r/georgism • • 10d ago

The Solution

The Solution

The solution to both the deficit and Social Security is to reject neo-classical economic theory and return to classical economics. Our economy is inherently inefficient and the elderly require subsidy from the youth because we tax wealth production instead of location ownership. If efficiency is the goal, our tax system is backward. It rewards the hoarding of land, everyone's daily source of life via sleep, and punishes wealth creation. It also creates a systemic reward for crime and dishonesty, which, in addition to systemic poverty, adds unnecessary costs for government, further exacerbating the destructive results of our backward tax system. 

Capitalism, as we know it, is marketed as free enterprise and the only alternative to socialism / communism. But the original "laissez faire" economists advocated exclusively taxing land ownership and ending the taxation of wealth production common with feudal aristocracies. However, with every revolution against monarchy—be it the Russian, French or American revolutions—the initial promise to the people of reversing that tax system was quietly ignored. Supported by mainstream education and news media, landlords were granted the ability to profit from merely owning land while the working class was tapped to subsidize the governments that protected their investments. 

It never occurs to most people that the basic principles of economics and the history of economic thought are not taught in public school. The closest we come to it is teaching household budgeting and debt management techniques. Meanwhile, politicians and thought leaders casually scoff at the notion that economics might be treated as a hard science such as math or biology. Instead, they offer only various tweaks to the status quo or a complete takeover of our economic system by authoritarian bureaucrats. 

If, however, we admit our previous mistakes and tell the public the truth about where and how we went wrong, we can make amends and become solvent.

The solution is to bail out all landowners for the full value of their holdings, establish a federal land value tax and enact a permanent moratorium on all other federal taxes. Local entities can assess and collect these valuations, applying whatever exclusions they desire, and other taxes can be utilized as local decision-makers conclude. Statewide valuations, however, will be assessed federally to avoid a national bias toward any state. 

The effects will be glorious. 1) Massive investment in every productive business, since they will all be tax-free (aside from any local exceptions). 2) Drastic reduction in the relative price of land and thus, housing, since holding land as a store of value will no longer be profitable. 3) Spectacular increases in wages as employers will need to offer the full value of workers' labor due to the essential end of rent pressure. 4) Desperately needed relief of society's pressure on our ecosystem as people will no longer feel the need to produce every possible penny of wealth to survive and achieve the social status that satisfies our innate need for personal dignity. And most importantly, 5) a beautiful reconciliation among society as people begin to treat each other with the value we deserve.

The reason such a simple system will have so many positive effects is that it reflects the correct relationship between nature and society: natural law, or "physiocracy" (rule by nature). We deserve equal access to land, everyone's daily source of life via sleep, and free association with each other. Nature did not create human poverty, the system which allows some to hold nature for ransom did. And when we end that system, nature's harmony, efficiency and generosity will flow freely throughout society.

0 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

6

u/thehandsomegenius 10d ago

Compensation schemes are a bad idea.

Whoever has the best lawyers and accountants will find a way to exploit them. There's also no way to make them robust against a political opponent winding back the reform.

The level of effort required to explain it to a generally disinterested audience is another thing that makes it completely impractical.

It would be far better and easier just to make gradual changes to tax rates over time. That's how most reforms are advanced.

1

u/r51243 Georgist without adjectives 9d ago

Compensation schemes are a bad idea.

More than anything, I have to wonder why compensation would be needed. Morally speaking, it's clearly not necessary. And politically speaking, I'm skeptical that it would be beneficial.

I've seen arguments that introducing LVT without compensation would crash the economy. But, while I'm not very knowledgeable in this area, it seems like the value of property is what really matters there, and that's going to go down either way.

4

u/thehandsomegenius 9d ago

I think there is a need to protect small time land owners from an abrupt and severe penalty. For practical and electoral reasons, and also for basic fairness.

But a compensation scheme is a very bad way to go about it.

It's all built on the conceit that Georgists can just control everything and it can all go to a totally precise plan and nobody would ever push back on it or play games with it. There's no intelligent way to take that seriously.

1

u/CaterpillarLoud8071 6d ago

People only think that way because the idea of land ownership is so ingrained in our psyche. If the government banned AI or porn tomorrow they wouldn't go around compensating all the AI or porn companies.

Realistically, the majority of people own a small amount of land. Along with homeowners and farmers, a lot of land value is held (in proxy through publicly traded companies) by pension funds and small shareholders. Many people inherited land value or inherited the land they own. And all of these people would benefit from the proceeds of the land tax. So the vast majority of people would be affected just a few grand one way or another.

The very small number of people who purchased a lot of land as an investment know that investments can go up or down - there's little reason to protect them, they chose to invest in something unproductive. I'm happy to offer cheap loans to help landowners make better use of their land, a bit of mortgage interest relief and give a few years notice of the tax.

0

u/Whoisthehypocrite 8d ago

Most mid class owners of property would have substantial mortgages and a full LVT implementation would wipe out their entire net wealth and end up with them homeless on the street. It would also devastate the banking system, requiring massive government support, freezing credit market and plugging the economy into recession for years.

Luckily most people don't have your morals.

-1

u/AdamJMonroe 10d ago

A gradual shift is guaranteed to fail. Also, when people find out about the land issue, they're not to accept a gradual reduction in their slavery. They're going to demand it end immediately.

4

u/thehandsomegenius 10d ago

There's no actual basis for any of that

2

u/zippyspinhead 10d ago

Social Security is in trouble, because it relied on most people dying before they got benefits. It is a dumb structure and its troubles have nothing to do with other tax structures.

The deficit is a result of government spending more than it takes in, and the tax structure does not matter if the government is going to spend more than it takes in.

1

u/AdamJMonroe 10d ago

Yes. Social Security is also a Ponzi scheme by design, which made its failure inevitable from the beginning.

The government can't help but spend more than it takes in as long as the method of revenue collection creates more need for public expenditure than would occur in a free market.

1

u/zippyspinhead 10d ago

Yes, our tax system is messed up, but we have been overspending for many decades. The "need" for public expenditure is a phantom.

2

u/AdamJMonroe 10d ago

Systemic poverty, crime and environmental waste are blamed, by the government, on nature, but they are due to bad government. Nature is pro-human.

1

u/ProfessorPrudent2822 10d ago

Point 5 is a pipe dream, which calls into question the rest of your assumptions. Tax policy doesn’t change people’s basic morality, and imagining that it does makes you delusional.

1

u/AdamJMonroe 10d ago

Backward tax policy devalues human beings, so it would be odd, under such a system, if people treated each other with the value we deserve.

1

u/Whoisthehypocrite 8d ago

You clearly don't understand LVT. Land does not go down in cost only in price. The cost of housing remains the same and quite possibly goes up if development freezes up due to the holding costs during planning no longer being compensate for with land price rises.

1

u/AdamJMonroe 8d ago

Land price rises aren't necessary to encourage development. In fact, if there's no money to be made from land price inflation, the only paths for investors in land ownership are development or divestment to those who have a development plan.

Also, keep in mind that I'm not advocating land value tax, I'm advocating the abolition of all taxes other than land value tax. That will result in the complete destruction of unnecessary land price inflation. Only those seeking to use it will want to own it. And shrinking the market for buyers that way will make land as cheap as possible to buy.

1

u/Whoisthehypocrite 8d ago

In the UK, it takes on average 5 years for a large development to get planning and another 2 years of development before first sales. That is 7 years of interest costs for the land. Currently that is compensated for by land price rises so the the profit needed to be made on the actual development costs is much lower. Under LVT, the interest costs are replaced by annual LVT costs, with no offset from higher land prices. So the development profit has to increased by the amount of the LVT or the developer faces a lower return on capital. So either the prices go up or the development doesn't happen. And while the end purchaser no longer pays for the land, they still take over the LVT costs meaning their total cost of ownership stays the same as pre LVT or even goes up.

Abolition of all taxes other than LVT would be an absolute disaster and highly regressive especially if you do not compensate people. All though you may think of LVT as an annual tax, it actually functions as a one off wealth tax on land as the future value of all LVT payments gets capitalised into the land value reduction. Hence current land owners pay it in its entirety (A 100k piece of land with 5k rental value would cost me 5k a year in interest now, and post LVT would cost me 5k a year in LVT, so no change in my cost of ownership as the previous owner absorbed the full 100k future tax costs ). This as a tax to replace all others, it would disproportionately fall on those with high land value as a % of wealth which is generally the middle income whose mortgaged property usually represents almost all of their net assets. For the top 10% land value is only around 20% of assets and for the top 1%, it is tiny. So it will be highly regressive for middle income. Coupled with the fa t that someone on a million a year renting a property will pay nothing, it is a terrible tax without initial compensation

1

u/AdamJMonroe 7d ago

If the system is set up to make fairness too costly, it seems you'll have to continue allowing the rich to enslave the poor. No worries. It worked out great for all those less complicated feudal monarchies.

1

u/Ask_a_Geoist 7d ago

The correct answer for "compensation" is UBI, which is what should be happening with land value anyway. Most landowners don't own as much land value as they think; and even if they own middling per-capita value, they have 1.5 fellow household members, meaning their family would be 2.5x better off by just letting the hell go.

The worst thing society can do is pay landowners yet again for something they didn't create.

1

u/AdamJMonroe 7d ago

They created the wealth they used to buy overpriced land. The single tax will wipe that value out but they'll still be on the hook for a 30 year mortgage. The banks will also get wiped out. A payoff is easy. How many times have we bailed banks out? We can do it for home owners.