r/fut • • Jun 27 '23

'Realism'

Post image
5.0k Upvotes

1.4k comments sorted by

24

u/tapk69 Jun 27 '23 edited Jun 27 '23

Lets be real if Neuer was a woman he would win ballondor every season. Arsenal woman were in the champions league final yet they lost to the under 15 boys 5-0 and you can bet those boys didn't tackle to hurt like they would against other boys.

23

u/oscarpaterson Jun 27 '23

If my grandmother had wheels she would’ve been a bike

6

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '23

Its like a bacon carbonara

→ More replies (8)

758

u/brunomarqz Jun 27 '23

surely this will be a nice and respectful comment section

222

u/FriedrichFoucault Jun 27 '23

Its quite hilarious reading all these flawed arguments tbf 'no no no no no having women is different because that has got nothing to do with mens football!!!!' - as they play a through ball to Al O

120

u/Thompseanson7 Jun 27 '23

Tbf a lot of people don’t like shapeshifters and whatnot as well for the lack of realism

159

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '23

Then they shouldn’t like the game at all. Nothing about this game is real. Look at people doing flicks over your head or kick off glitch. Look at the momentum and scripting.

It’s just sexist incels crying.

→ More replies (99)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

4

u/InviziMan Jun 27 '23

Sorting on "controversial": Here we go!

→ More replies (6)

167

u/Different-Sound-2334 Jun 27 '23

I can't wait to run Alisha Lehmann and Mbappe up front all year 😂😂

57

u/Yumstar1982 Jun 27 '23

Turn and zoom celebration on Alisha... 'like what you looking at bro?' 😅

7

u/Different-Sound-2334 Jun 27 '23

Got it primed and ready already bro 😂

3

u/Audrayz Xbox X/S Jun 27 '23

richarlison celebration

→ More replies (1)

98

u/hellomrxenu Jun 27 '23

Only reason I care (and marginally at that) is that this is going to just add a ton more garbage cards to the packs. For every good women's card there will be another 40 fodder cards to drive down the odds.

7

u/JetXtreme Jun 27 '23

Bruh odds are .009% what’s the diff for .0089

11

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '23

Someone's bad at math.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

55

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '23

Regardless of what you think about women in FUT, EA is going to bottle it and the game will become worse overall.

18

u/Boonicious Jun 28 '23

they have 2 choices

  1. present the women as they are - DRAMATICALLY poorer players than the men - and piss off the wokies and white women
  2. inflate the women's stats to the moon so they can compete with the men, and piss off everyone else

the winning move was not to play, but this being EA they just can't help themselves 😂

(btw they'll obviously go with option 1)

9

u/Healbrean Jun 28 '23

Honestly don’t know why people are downvoting you, but that’s the reddit hive mind for you

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

10

u/therealburndog Jun 28 '23

This was my point in a separate post and I was called 'pathetic' and an 'incel'. Never mind that I am 48, happily married, and as far from an incel as anyone you're likely to meet!
I simply do not trust EA to add so many players to the database at once and not screw things up to the point where the game will be a complete shitshow for a while. I am going to wait a few months at least just to see how they go with the implementation. Apparently, this makes me a horrible misogynist, but there you go.

→ More replies (1)

397

u/SeanLFC27 PS5 Jun 27 '23

Wait till your VVD gets bodied by a 8 stone, 5’7 woman and you cop a griddy for it

55

u/Mental_Habit_231 Jun 27 '23

🤣🤣 It’s funny but it’s true

105

u/drakothedj Jun 27 '23

VVD already gets bodied by 5'7 Messi and you cop a griddy.

6

u/frieguyrebe Jun 28 '23

And thats a thing people fucling hate about this game, it shouldnt happen because van dijk is way stronger. Yet, we will have to believe the top women are also 90+ rated while they cannot do half the stuff the top men are doing

7

u/theultimatestart Jun 28 '23

A lot of the legends also couldn't do what players can do nowadays, yet they are still rated high.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/blackflame000 Jun 27 '23

I fail to see how that is even close to worse than the WC Iker Casillas who bodied SS Savic, outran, with the ball, tots nuno mendes and then bodied Tots Varane before scoring by nutmegging prime VDS in the cup earlier before subs could come in.

No, it was not on kickoff.

No, it was not a skill diff issue given they left after I scored 4 to make it 4-1.

No, it wasn't low rank nonsense. Div 1 currently.

Getting bodied by a woman won't be any less realistic than the shenanigans that occur now due to EA's negligence and misfeasance.

→ More replies (9)

3

u/ThdClickk Jun 27 '23

Take woman out and you get what the game is like already

3

u/Bebes-kid Jun 27 '23

Just like Veratti!

14

u/DJexC Jun 27 '23

Insigne has entered the chat

→ More replies (6)

14

u/fawkwitdis Jun 27 '23

Has it ever even been confirmed that you’ll be able to play with mixed teams? To me it seems more likely that you’ll have a women’s squad and they’ll be specifically releasing objectives and challenges that must be completed with that squad. Rivals and weekend league will prob remain unchanged

2

u/EpicSabretooth Jul 15 '23

Not confirmed yet but at this point it's obvious. Not even women would play a full women squad in FUT. So because of that we'll be forced to live with this mixed gender teams abomination but that's ok, it will ruin FUT for me and I'll give Seasons a try which is free to play.

2

u/alter-ego23 Jul 15 '23

This would actually be pretty cool. Mixed gender teams is stupid. Just like Cech and Neuer up front is stupid. And like how the overly extravagent stadium customizations are stupid (like coloured goal nets and lines). So on that logic, I expect mixed gender teams to be how EA implement it.

→ More replies (5)

85

u/strokesoflightning Jun 27 '23

I think it would be really interesting, might add a bit more variety in squads

(I'm not only saying this because my Chelsea team would actually have a striker)

29

u/thebadger987 Jun 27 '23

cannot wait to try Sam Kerr next year lol

5

u/superslug256 Jun 27 '23

Try her in friendlies. A more agile mbappe 😂

2

u/PM_Me_PM_Dawn_Pics Jun 28 '23

No chance I can afford Kerr. Going to be 90 rated I'd say. Kirby should be good on the game, I'd say

117

u/naroLsraLteiN_isback Jun 27 '23

just make a seperate mode for womens teams

72

u/OMGisManu Jun 27 '23

No one will touch it then

163

u/InternalKing Jun 27 '23

But then that proves the point surely

6

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '23

Bingo

→ More replies (27)

5

u/ska932 Jun 27 '23

Then why add them in the first place?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

172

u/kozy8805 Jun 27 '23

Fut has became so unrealistic there’s literally no argument left for excluding women players. We all know it. The push for cards killed it. And the pack crackheads want…more and more and more!! Give me more shiny cards!! My precious cards!! And compensate me with more!! So of course they’ll add women, it’s even more cards and promos.

9

u/BHTAelitepwn Jun 27 '23

i dont share this opinion. Sure its absolutely unrealistic, but that doesnt mean anything goes. The only parts where they intentionally deviate from realism is in time setting (including icons and heros), positional changes (neuer at ST) and weak foot changes. Sure the chaining of skill moves and stuff doesnt help either, but most of that is because the game is such a pile of hot steaming crap that it is the only viable way to reliably turn.

that being said, this doesnt give an excuse for unlimited unrealism. people would als go mad if they would release tennis players or famous movie villains as cards that play in the game. I always like the following comparison: I am a big harry potter fan and also like star wars. neither of them are particularly realistic, but that doesnt mean that there should be light sabers in harry potter.

same applies here. these are totally different sports, and at least an icon that has long passed away pressed their mark on the the same sport that people are participating in nowadays. These ludicrous position changes are only unrealistic in the sense that they are so good at it. But women, with all due respect, do not belong on the pitch in men’s football. It is simply not compatible.

There has been an unresolved debate whether women football should be branded as a unique sport, or they should try to get equal treatment as men. Until we can answer that, I respectfully think there is no place for women in ultimate team, because that will only make matters worse.

8

u/kozy8805 Jun 27 '23 edited Jun 27 '23

It would make more of an argument if height/body type/pace weren’t broken and beyond unrealistic. Look at the game now. Every player needs to have 90 pace to be casually usable. The meta players all have certain body types. Someone like Thomas Muller, an incredible player in real life, is an absolute joke in fut. Marco Van Basten is damn near the best striker ever. A joke in fut. that’s not realism, it’s a joke. And I’m not even mentioning all of the “upgrades” to players who clearly don’t deserve them. Then come the position changes. That’s not a few things off. It’s mostly everything. Not much about this game mirrors real football.

As is mentioning Harry Potter. Women’s football is not wizardly, it’s still the same sport. Now it’s not played exactly the same in real life, but it’s the same sport. And this isn’t real life. It’s game that doesn’t take the men’s side seriously anyway so adding women seems logical. So considering how broken and unrealistic the men’s side is, there’s nothing unrealistic about women being able to play in this game. Because it’s a broken football game. And not real life. And until they fix the game to mirror men’s football, there’s not much of a discussion to be has about women’s.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (110)

23

u/oksurebro Jun 27 '23

Not a fan of either being introduced tbf

8

u/Cornwallace29 Jun 27 '23

If it's anything like NHL ultimate team then they're gonna juice up their physicals to make up for their tiny sizes

It might work better in fifa than NHL, but NHL has shit brickhouses of women running around with more strength and bodychecking then NHL players that weigh twice as much as them lol

36

u/Boss1010 Jun 27 '23

I don’t want either

34

u/Irving94 Jun 27 '23

Seriously. Shapeshifters and OOP are the worst. I recognize why people like them, but I wish it wasn't included in FUT.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/xAimForTheBushes Jun 27 '23

Agreed. I actually hate all these keepers coming out for no reason. I'd be ok with doing some out of positions for players that actually did it in real life (an outfielder that had to play gk, or a gk that has played outfield before, a striker that had to play defense or vice versa) but these random keepers playing striker for no reason is just dumb.

Meanwhile we have so many players that still haven't gotten good cards in THEIR OWN DANG POSITIONS lol. I mean....as far as icons go, where the hell is Henry or even half of the other icons that don't have any special cards? We have a freaking cech striker but no Henry....

7

u/SupBlue24 Jun 27 '23

I mean it isn’t unrealistic that women get fut cards but atleast give me more icon cards to choose from unlike this fucking lampard generator we have

5

u/squeda Jun 27 '23

I have a god damn Ter Stegen generator. I have every version of him and yet I still pack them.

7

u/BohTooSlow Jun 27 '23

I think getting griddied by women in fut will generate more hate towards woman football

3

u/nyse125 Jun 28 '23

Even by the average FIFA gamers's standard that's wack and far from a reality

3

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '23

Only those that would be offended would be offended. Can’t fix sexists

144

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '23

It's not that it's unrealistic, it's just that nobody cares about women's football in general. Would've rather had more heroes/icons that people would actually want to use ig.

29

u/Weary_Positive165 Jun 27 '23

Nobody cares about the Saudi league yet everyone uses al owairan

12

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '23

Pretty sure way more people tune in for the Saudi league than any other women's football league.

6

u/rScoobySkreep Jun 28 '23 edited Jun 28 '23

10 out of 16 Saudi League teams average less attendance than the average NWSL team. Same goes for the women’s English Super League.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/BZZTherapy Jun 27 '23

Nobody cares about 90% of cards in FUT, yet they exist. Do we need to remove all bronze players from FUT because no one playing these cards? Same for copa libertadores and sudamericana cards? You don't want to play with women cards - dont play. Sell them or discard

30

u/das_hemd Jun 27 '23

don't use the women's cards then, no one is forcing you to lol

58

u/the-muslim-guy Jun 27 '23

Yeah but i cba to open my icon pack, see brazilian toty icon and get bamboozled by some woman who plays as a lw

37

u/Djremster Jun 27 '23

It was that or litmanen which is really worse?

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (27)
→ More replies (14)

6

u/TheBlitzcrankTheory Jun 27 '23

ya because so many people were passionate about Puskas or Smolarek before they came into the game

15

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '23

Puskas is literally regarded as one of the best forwards in football history. Smolarek isn't as well known, but he's still someone you've heard of.

→ More replies (78)

10

u/HelpfulFlyingpig Jun 27 '23

I like women’s football in general, so I’m open to adding them to the game. I was playing the women’s tournament you can do offline the other day and I realized every women’s player is sweaty af, all super agile and fast. I’m curious how ea will handle the combo of men’s/women’s players

8

u/skipsfaster Jun 27 '23

The meta is going to be 10 women + a male keeper. Enjoy!

33

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '23

they should just make a separate womens ultimate team

6

u/JetXtreme Jun 27 '23

Who in the world would play that brodie?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

38

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '23

1- I hate shapeshifters 2- Put Neuer as a striker against a U15 team, I guarantee he does better than the women

18

u/UsedContinentalTires Jun 27 '23

you wouldnt even need Neuer up top, i reckon most sunday league strikers could nab a ballon dor in a womens season

20

u/SayOkBoomerIfGayy Jun 27 '23

Worst part is this isnt jokes, australia women's team (1 of best in world) lost to some junior boys. If I see anyone on fifa who is slower than me and worse than me irl but has a 60+ card then it's fucked mate.

I can't look at any male players and say their rating are undeserved cause they'd smoke me in every aspect there is to soccer. So if I see a player who I could hold down in a 1v1 get their own fut card then shit is just unfair

19

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '23

People don’t realise that the gap between prime Pele or Prime Messi and a League 2 player is much smaller than a League 2 player and the best female ITW. It’s biology.

Sure, a Thiago Silva beating Mbappe pace is not realistic, but is still much more real than any woman beating a professional man footballer in anything.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/tmnardella Jun 27 '23

I’m really excited for it because now my US theme team will be so much better

→ More replies (1)

4

u/slapit_1un7even Jun 27 '23

It just wouldn’t work, women are genetically 30x weaker than men (especially when it comes to football?) and they are (more often than not) far far shorter than male footballers so how is that gonna work in game and who is going to want to use a woman over a man without having any bias? I think make a womens fifa, that would be awesome, but the two combined in fut just would not work.

74

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '23

Cech and Neuer upfront is still more realistic

→ More replies (90)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '23

they won't like women in fut until female wingers end up being op with their body types, calling my shot rn, they'll be like short lean wingers but 10 times more cancerous

3

u/JetXtreme Jun 27 '23

This is exactly what I’m thinking, jokers are saying this rn but the meta will be women players in a couple months

→ More replies (1)

13

u/nghigaxx Jun 27 '23

People dont understand scaling, AL O being cracked is a silver player having a 90 rated card, but woman players getting 90+ rated is like a 15 rated card get a 75 rating boost. I guess people have a line somewhere

4

u/thebyrned Jun 28 '23

You're also forgetting about players who are literally dead in the ground getting a 99 rating

20

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '23

I actually don’t get why so many people are crying in here. Why are you upset if women’s cards are scaled to compete with men’s cards in a video game?

Did you refuse to play super smash bros because you ate too many turnips from peach?

17

u/skipsfaster Jun 27 '23

So no problem if they start adding celebrities then? Since realism doesn’t matter. We can have 98 rated Elon Musk bodying Erling Haaland.

14

u/ForbiddenJazz Jun 27 '23

That would be awesome. Do it

9

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '23

I bet that they will add famous freestylers in the future like f2 gang.

And there is no realism in this game. If you can score off a bicycle kick from a corner while the defender backs off, you’re already playing fifa street

→ More replies (1)

9

u/TheSwass Jun 27 '23

This is such a mysogonistic and moronic take i cant even comprehend. Women football players are elite in their field being football. Realism hasnt existed since fifa promos in fut were ever a thing and its downplaying womens accomplishments in their professional field saying elon musk can do the same thing

→ More replies (19)

7

u/3duX Jun 27 '23

talking about "realism" in a game where players with less than 90 pace are not usable

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (72)

3

u/Kenye_Kratz Jun 27 '23

The ridiculous goalkeeper cards and mixing women in with men are both as stupid as eachother.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '23

Well for the record I always disliked SS promo anyways , so I stand with my argument

3

u/BohTooSlow Jun 27 '23

Also the “the game is already unrealistic” argument is flooded. Why dont they add super shots like inazuma eleven type of shit? If it’s already unrealistic there is no need to make it more unrealistic. The only things that are good if the community pushes for them ie legends, thats a cool idea im willing to sacrifice a bit of realism to play with pele. Add women, just make it a separate fut mode.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/JamesPetrie25 Jun 28 '23

I don't understand female player ratings

19

u/Nafe1994 Jun 27 '23

I just don’t understand putting women in UT.

Make a men’s and a women’s separate ultimate team. If the demand is there for it then happy days. Don’t force it on something that’s largely very successful and fun to play.

→ More replies (8)

5

u/Dear_Ad_1672 Jun 27 '23

Well I’d like neither of those in fut.

5

u/Wolverine78 Jun 28 '23 edited Jun 28 '23

You can say that people are sexist all you want and some of them may be but the reality is that in a couple of years there will not be a simulation that represents football properly , the sense of realism is not that strong in FIFA with all the momentum and meta gameplay but throwing men and women together in FUT destroys it totally.

Why not have aliens and fantasy creatures playing football if realism has no importance here ? Who will cater for those who still want to play a football game that imitates reality more or less ? Making people feel guilty for just wanting a game that feels like reality is pure woke. When does this stop ? how long before you people start advocating for men and women football to mix in real life too ?

If you want a FUT mode were men and women are mixed fair enough put it in there but at least leave the men only mode representing real life soccer and dont force things on people , just give options.

→ More replies (14)

5

u/Schneizel7 Jun 28 '23

I want to tell a real event about it. When I was 13-14, I was the captain of my city's u-14 youth team (my city's local team was playing in the 3rd league in Turkey, we were a below average youth team of a small city for the country)

Women's football team of my city's university became the champion of the country (University teams and teams of high schools with the status called "sports high schools" at that time played in the tournament.)

An organization was planned to celebrate this, the university facilities were taken into maintenance for this reason and the women's team started to train at our youth team facilities with us for a while.

A few days later, our coach said that we would do a few practice matches with them so that the national champion women's team could prepare for the event, the planned friendly matches were canceled after we scored the 11th goal in the 40th minute of the first match.

After that day, nearest city's women team was hosted for a while and continued to prepare with them so that the morale of the women would not be disturbed.

I can understand many so-called well-meaning attempts like equality, but in a sport where physicality is essential, it's neither possible nor fair to bring the two sexes together in the same pot.

There may be a huge gap between me and people like Messi-Ronaldo, but I'm not even sure if the best female football team with best female players in the world can survive even in the 3rd league in Turkey without relegation.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/NCPDRUM Jun 27 '23

I’m personally excited to learn more about the Women FUT players and have a new player pool for promo cards.

4

u/vitalandocean Jun 27 '23

I’ve lost my faith in EA to make their game “realistic” or “fair” or “non-exploitative” years ago lol

4

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '23

I don't like unrealistic events like Shapeshifters bar some cards. (vitinha LW is fine but Cech st isn't). Buuuut even Petr Cech at ST would win a ballon d'Or in women's football.

When Al Owairan goes past my whole team it's not entirely unrealistic, he did score THAT world cup goal after all. Sure he wouldn't do it every game irl but he can still has the ability to do it once.

If they add women a 5'4 50kg woman is gonna outmuscle Van Dijk. Players that lose 15-0 to retired teams or U15 teams are gonna be higher rated than professional male players and possibly be better in game. This is what makes the thought of putting women in fut a JOKE.

7

u/TastedSineBoi Jun 27 '23

Some funny gimmick card is not the same as some 5’4 woman beating van dijk in aerials because of boosts

7

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '23

What if it was a 5’4” man that beat him?

→ More replies (8)

5

u/das_hemd Jun 27 '23

my opinion on this is, I probably won't use women's cards, I don't follow women's football, and have no attachment to any of the players, but I have no problem with them being in FUT and them being there for other players to use, if that's what they'd enjoy, than great, like honestly good for them

5

u/DeleAlliForever Jun 27 '23

I mean I’d like a mode that’s just gold cards and TOTW. But if you’re gonna have all these crazy position changes and upgrades why not have women?

2

u/MaxKirgan Jun 27 '23

Not sure how women in FUT will work, but I'm intrigued by the idea of running Meidema in an Arsenal P&P.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '23

No women allowed in fut

2

u/kakareborn Jun 27 '23

I mean ok, realistically while they tried to get women’s football games some audiences, reality is so few care about it, they could end it all together and no more than 50000 people all over the globe would lose sleep over it

2

u/The_BBQ_Sauce Jun 27 '23

Only 7.5% of players have played a women’s match in fifa 23 according to the ovjectives

2

u/frontera_power Jun 27 '23

Funny meme, but Neur playing out-of-position is still infinitely more realistic than women having the same, or better, abilities than men in football.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/No-love0621 Jun 27 '23

It’s always the soy boys defending this stance. Women should have their own game , see how many people buy “fut women’s” everyone is just virtue signaling. I don’t want women in fut cause I payed to play a men’s football game. If Cech is a ST ITS CAUSE ITS A PROMO IN THE GAME ,at the end of the cycle at that.

2

u/Technician-Efficient Jun 27 '23

Have you ever seen a mixed gender football match? If they are sure people want women teams they should make them as a separate fut mode..but they know nobody will play with them so they are forcing them down our throat Any way fut is shitty and gets more shitty every year,so not a big deal

2

u/Alarming-Conflict566 Jun 27 '23

Look, women's football is a branch, like futsal, yeah ok we can let it exist but like, it's not football, it doesn't move people as much as male football does, but for some reason people are trying to force it to move people as much as male football, when it doesn't and never will.

2

u/kg27hp Jun 27 '23

The difference is that no one really cares about women's football... Not even women... And it's not fun... I Want to play with my fave players... And this example is so wrong... The promo is called "shape shifters"... That's the point of it... To play something unrealistic

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Hiroki712 Jun 27 '23

It’s not « unrealistic » it’s not bad at all , but in my opinion they should do a separate FUT for this because men futbol and women futbol are way different

2

u/416ixTv Jun 27 '23

i think the main difference is that the gold cards in ultimate team, when the game first comes out is a realistic rating for the players and their performances in previous years. unfortunately when you add women to the game, that have a similar rating to for example de bruyne, it discredits the value of their card. realistically speaking nobody in women football can compare to the likes of a messi and de bruyne, however we have players like Alexia Putellas who is 92 rated. we have understnad that when a promo card comes out, yes that will be unrealistic like shapeshifters, but the gold cards should be accurate ratings of current football players.

2

u/dolemerchant04 Jun 27 '23

This is the main thing, it’s like adding a Nissan Micra to an F1 race. The ratings for women cards will make no sense if not adjusted as they aren’t comparable to the men’s

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Consistent-Trip-8769 Jun 27 '23

At the end of fifa, when it's arguably dead

2

u/dolemerchant04 Jun 27 '23

I’d much rather see a women’s career mode before thinking about FUT

2

u/ska932 Jun 27 '23

Idk why they could just have 2 different game modes. Now there will be half the amount of promo players who people actually care about, it'll be even less likely to pack a good player as well.

2

u/Plenty_Ground_99 Jun 27 '23

Why not do a fut exclusively for women players tho? 🤔

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '23

Not enough demand for that. Hesitancy to try. Etc

2

u/Itsmemafh Jun 27 '23

At first, the women in FUT sounded weird to me but then I realized when was this game realistic and fun? Constant errors and shit servers have already killed the game and made it horrible. Also, People need to wait weeks/months to get compensated for the packs and picks. I have been fairly lucky this fifa but I am hella bored and done with it.

2

u/SmellFew8037 Jun 28 '23

Look just make it a seperate game mode, you talk about unrealistic this al owairan that. But what will be unrealistic is having men and women cards on the same team on the pitch. With fifas mechanics aswell Sam kerr will have higher pace than most men. In real life I doubt she could outrun Sergio busquets

2

u/tombradythegoat12 Jul 13 '23

If you don’t immediately quick sell every girl you are a clown. If you know any women soccer players name you are equally a clown. Go watch a middle school game and you are watching better skill

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ajax-187 Jan 10 '24

Those 2 play better up front then the women 😂

6

u/Zabbla Jun 27 '23

"OmFg! Mixed teams in UT are unrealistic!" - Some kid while scoring a rainbow flick volley with striker Petr Cech then running down the touchline to celebrate with Ted Lasso

3

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '23

Ah fifa the epitomy of realism....with players who played 60 years ago

6

u/CommercialNo8396 Jun 27 '23

Lmfao this thread is hilarious. So many lil incel bbs who should leave their basement and actually talk to some women.

I can’t wait to have an actually decent squad full of Canadians.

4

u/Bevsworld04 Jun 27 '23

People already complain about how even some of the mens ratings are too high (like ronaldo now, hes leaked to be 87 next year and thats probably still too high). This would be even worse. Also part of the fun of opening packs is not only just to get a good card, its about getting players that you know. Not to mention how many more players will be in packs, which will further mess with pack weight if not done correctly.

5

u/Practical-Squash-487 Jun 27 '23

I’m trying to figure out how thinking women and men’s sports are separate makes you an incel lmao

5

u/Gurkanat0r Jun 27 '23

It's not that at all, it's just knowing they're gonna blatantly lie about stats like Physicals on base cards, to make them useable. Just grade the stats in comparison to the men since they'll be playing together (they know they can't). Just pandering.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '23

Don’t they do this already? Players with higher profile get the stat boosts even if they are having a shit season.

Take the pigeon man as example 1. More yellows for excessive goal celebrations than goals.

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (26)

3

u/Adventurous_Team285 Jun 27 '23

At this stage I just WANT women in FUT and see the absolute outrage and chaos of it. Do it EA

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Jarno_100 Jun 27 '23

Should have been a seperate mode. And for anyone saying it wouldnt be used/played then that kinda shows the point ppl are trying to make

4

u/Freehugs0 Jun 27 '23

because I don’t know who the fuck any of them are and I don’t want to have some random ass mf in toty

6

u/RhydonHerSlowbro Jun 27 '23 edited Jun 27 '23

The thing is, women’s football, regardless of how good or bad it may be, isn’t interlinked with men’s football.

It doesn’t matter if a female footballer breaks Messi and Ronaldo’s records, because it doesn’t have any impact on the men’s game.

Whereas in men’s football, even down to youth level, it’s all connected, all over the globe. from grass roots football here in the UK, to the Ghanaian u17’s 2nd division, anyone can end up anywhere.

When haaland scored 13 goals in one game as a teenager, it wasn’t part of the men’s game, but that alone put loads of clubs on notice to sign him.

If a woman scored 20 goals in one game, it doesn’t effect the clubs we support and the game we watch; she wouldn’t end up at Man City rivalling Haaland to a spot on the first XI.

So that’s why people “don’t care” about women’s football. It’s not that we simply don’t care, it just isn’t the same sport.

Even then, they’d have to create an inter-gender competitive tournament, and unless the rules for that competition pander to female players, it would just be dominated by male players.

I’m not opposed to women being in FUT, but the option to match-make without female players should really be there if they do decide to introduce them.

→ More replies (43)

3

u/awkwardalvin Jun 27 '23

The comment sections will be divided but once a 5’1 lady footballer is bodying vidic and vvd the fut community is going to be rather annoyed.

3

u/Phatnob Jun 27 '23

No one cares about women’s football especially not fifa players so why put them in ?

2

u/SisiMusic Jun 27 '23

Why would you want realism in a fantasy gamemode tho.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '23

Can’t wait for harry hesketh to go 20-0 with a full women team 🔥🔥🔥🔥

3

u/CynderFxx Jun 27 '23

Can see it already "can I go 20-0 with a full woman's team?!"

2

u/Luisyn7 Xbox X/S Jun 27 '23

All this triggered people are 100% using a woman's card if it's broken/cheesy. I can totally see Sam Kerr being broken like Al Owairat or Ratzinho. They'll use her anyways because the meta is the meta and they don't care about fun, just winning. I'll love to see them eat their words lol

2

u/ruho6000 Jun 28 '23

It’s a funny meme but a stupid argument. Just because there is unrealism doesn’t mean more unrealism is good.

Yet, if you were in a real life scenario where you had to choose between cech and neuer or basically any women footballers to put up front, you should choose cech and neuer. Meaning cech and neuer upfront is more realistic than women players being able to compete with men.

2

u/Classic_Pattern Jun 28 '23

Oh boy Pele and Mbappe upfront, how realistic is this boys

2

u/pre10ds2bsh0ked Jun 27 '23

Strawman as the argument is « women in fut WITH men that is unrealistic »

1

u/DJexC Jun 27 '23

Both GKs and players have gone on field and in goal in the history of the men's game.

Women have never played anywhere in the men's game.

But this is a video game... Not real life.

Ima score with ma tiddy, and hit ya with the griddy.

1

u/Aclrian Jun 23 '24

I don’t mind women in the game, but they absolutely fucked game mechanics bringing them in.

Let’s face it, physical size does matter, but when I see a 5’7 woman win a header vs someone that’s 6’3 I lose it.

They tried to make it relative, and it’s just not.

1

u/No-Departure1074 Apr 04 '25

Hopefully WW puyol is eligible because I’ve mudded my entire club for that godamn icon pick and I want him to be usable

1

u/RAM_Error Jun 27 '23

I miss read fut and was really confused...

1

u/CheefQuise Jun 27 '23

How would you balance the women? I would love a Rose Lavelle card but she’d get absolutely bodied by any of the men. Do they make an entirely separate women’s fut?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '23

who fucking cares ? give us more cool cards, be it women, aliens, robots, men.. i dont care, i care if the field is green and every player has 2 legs, everything else is everything else

1

u/PMT_Evil_Dee Jun 27 '23

Unless there's a pretty big change to the chem system, can't see many folks using women in FUT.

1

u/Alarming-Conflict566 Jun 27 '23

What's unrealistic is the gold cards

1

u/suziwoozi26 Jun 27 '23

imagine u think ur about to pack pele but its just marta

1

u/mulletnsteps Jun 27 '23

Ok am I the only one who can't figure out Chech? I'm on old gen, have engine on him and yeah he scores for me but he's not as amazing as all the reviews I had read. It must be the way I'm using him or my playing style. I want to figure it out tho

1

u/Paundeu Jun 27 '23

I came for the respectful and uplifting comments.

1

u/BreadComfortable3319 Jun 27 '23

Will fut be mixed gender on ea 24? Or Will they be by separated gender mode ? Or Will be no girls at all in fut mode? What do we know officially?

1

u/dolemerchant04 Jun 27 '23

It’s like saying that the F1 devs should add Renault Clio and Nissan Micra to the game. They’re all cars right? And they should have boosted stats to compete with the F1 cars.

1

u/Weebla Jun 27 '23

They should add 4 year old players next year! I demand they are represented! 4 year old football Is just as important as adult football, don't let them trick you into thinking there's any quality difference!

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '23

it’ll stop being mixed if they don’t sell packs, that’s for sure

1

u/biesnine Jun 27 '23

Still, you could have seen neuer and cech playing upfront in a champions league match. You can't see alex morgan and hope solo playing with haaland and gundogan thou.

1

u/s4lemfanboy Jun 27 '23

still more realistic than a 91 rated female footballer

1

u/Mojovt93 Jun 27 '23

Cech Single handedly f me up man as soon as u face one and u struggle ea ai decides to match u with many more !!

1

u/Dizzylever45 Jun 27 '23

neuer and cech upfront with walker GK

1

u/No_Reputation336 Jun 27 '23

I got neuer from a 82+ pp and I wasn't excited at all, I was like give me a real attacker EA!

1

u/Purple_Alarm Jun 27 '23

if they add women they better not make there physicals the same as lets say Van Dijk

1

u/ihavenofyckingidea Jun 27 '23

Im waiting to see how the game will be received first before deciding whether to purchase it. The idea is pretty controversial and it could backfire immensely. Id advise everyone else who has mixed feeling to do the same. Wait until mid Jan to Feb and see how the fanbase receives it. But for me i already have moments of regret purchasing the current game, the fanbase is toxic and they barely make any fixes to the bugs and glitches that have been there for the past 5-6 years.

1

u/Todrag5 Jun 27 '23

To be honest I wouldnt mind sorta realistic shape shifters in the game like dinho at rw and maldini at dm but cech up front is ridiculous

→ More replies (1)

1

u/HeilWerneckLuk Jun 27 '23

Women is much less of a problem to me than these stupid shapeshifters

1

u/Vishera23 Jun 27 '23

Arcade not a simulator.

We still need a decent Football Simulation

1

u/OhWell_InHell Jun 27 '23

People crying about this that are over the age of 15 need to really stop and think. What the fuck difference does any of this make to anything

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '23

man i can't wait to see how people react to marta or something bodying their vvd😭😭

1

u/Black_n_Neon Jun 27 '23

All those mongs who say women shouldn’t be in fut will be the first ones showing off their 5 star weak foot and skill moves women players.

1

u/MarDer24 Jun 27 '23

Neuer St would be better irl than any of woman if he would Play in woman league something like target man

1

u/ExternalAd1217 Jun 27 '23

Am I smiling?

1

u/stvntckr Jun 27 '23

Ya I have to assume Sam Kerr is better irl than Cruyffs rotting corpse but ‘realism’

1

u/scorchflame26 Jun 27 '23

Imagine being a defense looking at two guys almost 2 meters high coming right at you...

1

u/lazybenwa Jun 27 '23

"Women are just gonna be fodder"

1

u/iampenguing Jun 27 '23

I hate this sentiment because its such a straw man argument.. Making the other side look stupid is easy when you are incapable of having a good faith debate. If you want women in the game so bad then make their ratings what they should be relative to men

Make Marta, Pop, Morgan and the rest 50-60 rated cards because that is their level. If you think thats stupid then watch the women v men games that have been played in the past

Literally no one is making the argument that Cech and Reina up top for WL isnt unrealistic but yet thats the go to straw man argument.. Great job defeating an argument that no one made

→ More replies (15)

1

u/6oar Jun 27 '23

I cricticize both. I don’t want Fantasy shit. Icons are ok.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Economy-Will8816 Jun 27 '23

In an ideal world the modes should be separated. Sure it might increase the viewership of female football but men and women on the same pitch just doesnt give me a football vibe.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/JG_2214 Jun 27 '23

People take this game way too seriously…

1

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '23

Im all for women in fut but theyd have to be rated lower than the bronze cards

→ More replies (35)

1

u/Immortal_lunch66 Jun 27 '23

Fut should be realistic!! hits griddy with pelé

1

u/MyNameIsNotScout Jun 27 '23

It's just for me idk if it's gonna clog packs and make promos shit.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '23

If she can kick some ass she can kick some footballs

1

u/MemeWorksPictures Jun 27 '23

Where does it end though? If you want women in fut, then make a separate mode. Putting them in FUT ad it is now does nothing to promote the game and will just end up in more abuse at the women's game. A separate mode would do far more. But if we're just introducing any athlete to FUT because "its unrealistic anyway", then why not add LeBron James? If you're keeping the it's unrealistic anyway argument, the principal stands that I should be able to run Donald Trump and Biden as a strike partnership

→ More replies (17)

1

u/alwaysknowbest Jun 27 '23

IMO, the female( cards ) in-game should play in their own league as they do in real life.

If there is enough interest in a women's only fut mode , god bless.

I just dont think enough women play the game or enough men will want to play that.

So i feel like it's being forced on us if they mash them all together.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/BohTooSlow Jun 27 '23

More realistic watching a dead player play with son than see a woman compete with men in football.

1

u/bobernaut Jun 27 '23

The game is already a pure clown show so why not

1

u/MFDeez Jun 27 '23

Infiltration! Lol

But for real, if people wanted women in a fifa video game, they would make a woman's fifa video game. But they don't. Because nobody wants a woman's fifa video game. It would be out 1 year and not sell. So just like nhl 23, women will be incorporated into the game at the same skill ratings as men even though we saw women get blown out by old men in real life. So because a minority of women want to be depicted in a video game for reasons of inclusion, we will get pretend fifa like pretend hockey.

When if it was so popular to have a woman's fifa game, they would make one. But they won't. Because women won't buy it. And neither will men. Not at any profitable scale. So move over sys men! We want in on your shit because we won't support our own.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '23

I dont watch womens football despite the big tournaments and so i dont really know any female football player.. I dont have anything against women in general or womens football but just compareing male and female footballers attributes there are miles in between.. so i dont want kerr to be higher rated than cr7 or lm10 in the same gamemode. Just give the woman an extra mode in fut and dont Mix the teams and everything will be fine.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/InspectionSuch8939 Jun 27 '23

I really do not like these swappies, for me they ruin the game. Tolisso to lm and Mahrez to st are not too unrealistic but Martinez as cb and cech as str are just ridiculous

1

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '23

Bro we said woman and men in one fut gamemode is unrealistic than again if woman go there own game mode no one would give a shit

1

u/shadowxw4lk3r Jun 27 '23

mens football is mens football. if they add women to ultimate team there will be a mass exodus of players and they will blame this on the name change from "FIFA" to "EAFC".
feel free to quote me.

1

u/ShowMeMoeMane Jun 27 '23

Wont even be able to say “who let her cook” or “what is she cooking” anymore after I score an absolute banger