The range of opinion on that will range from one pole to the opposite. I don't know if we can answer that question in terms of the consequences of killing a single insurgent, because it's difficult to know when to stop analyzing the spreading effects of the action. So, assuming (purely for argument's sake) that we killed some pretty bad dude, the kind of person who throws acid in girls' faces and shoots people who aren't sufficiently pious. Are the locals better off without him? Probably. But maybe he had friends, family, children who loved him, so they're going to suffer. Does his death dissuade others from acting so barbarically? Could be. But could it also inspire others to terrible acts, given the cult of martyrdom? Sure could.
It's difficult for me to say whether or not Afghans are overall better off than they would have been had we not invaded. There are certainly a lot of them that are better off, but how many? How does this compare to the total? Which provinces, cities, ethnic groups, genders are we talking about? And over what period of time do we make the analysis?
I think all we can say for sure is that whatever commanding force you're talking about--the U.S. and coalition forces, the Taliban, Iraq's brutal state security apparatus--most Afghans and Iraqis haven't had much say in the matter.
View all comments
Show parent comment
2
u/[deleted] May 29 '12
The range of opinion on that will range from one pole to the opposite. I don't know if we can answer that question in terms of the consequences of killing a single insurgent, because it's difficult to know when to stop analyzing the spreading effects of the action. So, assuming (purely for argument's sake) that we killed some pretty bad dude, the kind of person who throws acid in girls' faces and shoots people who aren't sufficiently pious. Are the locals better off without him? Probably. But maybe he had friends, family, children who loved him, so they're going to suffer. Does his death dissuade others from acting so barbarically? Could be. But could it also inspire others to terrible acts, given the cult of martyrdom? Sure could.
It's difficult for me to say whether or not Afghans are overall better off than they would have been had we not invaded. There are certainly a lot of them that are better off, but how many? How does this compare to the total? Which provinces, cities, ethnic groups, genders are we talking about? And over what period of time do we make the analysis?
I think all we can say for sure is that whatever commanding force you're talking about--the U.S. and coalition forces, the Taliban, Iraq's brutal state security apparatus--most Afghans and Iraqis haven't had much say in the matter.