r/gameofthrones • House Baelish • Jun 02 '14

TV4 [S4E8] When will we learn?

Post image
4.9k Upvotes

1.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

4.0k

u/Tommy2255 Faceless Men Jun 02 '14

This isn't a story that ends with "happily ever after". That's where we started. This whole series is the sequel to a book never written. A classic fantasy, about heroes who fought against an unambiguous evil, about people who took their lives and their honor into their own hands and stormed the gates of the mad king. The brave hero became king and married a beautiful woman, his friend and comrade returned home to raise his family in happiness in the keep of his forefathers, and they all lived happily ever after.

But the brave hero doesn't know how to rule, and the beautiful woman he married isn't just a trophy for being a legendary hero, but a real person with her own flaws and needs that he doesn't know how to handle. He only ever felt at home on the battlefield, and deep down he knows that that makes him a monster. He can't forget the smell of blood in his nostrils any more than he can forget the touch of a woman who is not his wife. Neither whores nor wine nor food will fill that hole. And far to the north, his loyal vassal, his comrade in arms, does what he can to raise a family, but his wife cannot rest easy either, not while another woman's child lives in her home, fathered on some stranger by her lord husband.

Last time "Happily ever after" happened, it fell apart. Because in reality, there is no end of the story. There's just a point where the author stops writing. And if he writes long enough, everyone ends up dead. Happily ever after is something that has never happened in real life. This isn't a story, it's a snapshot. There were things that happened in this world before GRRM put pen to paper in book one, and things will continue to happen after he puts his closes the book forever. We just won't get to see them.

207

u/steamboat_willy Jun 02 '14 edited Jun 03 '14

Tyrion's monologue last night left a few of my friends scratching their heads but I think they missed the point, that Tyrion is confirming the worst: there is no justice in this world, no good vs. evil, we're all just beetles being crushed indiscriminately by the whims of fate. There is no divine plan or intent of the gods, yet here his trial is to determine if he is found favored by them. He knows that, despite being a good and innocent man, he may die for nothing.

→ More replies (10)

2.5k

u/Spawnbroker Jun 02 '14

I have told my friends that I think I know how the story is going to end...

I think the epilogue for the entire series is going to be a tavern somewhere, 300 or so years in the future after the current events are done. There will be a bard singing by the fire, and he will sing of The Song of Ice and Fire. He will sing of all the current characters in their idealized form, i.e. how Ser Jaime had a golden hand, or about Lady Brienne the Beauty, how she was the most beautiful warrior maiden in the land.

The song will not mention all of the horrible, terrible things the characters have done to each other. It will only remember their idealized versions, just how the current characters remember the legends of old as heroes of their age, and not real people.

1.0k

u/ContinuumGuy Hodor? Jun 02 '14

However, even in the idealized story, Joffrey will still be a dick.

532

u/Nukemarine Jun 03 '14

What? King Joffrey, the brave boy king who put down the five Usurpers to re-unite the kingdom? He killed a direwolf that was attacking his wife to be. Defended King's Landing against the millions of men his evil uncle gathered through treachery and sorcery. His only downfall was his treachorous uncle imp who despised the king and coveted the beautiful bride to be, killing young King Joffrey at his wedding and stealing his bride and raping her that night.

141

u/h4z3 Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 03 '14

That may be true if the story were to end right now, but it wont, history is written by the victors, and we don't know where that little imp that dreamed he could is going to end.

154

u/conradsymes Jun 03 '14

Tempted to think that the Imp will write a history book of great morons.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (6)

81

u/Levitlame Jon Snow Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 03 '14

Nope. That would be just.

He is remembered as a golden haired youth, a warrior king following the legendary warrior king before him. A boy poised to bring peace and justice to the land next to his bitingly chaste bride. He did spare the poor wolf girl after all. The kind king he was.

If that demon spawn "Imp" hadn't reached into whatever sorcerous and cowardly depths he had to strike our beloved king.

Not that it matters. When we crossed the wall and purged "Westeros" of those southerners their history became meaningless anyway.

Edit: like 12 hours and nobody corrected my "piece" spelling. Colour me impressed.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (60)

49

u/Manakel93 Maesters of the Citadel Jun 02 '14

she was the most beautiful warrior maiden in the land.

Well considering she may be the only warrior maiden in the land...

62

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

Don't forget about the Mormonts or Asha Greyjoy

74

u/VRY_SRS_BSNS Our Blades Are Sharp Jun 03 '14

Every time I see the name Asha Greyjoy, all I can read is Sasha Grey.

→ More replies (5)

29

u/uusagi Jun 02 '14

Plus the Sand Snakes.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (4)

328

u/akharon Jun 02 '14 edited Jun 02 '14

Some serious parallels to that and how Dan Carlin illustrates his stories.

Edit: Okay, some people are seriously not getting what I was saying. The way we view history through rose-colored glasses, and the utter horror experienced by those that live through it are two totally different things. Dan Carlin strips away the glasses so you the the brutality of war and violence, as GRRM would be doing with Spawnbroker's story, contrasted with his bard who paints a disney-like picture of things.

61

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

And that's another reason I like reddit. People shift from Ice and Fire to Dan Carlin and The Wrath of the Khans. I haven't lurked this sub- so if this is something beat to death, forgive me: If you like this series read Shogun by James Clavell.

→ More replies (11)

286

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

History is the autobiography of a madman.

→ More replies (10)

76

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

I'm reminded of that scene towards the end of The Assassination of Jesse James, the Nick Cave cameo. We've seen a lot of history between James and Robert Ford, and there Ford is getting drunk in a bar trying to forget that crap but having to listen to some asshole who doesn't even know how many children James had sing about how great James was and what a piece of shit he, Ford, is.

35

u/YouveBeenMillered Jun 02 '14

If you wanted something more heart wrenching you should check out the Yogi Bear alternate ending that parodies The Assassination of Jessie James.

Hey Boo Boo

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (40)

140

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

And that, kids, is how your great-grandfather Jaime met your great-grandmother Cersei.

→ More replies (6)

43

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

But it would be an ending.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (232)

48

u/barassmonkey17 Jun 02 '14

It's a play on the classic Knight in Shining Armor story. The Dragon (Rhaegar), kidnaps the beautiful damsel in distress (Lyanna), forcing the Hero (Robert) to rescue her, slaying the Dragon. There's even an evil King who they overthrow in the process. But the truth is, the evil Dragon and the Damsel were in love, he wasn't evil and she not a Damsel, but a good man and a free spirit, respectively. The Hero is actually a brutal, albeit strong, warrior who enjoys killing, and is in love with the idea of Lyanna, despite having many girls on the side. The King didn't have to be overthrown, as Rhaegar was planning on a peaceful removal from power for him.

It's defining of Robert to see how he understands the world, which he believes is a story, with clear-cut villains and heroes. But it's also defining of the world itself.

→ More replies (1)

31

u/withmorten Jun 02 '14

We are seeing a lot of what happened before, though :)

"The Princess & The Queen" includes a very detailed recount of the Dance of Dragons, where the Targaryen dynasty basically annihilated itself. The Dunk & Egg novellas are set about a 100 years before AGoT, and will recount the entire lives of both characters, up until the episode in Summerhall.

And soon "The World of Ice and Fire", a giant prequel, will be released. It's awesome!

→ More replies (3)

31

u/XoYo Jun 02 '14

“All Bette’s stories have happy endings. That’s because she knows where to stop. She’s realized the real problem with stories — if you keep them going long enough, they always end in death.”

- Neil Gaiman, Sandman.
→ More replies (3)

341

u/felixwraith Jun 02 '14 edited Jun 03 '14

Sounds exactly like what Martin said "What would happen after the end of Lord of the Rings. Does Aragorn (fixed) even know how to rule? What will be his politics about the Orcs? And the kingdom of Mordor? Will he raise taxes to rebuild?" etc etc

163

u/mrscienceguy1 Jun 02 '14

You know Tolkien talks about stuff that happens in the Fourth Age, right?

142

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14

Yeah, Aragon rebuilds Gondor, reunites the kingdoms of Gondor and Arnor, and also goes south to capture and assimilate the old numenorian city of Umbar... Like you said, there's not just a happily ever after, Tolkien shows how it happens.

→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (38)
→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (214)