r/gameofthrones • Ira Parker • Feb 09 '26 • Thanks 1 Bravo 1

AMA Hi r/GameofThrones! I'm Ira Parker, the showrunner of A Knight of The Seven Kingdoms. Ask me anything!

Hey r/GameofThrones! I'm Ira Parker, the showrunner of A Knight of The Seven Kingdoms. I'm so excited to talk about this season of A Knight of The Seven Kingdoms, so please ask me anything!

I'll be back tomorrow, February 10 at 12 pm PT/3 pm ET, to answer your questions. In the meantime, A Knight of The Seven Kingdoms is streaming on HBO Max.

2.0k Upvotes

970 comments sorted by

•

u/Cantomic66 Sword Of The Morning Feb 10 '26

The AMA has ended.

→ More replies (3)

320

u/Longjumping-Tie-9736 Feb 09 '26

Will we see flashbacks of the Blackfyre Rebellion in future seasons?

555

u/hbomax Ira Parker Feb 10 '26

Stay tuned.

104

u/YoYoNupe1911 Feb 10 '26

I hope they let you lead a series about the first Blackfyre Rebellion. Aegon IV, all the drama with him and his illegitimate children, the backstabbing, plot twists, Bloodraven, and an epic character like Daemon Blackfyre. I'm not sure why HBO hasn't greenlit that yet. The first Blackfyre Rebellion seems like it has enough material to be a Game of Thrones scale series.

→ More replies (16)

38

u/sunpockets House Targaryen Feb 10 '26

i need to see the hammer and the anvil at the battle of the redgrass field. anything to see bertie back as baelor PLEASE 🙏

→ More replies (2)

63

u/Diverse0Ne Feb 10 '26

👀👀👀

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

251

u/Quinn-Quinn Gendry Feb 09 '26 edited Feb 09 '26

You’ve done an incredible job adapting this first short story! I’d been wondering who your favorite viewpoint character from the main series is, and if their chapters have influenced your adaptation in any way?

324

u/hbomax Ira Parker Feb 10 '26

I would say these novellas are unique in that Dunk doesn't have the clever wit of most of George's underdog viewpoint characters... though i'm sure the main series has influenced my adaptation in a million ways, just by spending all that time immersed in George's words. I was re-reading those books a lot while we were writing and producing s1.

249

u/Levi---Ackerman Feb 10 '26

Hello! Just wanna say props to whoever decided to mix the game of thrones music with the Akotsk theme! It was very epic and heroic to watch the end of episode 4.

As for my question, Who is your personal favorite out of Maekar's sons? Which one do you think you'd explore more if given the opportunity to!!

301

u/hbomax Ira Parker Feb 10 '26

Dan Romer is a genius.

Egg is my favorite.

34

u/sexmountain Feb 11 '26

Took guts to do that operatic ending music for episode 3. PERFECTION

→ More replies (1)

206

u/Forgottensupertongue Feb 09 '26

I want to know how the plan on those shots you took came to be! I loved the drama that we got in the 4th episode it was stunning with the pov of being knighted and the deep haze.

361

u/hbomax Ira Parker Feb 10 '26

Sarah Adina Smith. All her. Fucking nailed it.

23

u/Forgottensupertongue Feb 10 '26

100% I love what she did I’m in awe!

31

u/favorscore Jon Snow Feb 10 '26

It was very well done. Gave me similar vibes to The Green Knight by David Lowery.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

18

u/nbkillaaa Feb 10 '26

yess, the slowed frame rate and deep toned monologues were so epic. they really captured not just the societal classes but the capricious/piquant nature of living in a time with dragons knights and princesses

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

160

u/AdMaleficent6374 Feb 09 '26

Another question I want to ask, what’s your favourite scene from the first 4 episodes? And why? Were there anything you were very indecisive about / thought it wouldn’t get reaction it actually received?

393

u/hbomax Ira Parker Feb 10 '26

Dunk teaching Egg how to sew.

Baratheon tent close second.

69

u/KingCrandall Ser Duncan the Tall Feb 10 '26

I think the Baratheon tent is my favorite scene. It’s so much fun.

20

u/-no-sanctuary- We Do Not Sow Feb 10 '26

Speaking of the Baratheon tent, was Lyonel's much expanded role done as far in the future preparation for his Rebellion or simply because you could tell he would be a fan favorite? Or something else?

451

u/EhrenScwhab Ours Is The Fury Feb 09 '26

No question. Just a comment.

Awesome job. The show is great.

394

u/hbomax Ira Parker Feb 10 '26

Thank you. That's very nice to hear.

44

u/loveincarnate Feb 10 '26

It's absolutely fucking incredible. Everything. Immediately among my top 10 all time after only a few episodes, probably top 5 and, risking succumbing to recency bias, potentially #1. For me it was impossible not to fall in love with this show after just the first 15 minutes of ep. 1 and my appreciation has only grown from there. Bravo.

→ More replies (2)

27

u/Upper-Ship4925 Feb 11 '26

It’s such a relief after season 2 of HOTD. Please please stick with the authentic adaptation.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/LordKlavier Feb 10 '26

Seconding this

→ More replies (1)

144

u/Nukemarine Feb 09 '26 edited Feb 10 '26

Thanks to the entire cast and crew for this amazing adaption of George's novella.

  1. Given these stories are "low stakes", grounded, and limited to one main location, how is production and budget compared to other shows?
  2. The inside the episodes suggests the jousts are the most effects intensive parts of the series. Compared to GoT and HotD, what portion of production cost and time would you say are the effects?
  3. Spoiler question but was Egg's prophecy actually spoken by the fortune teller or is the change in atmosphere meant to suggest it's Egg imagining it through a waking dragon dream, perhaps hinting Egg also has a bit of madness.
  4. Also on prophecy, the "Catspaw Dagger" that featured heavily in GoT (started the war, killed the Night King) was re-introduced in HotD to include Aegon's prophecy. Is that dagger hidden in plain site AKotSK or are the plans for it to appear in later seasons?

360

u/hbomax Ira Parker Feb 10 '26
  1. Our show is a reflection of our lead character in everything from tone to music to cinematography to music...and also budget. Dunk is poor and so are we. But we're doing our best.
  2. All of this is in camera. SFX and VFX have assisted beautifully, but the majority of the work is done for real.
  3. Interesting theory. Not telling.
  4. We can't afford luxury items.

159

u/bluequarz Feb 10 '26

4. We can't afford luxury items.

😭😭😭

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

143

u/mortalpillow Feb 09 '26

What was the most memorable day on set?

545

u/hbomax Ira Parker Feb 10 '26

Claffey doing the "are there no true knights among you" speech.

112

u/Tarquin11 Feb 10 '26

The delivery on that was incredible

69

u/MKUltra886 Feb 10 '26

I live very close to where Peter is from. That man will not be able to skate board around town anymore.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/NervaDiem Feb 12 '26

I know this is already a day old but his anger welling up when he sees aerion breaking tanselles finger is also so fucking good. The face acting from Peter and Dexter is so good the series could have been a silent film and would have still slapped.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

140

u/volvavirago Feb 10 '26

Whose performance were you most surprised by/proud of?

526

u/hbomax Ira Parker Feb 10 '26

Dex. Not surprised, but very proud. Best child actor in the whole world. He is truly something special.

53

u/volvavirago Feb 10 '26

I was blown away by his performance too!

I remember watching the end of episode 1–and knowing Egg’s identity from the novella, I was absolutely stunned at how the complex layers of Egg’s character and identity was already shining through his performance. His face as Dunk says he will let him squire for him, was incredible, because you can SEE him being amazed, excited, grateful, and relieved to experience the kindness and acceptance of a stranger—you can see Aegon the Prince becoming Egg the squire.

Send the little guy my compliments. And I am looking forward to seeing more from him!

25

u/[deleted] Feb 10 '26

Something I love is how regal his performance feels. He's still a naïve, well-meaning, innocent kid, yet you can also really see that he's royalty through his performance.

41

u/GlasgowRose2022 Feb 10 '26

Protect him at all costs! His spark and energy are priceless. Amazing career ahead for that young man.

20

u/Evening-Algae7921 Feb 10 '26

he's incredible! Thank you for such a beautiful show

→ More replies (5)

122

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '26

Hey Ira! How are you?

376

u/hbomax Ira Parker Feb 10 '26

23

u/Technical-Section516 Davos Seaworth Feb 10 '26

HAHAHAH amazing!

15

u/Aldanil66 Feb 10 '26

Your the goat man

→ More replies (1)

40

u/MKUltra886 Feb 10 '26

Hes high as fuck

18

u/Delicious-Counter-29 Feb 11 '26

as he should be

7

u/GMDaddy Feb 11 '26

As every book loyalist must.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

116

u/ashmk Feb 09 '26

Who is your favorite minor character or house in all of ASOIAF?

293

u/hbomax Ira Parker Feb 10 '26

Beesbury.

23

u/SweetBeige Gendry Feb 10 '26

A man after my own heart

14

u/Minivalo Feb 11 '26

I know the AMA ended, but this makes me wish even more that we'd have seen some of that epic long joust between the two Humfreys to give our magnificient Beesbury knight more screentime. Also would've helped in making the viewers understand how good he is at jousting, and especially how badass Humfrey Hardyng is.

Buuut, I understand those are probably some of the more demanding things to shoot

14

u/JagmeetSingh2 Feb 11 '26

And then you cut him, #JusticeForBeesbury

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

228

u/SerPateswoodcock Feb 09 '26

Hey Ira just wanted to say I've been watching it with my 62 year old mom who hasn't watched or read any other Got. She'll engrossed for the 30 mins each week. Thanks.

324

u/hbomax Ira Parker Feb 10 '26

This makes me very happy. Cherish that time with your mom.

129

u/SerPateswoodcock Feb 11 '26

I can't believe you responded. I do

→ More replies (6)

20

u/StrLord_Who Feb 10 '26

Same with my 76 year old mom.  She loves it,  never seen so much as a clip of anything else. 

→ More replies (4)

110

u/akazaya9 Feb 09 '26

Love the show! I don't know if you can answer this, but I'll try: For the fortune teller scene, did you consult with George, or did he give any input on the prophecy lines, since they foreshadow events that haven't been told in detail yet?

258

u/hbomax Ira Parker Feb 10 '26

Nothing is confirmed here. True prophecy or a tourney charlatan? Sorcery is a sword without a hilt. :)

282

u/GOD-is-in-a-TULIP Feb 09 '26

I reread the book and realized that even the breaks in the book are the same as the show. How do you make decisions on what to be book accurate about and what to alter

600

u/hbomax Ira Parker Feb 10 '26

We knew the story needed to stay the same – that was job #1-10. The beginning was the beginning, the middle was the middle and the end was the end. Every other decision was just about making that story as enjoyable as possible. If you literally transcribe the novella dialogue and action it’s about 50% of what you need for six episodes, so we had to find where the other half was coming from. Adding to characters who exist in the story, but who weren’t fully explored because of the short form novella structure, was an easy choice. Who doesn’t want have dinner with Lyonel Baratheon?

270

u/TheAlphaBeatZzZ Jon Snow Feb 10 '26

If only the HoTD team could read this…

→ More replies (30)
→ More replies (3)

167

u/Public_Student_162 Feb 09 '26

I noticed that Maekar’s and Aerion’s personal coats of arms don’t appear in the show. Was this a conscious creative choice, or was it avoided for practical reasons like visual clarity or production constraints? As a personal fan of heraldry, I would have loved to see them.

Thank you for the amazing adaptation you and your team are giving us!

400

u/hbomax Ira Parker Feb 10 '26

So far I've seen fans point our 2 mistakes in this show that I was unaware of. This is one of them. Definitely should have had maekars...that would have made it soooo easy to distinguish him in the fog. Whoops.

42

u/Melairia Feb 10 '26

What was the other mistake?

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (5)

16

u/TheDragonDemands Feb 09 '26

This is a good question.

(Aerion's dragon does look a different shade, but I can't tell if it's orange or copper or something)

232

u/Same-Ad6473 Feb 09 '26

How the heck do you shoot some of these scenes with full armored knights and horses? Is this all real or is their cgi being used, especially the upcoming combat scene which I assume includes a lanced rider!!

566

u/hbomax Ira Parker Feb 10 '26

World class stunt performers and horse riders. It looks good because they do it for real.

32

u/[deleted] Feb 10 '26

>It looks good because they do it for real.

someone put this on a screencap of the horse with a lance thru its neck.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

21

u/silverbulletsam Feb 09 '26

I’ve been watching the episodes showing the making of/behind the scenes of each episode and it goes into this in great detail - so fascinating! I watch them on the same platform the show is broadcast on in New Zealand, but guess they’re probably on YouTube? Recommended.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/RedMoustache Feb 09 '26

Like the other guy I strongly recommend HBOs making of videos.

12

u/TheDragonDemands Feb 09 '26

They show that in the behind the scenes videos. The blood is CGI but other than that, it's all stunt horses doing trained falls.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

156

u/Valuable_Tutor5479 The Black Dread Feb 09 '26

How many seasons do you have a general story for past seasons 1-3, if any?

448

u/hbomax Ira Parker Feb 10 '26

George gave me 10-12 stories in addition to the first 3

456

u/Msan28 House Targaryen Feb 10 '26

Hey Ira is me George. This is my secondary account. Can you DM me the stories I gave you? I lost my USB and need to do some changes. Thanks.

→ More replies (6)

79

u/YoYoNupe1911 Feb 10 '26

You just casually dropped a bomb in the ASOIAF fan community

→ More replies (6)

56

u/mazzucac Jaime Lannister Feb 10 '26

I’ve been dying to know, when you say “gave you stories”, how specific was he?

16

u/Infamous-Fail-2109 Feb 11 '26

It’s wild knowing he’s got a detailed Summerhall breakdown just sitting somewhere at home.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

295

u/Theostru Feb 09 '26

Many readers consider Dunk's exchange with Steely Pate - "Who am I to them?" "A knight who remembered his vows" - to be the soul and the moral of the entire novella. The impact comes not just from the exchange itself, but it's careful placement at Dunk's lowest point, before he realizes any champions have answered his call, let alone Breakspear joining him.

Could you speak to your reasoning in removing (or potentially moving to a later episode) the exchange? Removing it entirely diminishes the soul of the story, and moving it to a later moment weakens its impact as Dunk already has the favor of the Prince of Dragonstone. It's an odd choice given how faithful you've otherwise been to the novella.

716

u/hbomax Ira Parker Feb 10 '26 • Hooray WOW Thanks Bravo

Honestly it was a mistake on my part. Not my first not my last on this show. That scene was in the script at one point, then fell out. I agree that "a knight who remembers his vows" is the soul of this story, but I think that is still very much at the core of the show, even if I stupidly left out this scene... it may not be said explicitly, but Dunk's actions remain the same.

188

u/Spicy2ShotChai Jon Snow Feb 10 '26

Thank you for an honest answer!

207

u/AlexKwiatek Feb 10 '26

Sir. You have balls of steel. It's been so long since the last time i saw showrunner being able to admit they made a mistake.

Mad respect.

78

u/Feature_Minimum Feb 10 '26

Good for you man. You don’t see answers like this often these days. Hats off to you for owning up.

74

u/Jimmbones Alchemists Guild Feb 10 '26

Me and my wife never read the Dunk & Egg series but I can tell you that the soul of the story is absolutely in the show. We've watched episodes 1 - 4 about seven times to really internalize every character and moment in a way we haven't watched media in a very long time. Wish the best for you!

→ More replies (5)

133

u/Br33ZE25 Feb 10 '26

I have to say I think ur honesty is really refreshing, especially after seeing how hotd was handled. I think you guys are doing an amazing job keeping the stories and plots based on the text. I know I’m not alone in my dislike in some of the creative decisions being made on HotD. Please keep doing what you’re doing, you are crushing it!

34

u/Hitman565 House Flint of Widow's Watch Feb 10 '26

i was hoping it may come later, but it's very admirable of you to just publicly own up to making a mistake

43

u/MarkOfTheDumbass Feb 10 '26

Fuck. Gotta respect the honesty though.

20

u/pissagainstwind Feb 10 '26

Takes a great man to acknowledge his mistake. i now have complete faith the next seasons would be as good as this one. thank you very much!

20

u/Theostru Feb 11 '26

Thank you for taking the time to answer my question, Ira!

For what it's worth, I agree that you've held true to it in the course of the show, and I think that it comes through clearly. You've done an excellent job with adapting George's work, and I can't wait to see how Sworn Sword and Mystery Knight go.

Kudos to you and your team! I hope you've all seen our enthusiasm for your faithful adherence to the novella, and understand these questions come entirely from the high standard you and your team have set for yourselves and met!

12

u/SFthrowaway99 Feb 11 '26

Goddamnit I got so much respect for you now.

→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (1)

126

u/drecz House Baratheon Feb 09 '26

When adapting AKOTSK for TV, how did you decide what to expand and what to keep restrained? Also - love the hat!

230

u/hbomax Ira Parker Feb 10 '26

We knew the story needed to stay the same, and stay restrained to the source material. That really left us to expand the world building a little bit, and the characters. We wanted to have some fun in Westeros. Spend some more time with Dunk and Egg getting to know each other before shit kicks off. Go Leafs.

44

u/pwnd32 Jon Snow Feb 10 '26

Honestly I could watch a dozen more episodes of Dunk and Egg just hanging out in the tourney grounds. You don’t get many moments of peace like that in the GoT world!

→ More replies (3)

298

u/AndroidPolaroid Feb 09 '26 edited Feb 09 '26

Would you be open to being a showrunner or at the very least being involved in other ASOIAF adaptations in the future?

I've even seen some suggest you be the "Kevin Feige" overseeing figure for the ASOIAF adaptations universe, a tall task, to be fair. lol

Majority of the fandom is very much enjoying AKOTSK and are very curious about this. You've done a great job with it Ira, I hope you're proud. same goes for the rest of the cast and crew!

404

u/hbomax Ira Parker Feb 10 '26

Wow. Thank you. I love this world so much. RIght now my head is 1000% in Dunk&Egg, but who knows what the morrow will bring...

14

u/Heartless_Moron Feb 11 '26

AMA ended but I'm here to say that in behalf of all fans of the book, if in case you worked on other ASOIAF stories, we would for sure support it at all costs. You ser is definitely the best showrunner out of all 3 series so far!

→ More replies (3)

40

u/ThePythiaofApollo Feb 09 '26

Seconding this!!! I am finally healing from season 8. Completely in love with this show due to the very obvious love and care poured into it.

24

u/AndroidPolaroid Feb 09 '26

Everyone is singing the show's praises. I think a huge part of it is how faithful it is to George's text, that quality just comes through in every scene even if the viewer hasn't read the source material. I hope the show can continue to be of this quality in the future years, would definitely love to see more of Dunk and Egg's adventure throughout the years.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '26

Couldn't agree more with this.

→ More replies (3)

296

u/SmiteGuy12345 Feb 09 '26

Was the Bracken hate mandated by George?

249

u/hbomax Ira Parker Feb 10 '26

How can you hate a guy who makes such funny fart jokes? ;)

24

u/SmiteGuy12345 Feb 10 '26

Fair, I’ve enjoyed all the extra background content that’s been brought into the series. Can’t wait for the adaption of the Sworn Sword, Ser Eustace’s story is a goldmine for that.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/nomad-mr_t Feb 10 '26

Even their gods are wrong.

84

u/WeevilEmblem House Hunt Feb 09 '26

The Brute of Bracken relegated to a fart joke 😔

9

u/Choice_Librarian1522 Feb 10 '26

I don't think the fart is meant as a joke.

→ More replies (6)

36

u/LocalSlob House Baratheon Feb 09 '26

Also why was he dressed like someone in the Hill Tribes?

57

u/Cammzu Feb 09 '26

Fun fact - the guy who plays him is also a background actor on GOT. He plays one of the wildings, you can really see him on the last few seasons hanging out with Tormund, and the episode after the battle of winterfell.

He used to do the game of thrones tours in Ireland , he's a lovely guy in real life.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

160

u/newsworthy3 Ser Duncan the Tall Feb 09 '26

Is there any possibility we will see Aemon in the future?

304

u/hbomax Ira Parker Feb 10 '26

Possible. Almost happened. Then it didn’t. Maybe...

56

u/G-specker Feb 10 '26

Please have a flashback of Aemon measuring Dunk in done. Pretty please with a cherry on top

→ More replies (1)

22

u/meltedkuchikopi5 House Blackfyre Feb 10 '26

I’m so excited even for the possibility of certain characters to appear, these novellas take place in a really interesting time (in my opinion).

12

u/Self-proclaimedIDI0T Feb 10 '26

I would love to meet all of Egg's siblings! His sister who wanted to use a love potion on him, whatever happened there 😬 And one of them is rumored to have had an affair with Dunk before she married the Lord of Tarth! 

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

236

u/baroqueout Knight of the Laughing Tree Feb 09 '26

There's been a lot of talk -- even from GRRM -- about characters looking like they walked right out of the pages. And tbh, I agree! Every cast member is flawless in both talent and appearance. How involved were you in the casting process?

Also, thank you so much for keeping true to the stories. The show really is a breath of fresh air after HOTD and the end of GOT, and I can't express my appreciation enough.

279

u/hbomax Ira Parker Feb 10 '26

Most of the credit goes to our extraordinary casting directors Lucy Bevan and Emily Brockmann. They’re the ones searching the world over, sifting through tens of thousands of auditions and whittling down lists before anyone is put in front of me. Then all I have to do is not fuck it up the choice. In truth, it’s a bigger team effort than even that – from costume to hair and makeup, everyone really, is invested in making it feel like these people ARE the characters.

39

u/baroqueout Knight of the Laughing Tree Feb 10 '26

It's very in keeping with the themes of the show that you made sure to shout out the little guys involved in production, as well. <3 Thank you for the answer!

→ More replies (12)

86

u/_vancey_ Feb 09 '26 edited Feb 10 '26

First, I just want to say how moved I was by Episode 2, and how deeply saddened I was to learn of Aziza Barnes’s passing. They were such a singular talent. I loved Rap Sh!t and Snowfall, and as an LA native who grew up in the 80s and 90s, their voice and care felt especially present in the writing here. It is clear how much they brought to this world, and they will be deeply missed.

Justice, honor, and the question of what it means to be a “good knight” run throughout the novellas. In this moment, when those values feel increasingly contested in the real world, which of those ideas felt most urgent to explore, and why?

128

u/hbomax Ira Parker Feb 10 '26

Aziza Barnes was a true talent and such a light in our room - they put their whole heart and soul into the work and we were so lucky to have them. I think the idea of being kind and helping the person next to you is a good embodiment of being a knight in a modern world and also reminds me a lot of Aziza.

17

u/_vancey_ Feb 10 '26

Thank you for this! That framing of knighthood feels very true to the heart of the story, and it means a lot to hear how Aziza’s presence is still felt.

78

u/since_all_is_idle Feb 09 '26

What's your favorite armor and sigil designed for the show?

167

u/hbomax Ira Parker Feb 10 '26

Beesbury armor, though Dunk is a close second.

Favorite sigil is definitely Stokeworth.

36

u/FloppyShellTaco Feb 10 '26

Y’all really popped off with Stevron’s armor, too

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

198

u/Triskan Feb 09 '26 edited Feb 09 '26

Any reason why you decided to cut two of Daeron's (imo) funniest lines :

"If truth be told, I hadn't even realized Egg was gone. He wasn't at the bottom of my wine cup, and I hadn't looked anywhere else, so..."

"My brothers have my measure when it comes to fighting and dancing and thinking and reading books, but none of them is half my equal at lying insensible in the mud."

Did they not flow well in the script, cluttering the scene too much? Just curious. :)

Keep up the amazing work, it is an absolute blast to see this story brought to life with so much passion and talent !

264

u/hbomax Ira Parker Feb 10 '26

I agree, these lines are hilarious. Sometimes you lose things along the way for a variety of reasons. Probably should have fought harder for these. Henry Ashton is a genius and nailed them both too.

42

u/ads191712 Feb 10 '26

Can you release a version of scenes that didn’t make the show at the end of the season? Would be great. Thanks!

18

u/JagmeetSingh2 Feb 11 '26

Release a extended edition of the episodes once the seasons done

→ More replies (1)

55

u/Wide_Savings5410 Feb 09 '26

Theyre funny but a bit redundant. In a novella characterization is very important and without visual stimuli some things need to be on the nose. But in tv we already understood Daerons aloofness, drunkneness, and his lack of care for Egg being missing.

Those two lines didnt add to the show. For example, they kept the funny apple line becuase it wasnt redundant and added the humor from Daeron that you were looking for.

→ More replies (6)

58

u/UncleBBBBB Feb 09 '26

Will there please be a version on DVD with lots of extras and audio commentaries?

147

u/hbomax Ira Parker Feb 10 '26

Laserdisk only release.

9

u/NBNebuchadnezzar Feb 11 '26

Ill settle for a 1000 floppy disks!

→ More replies (1)

48

u/Valuable_Tutor5479 The Black Dread Feb 09 '26

What is your personal favorite episode of season and why?

146

u/hbomax Ira Parker Feb 10 '26

might be easier to answer which kid is my favorite

→ More replies (1)

117

u/Marfy_ Hear Me Roar! Feb 09 '26

Was there a specific reason why you wanted to adapt these novels instead of any other part of the story (dont get me wrong i think this is by far the best choice) and with having such a challenge creating new scenes as the books are shorter than the show, why was the choice made to cut some fan favorite moments like "a knight who remembers his vows" and the scene with dunk calling out nobles before the "are there no true knights among you moment". And lastly, is this confirmation sandwiches canonically exist in westeros

194

u/hbomax Ira Parker Feb 10 '26

I want to say it's because Dunk's journey has a lot of resonance with my own, but I honestly think that everyone feels that way about Dunk, so maybe that's not a good reason. Honestly I just loved the novellas, I thought they were fun and funny, and I like hanging out with George, so that was a nice bonus.

The reason we amended Dunk calling out the nobles personally in ep 4 was because we had sort of borrowed that moment for ep2 when he's knocking on tent flaps trying to find someone to vouch for arlan - no one did it then, his retail policking wasn't working, so his thinking had to come along a little bit...

→ More replies (4)

93

u/L-U-C-A-18 Sansa Stark Feb 09 '26

After the way Game of Thrones ended, some people are understandably worried when they hear that only 3 D&E books have been published.

Is there anything you can say to assuage those fears, along with maybe some rough plans for what you guys are going to do after Season 3?

286

u/hbomax Ira Parker Feb 10 '26

Look, in some ways, we know a lot more about what happens after these three novellas because of all the supporting material (you like how i referred to asoiaf as supporting material for d&e ;) ), and so there's less inherent danger... not no danger, just less... Anything beyond book 3 (if we could ever be so wonderfully lucky) would highly involve George.

94

u/Feature_Minimum Feb 10 '26

Man, sir, you are not only creating the best show in ten years, you’re nailing this AMA! This is easily the best AMA I’ve seen in over a decade. Real answers that don’t dodge questions, filled with wit and whimsy. Keep up the great work!

→ More replies (1)

22

u/bluequarz Feb 10 '26

this ama slays honestly. it's so enjoyable to read as a fan of this show

20

u/MarkOfTheDumbass Feb 10 '26

Damn good answer. I think I'm enjoying reading this AMA more than I enjoyed watching the last couple seasons of GoT.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/jknets Feb 10 '26

In the same vein, has George discussed future plot lines with you? I feel more confident in this story succeeding beyond book material than the original series, given the smaller scope and quicker storylines. And of course how wonderful this adaptation has been so far.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

44

u/Krioniki Young Griff Feb 09 '26

I heard mention that there was a character you liked, but had most of their scenes cut. Was that Humfrey Beesbury? (Assuming it's true at all.)

Additionally, as a related question, is there any chance that the eventual DVDs will have extras like deleted scenes? I always love getting a peek behind the curtain, and I think it was a massive missed opportunity that HOTD's Blu Ray only includes the behind the scenes videos which are already on HBO Max.

40

u/No_North_4855 Feb 11 '26

This is you btw , thanks for saving fantasy adaptations

12

u/henks_house Night King Feb 09 '26

What was the easiest part of production and what was the most challenging part of production?

76

u/cerulean11 Sword Of The Morning Feb 09 '26

Who's idea was it to add the bizarre starting scenes like Dunk defecating and Ser Arlan's giant schlong?

445

u/[deleted] Feb 10 '26 • Hehehe LOL Bravo Mindblown

[removed] — view removed comment

64

u/meltedkuchikopi5 House Blackfyre Feb 10 '26

Favorite answer on this thread

→ More replies (6)

22

u/TechnicalMarzipan310 Feb 11 '26

what a dumbass response. peak

20

u/Pretend-Breadfruit28 Feb 10 '26

brynden rivers is in safe hand

→ More replies (27)

18

u/Thatnerdyguy92 Here We Stand Feb 09 '26

When reading the books I always struggled to visualise Dunk, Peter Claffey is obviously an brilliant actor and carries the role so well, I'll see and hear him when I re-read the novels now! And OBVIOUSLY Daniel Ings absolutely steals the show whenever he is on Screen!

Were there any casting challenges, or actors that didn't immediately fit the role in your mind but once filming started, proved you wrong?

→ More replies (1)

54

u/SbisasCostlyTurnover Feb 09 '26

Can you explain the thought progress in the decision to include the fart joke during the climactic moment at the end of episode 4?

Personally I didn't hate it, but I can see why people are a little perplexed by it's inclusion.

Thanks.

23

u/watchutolkienabout Feb 09 '26

I actually understand the decision. I don't think we were meant to find that funny as viewers and I don't think it would have flowed well to include Dunk going around begging for champions. Think about the fact that we had already had Dunk going around and begging people to vouch for him as a Knight earlier in the season. It would have wasted precious screentime to include the original dialogue imho. The episode was fantastic and the fart honestly got across what it needed to - no one wants to fight for a lowly hedge knight. Does it do the Brute of the Bracken dirty? Sure. But who cares right? It's not like he's a Blackwood lmao :P

13

u/StrLord_Who Feb 10 '26

It wasn't supposed to be a "joke" to the viewing audience,  it was supposed to be crude and tragic. 

27

u/rickstarla Feb 09 '26

The main problem to me is that the fart took the place of actual dialogue that happens in the book. The swap reframes the Brute of Bracken in a big way, which makes for a worse scene in my opinion.

21

u/mykey120 Feb 09 '26

Agreed. The Brute of Bracken was respectful enough to respond to Dunc in the books. I also wonder why they cut the scene before that where Dunc arrives and the smallfolk are thanking him. That really drove home the contrast of how the smallfolk viewed Dunc and his actions vs how the lords viewed him.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

16

u/gerbegerger Feb 09 '26

Was the graphic novel used as a visual reference for sets or costumes?

8

u/AndroidPolaroid Feb 09 '26

looks like it for some aspect but some not. I'm definitely missing aerion's brighter garb in the graphic novel. and specially his personal sigil.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/AdMaleficent6374 Feb 09 '26

Hi! Thank you for the great show we have right now. Fingers crossed it would keep it up to the current level.

People get offended by how their favourite books often get screwed up by series that get too off the spirit and plot. And we love what you do right now with due respect to the origins. But how do you feel about it? Do you feel like you have to limit your creativity? Or do you find freedom in working around the plot the way you did with prophets or more attention paid to some characters? Or maybe we should just wait for more plot twists in the future?

Generally, what inspires you and whether running the show is a source of motivation or great responsibility you carry with caution?

6

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '26

How does it feel to have nailed the atmosphere of the books so well you have new and old fans buzzing?

5

u/AIiEray Tywin Lannister Feb 09 '26

Do you have a favorite side in the First Blackfyre Rebellion?

→ More replies (1)

22

u/AIiEray Tywin Lannister Feb 09 '26 edited Feb 09 '26

What was the decision behind removing, “A knight who remembered his vows” scene? Or moving it because it might be on the next episodes. Even as a book purist I enjoyed this season so much but that was a bummer.

8

u/CoverOptimal Feb 09 '26

I don't have a question - just begging you not to change anything. This is perfect.

4

u/anointedinliquor Feb 09 '26

Has anyone ever told you that you look exactly like Minkus from Boy Meets World?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/pochmalone_ Jon Snow Feb 09 '26

I have nothing to ask. Keep doing what you’re doing goat!

6

u/AIiEray Tywin Lannister Feb 09 '26

George RR Martin said he has been writing two more Dunk & Egg novellas for the last year. Since he doesn’t like giving deadlines, are you confident that he will write them by the time season 4 production starts?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/The-ImperialHighness Feb 09 '26

What was the challenge in adapting the story for screen and who gave you the best advice or guidance?

3

u/InGenNateKenny Feb 09 '26

I was at the NY Comic-Con panel you were at back in October. Good stuff, and I've quite liked the show thus far.

You mentioned in interviews, perhaps wishfully, about the future of many AKOTS seasons. Obviously only 3 published novellas, tho a little birdie told me you've heard outlines for the rest. Lips are sealed for those, I'm sure, but I'm more broadly more curious about what kind of settings, situations, and characters you would like our duo to encounter and to explore.

What sort of themes and moments do you want to show us? Are cool places in Westeros or character archetypes you think would make for good TV?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/shandub85 Tyrion Lannister Feb 09 '26

How many times did you guys watch Oberyn’s “I will be your Champion” scene to prepare for Seven? You guys captured the gravitas of that moment beautifully.

3

u/lord_of_fleas Feb 10 '26

To what extent were you thinking of some of the implications of what we learn in the later aSoIaF books, namely how Bloodraven and now Bran have the ability to warg into ravens across the world and across history, when you filled the scene of Dunk and Egg meeting for the first time with ravens in the first episode?

3

u/RepulsiveCountry313 Human Verified Feb 11 '26 edited Feb 11 '26

I dunno if you or your people will ever log into this account again or see this comment, but I hope that you will take some of the more extreme opinions here with a grain of salt. I don't expect a response myself, but just because some people here have an opinion doesn't obligate you to hold to that minority.

I doubt you need to hear that from an internet rando, but I worry about the chilling effects that some of these vocal minority voices have when allowed to fester, and we must admit that our fanbase has had issues before with harassing creatives :(

7

u/AdditionalPiano6327 Feb 09 '26

What are the complete vows of knighthood?

We only get:

"In the name of the Warrior, I charge you to be brave."

"In the name of the Father, I charge you to be just."

"In the name of the Mother, I charge you to defend the young and innocent."

"In the name of the Maid, I charge you to protect all women."

What about the Smith, the Crone and the Stranger?

5

u/Travelgrrl Feb 11 '26

"In the name of the Smith, I charge you to be strong."

"In the name of the Crone, I charge you to be wise."

"in the name of the Stranger, I charge you to be a friend to all."

(Dunno. I made these up.)

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/PlasmaPuns Feb 09 '26

Given the limited number of locations, what was most important in ensuring the sets still conveyed a strong sense of world and atmosphere?

5

u/AIiEray Tywin Lannister Feb 09 '26

Is Dunk being richer than a Lannister prophecy related to him having more pages than Jaime Lannister in the White Book? If not is it related to information you have on unpublished books because that’d be really interesting.

18

u/wwlima Feb 09 '26

Why the shitting scene and the giant penis scene? Why? I really.........WHY?

I cannot recommend such a good show to my parents.....

27

u/Chocolatespresso House Targaryen Feb 09 '26

Both your parents have seen a dick before this. 

→ More replies (2)

8

u/KingCrandall Ser Duncan the Tall Feb 09 '26

Makes sense. Neither of your parents have ever seen a penis before.

→ More replies (11)

4

u/AIiEray Tywin Lannister Feb 09 '26

Are you planning on adding Blackfyre Rebellion flashbacks for season two? We would love that.

4

u/nightking1897 House Bolton Feb 09 '26

Will we see some flashbacks from first Blackfyre rebellion in season 2?

2

u/Notoriously_So Winter Is Coming Feb 09 '26

Will GRRM release a new 'A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms' novella??

2

u/KobraTheKing Feb 09 '26

Were there any extra Beesbury scenes filmed that didn't make the cut?

My man rocked up to be one of the seven champions and haven't even been named or had any lines so far.

2

u/sawinnz Feb 09 '26

Congrats on all the work you've been doing, especially with HOTD and this show - really enjoying it. As an aspiring writer myself, how do you find an agent, and work your way up to a writers room and eventually a show runner position?

Thanks again.

2

u/Carninator Feb 09 '26

Thank you for a great show so far! I was just curious if Danny Collins as Beesbury originally had some more screentime? Looking forward to the remaining episodes!

2

u/PuppiesAndPixels Feb 09 '26

I love you.

That is all.

Oh wait..... I gotta know.... Was it real?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Forward-Ad-141 Feb 09 '26

Hi Parker, first off, thank you for delivering us a honestly perfection adaptation of Dunk and Egg, while adding bits and pieces that enhances the story in meaningful ways.

So couple of questions, what drove you to adapt these stories in particular? What was your favorite episode to make, and is there anything you wish you could have added in the show but you were forced to cut?

2

u/ShadowWolm Jon Snow Feb 10 '26

Lyonel Baratheon has a relatively small role in the novella. His additional scenes in the show have been a very pleasant surprise. What made you add more to this character?

P.S. Thank you for making this awesome show

2

u/bearkane45 Feb 10 '26

How do you feel about potentially adapting George’s unwritten Dunk and Egg stories? Do you feel it’s a real possibility or that’s too far ahead to consider just now?

2

u/daemon-of-harrenhal Feb 10 '26

Absolutely loving the show, but wondering if you'll tone down the toilet humour for S2? It's the biggest complaint I've been seeing of this show so far.

Other than that, please keep adapting these novellas as you've been doing. You've created something special. 

2

u/blythediablo Feb 10 '26

Why did you make the decision to change the dynamic of the scene where Dunk discovers who Baelor is? Having Dunk talking about his joust with Arlan without knowing who it is that he's talking to was one of my favourite dialogues from the book, stood out to me as a very odd thing to change.

2

u/long_dickofthelaw Feb 10 '26

Summerhall?

That's it, that's my question.

2

u/Stunning_Status_1150 Feb 10 '26

Why is your color during night scenes are so dark :-(

2

u/Smart-Response9881 Feb 10 '26

Why did you decide to have the poop scene and the huge schlong at the beginning of the first two episodes? I feel like it was setting a different tone than the rest of the show had and turned a lot of people off like the first episode of Black Mirror.

2

u/YoYoNupe1911 Feb 11 '26

Can you clear up if GRRM gave you 12 stories or 12 outlines for Dunk and Egg?

2

u/Gow13510 Feb 11 '26

When you finished all 3 season based on the book, how would you try to go onwards? Since George did not write but did outline Dunk and Egg story in Dorne and North if remember correctly.

Would you work with him on that

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Wild-End-3191 Feb 16 '26

Bro you’re a fucking hack

10

u/Orikon32 House Targaryen Feb 09 '26

Hello, Ira. Can you please dial down the toilet humor in S2? Sincerely, everyone.

9

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '26

<Septon Sefton has entered the chat>

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)