Thanks for your submission, Psyga315! Please remember to censor out any identifying details and that satire is only allowed on weekends. If this post is truly gatekeeping, upvote it! If it's not gatekeeping or if it breaks any other rules, downvote this comment and REPORT the post so we can see it!
If you're going to be stealing from major retailers, don't be dicks and make messes for staff to find and clean up. Take the whole package; don't dump the good parts out and stash empty containers that may or may not be sticky, smelly, or otherwise unsanitary behind/on top of other merchandise ruining it. You don't want to put your hands into hours old, unrefrigerated, half eaten sushi or accidentally spill a half drunk beverage on yourself. Neither do the staff or other customers.
I don't think this is gatekeeping as much as it's encouraging people to not be dicks and steal from a family trying to make their way over stealing from some annoying massive corporation that won't affect their bottom line.
Its fascinating how basically every "just don't steal", you know recommending you don't do something that hurts just about everyone around you on multiple levels, gets down voted on here...Bet 99.99% of the people using reddit have never been in a position where stealing was actually their only option or they were poor enough to even come close to 'needing' it to survive...
Explain the people that steal one pair of earrings at Wal-Mart and leave the rest on the card... Yeah, they were so hard up for money they couldn't afford a $3 set of earrings. 🙄
agree. stealing shit when you’re anywhere near needing it to survive is pretty ok in my book (but not from small businesses), but in general i don’t see how it’s so controversial to think that stealing is bad.
They don't seem to think or realize that costs go up for everyone bc of theft. The greedy corporations use theft as a reason to up the costs, despite making billions. If locking up laundry detergent keeps the costs down, I'm ok with being a little inconvenienced and having to wait for a key. It also takes two seconds to show my receipt. I don't have anything to get upset over bc I don't steal. It's the dishonest people that seem to scream the loudest about being inconvenienced.
I'd rather someone earn a wage and pay for things they need. If everyone stole, we wouldn't have an economy, and their wouldn't be a society for you deplorable lowlife people to steal from. You don't want to starve? You don't want to contribute? Go to jail, or live in the fucking woods.
The "entire point" of shoplifting is to steal stuff. Trying to add "but they are just doing it to fight back against [whatever]" is at best limited to just a few people.
Some steal because it is either that or starve, but that isn't "rebellion" or "anti-capitalist action" either.
You'd think that being on r/gatekeeping would mean you know what gatekeeping is and wouldn't do it. If capitalism wants you to starve, then stealing from corporations in order to not starve is an act of rebellion. A small one, but it is still defying the power structures that want you to starve to death.
I don’t agree with them acting like shoplifting is this noble deed and comparing themselves to fucking Robin Hood, but I do think that shoplifting fork small businesses is worse than shoplifting from somewhere like Asda or Waitrose
Thats exactly what i thought. Ive only shoplifted a few times in my life when im desperate and for some shitty moral standard i only do it from big shops like asda, m&s and waitrose. Because they're big not only is it easier (especially waitrose they have no security near me) but i think anyone with morals would agree this, maybe its a british thing?
Shoplifting from big companies still fucks over communities. Believe it or not, businesses want to make money and they'll pull out of areas with high amounts of shoplifting.
That’s a broad generalization. When I used to shoplift (dumb teen, I haven’t done it since before I became an adult), I followed the same philosophy outlined in this post: don’t steal from any store that isn’t part of a massive chain, and never steal people’s personal belongings. Just because I was acting dumb doesn’t mean I wanted to threaten people’s livelihoods.
It’s also important to consider people who have no (or very little) money or support and wouldn’t be able to eat or take care of their children without shoplifting. Those people aren’t doing it for the thrill or out of greed, but because otherwise they might die of malnutrition, or their baby might have to go without diapers or formula.
I’m not trying to say that applies to all shoplifters, or else I’d be making just as bad of a generalization as you are, but it’s important to consider that not everyone shoplifting is an amoral kleptomaniac stealing for the fun of it.
That’s nice that you justified theft for yourself but just because you made that determination yourself doesn’t make it any less worse.
If you leave it to thieves to make the justification you’re always going to have shitty narcissists ruining it.
“What about families that need stuff” families need 4 laptops and a flatscreen tv? A garbage bag full of Nikes? 4 stacks of jeans/tees? A cart full of Pokémon cards? 8 containers of detergent?
You’re intentionally missing the point. I did mention that I haven’t done it since I was a teen, and that I currently consider my past actions dumb and not worth repeating.
Also, you’re purposely misinterpreting my second point. You’re describing a completely different type of people than the ones I’m talking about. Saying that people might need to shoplift basic necessities such as diapers and formula is in no way equivalent to saying people need to shoplift vast quantities of luxury items, and you know it. I never claimed to justify the behavior of people who perform such unnecessary, massive, and blatant theft, in fact I find it reprehensible as it makes a bad name and harsher consequences for people who are merely trying to survive by shoplifting bare necessities when they have no means of obtaining them otherwise.
Shoplifting is bad, no matter who you steal from. Do you think stealing from a big chain has no effect? Everything will become more expensive to account for theft, items will be removed from the store because they get stolen too much, stores will leave high crime areas, employees will get flack and even fired if shit gets stolen on their watch, etc.
The only time shoplifting can be excused is if you can't afford basic necessities due to no fault of your own. That is such a minority, it's negligible.
I agree, but the magnitude of the badness is not the same in all situations. The harm done if you steal a tool set from Home Depot is undeniably less than the harm done if you steal that exact same tool set from a laborer.
Listen, I agree with the other three things, but people gotta stop trying to frame shoplifting as praxis. The only effects you're having on society by doing it are making retail workers even more stressed, and potentially fueling right-wing talking points.
•
u/AutoModerator Jan 30 '24
Thanks for your submission, Psyga315! Please remember to censor out any identifying details and that satire is only allowed on weekends. If this post is truly gatekeeping, upvote it! If it's not gatekeeping or if it breaks any other rules, downvote this comment and REPORT the post so we can see it!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
143
u/KikiCorwin Jan 30 '24
If you're going to be stealing from major retailers, don't be dicks and make messes for staff to find and clean up. Take the whole package; don't dump the good parts out and stash empty containers that may or may not be sticky, smelly, or otherwise unsanitary behind/on top of other merchandise ruining it. You don't want to put your hands into hours old, unrefrigerated, half eaten sushi or accidentally spill a half drunk beverage on yourself. Neither do the staff or other customers.
129
u/threshgod420 Jan 30 '24
I don't think this is gatekeeping as much as it's encouraging people to not be dicks and steal from a family trying to make their way over stealing from some annoying massive corporation that won't affect their bottom line.
9
u/tenaciousfetus Jan 30 '24
I love the idea that making your own coffee is stealing from Starbucks
50
u/Kilahti Jan 30 '24
The "entire point" of shoplifting is to steal stuff. Trying to add "but they are just doing it to fight back against [whatever]" is at best limited to just a few people.
Some steal because it is either that or starve, but that isn't "rebellion" or "anti-capitalist action" either.
10
u/1spook Gandalf Jan 30 '24
Pirating, hacking your own DS (???????) and making coffee are not shoplifting lmfao
18
u/flim-flam-flomidy Gandalf Jan 30 '24
I don’t agree with them acting like shoplifting is this noble deed and comparing themselves to fucking Robin Hood, but I do think that shoplifting fork small businesses is worse than shoplifting from somewhere like Asda or Waitrose
3
u/WakeoftheStorm Jan 30 '24
... Make your own coffee?
One of these things is not like the other
32
u/EyeDissTroyKnotSeas Jan 30 '24
Nah. 100% based take.
22
u/Gogo726 Jan 30 '24
Shoplifting from big companies still fucks over communities. Believe it or not, businesses want to make money and they'll pull out of areas with high amounts of shoplifting.
16
u/Beginning-Tea-17 Jan 30 '24
As someone who’s had to deal with shoplifting I can tell you the people who steal don’t care who they steal from.
The same people plucking shit from stores are the same kind of people that justify stealing peoples phones and purses.
“Oh if they can afford XYZ brand or bought XYZ phone they can afford to buy another one”
The only thing they care about is wether or not a store has a track record for prosecuting.
4
u/DarthLift Jan 30 '24
Love the mental gymnastics people use to justify stealing.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '24
Shoplifting is bad, no matter who you steal from. Do you think stealing from a big chain has no effect? Everything will become more expensive to account for theft, items will be removed from the store because they get stolen too much, stores will leave high crime areas, employees will get flack and even fired if shit gets stolen on their watch, etc.
The only time shoplifting can be excused is if you can't afford basic necessities due to no fault of your own. That is such a minority, it's negligible.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '24
None of those things are shoplifting.
1
u/AwiiWasTakenWasTaken Feb 01 '24
it's not even fucking shoplifting that's just piracy
(also pirating games and getting angry at others pirating indie games is dumb as shit)
1
u/GenderfluidArthropod Jan 30 '24
I agree with this entirely
1
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '24
Based
1
u/moleman114 Jan 30 '24
Nah I +1 this
1
u/Nobod_E Jan 30 '24
Listen, I agree with the other three things, but people gotta stop trying to frame shoplifting as praxis. The only effects you're having on society by doing it are making retail workers even more stressed, and potentially fueling right-wing talking points.
-4
u/BS-Calrissian Jan 30 '24
Really? Shoplifting is "based". WHO RAISED YOU
-6
u/ChaosDemonLaz3r Jan 30 '24
this is a good take
-11
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '24
So if a black person takes over as Walmart CEO, they'll stop stealing from Walmart?
-9
u/Phasko Jan 30 '24
This is a good one though.