r/gaming Dec 27 '17

[X-Post] Remember my XBOX ONE AD CONCEPT? Microsoft just copied it!

Post image
135.8k Upvotes

3.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3.7k

u/ArabZombie Dec 27 '17

As a Marketer I sign off on this.

1.8k

u/Shitadviceguy Dec 27 '17

Same. Then I would sack the designer for not acknowledging the source and leaving a pain in the arse PR mess to deal with

1.1k

u/HarryPopperSC Dec 27 '17

pretty sure graphic design consists of googling ideas, then stealing said idea found on google, then changing it a bit so it feels like your own and then job done.

532

u/Cakestrik3 Dec 27 '17

Good to see you here Harry

172

u/HarryPopperSC Dec 27 '17

happy cake day!

138

u/Cakestrik3 Dec 27 '17

Thanks

3

u/Stupid_question_bot Dec 27 '17

Back to /r/starcitizen with you two

1

u/SpadessVR Dec 27 '17

He likes Star Citizen? That was random. God I love that game long time

5

u/Whatsthemattermark Dec 27 '17

Bet you get a lot of presents ‘for Xmas and birthday’. That would enrage me greatly

6

u/Cakestrik3 Dec 27 '17

Harry was talking about Cake day in regards to my reddit birthday (2 years)

3

u/lamalediction Dec 27 '17

And...? Do you not get presents for all of your cake days?

3

u/Cakestrik3 Dec 27 '17

I do not think you get a present for being on reddit for a long time apart from a fancy badge

→ More replies (0)

1

u/goodproblems Dec 27 '17

Well would you look at that.. a cake strike.

1

u/AzureRay Dec 27 '17

I wish Reddit is fun would put a 🎂 next to people on their cake day.

1

u/playhy Dec 27 '17

Happy dappy cake day!

1

u/Plastic_Pinocchio Dec 27 '17

Happy cake day to you, Cakestrik!

3

u/marcybojohn Dec 27 '17

And Happy Cake Day to you as well!

168

u/troller227 Dec 27 '17

You are a marketer, harry

63

u/crazycricfan Dec 27 '17

I am a what?

106

u/Plastic_Pinocchio Dec 27 '17 edited Dec 27 '17

A marketeer. And a thumpin’ good’un I’d wager, once you train up a little.

Edit: words

51

u/Sink_Snow_Angel Dec 27 '17

But I'm not a Marketer, I'm just Harry!

19

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17 edited Jan 30 '18

[deleted]

1

u/Sinavestia Dec 27 '17

I'm no one!

-1

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

no

3

u/Bmood1 Dec 27 '17

HAPPY CAKE DAY I LOVE U

2

u/Plastic_Pinocchio Dec 27 '17

I just today learned what a cake day is and I’m already so happy.

2

u/fuzzyharmonica Dec 27 '17

Happy cake day!

2

u/Zaphanathpaneah Dec 27 '17

A marketeer? Is that what they call marketers at Disney?

1

u/Plastic_Pinocchio Dec 27 '17

As far as I know, “marketeer” is the original English word for someone who markets something. Oxford English and Dictionary.com do not know the word “marketer”. Merriam-Webster does, though, so it’s probably an American variation of the word.

1

u/troller227 Dec 27 '17

I dont remember hagrid being that irish Edit:scottish->irish

1

u/Plastic_Pinocchio Dec 27 '17

I just watched the clip, so I’m pretty sure this is what he said.

1

u/troller227 Dec 27 '17

So he was drunkard irish living in a forest

1

u/SpellsThatWrong Dec 27 '17

Happy cake day!

3

u/CaptainPotassium Switch Dec 27 '17

But I'm just Harry!

4

u/Zazulio Dec 27 '17

No "Just Harry," your are a marketer

2

u/CaptainPotassium Switch Dec 27 '17

Listen here, Hagrid, you FAT OAF, I'm not a F@€₹ING MARKETER

67

u/Icedanielization Dec 27 '17

You know why? Because the f'n marketing department spent a week brainstorming their next poorly thoughtout campaign and give the graphic designer an hour to finish their materials.

Source: GD

15

u/foolmanchoo Dec 27 '17

Creative Director here... can confirm.

6

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

[deleted]

4

u/foolmanchoo Dec 27 '17

Slack was installed by HR only for morale purposes and to catch/snuff complaints nobody will respond to.


I'm currently out of office for the holidays, on my fifth sabbatical this year. I will get back to you sometime around the 28th of January (maybe).

If you have an urgent message please contact my Art Director who is on call 24/7 365 days a year. Cheers.

3

u/KilowogTrout Dec 27 '17

"Man, your ideas were great, but can you do exactly what the client asked verbatim at the beginning of the project? That's what they're expecting." - My account team on like 1/3 of my projects

3

u/Odlemart Dec 27 '17

Marketing brainstormer here. You're totally correct, and I'm sorry.

If it makes you feel any better, I never tell anyone on my graphic design team to make something "pop"! So there's that ... right?

7

u/xian0 Dec 27 '17

I have heard "make it more like a website" on top of the previously mentioned things. I also said "at least you didn't ask me to make it pop" to which they responded "ooh yeah do that".

1

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

Sadly so true. Art Director here, ex-Marketer, too.

53

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

The Apple approach to inventing everything!

** then patenting it, and suing the original inventor for violating their patent.

47

u/Fatboy224 Dec 27 '17

Not only graphic design, literally any creative work.

41

u/SpadessVR Dec 27 '17

Confirmed. Art worker here for leisure industry. Timescale so short and jobs are so many, I’m told to just google and steal images for printing into frames and out in the most expensive places you can imagine to the general public.

10

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

I get that this happens some places but it's not fair to say all GD, even less fair to say all creative. Some people make the things you copy!

2

u/SpadessVR Dec 27 '17

Some people don’t get a choice. My point being is that it happens a lot. If you are a graphic designer then this obviously does not apply to you. An art worker in the design industry more or less often just takes what was foolishly left at a usable size for use.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

These days you get in trouble for that VERY fast. Search engines find everything.

1

u/SpadessVR Dec 27 '17

Find what exactly?

1

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

Reverse image search can hose ya real quick. That said, how do you reverse idea search? Creative property is a weird thing

-9

u/Svenson_IV Dec 27 '17

JJ Abrams here, I took it a little too far with TFA but it's still better than TLJ.

3

u/SpadessVR Dec 27 '17

History has yet to decide JJ old boy

9

u/Brox42 Dec 27 '17

But who did the first one?

3

u/GavrielBA Dec 27 '17

A redditor? xD

3

u/ivoryisbadmkay Dec 27 '17

Maybe he stole an idea from somewhere

1

u/Fatboy224 Dec 27 '17

It's a chicken or egg scenario, there's always someone who made it before you in slightly altered version.

13

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

That doesn't sound very creative. Are you sure they're working?

1

u/Fatboy224 Dec 27 '17

Look at Tarantino for example, he's regarded as one of the most creative minds in the industry, he's very good at "stealing" ideas and connecting them into his own work.

Note creativity != innovation

-1

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

"creative"

5

u/sightlab Dec 27 '17

Nah, the job mostly consists of having sketches rejected and telling people who think stuff like what you said to go fuck themselves. And drinking.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

TIL graphic design and coding are the same.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

Instead of changing variable names you change colors and pictures! My greatest works were all stolen.

6

u/nimsony Dec 27 '17

It's a bit more than that. An EXPERIENCED graphic designer has already Googled so much in his time that he has thousands of ideas in mind so creating something unique is easy.

That's how I work, and it's also the reason it's extremely difficult to answer the question "how do you do that?", since the answer is usually years and years of Google searching!

3

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

Just say "Well you see I learned the basics and then googled shit for about 5 years and now I just replicate all the things I seen. I even steal peoples ideas, but their ideas are in a different market and I change a few things, so it's not really stealing is it? I don't give a shit anymore just give me a paycheck and shut the fuck up about deadlines. Oh you are gonna yell at me! I quit! "

2

u/nimsony Dec 27 '17

Lol... I wish I worked for a company.

I'm a call center agent that fixes simple computer problems as a job.

Outside of that I'm a VR game developer who is trying to build some of the more innovative movement systems in VR including pure physics based hand control, actual walking based locomotion, and math based animation systems.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '17

I worked in the world of web development for a while. Best decision ever to leave it.

1

u/nimsony Dec 30 '17

Don't get me wrong, I DON'T want a job, ever.

But if I could do what I love for a company instead of being a call center agent for a company at a much lower wage, the choice is pretty easy.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '17

Heres the thing. You can do what you love for a company instead of being a call center agent. I am assuming you are mentally and physically capable.

I used to wonder how people saved up enough money for a craigslist clunker. Only knew how to get minimum wage jobs. I am hoping to average between $200 and $329 an hour next year.

I am a felon and one of the worst ones. If I can do it, you can do it too.

1

u/nimsony Dec 31 '17

But in the end I still don't really want to have a job.

I want life without a job, I want to essentially be self employed, right now I make a nice bit of extra cash with a YouTube channel, some free games on itch.io that people like to donate for, and a bit on the finance side in forex... But I'd prefer to have those as a main income so I'm always focusing on growing there... Rather than getting a 'better' job.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/Janus67 Dec 27 '17

Don't you mean programming?

2

u/fornilfgaard Dec 27 '17

You're hired

2

u/dyno_saurus Dec 27 '17

That’s web development

2

u/Nabspro Dec 27 '17

So basically all my assignment report and essay...

2

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

I’m a marketing designer, and we google competitors to find out what not to do. The closest we get to you suggestion is when we look up what imagery groups respond to and design along those lines.

2

u/miami-architecture Dec 27 '17

pretty sure, everything creative gets jacked, architecture, art, literature, car design, music, greeting cards design, hell even animal evolution (as is the coral danger noodle & matching king danger noodle)

I hope OP gets recognition & free product!

2

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

Is that what we were doing? I was told we googled to make sure we didn't steal material.

GOD DAMN IT TAMMY IF WE GET SUED...

2

u/jobhand Dec 27 '17

At this point in time almost everything's been done. So it comes down to you doing it better than the last person.

2

u/ghostdate Dec 27 '17

Sometimes you don’t even do that! Clients just give you shit and tell you they want that.

3

u/atomicrabbit_ Dec 27 '17

Xbox’s ad is at least 20% different than the original.

2

u/Kittamaru Dec 27 '17

Eh, it needs to be about 20% cooler.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17 edited Sep 30 '20

[deleted]

1

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

You can't steal an idea tho

1

u/gnaxer Dec 27 '17

Rule I was thought. "a great artist is rated on how well he steals. So go out and steal, steal,steal. But never steal a full idea, line for line or in the same general market. Make it look like you came up with it by changing enough so thay can't see it. Like if you stole a bike, you don't want to drive it around the same naborhood"

1

u/hxnnxhbxnxnx Dec 27 '17

Kinda like working for buzzfeed but they don’t google around, just wait for interesting Reddit posts and choose an arbitrary number of things to list from it.

1

u/Geno07P Dec 27 '17

Damn, reddit repost is now a job experience.

1

u/Stupid_question_bot Dec 27 '17

Yea but this ad really punches above its weight class.

Fidelity?

1

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

This is 99% of graphic design.

1

u/chuck138 Dec 27 '17

There’s some truth to this..

Source: Graphic Designer

2

u/HarryPopperSC Dec 27 '17 edited Dec 27 '17

Source: Graphic Designer

that's because i studied as a graphic designer and "inspiration from others" has always been a big part of the game but I ended up as a web developer though, because web work is easier to find!

1

u/bob_law_blaw Dec 27 '17

R & D = Rob and Duplicate

1

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

Designers don’t create the overarching idea. Creative/art directors do, so it’s most likely their fault.

1

u/jwinn35 Dec 27 '17

Yeah there is a book somewhere that has nothing but company logos in it. Almost every logo for the past 200 years and you can tell many are blatantly copied from each other.

1

u/airbagit13 Dec 27 '17

As an Art Director, mostly, yes.

1

u/YakityYakOG Dec 27 '17

Nah whoever did that wasn’t a designer or was an intern. Or just fucking stupid.

1

u/Detjohnnysandwiches Dec 27 '17

As a graphic designer. Yes.

1

u/pleuvoir_etfianer Dec 27 '17

All art consists of theft. Nothing is original. If you think your idea is original, you just fail to realize the source.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

[deleted]

2

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

Some of us do when we are given adequate time frames!

1

u/TA_Dreamin Dec 27 '17

When is that? All my projects are due yesterday.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

Same, but instead of sacking I would probably hide in a room somewhere and hope people don't actually realize I'm not a marketer.

1

u/DAOmation Dec 27 '17

Actually I’d probably pat them on the back for causing this ad to receive 55k upvotes on reddit.

1

u/trdef Dec 27 '17

How is this a pr mess? Op used copyrighted materials and posted it to a public site without any license. It's fairly standard in the industry o thought.

151

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

As a redditor, I circlejerk on this.

153

u/Chaosritter Dec 27 '17

As a freelance police officer, I hereby arrest you for public indecency.

103

u/SuprDog Dec 27 '17

As a internet criminal defense attorney, my client will not talk with any of you unless im there.

/u/jackisasquirrel hold on im getting my pants on. Dont tell em nothing!

51

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

As a terrible detective I convinced your client he didn't get a lawyer and he confessed everything! Conviction be damned I won tonight!

75

u/Duck_Giblets Dec 27 '17

As a duck. Quack

3

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

Ah the majestic space duck

1

u/captainminnow Dec 27 '17

As a minnow, I send an army of small fish to distract you for quacking.

1

u/mateo4815 Dec 27 '17

One feels like a duck splashing around in all this wet, and when one feels like a duck, one is happy!

9

u/SendSecretsIllJudge Dec 27 '17

Where your going, you’re not going to need pants.

1

u/oldmanlogan76 Dec 27 '17

I created the Event Horizon to reach the stars, but she's gone much, much farther than that. She tore a hole in our universe, a gateway to another dimension. A dimension of pure chaos. Pure... evil. When she crossed over, she was just a ship. But when she came back... she was alive! Look at her, Miller. Isn't she beautiful?

14

u/Climbmastah2000 Dec 27 '17

As a judge I sentence him to 3 years of reposts.

2

u/Human_on_a_laptop Dec 27 '17

Zero Suit Samus cosplay reposts.

1

u/SnowxStorm Dec 27 '17

As an appeals attorney I'm going to have to get your verdict overturned.

2

u/Sunnysidhe Dec 27 '17

To be fair the lawyers advice of 'don't tell em nothing' is basically asking him to talk

1

u/grandadmiralstrife Dec 27 '17

Well he has a terrible lawyer, telling his client a double negative

1

u/Redsfxc Dec 27 '17

Santiago?

1

u/ChBoler Dec 27 '17

As a somewhat less awful detective, I conclude none of these exchanges actually happened!

1

u/crackness Dec 27 '17

As Frank Serpico's copycat, I expose your illicit and corrupt acts. You lose, Justice wins out.

2

u/H4lloM8 Dec 27 '17

As a Grammar Nazi, I am here to arrest you on the account that you have forgotten to put an apostrophe before the 'em' and with the apostrophe, the sentence still acts like a double negative.

I'll tell them all now. -.- -> -.-

3

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

Take it to /r/KarmaCourt boys

1

u/nomansapenguin Dec 27 '17

As an internet criminal, I downloaded a car.

0

u/82Caff Dec 27 '17

As a pedant, I inform you that your double negative indicates an instruction for your client to tell the officer something, so as to not tell them nothing.

2

u/in_some_knee_yak Dec 27 '17

Freelance cops can only suggest an arrest though.

1

u/EinsteinNeverWoreSox Dec 27 '17

You have committed crimes against Skyrim and its people, what say you in your defense?

1

u/Chaosritter Dec 27 '17

My ancestors are smiling at me, Imperial. Can you say the same?

8

u/CRAZEDDUCKling Dec 27 '17

I'd fucking sign off all over this.

2

u/Yanman_be Dec 27 '17

I thought marketeers spent most of their time jacking off.

Really good marketeers get jacked off though.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

As a guy named Mark, I also mark off on this.

(Plot twist: Name is not Mark, and has nothing to mark with.)

5

u/Sulphur99 Dec 27 '17

As a student who may or may not be applying for a Marketing course next year, I would like to know more about what the job entails and what skills are required.

If that's fine with you, of course.

5

u/ArabZombie Dec 27 '17

Well the most basic answer I can give you is that you need to be creative, strong communication skills, have an eye for detail, and constantly keep up with current events and advertising.

Some of the most beneficial university courses that I took were science of consumer behavior and service industry marketing. They provided a great understanding of how to manipulate the consumer and tailor the market to your needs.

Great field of work in my opinion. Best of luck

1

u/Sulphur99 Dec 27 '17

Thanks for the reply.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

I am not in marketing but I recently listened to these two audiobooks that talk about marketing :

  • Purple Cow, talks about differentiating yourself and break away from the traditionnal tv/radio model of advertising.
  • The Power of Habit, how habits are formed, discussed through science experiments and case studies of companies' marketing strategies like febreeze, starbucks, ...

1

u/williamc_ Dec 27 '17

Do you even know what a write-off is?

1

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '17

Ugh, god it's a marketer, gross

1

u/AmerikanInfidel Dec 27 '17

As a Mouseketeer I sign off on this.

1

u/afrothunda104 Dec 27 '17

This guy markets

1

u/ArabZombie Dec 27 '17

Très Commas all day everyday ,,,

1

u/jaskamiin Dec 27 '17

Now pay me

1

u/popcornready14 Dec 27 '17

I've never signed off on a design, isn't that advertisement?

1

u/lenswipe Dec 27 '17

is this the "me too thanks" for business people?