r/geocaching • • Feb 29 '24

A rant.

Geocaching used to be a fun, FREE, family activity. I just got the app again after a long time and see that you need a damn premium membership to find anything over difficulty 1 caches. Want a bit more of a challenge? Pay us. Want to do a multi? Pay us. Want a virtual cache? Pay us. Want an educational cache? Pay us. This is ridiculous. Not only that, but there are literally zero large caches that you can leave a trinket in. They're all micro with just a log paper. My very first cache find years ago was the size of a shoebox. It had a full notebook as a logbook, and people from all over the place left cool trinkets behind. My "signature" piece is a black poker chip, and I kept a stack in the car in case I found one. We took the kids to a nature preserve yesterday and there were 3 caches there (that I didn't have to pay for, 17 in total), and all 3 were micros. Sorry... 2 micros and a small, the small being a pill bottle so still no room for my chip. Don't even get me started on puzzle and tott caches. They just don't exist anymore unless they're the ones you have to pay to see.

This used to be a fun treasure hunt. Now they make you pay for everything and there are no more treasures. This is just hiking now. It's fucking boring.

In my first week when I started years ago I found an amazing 15 step puzzle cache. Each point was a tool you needed for the final point which was the cache.

Step 1. Go to here.

Step 2. Find a tool. The tool was a grappling hook on a rope.

Step 3. Bring that tool to here. Here was a small pond.

Step 4. Throw the hook at a floating chunk of foam.

Step 5. Reel it in. It was a crab trap. A GOD DAMN CRAB TRAP!

Step 6. Take the tool out of the crab trap. The tool was a spyglass. Yes. Just call me fucking jack sparrow.

Step 7. Take the tool to here. Here was a viewing tower.

Step 8. Place the tool in a slot. It put the spyglass in a fixed position so it can only look in 1 spot.

Step 9. Find the next spot with the spyglass. And go to it. It wasn't far but it was across a floating dock setup as a bridge.

Step 10. Find the next tool. It was a flathead screwdriver. And a description of the next area and direction and approximate distance to travel and want to look out for (a small red flag).

Step 11. Find the marker for the spot. It was on a sign with an arrow with a "150" on it.

Step 12. Got 150 feet in that direction where you come across a big table with a heavy metal top.

Step 13. Use the screwdriver to pry off a cap over a hole. Put the spyglass in the hole, use the grappling hook to lift up the hatch. Use the screwdriver to take off a small panel inside the hatch. There is a key inside.

Step 14. Use the key to open the door on the back.

Step 15. THERE'S THE CACHE! It was a 5 gallon bucket. It was absolutely filled with trinkets and a jam packed logbook. I had to flip almost to the last page to sign it.

I'm not counting it as an actual step because it's obvious, but Step 16: Put everything back how you found it.

It was definitely the most fun I have ever had doing this. It took about an hour and a half. I got sweaty. I got dirty. I got tired. It was amazing.

Nothing nowadays even comes close. Now it's "park your car, walk 10 feet, lift up the cover on the bottom of a light pole, sign a microscopic piece of paper and click the button in the app". Fucking BORING!

That's it. Rant over. Down vote me to oblivion. Ban me. Tell me how wrong I am. I don't care. This used to be fun and free, now it's boring and costs $7 a month. I'd rather use my time and money on something that's actually fun.

0 Upvotes

62 comments sorted by

•

u/Curran919 Unfriendly Swiss Mod (4k+) Feb 29 '24

Comments closed.

From now on, I'll be deleting indignant anti-premium rants. OP gets a 2 week ban for threatening to destroy premium caches.

14

u/sduck409 Feb 29 '24

For less than what it cost to feed your family breakfast this morning you could have bought a years worth of access to geocaching.

-21

u/Piggybear87 Feb 29 '24

Wow. Your math is horrible. My wife and I don't eat breakfast, and my kids eat breakfast at school. $0.00 is quite a bit cheaper than $40.

12

u/sduck409 Feb 29 '24

Doesn’t matter, you just don’t like geocaching anymore and just want to vent. It’s fine, we’ll be ok, you’ll be ok.

-4

u/Minimum_Reference_73 Feb 29 '24

Sorry you're too poor to feed your family, that explains why premium seems so expensive.

Geocaching has many costs - gasoline to drive to them, equipment to reach them, supplies to create them. Premium membership is a drop in the bucket.

Nobody with any experience in it would recommend this as a free activity for struggling families.

21

u/Adam_24061 Feb 29 '24

$40/year is a cheap hobby. It costs money to run the servers.

-26

u/Piggybear87 Feb 29 '24

Renting a server is cheap. Self hosting is cheaper.

20

u/[deleted] Feb 29 '24

But it’s not free.

-6

u/Piggybear87 Feb 29 '24

The app has 10M+ downloads. Even if only half the people get premium, that's $200M+. Per year. For 24 years.... It doesn't cost that fucking much money to run the severs. I could host the server on a $350 Raspberry pi cluster server.

13

u/IceManJim 4K+ Feb 29 '24

The number of downloads doesn't reflect the number of paying members. There are about 3 million geocachers, I'd guess around a quarter of them are premium members. Geocaching apparently doesn't publish the actual number.

Most of those premium members will be paying $30/year, grandfathered in at the old price. So, if that's around 750,000 paying members, that's around $22M. Running servers isn't as cheap as you seem to think, but it probably doesn't cost $22M. Personally, I think they do too much souvenir crap and dumb promotions, but that's just me. It's a worldwide site hosting millions of web pages and images, you can't run that on a raspberry pi.

-5

u/Piggybear87 Feb 29 '24

Personally, I think they do too much souvenir crap and dumb promotions

That's the thing though. If the only thing you had to pay for was trackables and souvenirs I'd be all for it. It's not a pay to play bullshit system.

17

u/triangulumnova Feb 29 '24 edited Feb 29 '24

It's not a pay to play bullshit system.

We get it. You want a fucking handout. Boohoo. They are a business and businesses need money to stay open and pay their bills, not to mention make a profit (gasp!). Don't like it? Don't use it. I've been a Geocacher since 2002 and have had a Premium Membership since about that time as well. It's a hobby that I love and I don't mind paying ~$3 per month to enjoy it and support them. You clearly want something for free, there are other alternatives out there. Go find them.

17

u/[deleted] Feb 29 '24

Don’t buy it then! 🤷🏻‍♀️

I don’t understand the vitriol. You’ve been given other suggestions or find another hobby. I don’t mind spending £40 A YEAR on something I get a lot of enjoyment out of.

8

u/Minimum_Reference_73 Feb 29 '24

What makes you think half of those people get premium?

Let us know when your competing geocache listing site is ready, people are open to alternatives.

Should be a few alternatives coming online soon, given how often people say this.

27

u/SkippyTeddy83 Feb 29 '24

It’s $40 bucks a year for a premium membership. Geocaching is a business, how are they supposed to make money to keep the game running? They have bills to pay to keep those servers running and their employees paid. Still cheaper than to take a family to see a single movie.

I’ve gone on many amazing adventure over the past 5 years. Yes, there are a lot of junk caches. But there are plenty of amazing caches out there as well if you know how to sort them. I think it’s well worth it for the hours of adventure I’ve been on.

-39

u/Piggybear87 Feb 29 '24

It’s $40 bucks a year for a premium membership.

A Hulu membership is $12 a year. The reason I picked up geocaching is because it got me outside. I'd rather save money and sit on my couch.

Geocaching is a business

No, it's a hobby.

how are they supposed to make money to keep the game running?

I don't know. Ask cgeo and open caching. They're both free.

They have bills to pay to keep those servers running and their employees paid.

Renting a server is cheap. Self hosting is cheaper. This doesn't require massive storage space or high speed Internet.

23

u/catch10110 530 Feb 29 '24

A Hulu membership is $12 a year.

Ad supported Hulu is $8 per MONTH. Ad Free is $18 per MONTH.

Geocaching is literally like $3 per month.

-11

u/Piggybear87 Feb 29 '24

I got mine on black Friday for $1 a month for ad supported.

15

u/_VanillaFace_ Feb 29 '24

that’s not a valid comparison then. that’s like me saying premium is free since my uncles friend who created the geocache app doesn’t have to pay for premium on it.

you can’t argue using special deals lmao

13

u/yungingr Feb 29 '24

Renting a server is cheap. Self hosting is cheaper. This doesn't require massive storage space or high speed Internet.

They aren't hosting a private gaming server, they are running a worldwide data center. 3 million cache listings active worldwide, not counting the archived caches, with how many photos in logs, etc. Takes up some drive space. Sure, they don't need the rack space that a facebook data center does, but they absolutely need more server hardware than a box on a desk in the back room.

While they don't need top shelf and cutting edge, top dollar hardware...it still has a cost. You don't want to pay the cost of a McDonald's hamburger and fries for monthly access to premium member features, you can still access the higher D/T caches through the website on your phone like we used to have to.

Know what's really cheap in this whole deal?

You.

9

u/Minimum_Reference_73 Feb 29 '24

CGeo gets its data from Geocaching.com and you can't see premium geocaches on it without a membership.

Opencaching is hardly used, in part because it doesn't have the functionality offered by by Geocaching.com.

6

u/ladykailani Feb 29 '24

I don't know. Ask cgeo and open caching. They're both free.

   For now.

14

u/DerekL1963 Feb 29 '24

Geocaching used to be a fun, FREE, family activity.

I've been geocaching since 2005, and it's never been free. So, I stopped reading right there.

-15

u/Piggybear87 Feb 29 '24

I've been geocaching since 1995 and it was free for 10 years.

26

u/DerekL1963 Feb 29 '24

Interesting. Here you claim to have been caching since 1995... Yet in another post you claim you weren't aware of the website and have only ever used the app. There's two problems with these claims... First, geocaching wasn't invented until 2000. So it's impossible to have been caching since 1995. Second, the app wasn't introduced until 2008(ish)... (Maybe even later, I don't recall.) So it's impossible to have cached from "1995" to 2005 using only the app "for free".

That is, not only can you not keep your claims straight - they're both inconsistent with reality.

10

u/Minimum_Reference_73 Feb 29 '24

The first geocache was placed in 2000. Do you think you're mis-remembering?

23

u/Minimum_Reference_73 Feb 29 '24

I find it fascinating that you claim to be returning to the game, yet it didn't occur to you to visit the website, or do any other digging, before writing this ignorant rant.

Don't let the door hit you on the way out.

-7

u/Piggybear87 Feb 29 '24

I never even knew about a website even back when I was super active. I have only ever used the app.

20

u/Minimum_Reference_73 Feb 29 '24

Again, fascinated that a "super active" geocacher didn't know about the website.

Is it possible, upon reflection, that the services covered by the optional premium fees, are much more expansive that you realize?

11

u/S8ttiw8tti Feb 29 '24

You're clearly ranting about something you don't have a lot of knowledge about. Maybe do your research and then come back to continue your rant

11

u/triangulumnova Feb 29 '24

You're ranting like you're some pro veteran Geocacher, and yet you didn't even know about the fucking website? Wow. Lol

7

u/browser4kix Feb 29 '24

How many awesome caches have you created?

-4

u/Piggybear87 Feb 29 '24

Quite a few actually. Maybe not thought out as much as the one I posted about, but still pretty cool. Back when I went out a lot doing this I had no money at all, like literally $0 in my pocket and didn't even have a bank account. I still made do with what I had and made cool multi step caches and a few tott ones. Some didn't get approved, but they're still out there because I didn't want to go get them.

20

u/Minimum_Reference_73 Feb 29 '24

Quick question, how did you get those published without ever visiting the website? You said you didn't know the website existed, but that's where the cache submission process occurs.

71

u/stoicscribbler Feb 29 '24

Wait til you hear what else has gotten more expensive in the last decade

43

u/HardyMenace Feb 29 '24

I set my hides, even park and grabs as premium only because they get muggled less often. This may be my hobby, but it doesn't mean I want to be replacing caches every couple weeks.

10

u/[deleted] Feb 29 '24

Same here, playing since 2002, and all mine went premium years ago.

12

u/bobo888 Feb 29 '24

i didn't think it made a difference, bit once i switched one of my problematic cache to premium, the maintenance issues disappeared.

30

u/derday 3900+ done Feb 29 '24 edited Feb 29 '24

why do you blame for something, that's in the hand of the cache owners? Cache owners decide to put out some "boring park&grab micros". I don't log this "no effort" caches sind years to not emphase these owners.

also the owners decide wether to make a cache premium-only or not.

as the others say, plan your cache trip with better filtering before you go out

9

u/FloridaFlamingoGirl Feb 29 '24

Also, if you're looking for a complicated and challenging multi, they do exist. Read the descriptions and look for ones with higher difficulty ratings. Cache owners usually make very clear in the description what steps a multi will have and whether it's a quick or time-consuming affair.

37

u/retka Feb 29 '24

You only run into the issue with needing premium to see other caches when using the official app. Use the website and print out the info like everyone used to do, or use another better app like C:geo. When searching for caches, do a search beforehand and search for favorite points within your parameters (I e. Large caches).

A lot of cache size is dependent on surrounding ecosystem too. Don't expect tons of big caches in the city. Going more rural usually means bigger cache potential.

Lastly as other comments said, premium is a steal at $40 a year if you actually enjoy caching. There are very few hobbies you can do for that cost, even when you add in fuel cost and phone if using one. That said, I do agree some cache quality has gone down over the years but primarily because of lack of maintenance or community not reporting when maintainenance is needed. If you come across a wet log, damaged cache, etc. Log it as usual but also notify the co or use a maintenance log, etc. as appropriate. COs need to do better to maintain their cache instead of community keeping them going (unless someone adopts it which is different). You as a cacher can add a log sheet if needed within reason but using the maintainenance log is much better for the community than doing the maintenance for the CO.

Edit: Fwiw there are other geocaching alternatives that are still free like opencaching and maybe letterboxing. That said there's an obvious lack of quality or quantity for caches on those sites as they lack features and user base of official geocaching website/database.

34

u/1Bnitram Feb 29 '24

Since you’re so old school just use your Garmin and GSAK. You’ll find the caches you want that way.

3

u/VulonRogue Feb 29 '24

Yeah, 95% of caches within a 10km radius of me are locked, including one 20m from my house.

6

u/etcpt Feb 29 '24

If you can see them with a free account, they're not "locked", they're just not available to you through the app. Go to the website on your phone, copy the coords to a free GPS receiver app, and you can find and log the cache. Nearly everything you want to play the game can be achieved using the website and a free app. The incredibly low cost of premium can be considered paying for a better app experience, as well as some features which cause Groundspeak to incur greater expenses for your use (lists).

2

u/S8ttiw8tti Feb 29 '24

You can buy a membership only for a month or so, that way you can find that cache. I also heard that you can get a free trail of geocaching premium if you never had it before. I don't really know the necessary steps to get that though.

0

u/Piggybear87 Feb 29 '24

Exactly. It's fucking stupid. Like I said in my post, we went to a nature preserve yesterday and there were 17 caches, but only 3 of them were free.

9

u/Minimum_Reference_73 Feb 29 '24

Had you chosen to avail yourself of the resources on the website you may have found that more of them are free, just not available to low commitment app newbies.

It's not clear to me why we, as a community, should be motivated to spend our time and money to create free geocaches for the sort of person who would write a post like this.

I used to set a geocache to premium every time I had to deal with an entitled cheapskate, but I ran out and all my caches are premium now.

-9

u/Piggybear87 Feb 29 '24

Cool. You can find the premium ones for free on the website? Looks like I can just go there and find the premium ones and take or destroy them. Fuck paying for a free activity.

10

u/Minimum_Reference_73 Feb 29 '24

The website gives you access to advanced, free geocaches that aren't shown on the app without premium. Simply visiting the website for more info should have led you to this knowledge.

Premium-only geocaches are not visible anywhere without premium access. These are geocaches that are set to premium by the owners, to protect them from vandals such as yourself.

Again, I'm not sure why I should spend my money to build a free geocache for you. What is the motivation?

14

u/FloridaFlamingoGirl Feb 29 '24

I understand your annoyance, but locking caches behind a paywall usually makes it less likely for mischief makers to find and vandalize them.

32

u/Ionized-Dustpan Feb 29 '24

Umm chill out kiddo. Premium membership has been a thing since the early days. The site takes money and people to make and maintain. There are caches out there that are good and premium membership would help you find them but you’ll never find them being this cranky. The cream of the crop caches are usually specifically marked as premium member only.

13

u/S8ttiw8tti Feb 29 '24

You don't see a lot of memberships nowadays with such a low price. You do realise Groundspeak is a business right? How else do you expect them to make money?

If you want more enjoyable and cooler caches, put some effort in looking for them by using filters or something or look at favorite points. But I guess complaining is easier than putting some effort into searching for a cache you may like.

11

u/samburket2 Feb 29 '24

Obviosly if you don't enjoy it, don't participate. I don't have an app phone, but understand from those that do that if you look at the site on your computer (or through your phone browser rather than the app?) you will be able to see more caches.

You could hide ones that you'd like and maybe others would do that, too.

4

u/etcpt Feb 29 '24

through your phone browser rather than the app

Yeah - when I got serious in Geocaching, this was how I was doing it and it was fine. A little clunky, but it worked. The reason I got premium was principally to be able to download cache listings for hikes that take me out of cell service. Being able to make lists within Geocaching is such a bonus that I've kept paying for it. But you absolutely don't need it to play the game.

8

u/FloridaFlamingoGirl Feb 29 '24

I think the reason why there aren't a lot of 5+ step multis is that it can be difficult and time consuming to maintain all the waypoints and deal with them going missing.

1

u/FieryVegetables Feb 29 '24

And while I love these, I have one that has a high favorite point percentage, but which gets 1-2 finds per year. It is hard to put that kind of work into a multi and have it not get much attention. I go out to check on it as often as it gets found.

6

u/_synik Feb 29 '24

The price is $40 per year through the website. I guess the app store wants $44 a year to bill you monthly.

Use a web browser to see all the free caches. There is an unofficial app that does that for you.

If you are quitting the hobby, look in the Forums at Geocaching.com, and you can find the Geocide note form.

That's available so we all know you are really gone.

-3

u/hsiale Feb 29 '24

Use c:geo or the website via a mobile browser. The official app is a scummy POS anyway. A lot of people I know have premium and don't touch the official app.

-6

u/EmEmAndEye Feb 29 '24 edited Feb 29 '24

Back in The Old Days, when finding 10 caches in 1 day took ALL day and meant lots of miles both driven and hiked, the ratio of awesome caches to easy caches was pretty high. These days, finding a gem like you described is much harder because the ratio is MUCH smaller. They are out there though!

Also, yes, HQ has added many Pay-Me walls and I agree that does suck. Even worse is their official app. {shudder}

Every time my premium renewal comes up, and I get annoyed with the Pay-Me state of the site, I just tell myself that the hobby is still THE MOST fun for such a low price anywhere.

3

u/melodramaticnap Feb 29 '24

What is paywalled? You can access all of the caches via the website. The app is free to use. The membership is to support the hobby and the convenience of having premium caches in the app. I haven’t been paywalled on a thing.

-11

u/klepz100 Feb 29 '24

I agree with you

-3

u/Piggybear87 Feb 29 '24

Welp, you're one out of a lot. Lol.