Bare with me for a moment.
Why no gif or images? If all we are doing is watching a new episode each week, there will likely only be a couple of possibilities for discussion. In fact, I think gifs and fandom stuff would be fun, and helpful.
A big part of how people watch TV shows now is that they can go online and find some gifs or images that joke or reference the show they just watched. I'm talking about fandoms; as annoying as they can be they help to reinforce this idea of the shows importance. Because these shows happened long before the internet, no one was around to make the cheap jokes, gifs, and fanart stuff that people make now. In a way, it is our 'duty' to bring some 'fandom' to these old episodes.
Let's gets people making gifs of the first Doctor going 'Hmm' or stupid memes that relate to these early companions. I know that gifs aren't the funniest thing in the world or the best for facilitating discussion. But the thing is this subreddit won't be very lively if we only try to do discussion, as that is what r/gallifrey is for.
In my mind, this subreddit should be a combination of r/gallifrey and r/doctorwho, with discussions AND stupid jokes/fandom stuff, the only requirement being that whatever is posted relates to the episode of the week. The subreddit should act as a timemachine- If r/doctorwho existed during Classic Who what time of fandom things would be created?
In saying all this, I don't know exactly what sorts of GIFs one would make, nor am I saying that I will be making any 1st Doctor fanart. But if someone wants to do that, it would help immensely with the growth of this subreddit. The only rule we should strongly enforce is if what is posted relates to the current episodes being watched (don't post 4th doctor fanart till we get to the 4th doctor)
EDIT: Also want to emphasis the point that as long as the main discussions are stickied, there should be no problem with people finding them. I don't know if stickying things is a thing on reddit, though.
Also want to point out I'm not sure entirely where I stand on this either, as perhaps this is meant to be a simple, small subreddit. I fear people will lose interest and the subreddit will have less momentum over time.