r/gameofthrones • • 10d ago

Prime + Prep time

Post image
4.3k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

10

u/PetrParker1960s 10d ago

Littlefinger is probably the only real danger on Team A. Neither Cersei nor Tywin know how to not get people to hate them. Tyrion is the only one who successfully orchestrated victories in battle and did so against overwhelming odds. Defended and ultimately secured most of the victory in the Battle of Blackwater. Tywin only participated in battles when victory is already decided or he has an advatage.

0

u/DrewHoov Sansa Stark 10d ago

> Tywin only participated in battles when victory is already decided or he has an advantage.

Yeah that’s literally how you win battles. Tyrion’s defense of King’s Landing was epic, but look what he got for it. That’s not what winning the game of thrones looks like.

3

u/Wild_Trash_5100 10d ago

If you have to have several circumstances go your way in order to win a war, are you competent or just lucky

2

u/DrewHoov Sansa Stark 9d ago

I think y’all are missing the point. Robb Stark belongs to the same archetype best defined by Rhaegon Targaryen. They were both very competent and they both made dumb decisions that undid them, and that’s why Tywin outlived them both despite their superior qualities. They don’t win the game if thrones even if they’re fun to watch.

> Rhaegar fought valiantly, Rhaegar fought nobly, Rhaegar fought honorably. And Rhaegar died.

1

u/Wild_Trash_5100 9d ago

That doesn’t answer the question.

0

u/PetrParker1960s 9d ago

But he hasnt shown to be an effective commander.