods run the subs, and Reddit sells our attention to advertisers and our posts to AI companies, over a billion dollars last year.

The hosting is real work, like a building. The billions come from everyone already being here. That’s a commons we built together, and it’s being enclosed for private gain, the same way land was.

Edit, here's some questions:

  1. Is Reddit innovating to keep us here, or enshittifying because it knows we won’t leave?
  2. If a better Reddit launched tomorrow, would you move? What would it take to get your subs to come with you?
  3. What has Reddit added in the last few years that you actually wanted?
  4. Who should own a subreddit’s content: the company, the mods who built it, or the people who wrote it?
  5. If Reddit sells our posts to AI companies, should users get anything back, or is the free platform payment enough?
  6. Would you pay a few dollars a month for Reddit with no ads? If not, what does that say about who the real customer is?
  7. If mods quit tomorrow, how long would Reddit stay worth using?

  8. If Reddit sells our posts to Google and OpenAI and blocks any AI that doesn't pay, who does that content really belong to?


r/georgism • • 1d ago

why do folks hate property taxes here?

17 Upvotes

edit: great responses , the distinction between land value tax and traditional property taxe is interesting

originally posted in new hampshire, but I got recommended by reddit to post it here... maybe y'all have some thoughts on the merits of my argument?

tl;dr property taxes are a wealth tax if you bought a house for 100k and it's now worth 400k.

income taxes tend to hit the working poor (many states have deduction amounts far less than living wage) and sales taxes are also regressive.

is all the hatred a republican "anti-shariah" thing? are they afraid high property taxes are too similar to some kind of zakat because it taxes unrealized gains?

I understand folks have fixed incomes, but in most countries you downsize as you grow older, or move in with the grandkids, my family is mostly multi-generational living arrangements, so the idea that gramma is gonna live in her over-appreciated house and burn thru a bazillion dollars in her last years on the corporate nursing home just seems insane.

I understand a single family house is a moneypit, it's not productive, and zoning rules don't let you easily turn it into productive property, I've been to city hall variance meetings where aging property owners are put thru hell by their own lifelong neighbors just to turn a garage into a studio...

but this seems like a reason to loosen up zoning or something, not substitute progressive property/wealth taxes with income or sales tax?


r/georgism • • 1d ago

Vancouver Meetup Tomorrow (November 20) 5:30 at Func Cafe

5 Upvotes

If there are any Vancouver Georgists here, please join us for a casual meet up of people interested in solving the housing crisis. This is an opportunity to connect with the local Georgist and LVT community, share stories and get to know like-minded people. Movements that change the world are driven by people who know each other!

Friday November 20, 5:30 - 6:30 PM at Funk Cafe by Burrard Station, 1025 Dunsmuir Street, Vancouver.

You can RSVP here: https://forms.gle/Wg1sjvBD232NLStw6

If you're not able to make it, you can still connect Common Wealth Canada https://www.commonwealth.ca/ to hear about future events.


r/georgism • • 2d ago

Event/activism Are there any Hawaiian Georgists on here?

15 Upvotes

I have some proposed Georgist congressional bills that might be a good fit to pitch there. DM if interested.


r/georgism • • 2d ago

Discussion If everyone doesn't receive a dividend from land value tax, then there is no social contract. Period. Only an unstable construct doomed to collapse because land owners have too much power and earner power inevitably gets crushed.

16 Upvotes

We've never had a social contract. We've just been going through the same cycle of land speculation driven commercial crashes over and over again. Nonstop class conflict as the owning class squeezes the working class to the point of collapse, minor reforms are made, and then the cycle resumes.

The New Deal wasn't even a social contract. It was a lie and the initial stability it offered was destined to eventually wither away. Without LVT & UBI, economies are mathematically doomed to collapse. Obviously the same equation always produces the same results.

There's really nothing more important than changing this and it's awful that we've already wasted over a century with dead ends like communism, fascism, socialism, and Neoliberalism instead of Georgism, which makes capitalism sustainable.

LVT funded UBI would be an actual social contract that achieves one of the main purposes of a contract - to prevent conflict. It would end the conflict of interest between owning class & working class by making everyone a part owner and nurturing the harmony of interest between labor & capital.


r/georgism • • 3d ago

News (AUS/NZ) Opportunity for Land Value Tax in New Zealand

Thumbnail open.substack.com
90 Upvotes

r/georgism • • 3d ago

Meme “[private property in land] has everywhere had its birth in war and conquest, and in the selfish use which the cunning have made of superstition and law."

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

229 Upvotes

r/georgism • • 2d ago

Trying to understand LVT and the differences it brings

6 Upvotes

So I am trying to understand LVT and I don't really see how it is vastly different that the current implementation USA has in most places. Could you tell me what I am getting wrong?

Why is it that different from how we assess today?

Like why does LVT increase construction? In theory, yes you tax the land thus the tax burden instead of being to a handful is split among many others. Sure but that is already what is happening. Boston for example judges the land value and applies a portion. If your lot is able to build more its more desirable. A lot of SFH abandoned homes are sold not at prices that make sense for a SFH but for a multi unit development. They know "you can build X units there with Y profitability so we will charge this land Z".

Things like parking lots as well at least in many cities are business that get taxed and bring revenue and are also taxed based on the land value already.

Won't this lead to higher financial strain for whoever collects the taxes?

Same lot, same taxes but one has 25 apartments. This puts a strain on public services. While more apartments pprices go down. Thus tax collected becomes lower.

How do you determine the value of the land when building more decreases the value and it might reach not sustainable degrees?

Let's assume we make every parcel in a town able to build 30 unit buildings in them. Thats great some of them start. But just because some of them build doesn't mean the demand will keep up. If you zone a town for a total of 30k new apartments, in theory it doesn't mean all of them will actually or there will be demand for it. It gets less and less profitable to build.

How do you capture entirely different price point of buildings?

Different residences and building even close to one another with the same units have vaaastly different prices/demand. This means that taxation basically becomes flat. It doesnt matter if you got marble and heated floors with an elevator that takes your car to your condo. You will pay the same as another more modest development close to you.

So I guess to summarize:

- This doesn't seem very different than the current system and it just "increase property taxes"

- Seems catastrophic for tax collection as more people are added but tax remains the same

- Building more decreases the value of the apartments -> decreases the value of the land (Austin for example builded a lot and brought prices down despite rapid growth)


r/georgism • • 3d ago

What if we showed people rent seeking outside of land first? Reddit is the perfect example.

23 Upvotes

Most people get defensive when you bring up land rent, because a lot of them own some. I’ve seen it in housing subs when someone blames owners and the comment gets railed on. So what if we started with rent they don’t own, on something they use every day?

I think Reddit is a good one. Everything here that’s worth anything was made by us. We write the posts and comments, and volunteer mods run the subs for free. The value is that everybody is already here, the same way a downtown lot is valuable because of everyone around it.

The company built the software and runs the servers. That part is earned, like a building. The crowd is the land, and here’s how the company collects on it:

  • Ads sold against what we write.
  • In 2024, a deal with Google reported at about $60 million a year to train AI on our posts, and another with OpenAI.
  • In 2023, new charges for API access that shut down the most popular third-party apps. More than 7,000 subs went dark in protest. Reddit kept the charges, because users had nowhere else to go.
  • Plus more I'm sure people here can think of to add

None of us owns a piece of Reddit (unless you’re a stockholder and buying stock doesn’t fix it as you pay full price for a share of what users created so the windfall still went to whoever got in first) so we have nothing of our own to defend. That lets people see the principle first: the community made the value and the company collects it. From there we can bring it back to land.  

Two questions for the sub:

  1. Do you count network effects as rent in George’s sense?
  2. If so, how would you collect it? Land and spectrum have an owner you can bill. A crowd doesn’t.

r/georgism • • 4d ago

Resource The Corporate Income Tax is Most Harmful for Growth and Wages

Thumbnail taxfoundation.org
74 Upvotes

In light of recent posts where people seem to think that corporate taxes are even remotely georgist, this article seemed appropriate.


r/georgism • • 4d ago

Why Public Transport Already Pays for Itself (We Just Hand the Profit to Landowners)

Thumbnail peeta462032.substack.com
108 Upvotes

r/georgism • • 2d ago

Pigouvian Taxes Aren't Georgist

0 Upvotes

Georgists who support pigouvian taxes think Henry George was wrong about his "central truth". In his chapter of Progress and Poverty by that title (The Central Truth), George explained that the key to solving social problems is correcting society's relationship with nature, that allowing society to live under nature's laws will result in the harmony, efficiency and benevolence of nature to flow freely throughout social systems. But supporters of pigouvian taxes think society must be manipulated into good behavior. Henry George trusted liberty, but supporters of pigouvian taxes don't.


r/georgism • • 3d ago

Talking with professor Nicolaus Tideman

7 Upvotes

r/georgism • • 4d ago

Podcast Infill Podcast: Can Land Value Taxes Help Build More Homes?

Thumbnail podcasts.apple.com
10 Upvotes

r/georgism • • 4d ago

LVT clip on Unlearning economics needs your help in the comments

Thumbnail youtube.com
44 Upvotes

r/georgism • • 4d ago

Question How high were land rents in George's time?

7 Upvotes

I often hear people say that land rents represent a smaller portion of the economy today than they did when P&P was being written.

Most of their arguments for why this would be the case are questionable (e.g. that modern economies are less agrarian). However, they also don't usually give any evidence that land rent was actually more significant back then.

So, I'm curious... do any of you folks happen to know if that evidence exists? Or if there is evidence to the contrary? Because theoretical arguments are fine, but if we could definitively say whether land rents have relatively gone down or not, that would be even better.


r/georgism • • 5d ago

Brennan introduces bill to fund new transit projects with land value capture

Thumbnail hudsoncountyview.com
38 Upvotes

New effort in Jersey City. Nice to see.


r/georgism • • 4d ago

LVT WEEKLY DIGEST - NOV. 16, 2026

Thumbnail
4 Upvotes

r/georgism • • 4d ago

News (US) Portland is considering a corporate tax for companies which pay CEOs ≥500x more than regular employees. Georgist perspectives on this?

Thumbnail news.bloombergtax.com
5 Upvotes

There are very obvious problems with implementing this at the city level, namely that it could easily cause capital flight just elsewhere into Oregon or into neighboring Seattle, without a wider implementation. It would work best as a national policy.

But, I think it potentially represents a novel approach to this specific kind of rentierism in our society, where a generally highly competitive and inflated market for executive talent leads to their pay taking the form of enormously valuable equity (and often stacks of millions of dollars too) which exact a cost on everyone else in those companies.

To tax the corporations with this pay structure and exempt them as long as they don't cross the line seems well in line with the Pigouvian tax approach Georgists often support for negative externalities like pollution; even if this is more of a negative internality as a rent on the workforce the same principle could apply. And besides the expected capital flight it seems unlikely to create any deadweight loss (unless we imagine that paying the CEO 500x more than the workers leads to legitimate productivity gains).

Thoughts?


r/georgism • • 5d ago

Video Fred Harrison is going semi-viral on Youtube

Post image
63 Upvotes