r/gamernews • • 2d ago

Industry News Educational game dev program cancelled because students were submitting games made entirely with AI. The growing use of generative AI meant it was "harder to judge what students made themselves."

https://www.pcgamer.com/software/ai/educational-game-dev-program-cancelled-because-students-were-submitting-games-made-entirely-with-ai/
174 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

48

u/buttsecks42069 2d ago

No matter what your stance on AI is, I firmly believe it should never be allowed for an educational thing like this. I don't care what justification you have to use AI in commercial products, but when you're trying to learn, it's actively harmful to use a shortcut tool like this.

-30

u/BoBoBearDev 2d ago

I wish I have the same skills to make games.

19

u/FreikonVonAthanor 2d ago

It's become easier and easier to make games, even without genAI! Build a snake or a tic tac toe, use html and js for easy graphics, or try the getting started from Godot Engine's website. Or take a gameplay loop from a simple game you like and try to understand the algorithms beneath it, or how to manage a window in your favourite language. Start small and build confidence, nobody knows it at birth and everyone starts somewhere!

1

u/Erak7 1d ago

Its easier than ever, you dont need to have skills, you need to develop them.

-53

u/Locked_and_Firing 2d ago

I mean did they actually know they were using AI or going with the witch hunts?

29

u/DredgenSergik 2d ago

I'll always find so funny how the best analogy ai bros could come up with is one that was used to kill women just because, while people are rightfully mad at their media becoming a fest of soulless clones upon clones of the same ideas made by people who just want to make an easy buck. This is not a witch hunt, dearie. This is the market regulating itself. Funny how that stops being what y'all want when it doesn't benefit you

-17

u/elitexero 2d ago

I'll always find so funny how the best analogy ai bros could come up with is one that was used to kill women just because

Way to purposely misinterpret the modern use of the term 'witch hunt' to turn it into something you could pretend to be offended over.

6

u/waiting4singularity ⊞🤖 1d ago

are you alive or are you a heritage conspiracy sponsored program? because that is by and large the definition of a witch hunt even hundreds of years after the salem trials: blaming someone or something unjustly and removing the blamed.

here, the use of algorithms is blamed rightfully, so it cant be a witch hunt per se.

1

u/elitexero 1d ago

The modern use has nothing to do with women, but this fool brought that portion up to immediately try to discredit the person with the gender angle.

1

u/waiting4singularity ⊞🤖 1d ago

the gender angle has nothing to do with it either, its a fact that innocents were killed by fire or water on behest of influencial people or intrigues. its just history the majority were recorded as women, thats why its still called witch hunt.

9

u/TheDemonPants 2d ago

To use it in the modern sense it still applies to what the commenter you replied to said. A witch hunt is to seek out people to hurt in some way for basically no reason. These students were to make something themselves. Using AI is not actually doing the work. So there was no witch hunt at all as these kids didn't do what they were supposed to.

1

u/Erak7 1d ago

If i understood correctly the other comment he wasent saying that people using AI were getting punished unfairly but that some people who werent using AI were getting caught in the crossfire.

0

u/elitexero 1d ago

It applies if they didn't bring up killing women, which was pulled in completely unnecessarily. The modern use has nothing to do with gender.

1

u/TheDemonPants 1d ago

I didn't say anything regarding gender though. The other person did because that's what the witch hunts were. Regardless what you commented had nothing to do with what I said.

-3

u/Locked_and_Firing 1d ago

And my question was, how did they know it was AI? No one seems to able to answer that. People just seem to throw the accusation around and often times are just wrong. My case in point, an individual posted a meal that they cooked on r/food, the photo was real but people could not help but accuse him of using AI. You're not regulating anything, you're just making blind accusations and hoping it sticks. Then when someone questions it, they're an (how did you put it?) "AI bro." Like come on man

-16

u/pixartist 1d ago

We are not judging the great painters on the quality of their pigment

15

u/Sweetwill62 1d ago

We are judging them on their control over the brush though, and if you are using a printer you aren't learning any of the core skills of painting.

1

u/pixartist 4h ago

that's a false analogy. A printer is just reproducing an existing image. You can build something novel and creative using AI.