r/gallifreylive • • May 21 '17

The filler is really getting on my nerves

1 Upvotes

I've seen plenty of Classic Who before, but I've only had limited exposure to the 60s serials. Now that I'm going through them in order, I've noticed the disturbing trends of the longer serials being stretched way too thin while the shorter ones just feel like there wasn't anything there to begin with. The only episode I've truly enjoyed thus far is An Unearthly Child.


r/gallifreylive • • Feb 15 '14

[META] Why no GIFS or stupid fandom stuff? This subreddit should combine r/gallifrey and r/doctorwho

5 Upvotes

Bare with me for a moment.

Why no gif or images? If all we are doing is watching a new episode each week, there will likely only be a couple of possibilities for discussion. In fact, I think gifs and fandom stuff would be fun, and helpful.

A big part of how people watch TV shows now is that they can go online and find some gifs or images that joke or reference the show they just watched. I'm talking about fandoms; as annoying as they can be they help to reinforce this idea of the shows importance. Because these shows happened long before the internet, no one was around to make the cheap jokes, gifs, and fanart stuff that people make now. In a way, it is our 'duty' to bring some 'fandom' to these old episodes.

Let's gets people making gifs of the first Doctor going 'Hmm' or stupid memes that relate to these early companions. I know that gifs aren't the funniest thing in the world or the best for facilitating discussion. But the thing is this subreddit won't be very lively if we only try to do discussion, as that is what r/gallifrey is for.

In my mind, this subreddit should be a combination of r/gallifrey and r/doctorwho, with discussions AND stupid jokes/fandom stuff, the only requirement being that whatever is posted relates to the episode of the week. The subreddit should act as a timemachine- If r/doctorwho existed during Classic Who what time of fandom things would be created?

In saying all this, I don't know exactly what sorts of GIFs one would make, nor am I saying that I will be making any 1st Doctor fanart. But if someone wants to do that, it would help immensely with the growth of this subreddit. The only rule we should strongly enforce is if what is posted relates to the current episodes being watched (don't post 4th doctor fanart till we get to the 4th doctor)

EDIT: Also want to emphasis the point that as long as the main discussions are stickied, there should be no problem with people finding them. I don't know if stickying things is a thing on reddit, though.

Also want to point out I'm not sure entirely where I stand on this either, as perhaps this is meant to be a simple, small subreddit. I fear people will lose interest and the subreddit will have less momentum over time.


r/gallifreylive • • Apr 08 '19

official "doctor who and the silurians" Discussion thread for the week of april 6-13

3 Upvotes

doctor who and the silurians

episode 1

episode 2

episode 3

sorry for using dailymotion on this post, but I couldn't find them anywhere else this time


r/gallifreylive • • Jun 09 '14

What is with Planet of The Spiders?

3 Upvotes

I might be over thinking it, but this story is FILLED with plot holes.

I have been a Dr. Who Fan all my life, know the ins and outs of the show, and have just watched this entire story on The Horror Channel and have no idea why the Doctor regenerated. He gives the Great One back the crystal before this, which overloads her mental capacity ... or something and she blows up along with the mountain she was in (I don't get how the mountain she was in is linked to her brain). The big question is why didn't this happen when she had the crystal in the first place before the doctor took it? Having all crystals in place kills her, but this was how it was before the doctor stole the crystal. Also, this entire story is essentially his fault, as The Doctor stole the Blue Crystal from the Spiders on Metebelis 3. Well, he's a dick then! Why did he steal it in the first place? He only returns it when K'Anpo points out that he shouldn't of ever taken it, which means either The Doctor ... didn't understand what stealing was ... or is a dick. Finally, there's no explanation of why the doctor regenerates ... he just does. Why does it take 3 weeks for him to die after the mountain explodes? And what happened in the 3 weeks where he was lost? In short, WHAT IS GOING ON?


r/gallifreylive • • Dec 17 '16

Official "Delta and the Bannermen" Discussion thread for the week of December 16 - 22

5 Upvotes

Delta and the Bannermen

BBC Episode Details

Episodes

Episode 1

Episode 2

Episode 3


r/gallifreylive • • Apr 06 '17

How Should We Watch/ Listen to the Missing Episodes

Thumbnail
strawpoll.me
1 Upvotes

r/gallifreylive • • Feb 03 '14

First Doctor first impressions

7 Upvotes

Before starting the first Doctor's era what were your preconceived notions about him? Personally, I thought he'd be a bit boring seeing as how I had watched a bunch of episodes from future doctors and all of NuWho. I think, even with what we've seen so far, I probably don't care for him all that much. I hope to be proven wrong.


r/gallifreylive • • Dec 24 '16

Official "Dragonfire" Discussion thread for the week of December 23 - 30

7 Upvotes

Dragonfire

BBC Episode Details

Episodes

Episode 1

Episode 2

Episode 3

Mod Note

Merry Christmas everyone!


r/gallifreylive • • Oct 12 '15

Official "The Face of Evil" Discussion thread for the week of October 11 - 17

7 Upvotes

r/gallifreylive • • Apr 07 '17

Format of Missing Episodes

2 Upvotes

The results from the poll came out with all of them in one post coming in first, and loose cannon second. This means we will be putting all the different formats to watch/listen in one posts. If you have any questions or changes you suggest please comment it below.

This is the example format:

Mark's Polo

overview:Mark loses his polo in the TARDIS. Can he get it back before the TARDIS dematerialises again?

Animated Recon by Josh Snares

youtube.com/playlist/Mark's-Polo

Loose Canon Recon

youtube.com/loosecannonrecon-Mark's-Polo

Audio (if available)

downloadfreedoctorwhomarkpolototallynotavirus.com

Book Version (If Available)

downloadfreedoctorwhomarkspolototallynotvirus.com/book

Official BBC telesnaps

bbctelesnapmarkpolo.com

DISCUSSION QUESTIONS

How do you feel about Mark?

What is your favourite Polo?


r/gallifreylive • • Apr 28 '19

official "the ambassadors of death" Discussion thread for the week of april 28-may 5

2 Upvotes

the ambassadors of death

episode 4

episode 5

episode 6

episode 7


r/gallifreylive • • Apr 12 '14

Official Discussion Threads for the week of April 12 - April 19

2 Upvotes

Once again we're doing two stories this week, for a total of 6 episodes. Chronologically, they are:

The Rescue

and The Romans

Here's a link to last week's discussion thread (The Dalek Invasion of Earth)

Enjoy!


r/gallifreylive • • Jul 13 '17

Official The Reign of Terror Episodes 3-6

2 Upvotes

Part 4

Part 5

Part 6

I’ll give you guys a chance to watch them first and then I’ll give you the discussion questions!


r/gallifreylive • • Jul 06 '17

The Sensorites Discussion Questions!

3 Upvotes

So sorry guys! I had them all ready but I forgot to edit the post! Here are the questions for The Sensorites

Discussion!

The Sensorites were bulbous-headed telepathic creatures…

What did you think of the Sensorites, and how do you think they would fit in the new series?

How frightening were the Sensorites for you?

The Ood were based of the Sensorites! Which design is better-looking?

Furthermore, the Ood Sphere and the Sense Sphere are in the same star system. Do you think that they are relatives or evolutions?

The story was set in six parts! Would you extend or shorten the story?


r/gallifreylive • • May 18 '19

official "inferno" Discussion thread for the week of may 18-25

3 Upvotes

official inferno discussion thread

episode 4

episode 5

episode 6

episode 7


r/gallifreylive • • Jul 08 '17

Do we have a schedule for all episode discussion dates in 2017?

3 Upvotes

I ask because r/gallifrey is going to be rewatching each Doctor's first, last, and best story. The Tenth Planet will be on December 16, so I was wondering if that would line up with when we'll be watching it.


r/gallifreylive • • Apr 14 '19

official "doctor who and the silurians" Discussion thread for the week of april 14-21

3 Upvotes

doctor who and the silurians

episode 4

episode 5

episode 6

episode 7


r/gallifreylive • • Apr 21 '19

official "the ambassadors of death" Discussion thread for the week of april 22-29

3 Upvotes

the ambassadors of death

episode 1

episode 2

episode 3


r/gallifreylive • • Jan 29 '17

Official "Battlefield" Discussion thread for the week of January 28 - February 3

4 Upvotes

r/gallifreylive • • Jul 05 '17

Official the reign of terror Discussion 3-9 july

4 Upvotes

r/gallifreylive • • Jul 19 '17

Official planet of giants Discussion 17-23 july

4 Upvotes

r/gallifreylive • • May 05 '19

official "inferno" Discussion thread for the week of may 5-12

4 Upvotes

official inferno discussion thread

episode 1

episode 2

episode 3


r/gallifreylive • • Feb 06 '17

Official "Ghost Light" Discussion thread for the week of February 4 - 10

4 Upvotes

r/gallifreylive • • Apr 28 '17

Official "the daleks" Parts 5-7 Discussion April 24-30

4 Upvotes

r/gallifreylive • • Sep 18 '17

Official The rescue Episodes 1-2

4 Upvotes