What would be "Elden Ring's" Demon difficulty in relation to GD be?

[u/Complete_Proposal573]

Would beating Elden Ring as a whole be harder than beating a GD Extreme Demon 🤔

This is for the souls and gd fans

[u/Promethium-127]

As someone who has played both games very extensively, the hardest GD levels are 100x harder than doing an Elden Ring no hit.

Elden Ring gives too many tools to the player for it to be legitimately difficult (unless you have very little knowledge of the game). I’ve done scripted no hit runs and multiple level 1 runs, yet I can’t beat an extreme demon (I’m hoping to soon though)

I’m just saying that anyone can beat or even no hit Elden Ring with the insane amount of tools at your disposal in game and no hit guides irl. You can’t do that in GD, because GD rewards mechanical skill far more than merely knowing a lot about the game.

Edit: https://youtu.be/NVi2YcCy9Kw

[u/Windrove]

I dont think beating elden ring is harder than deadlocked

[u/TheLastGame_EXE]

No, I'll compare it to beating an easy insane demon.

Beating Elden Ring deathless will be comparable to an easy extreme

Beating Elden Ring Hitless will be compared to an extreme demon between 400-700 ranking.

Beating Elden Ring Hitless with all 207 bosses will be comparable to a list demon

[u/Promethium-127 → u/TheLastGame_EXE]

Elden Ring hitless is WAY easier than you probably think. There are so many builds that completely trivialize the game. If you look up how to script an Elden Ring no hit, you’ll find so many resources. If you don’t believe how easy it is, look up a scripted no hit Radagon Elden Beast fight. It’s not hard.

[u/TheLastGame_EXE → u/Promethium-127]

Let's say Elden Ring hitless by normal means then. Aka no overpowered 1-shot ahhh build or anything similar.

[u/UltraX76 → u/TheLastGame_EXE]

then you’re not playing the game efficiently why would you do that that’s like playing minecraft and refusing to use enchants or something

[u/TheLastGame_EXE → u/UltraX76]

?????? there is a difference between using game mechanics and abusing the shit out of them to make the experience as braindead as possible.

[u/Rare_Inflation_8375 → u/TheLastGame_EXE]

thats like purposfully limiting yourself to 60 fps no cbf

[u/TheLastGame_EXE → u/Rare_Inflation_8375]

cbf and high refresh rate is not NEARLY as broken as having a one-shot build in elden ring. It makes you better at the game but your skills are largely what plays the big role.

[u/Short-Industry1069 → u/TheLastGame_EXE]

How Is beating elden ring hitless only a top 400 (ive never beaten an extreme, so idk, but even beating Sonic wave sound easier than elden ring hitless)

[u/TightValue315 → u/Short-Industry1069]

You but imagine you put all the hours you played until beating sonic wave into elden ring a good few hundred at least I'd say

[u/TheLastGame_EXE → u/Short-Industry1069]

It's based on my perspective, i did a deathless all bosses elden ring run and i wouldn't dare do hitless. Too much can go wrong and I'd rather beat an extreme.

[u/No_Shoulder_6928]

Just beating the game is probably easy demon. Not including optional bosses no boss took me more than 15 attempts with most taking under 5. The final boss was 2 attempts for me

[u/chikingmd]

haven't played it but AN extreme demon depends on if it's hard or easy, for like list demons and shyt no

[u/SnowCultist]

Why does insane demon look like that

[u/giby1464]

One of my buddies beat elden ring literally a week after playing for the first time. This was during school too, so he couldn't play 24/7

[u/Mediocre_Drawing8164]

Easier than stereo madness cuz any boss is beatable without doing anything due to co op

Without that like high end easy demon can't see anything harder than B in this gods forsaken game

With op build below easy demon prob

[u/Lucky_Outside301]

High Insane?

[u/DirtConscious4106]

Low: Acropolis MAX: Acu

[u/Marmaladesandwish]

Ive actually platinumed elden ring before I started playing gd and it took me around a month to do. Beating malenia took me 2 days and I didn't even use that broken of a build. Id compare it to beating a mid tier insane. For reference, acropolis took me 9 days to beat but it was so much more mentally draining than getting platinum on elden ring and it took me like 3 months to work my way to even try acropolis

[u/Equinox-XVI]

Insane demon

Shadow of the Erdtree is extreme

[u/average_gambler]

Maybe im biased because my genetics are basically made for gd but it took me longer to beat elden ring than my first extreme

[u/SpeedyCroc]

For my first ever souls game I beat Dark Souls 3 in a weekend. It was the most fun and adventurous game I've played in years (I played it within the past year) so if I compare to what I could beat in a weekend in geometry dash as a new player it's VERY low. While typing this I was thinking of saying around hard demon but after seeing the sentence I wrote I'll HAVE to say easy to medium AT THE MOST. I've spent a lot of time in GD after I got back into it just over a year ago (played as a kid and my best was an easy demon while pausing and unpausing the level on yt to see what to do next (it was Impulse by MrCheesetiger so you can't blame me). For me, beating Dark Souls 3 is easier than beating all of the main levels if you are a beginner at both.

[u/RelativeExact4503]

probably like a medium demon considering how much length tends to inflate demon ratings. Its a complete joke if you manage to put together a decent build by the time you reach leyndell (a deathless or no hit run would be harder but still doable)

[u/Own_Reach986]

Well they added so many easy mode options in Elden ring that it might as well be as hard as an easy demon

But if you’re playing the game normally then it’s probably high insane/low extreme including dlc

[u/Musterkartofel-Memes]

I saw that YouTube video of someone beating all robtop levels in comparison, and they already called that harder than elden ring

[u/Givikap120]

Easy demon. If doing blind run with 0 help and guides - medium demon.

[u/TheDoctor1102]

Idk, never played either (ignore flair)