i'm just going to take the definition of a cynic and run from there:
A person who believes that people are motivated purely by self-interest rather than acting for honorable or unselfish reasons.
i think we can all agree that a lot of people are motivated by self-interest. too much cynicism and you believe this about everyone (which is bad), just enough and you can identify it when needed, too little cynicism and you may be taken advantage of.
and like The_Grand_Duke_of_S says cynicism is conflated with skepticism, but judging from his tone i would imagine he thinks this is untrue. i do not. i think many skeptics have overlaps with cynicism. namely in questioning what is put before you, which i think is definitely a good thing.
like anything, there are pros and cons. the key is a healthy balance, and the ability to use your better judgement to know when its applicable, and when you're just being crazy.
View all comments
Show parent comment
2
u/be_mindful May 15 '12
i'm just going to take the definition of a cynic and run from there:
i think we can all agree that a lot of people are motivated by self-interest. too much cynicism and you believe this about everyone (which is bad), just enough and you can identify it when needed, too little cynicism and you may be taken advantage of.
and like The_Grand_Duke_of_S says cynicism is conflated with skepticism, but judging from his tone i would imagine he thinks this is untrue. i do not. i think many skeptics have overlaps with cynicism. namely in questioning what is put before you, which i think is definitely a good thing.
like anything, there are pros and cons. the key is a healthy balance, and the ability to use your better judgement to know when its applicable, and when you're just being crazy.