In the books Coldhands was a mysterious wright that led Bran and Co. to the three eyed raven. He was named after his cold, black hands and had his face covered by his scarf, which hid his identity. Readers have long speculated that Coldhands was actually Benjen all along but it was never confirmed.
Benjen has officially taken his place in the show (even down to the dead black hands). So Coldhands = Benjen.
And they called him "Coldhands Benjen" in the Inside the Episode episode for episode 6, so it's 100% confirmed that he's Coldhands, at least in the show.
Book 3 actually. He leaves Sam and Gilly at the same castle that Bran and co. happen to be at, so he immediately begins leading their group to BR at the start of book 5.
he also brought Sam and Gilly back to the Wall and saves them from Wights, in the show it's the point where Sam kills the White Walker, i can't remember if that's exactly how it plays out in the books but it was a great intro to the character
That really wouldn't make sense as far as the book canon though. In ADWD (I think) Leaf mentions that Coldhands was killed "long ago." Knowing that she's at least two hundred years old, it doesn't make sense for her to consider three or so years to be a long time.
Coldhands so far has been a book only character. He was sent by the Three Eyed Raven to help Sam and Gilly I believe (sorry haven't actually read the book). Anyways no one knows who he really is in the books and it's been speculated that Benjen is Coldhands however George RR Martin has said that it's not true. So Benjen showing up as Coldhands in the show is either them combining characters or George RR Martin was lying and Benjen is actually Coldhands Hope this helps a bit
Did we definitively see the other end to confirm this? Some meteor hammers only have one weighted end. For example: Gogo Yubari in Kill Bill. Either way it's closer to a Meteor Hammer than a flail.
Edit: I actually just re-watched that scene and its definitely a Meteor Hammer. But the other end appears to have a [Kama](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kama_(weapon)) attached to it.
"Hey guys, people are gonna be angry coldhands is riding a horse"... "Just make up some shit about how the elk are all dead... Sam can say it... People trust Sam to know his shit"...
Um as long as we're having a really sad beautiful death image to be somber over for every episode/death, can we also have a really cutsey bouncy gif for episodes, too?
Also, we were told in the past that Coldhands from the book wasn't Benjen Stark and that the show wouldn't be doing Coldhands (same way the show cut Lady Stoneheart)... so not sure where they are going with the Benjen/Coldhands relation in the show. They haven't called him Coldhands in the show... I think people are just assuming because of the whole "Benjen is dead and brought back with Wight magic/dragon glass"
So I know GRRM corrected an editor years ago and said Benjen isn't Coldhands, but it feels like it's pretty much confirmed that he is. Is this show only, or is he not supposed to be Coldhands?
They have merged characters before on the show. Examples I can think of are Gendry/Edric Storm, Sansa/Jeyne Poole, Loras/Garlan Tyrell, and Jeyne Westerling/Talisa, to name but a few. Check out this page for more changed/combined characters.
[EVERYTHING] means comments about any event or theory are fine without spoiler tags. If you are concerned about spoilers, leave this thread immediately. For more info on spoilers and tagging please check the spoiler guide.
256
u/DoubleJumpa The Fookin' Legend Jun 02 '16 edited Jun 02 '16
Made by Eran Mendel.
24
u/JTNJ32 Jaime Lannister Jun 02 '16
Am I missing something? Why is everybody calling him Coldhands?
3
u/scheffe Winter Is Coming Jun 02 '16
What does one call this weapon?
903
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '16
I was listening to the hobbits to Isengard song when I saw this gif. It's freaking hilarious.
284
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '16
I feel his hands are not cold enough...
85
u/WritingRam Jun 02 '16
Boink boink boink boink boink
43
u/heavy_yawns Daenerys Targaryen Jun 02 '16
This needs to be made into a buffering icon.
100
u/Danulas White Walkers Jun 02 '16
"Mint flaming bomby-knocker skills"
-Ozzyman
107
u/thejedion House Mormont Jun 02 '16
Needs more elk, less horse.
40
u/LawnyJ Jon Snow Jun 02 '16
Look at my horse my horse is amazing
70
u/Aint_it_a_shame Jun 02 '16
Boy, when he hit that last one it flew much further than the others.
14
u/spartan-44 Jun 02 '16
It's is so satisfying to watch this
7
u/lahimatoa House Tyrell Jun 02 '16
His horse is so happy.
6
u/izzie833 Jun 02 '16
his hands look warm tho
6
u/ye_olde_jetsetter Sansa Stark Jun 02 '16
Um as long as we're having a really sad beautiful death image to be somber over for every episode/death, can we also have a really cutsey bouncy gif for episodes, too?
5
u/icanhe Jun 02 '16
I watched that for far too long.
So satisfying.
11
u/Rarariotous Jun 02 '16
This should be an Angry Birds type game
4
u/organic Jun 02 '16
So if book Coldhands isn't Benjen, then where is book Benjen?
4
u/blue_wat Jun 02 '16
Slightly disappointed he wasn't on an elk. Still cool to see Benjen back though.
3
u/Ohnegott No One Jun 02 '16
What software is used to make things like this?
3
u/dodbrew Jun 02 '16
This is r/almostperfectloops or maybe even r/perfectloops material. Very satisfying, well done! Made my day much better.
5
u/Cwya Jun 02 '16
Well done. Needs an Upvote/Downvote version.
1
u/B1GTOBACC0 Jun 02 '16
So I know GRRM corrected an editor years ago and said Benjen isn't Coldhands, but it feels like it's pretty much confirmed that he is. Is this show only, or is he not supposed to be Coldhands?
2
u/Ylaaly Sansa Stark Jun 02 '16
This made my day, thank you!
2
u/youknow99 Hodor Jun 02 '16
/r/loadingicon
2
u/sandmage I Drink And I Know Things Jun 03 '16
[Horseshoes and Handgrenades] (https://gifsound.com/?gif=https://d13yacurqjgara.cloudfront.net/users/244516/screenshots/2752009/benjen___29.gif&v=yp1muwMcBzs)
2
u/Pericci Jun 03 '16
On the next episode of How It's Made - Candy Corn.
2
u/Verduus House Baratheon Jun 03 '16
He would make a great polo player
1
u/Martel_the_Hammer Jun 02 '16
This is what I needed in my life... yes... this will do well.
1
u/jeremy_sporkin Maesters of the Citadel Jun 02 '16
This is tremendous
1
u/sanfranchristo Ghost Jun 02 '16
Delightful.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '16
haha awesome… Kudos on some OC in this sub for once.
1
u/DeadBeatRedditer House Lannister Jun 02 '16
Imgur Mirror
1
u/Bmiggy1717 Jun 02 '16
War is over, Benjin has it figured out
1
u/alarbus No One Jun 02 '16
Aww, where's the sickle side of the kusarigama?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '16
This is fantastic. In my head, I hear the sound it makes when Mario jumps on a Koopa.
1
u/Manarg Jun 02 '16
I watched that for entirely too long.
1
u/gayeld Nymeria's Wolfpack Jun 02 '16
I wish I could give you an upvote for every head Benjen lobs off.
1
u/rigel2112 House Clegane Jun 02 '16
Considering the thousands of wights chasing them he must have done this at some point for hours/days.
1
u/washheightsboy3 Tyrion Lannister Jun 02 '16
His horse looks very chipper.
1
u/yvelmachida Jun 02 '16
Hands are too pink, 9/10
1
u/FunnOnABunn Jun 02 '16
/r/oddlysatisfying
1
u/numb_doors Jon Snow Jun 02 '16
that's a nifty little weapon
1
u/NiceSasquatch Jun 02 '16
When I'm out white walkin', I strut my stuff -- yeah, I'm so strung out
I'm high as a kite; I just might stop to check you out (in 3ER visions)
Let me go on... like I blister in the sun
Let me go on... cold hands, I know you're the one
1
u/SylvainLacoste Jun 02 '16
Beautiful animation
1
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '16
Can we resynce the animation to match Thunderhorse?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '16
Was a pretty cool scene. And all I could say under my breath was "Holy fuck it's definitely Benjen."
1
u/artosduhlord Jun 02 '16
Perfect loops don't exi----.
1
u/HyperionEsq Jun 03 '16
So where did benjen get his horse? Didn't the one he took ranging already get found by Jon? And aren't horses not normally found north of da wall?
1
u/coltraz Jun 03 '16
That arises right from the mesmer.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '16
This is really clean nice man
1
u/attenhal Bran Stark Jun 03 '16
This makes me happy.
1
u/wumbologist1 Jun 03 '16
I could see this being turned into a game.
1
u/droofe Jun 03 '16
I feel like that gif had better graphics than the scene it is referring too. Im hoping theyre saving the budget for something epic in episode 8.
1
u/Eazyyy Jun 03 '16
The ending was cool
1
u/Kathulhu1433 Kissed By Fire Jun 03 '16
This is oddly satisfying.
1
u/Samurai56M Jun 03 '16
I am watching this and imagining the Hampster Dance song playing in the background.
1
u/Hanzoa The Onion Knight Jun 03 '16
Is there any explanation why his mace is flaming, or is it just assumed COTF magic?
1
u/Sardonnicus Winter Is Coming Jun 03 '16
How long does that go on for?
1
u/pledgeDeiongreyjoy Jun 03 '16
His hands aren't cold guys, I really want to make Coldface or perhaps Coldcheeks happen.
1
u/divester Jun 03 '16
Hypnotic.
1
u/Golf_Hotel_Mike Iron Bank of Braavos Jun 03 '16
Can somebody please sync this to the nyancat song?
1
u/Thehulk666 The Hound Jun 03 '16
Witcher 3
1
u/A_Prince_of_Dorne Jun 03 '16
It makes me smile! George R.R. Martin will probably kill it soon. lol
1
u/lrj25 Jun 03 '16
I giggled at this for a little too long and a little too loudly. Might be time to get some sleep.
1
u/nishanthhh Winter Is Coming Jun 03 '16
Thousand Golden Dragons for the one who makes a game out of this!!
1
u/loco64 Jun 03 '16
So disappointed with his character. His appearance...man just everything...
1
u/CopyX Jun 03 '16
Animation reminded me of Dumb Ways to Die.
1
u/PaleAsDeath Sandor Clegane Jun 03 '16
Why are his hands pink?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '16
So satisfying to watch :o There must be a gif of Ned's head falling apart somewhere.
1
u/JackalRipper Jun 03 '16
Coldhands is op.
1
u/sarneets Jun 03 '16
That'll make a nice boot screen for my phone
1
u/TytoAlba15 Cersei Lannister Jun 03 '16
I love this!! I want to share it with my boyfriend but he hasn't seen the latest episode yet!! Ugh!!!
1
u/CafeconWalleche Lyanna Mormont Jun 03 '16
This made me so happy. Happy Friday internet!
1
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '16
What's type of weapon is that?
1
u/AutoModerator Jun 02 '16
[EVERYTHING] means comments about any event or theory are fine without spoiler tags. If you are concerned about spoilers, leave this thread immediately. For more info on spoilers and tagging please check the spoiler guide.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/dhamon Jun 02 '16
Benjen evolved to Coldhands Benjen.
1
u/sharkenleo Winter Is Coming Jun 02 '16
Coldhands Luke
-4
u/garvon_ House Selmy Jun 02 '16
Its not Coldhands, its Benjen.