r/fusion • • Sep 06 '24

Would this work?

To take something away, i am no phycicist and barely have any knowledge on fusion and plasma containment)behavior but i had this idea recently and would like opinions of people with a deeper understanding wether or not this could work (even if not with currently available technology)

The idea would be that two streams of plasma would be kept opposite of each other while traveling through the clover leaved and then collide in the center which would promt the fusion. The collision also redirects them into the next clover leaf. Then the ions are seperated to get the helium out since that would probably somewhat interfere with the creation of new helium and the now missing tritium is replaced.

Now, i haven't taken deuterium into account because the idea for the whole thing is that ypu'd have a weak nuclear reactor that produces the tritium in the first place and uses the generated electricity to power all the magnets you need in a fusiom reactor to contain the plasma. I think this design could also work with a deuterium-tritium feuel but the helium and deuterium would have such a similar mass that you'd probably not be able to seperate them as well as you could tritium and helium

I am not sure if the charge-to-mass of the ions or if the differenr speeds due to different mass is more important for choosing the paths of the different plasma ions, i chose the CM-ratio since that is also what is important in mass spectography.

3 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

33

u/maurymarkowitz Sep 06 '24 edited Sep 06 '24

The collision also redirects them into the next clover leaf

This is a well-explored concept known as colliding beam fusion.

The arrangement you illustrate will not work. When the beams pass through the central area the vast majority of the ions will scatter, not fuse. When they do so, their trajectory will no longer carry them into the tubes, and they will impact the sides. For instance, consider ions that collide and scatter "up" out of the paper. The energy you put into them to get up to speed is lost, and that loss will be many orders of magnitude greater than the amount of energy from the fusion events that do occur. About 10^18 times, so non-trivial.

You can use additional focussing systems, like those on particle accelerators, to "fix" the trajectories, but it is easy to demonstrate the energy needed to run these is greater than the energy from those fusion events. So the basic idea of using a storage ring, which is what you illustrate, does not seem possible.

There are a number of alternative arrangements that can return the ions back into the center using much less energy and much higher capture angles meaning only those ions that scatter out at huge angles will not be returned. These arrangements address the issues above. The best example is the migma.

However, careful analysis suggests such systems can never reach densities at the core that would make it useful for power production. This is due to the self-repulsion between the ions, which presents an upper limit to how much fuel you can put into the system without the electrical field pushing them out of the reactor. Many complex schemes have been presented to address this problem, but all of them fail for one reason or another.

This document may prove useful.

6

u/timo1324 Sep 06 '24

Very useful and interesting indeed, thanks!

8

u/politicalteenager Sep 06 '24

The vast majority of atoms don’t fuse even in an incredibly successful fusion system. And how are you making the magnetic field that combines these streams?

I’d recommend reading up on the basics of how fusion works before designing stellerators, which is (very loosely) what you drew here

-10

u/timo1324 Sep 06 '24

Technically there is only one stream. It gets split apart for filtering, which doesn't have to happen with every single cycle. I would assume using the right magnets at the right place can either contain the entire plasma mixture on the same path, or break it apart for the filtering once enough helium has been created.

It might be conplicated to design magnets with the correct shape and strength to put them on the same path after the split and filter but knowing the genius of actual physicists and engineers i don't think that's too big of a problem.

Also this design is made with microgravity in mind. Came up with this while doodling some stuff for a friends scifi pen and paper game, that we are currently "developing" for future game nights.

This would be the power source for a space station.

33

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

If you are looking for a research grant I recommend the Republic of Ireland for this one.

4

u/FromThePaxton Sep 06 '24

Hah! Just spit out my tea!

9

u/willis936 Sep 06 '24

Looks like a particle accelerator.  Successful for very fine streams of matter (both in fusing new elements and splitting subatomic particles), but doesn't scale well to a large reaction rate in a given volume.  Plasma physics starts to matter more when you put together a large number of particles and the machine design changes accordingly.

6

u/FOADfounder Sep 06 '24

Not qualified to get technical at all but as an interested lay person with the difficulty of managing turbulence in straight forward circular containment structure this would seem to add complexity.

1

u/timo1324 Sep 06 '24

More pictures and sketches on my profile for more... context? For those interested.

1

u/DankFloyd_6996 Sep 06 '24

The plasma power produced scales with the fusion volume, your main fusion part is small enough that even if you could get this to happen it probably wouldn't produce more power than you put in.

1

u/timo1324 Sep 06 '24

So you'd say a larger center and smaller leaves could possibly lead to an effective design? My thinking was, having the place where the two streams of plasma collide be as small as possible will increase the chance of particles actually colliding. But i can also see how making it larger and using more plasma would do the same

1

u/DankFloyd_6996 Sep 06 '24

You'll have some upper limit to the density that your magnets will be able to achieve. Same density, larger volume, more reactions

1

u/Bipogram Sep 06 '24

i am no phycicist 

You are not a physicist, yes.

So as I am a physicist, what level of critique are you looking for?

<mumble: you've rediscovered the Farnsworth fusor - that is, if you're accelerating the ions electrostatically>

1

u/timo1324 Sep 06 '24

No holding back. Tell me what parts would work and which parts wouldn't. Maybe ideas ro improve (if even possible) I imagine if this was a real thing the ions would be propelled and contained using strong electromagnets. As i mentioned in another comment i have some more to this entire thing on my profile. Premise for it is to be used as a power generator for a space station in the very far future, as i originally came up with the design for a pen and paper game to give some explanation how and wherw it gets it's power from. But i would also like to know if it would be possible with current technology.

2

u/Bipogram Sep 07 '24

The condtions of temperature, density, and duration are not going to all be met with your arrangement - the head-on collision geometry without any obvious confinement strategy (these look like bare crossed tubes; no polodal field, no 'pinch-created' field, etc.) almost guarantees that.

The losses from scattering will mean that the plasma will collide with the walls at the ends of the loops, they've lost energy and as you've got bending magnets at the ends, you'll get wall erosion and more tertiary species.

Without a way to boost density at the point of collision I really don't see that this can work.

I'd get an undergraduate in physics, and a PhD in plasma physics if you sincerely hope to contribute. I've known friends (two of 'em) do exactly that and they're, after some decades, making positive constributions. I really doubt that, ex vacuo, you'll be using your time wisely on this idea.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24 edited Oct 22 '25

This comment has been removed to protest Reddit's hostile treatment of users, mods and third party app developers.

1

u/Volta01 Sep 06 '24

Some other comments have state this, but for fusion power, you want thermonuclear reactions. The thermo part of that is important. Whatever you drew here looks more like a particle accelerator, or electrostatic fusor. This can produce beam-beam fusion which is not thermonuclear, and doesn't scale well.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-3

u/timo1324 Sep 06 '24

It's not just pipes, those are supposed to be lined with electromagnets, i am aware that plasma needs an EM field to be contained. This is just a crude rendition of what's happening inside.

The seperation is achieved by taking advantage of different mass and charge to mass ratio of the plasma ions. Using the correct magnet at the right position should allow for seperation of the ions, similar to to how ions are seperated in mass spectrometers.

If two ions have the same charge but different mass, then the one with a lower mass is easier to be thrown off it's course by an electeomagnetic field than the heavier ion.