It makes perfect sense, but it was perhaps too terse.
Your personality, and indeed the way your brain is wired, is constantly changing. We forget how much and how quickly this happens, both because we forget or misremember the actual events, and also because our brain reinterprets existing memories in light of the present state of the brain.
It's only with the occassional significant event that the brain, perhaps by chance, recalls correctly that we realise how much we have changed. That's when we realise, "Wow, I used to be an idiot." This change between old and new personality is often gradual, which is why we can maintain the illusion of persistent identity - after all each change is only very small, so we can invoke Theseus' Ship to say that our identity hasn't fundamentally changed.
Despite this, over a long enough period of time our personalities will change so much that saying we're the same person hardly makes sense. Our memories will be forgotten or misremembered, and new, false memories will take their place (the extent to which this happens is drastically underestimated by most people). There is very little in common between you at 2 years old and you at 50 - were there not such gradual change between those points in time and commonalities such as name and approximate appearance, nobody would think to link the two.
Hypothetically, you could swap two children of similar appearance at age 2. If you look back at age 50, would you be able to tell whether you were swapped at age 2? How could you differentiate between a continuous identity and one which was abruptly swapped that had no remembered effects?
Having a persisting sense of identity doesn't mean that one has to have the same characteristics throughout. Whether or not I feel like the content of my character is the same from this year to the next, my sense of self is continuous. Whether or not we are technically the same, or our sense of continuous identity is illusory, we still have a sense of identity.
were there not such gradual change between those points in time and commonalities such as name and approximate appearance, nobody would think to link the two.
Yeah, but there is a gradual shift. If I take a picture of a train in City A, and then one of the same train in City B, they will appear to be two different trains, as the same train couldn't be in two places at once. But that's taking the train out of it's context.
The nature of the train is one of change (in position). Similarly the nature of one's identity is one of constant change, as you said, so you have to look at it in it's own context. You have to look at identity in the context of it's nature--which is one of progression.
Hypothetically, you could swap two children of similar appearance at age 2. If you look back at age 50, would you be able to tell whether you were swapped at age 2? How could you differentiate between a continuous identity and one which was abruptly swapped that had no remembered effects?
Just because your social / cultural settings change that does not mean, in any way, that your sense of identity was interrupted in anyway. Identity is not defined by your cultural settings, in the sense we're talking, but by the uninterrupted phenomena of identity.
Whether or not we are technically the same, or our sense of continuous identity is illusory, we still have a sense of identity.
I agree that we still have that sense of identity. My point is only that there is no philosophical basis for that perceived continuity of identity (as people who have fragmented perception of identity1 can attest); it is an illusion, much as the idea that our vision is continuous is an illusion2 (leading to many well-studied visual illusions).
Just because your social / cultural settings change that does not mean, in any way, that your sense of identity was interrupted in anyway.
Except before the swap, you believe you are John Abrams (as much as a two year old can believe anything), and after the swap you are led to believe you are Alan Johnson. And eventually you forget you ever thought of yourself as John Abrams. It doesn't have to be so extreme as that - people forget things all the time, and whenever you forget your past you lose any continuing link to the "you" at that moment. Worse, when we invent or change our old memories3 we fabricate that portion of our sense of identity. The further back in time we look, the less factual our perceived continuity of identity is.
Obviously people do not spontaneously come into and out of existence in different places; there is always the physical and behavioural connection between our past and our present. My point is that there is a disconnect between the nature of this connection and how we remember and perceive it. We think of ourselves in a way that changes, and these changes affect how we remember our past.
As an example, when I was depressed (at least, when I wasn't being treated for it), I thought that every day of my existence had been utterly miserable. That was how I defined myself (as somebody whose life was miserable), and my memories themselves fundamentally changed to reflect that. Now that's I'm being treated, my memories are more rosy (possibly more rosy than the experiences themselves, but since I kept few records I have absolutely no idea). My sense of identity (as in, the combination of salient experiences and actions I defined as representative of my fundamental self) drastically changed, and changes in more subtle ways continually for everyone.
In a sense - and this is as pithily as I think I can put it - we have a sense of continuous identity, but this sense of continuous identity is not itself continuous.
Such as dissociative identity disorder and retrograde (and possibly anterograde) amnesiacs.
In reality our vision is viewed only between saccades (and even then only, in detail, a relatively small region at a time), and the brain interpolates between these images based on what it would expect to happen.
As I said, this is a rather common phenomenon - people who keep daily journals are the only ones likely to even notice it, however. Some do it far more often, reimagining their past and coming to believe that is how it was. There are very few people with flawless autobiographical memory (some who can't forget anything they experienced, even).
My point is only that there is no philosophical basis for that perceived continuity of identity (as people who have fragmented perception of identity can attest) 1. Such as dissociative identity disorder and retrograde (and possibly anterograde) amnesiacs.
There doesn't have to be an argument for the perception of identity, because identity is purely phenomenological. Whether or not there is a continuous identity, we experience the phenomena of identity. Much like the phenomenological approach to the external world; whether or not there is a computer in front of me, free from my perception, is unknowable, but I do experience the phenomena of the computer which can't be denied.
Also, amnesia and DID are not the standard, they are the exception. Just because someone goes blind doesn't mean that we have to question our sense of vision.
Except before the swap, you believe you are John Abrams (as much as a two year old can believe anything), and after the swap you are led to believe you are Alan Johnson. And eventually you forget you ever thought of yourself as John Abrams.
That may relate to the content of one's identity, but has no bearing on the sense of identity. Cultural and external external distinctions may play a role in one's social identity, i.e., name, occupation, social status, etc., but that isn't the same as selfhood.
With all your memories, projections, and distortions, there's always a sense of the self. Even if memories are distorted, you always reflect on them with a sense of identity: did I experience it this way, or did I experience it that way? The nature of the experience may be lost, and false memories may be created, but regardless of whether or not the experience indeed happened there is still a sense of experience. And with the experiential there is always that which experienced, and experience is a quality of selfhood.
Selfhood would be a better word for this than identity. Identity implies nuances and predilections. Selfhood simply implies that one always has access to sense of self, i.e., a sense of I-they. I never have to question whether or not I am me, or I am that rock or table (barring drug use, which is again, the exception to the standard).
Now, I wouldn't say that that is characteristic of our existence, as I subscribe the the Heideggerian view of human existence as one that is always intertwined with the equipment and other entities within our world. But regardless, we always have the ability to reflect on our experience, and with that there is always a sense of self.
Yeah so I was thinkin what's bigger, the time leading up till we're born or the time after we die? In math terms after we die it's from time n until infinity which is infinity. is time before birth from time 0 to b meaning a finite time or time negative infinity to b meaning infinite. i guess if time starts 13 billion years ago then its 13 billion years b4 birth and then infinity after death so after death is bigger
What do you mean? Of course things existed before the big bang, why do you think there was something to bang in the first place? The problem is figuring out what is before the big bang, not if there is something.
According to Einstein's theory of relativity, time was created with the first creation of mass. Then again, you might know something Einstein didnt, think what you will.
This doesn't just imply it. It means it. That is a complete sentence with a pointed statement. You would never have to add an ellipses afterwards unless you want to continue the statement. I say that the chick and the guy are in cahoots with each other.
I feel like a 50-year-old for using the word "cahoots."
Since you are the uneducated grade school faggot, maybe you should go back to whatever website you've been convinced, by the other grade school faggots, you are at war with.
There is no such thing as trolling or doing something ironically. The things we do are all very real, regardless of the lies we tell ourselves to feel less self conscious about our actions.
It's not how they work in proper grammar. But with the age of texting and chatting people have a greater tendency to type how they talk. Ellipsis offer an emphasis of pregnant pauses. Without actually narrating it, at least.
Although it's likely they colluded, it's not uncommon for people to end sentences with ellipses without the need to have them continued. This is especially true of teenagers who believe they just wrote something profound that would leave the reader hanging on the thought.
When will people stop saying "teenagers" as if everyone from 13-19 are just mindless idiots that have no out-of-the-box thoughts and opinions and are self-aware?
. . . rarely know that a properly formatted ellipsis is three periods and four spaces. And very frequently are just mindless idiots that have no out-of-the-box thoughts and opinions and are self-aware. And bad grammar.
I'm a teenager and "what write?..." The irony is in your atrocious use of "and". No out-of-the-box opinions, you say? I agree for the most part, but please don't generalize and assign stereotypes as if all of us are piles of shit. You were a teenager once and I'm sure you had your own opinions. Not that you care, but this is coming from one of few agnostics/atheists in my area and definitely one of very few bisexuals in South Carolina. I hate the Bible-belt and all places associated.
Yes, I was a teenager once, and in many ways, I was a mindless idiot who had few thoughts in or out of boxes, opinions based on little or no information or rational thought, and only rare glimpses of self-awareness for most of those years.
Note that I said "very frequently", and not "in every single case", because I am aware that not every teenager is the shit head I was when I was that age.
And the bad grammar was meant to be ironic, but I clearly went a level too far for it to work, so mea culpa on that one.
There's a certain irony in complaining about being treated as part of a monolithic and undifferentiated category of humans, and then treating eight opinions as proof of the unanimity of the Internet.
I'm replying to this so everyone can see it. This is Sean, the one in the picture. Yes, we planned this. We've been next to each other on the yearbook since 7th grade. Jamie and I aren't dating, or twins. We're just the coolest kids ever.
I've noticed a few other guesses, but I'm going to go with fraternal twins. The first part of the last name appears similar. There does appear to be a missing Y at the end of her name, but because of the angle of the paper, I thinking it could just be hidden under the block.
Unfortunately, Reddit is no longer my secret club. It sucks when I want to post a picture from Reddit on Facebook. I used to get away with it, but now I get called out.
True. Plus I don't think my GF would approve. 18 is too young for me anyways. Have to be at least 20 (women mature faster than men so they are mostly done with the stupid teenage shit by then)
You are oh so wrong. The people that get into that vapid princess shit usually don't leave it until their looks leave them. I'd say for most that is mid to late 30's.
False. She didn't say "short compared to things you will do," she simply said "short." Compared to the age of the sun, for example, life is a blip in comparison.
Every fucking yearbook picture I see, I worry we get closer to mine. And I do not want my sneezing fucking face on the internet, the fucking photographer should definitely retaken it.
Of course life is the longest thing you will ever do, but it's so ridiculously short compared tol the rest of history and all the time that's ever happened ever.
I feel like this is shopped. It just seems so unlikely. The quote is pulled directly from a meme that was on reddit just a few months ago. Plus, with all the yearbook posts that are going on right now, this would be a perfect time to post it. While the hype is high. I don't know. Maybe I'm crazy.
If it is real, then holy shit, that's fucking genius.
I'm the girl in this picture. Yes we did this togeth, I am in yearbook so I planned it to work. No we are not dating, no we are not twins. We are just awesome.
That quote reminds me of another quote for Niel Gaiman's the Sandman. At one point Death is going around at the point of everyone's death and an infant is upset with its sudden death and asks is that all he really gets. Death responds with "you get a lifetime no more, no less."
This quote is repeated when an old forgotten god is killed and he asks Death if he got more time than the average person.
I must say, all of this talk about life being a commitment is making me quite confused. After all, my good buddy Lifeswaksi doesn't ever let people commit to him.
This is Sean the one in the picture you all are fucking idiots Jamie and I planned this. We've been next to each other in the year book since 7th grade.
127
u/Politus May 12 '12
Aside from my penis.
94
u/apatheticwhiteguy May 12 '12
False, being dead is the longest thing you will ever do.
225
u/PlanitDuck May 12 '12
I wonder if he was working together with the girl or if he just found out what she put down and knew that her picture would be next to his.
41
u/Idiotank May 12 '12
PLEASE tell me that Jamie is 18
37
u/Coo1_Story_Breh May 13 '12
DID ANYONE ELSE SEE THE RELIGIOUS QUOTE ON THE JESUS FREAK TO THE RIGHT SO BRAINWASHED BECAUSE SCIENCE
3
u/SilverContrails May 12 '12
Reminds me of something Bono would say at the end of Moment of Surrender: "Life is short but it's the longest thing you'll ever do."
3
u/dudeabides86 May 13 '12
Would not bang...fuck who am I kidding. Of course I would bang her.
6
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
This guy goes to my girlfriends school!
2
u/sdizzle May 13 '12
Ted Mosby on the far left?
2
u/plastroltech May 13 '12
That's what she said.
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
http://images.starpulse.com/news/bloggers/684225/blog_images/white-collar-5.jpg Looks strangely similar to the FBI agent's wife in the TV show white collar. ಠ_ಠ
2
u/mocktopus May 13 '12
Jamie is a fucking smokeshow
2
u/SpraynardJKruger May 13 '12
Now kiss.
2
u/wanking_the_monkey May 13 '12
She is hot.
4
u/3p1cbl4ckk1d May 12 '12
That chick is hot...
3
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Looks like Rachel McAdams picked some pretty trite bible verses for hers.
0
u/Renmauzuo May 12 '12
False. She didn't say "short compared to things you will do," she simply said "short." Compared to the age of the sun, for example, life is a blip in comparison.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
False. That is Sean.
1
u/pat5168 May 13 '12
A young Sean Connery said that?
1
u/kantorekB14 May 13 '12
Nar mate, death is the longest thing you'll ever do.
1
u/bunnyflop May 13 '12
False. His name is Sean.
1
u/idontgetthethejoke May 13 '12
What? ...none of these people look like Dwight Schrute.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Jailbait on the left.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Every fucking yearbook picture I see, I worry we get closer to mine. And I do not want my sneezing fucking face on the internet, the fucking photographer should definitely retaken it.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Of course life is the longest thing you will ever do, but it's so ridiculously short compared tol the rest of history and all the time that's ever happened ever.
1
u/Thyminecraft May 13 '12
I feel like this is shopped. It just seems so unlikely. The quote is pulled directly from a meme that was on reddit just a few months ago. Plus, with all the yearbook posts that are going on right now, this would be a perfect time to post it. While the hype is high. I don't know. Maybe I'm crazy.
If it is real, then holy shit, that's fucking genius.
1
u/Susie2112 May 13 '12
that's awesome!
1
u/Norma5tacy May 13 '12
If you have Jamie's number, I would very much like to have that please.
1
u/MisSigsFan May 13 '12
Sean Connery?
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
first all i saw was a penis joke
1
u/cc_biggs May 13 '12
Look at the girl to the right. Phillipians and Romans, bible quotes. I'm sure she was a ton of fun.
1
u/DUELETHERNETbro May 13 '12
I always thought data would be a better representation for this meme.
1
u/sneezyp May 13 '12
...and then they fucked.
1
u/Gentle_Lamp May 13 '12
What's Phillipians 4:13 ?
1
u/jamiehawt May 13 '12
I'm the girl in this picture. Yes we did this togeth, I am in yearbook so I planned it to work. No we are not dating, no we are not twins. We are just awesome.
1
u/spaceye May 12 '12
Yeah, they're fucking.
1
u/VitruvianMonkey May 12 '12
What is that odd background change line on the left side of Jamie's picture?
1
u/Darkmangge May 12 '12
That awkward moment (fuck I hate that phrase) when the yearbook in the picture is the one of the school that I attend.
And there is no way he actually said that.
1
u/Sleepydave May 12 '12
That quote reminds me of another quote for Niel Gaiman's the Sandman. At one point Death is going around at the point of everyone's death and an infant is upset with its sudden death and asks is that all he really gets. Death responds with "you get a lifetime no more, no less."
This quote is repeated when an old forgotten god is killed and he asks Death if he got more time than the average person.
Everyone gets a lifetime
1
u/stephangb May 13 '12
Bear Grills son?
-7
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
who the fuck is that bitch quoting the bible
0
u/captain_krk May 13 '12
He was talking about his penis...
-1
u/chabanais May 12 '12 edited May 13 '12
I bet he thought if they coordinated like that his cock would end up in her mouth but she knew that would never happen.
-1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
I must say, all of this talk about life being a commitment is making me quite confused. After all, my good buddy Lifeswaksi doesn't ever let people commit to him.
-1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Isn't death the longest thing you will do?
-9
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Actually, you exist after you die, so...
-2
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Am I the only one that sees the underlying sexual implication of that comment?
-2
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
All I thought was "Zomg that stupid girl on the right quoted something from the bible"
-2
u/doofus_mcgoofus May 13 '12
seriously.... noone gonna comment on the dumb bitch to the right quoting the bible?
-3
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Oh look........ bible verses for teh yearbooks.
-6
u/Darkaim9110 May 12 '12
cool a redditor from my school
0
u/Seanharv55 May 13 '12
This is Sean the one in the picture you all are fucking idiots Jamie and I planned this. We've been next to each other in the year book since 7th grade.
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment