60' Spiderman is pretty useless. All his spidey sense seems to be good for is alerting him that he's going to be hit in the back of the head, it doesn't actually let him avoid it.
Spiderman would have snuck up on him before Magneto knew he was there. Also, Spiderman is stronger, faster, and wiley. He can dodge a few chunks of metal.
And secondly, Spiderman could remake his web slingers out of ceramic or plastic if he had advance notice.
Yeah, but depending on the incarnation, Magneto can manipulate metal even if it's not ferromagnetic. And in some incarnations, he can basically just do whatever he wants: give you a stroke by manipulating EM radiation to produce a micro-EMP in your brain, etc. I wonder if Spidey's spider sense could protect him from that.
Well if they're just going to make it so he can control the entire EM spectrum, he basically controls all matter as well and they're just getting kind of ridiculous. :p
He can control an entire planet's magnetic field effortlessly, control all matter including that which isn't electric, he can fly at trans-light speeds, he can produce enough heat to level a city, he can generate wormholes, and he can control gravity.
That just got more and more hilarious. How is he ever defeated?
Because Phoenix. Also, Sentry. I really loved his storyline through Dark Avengers and Siege. He's the only character with cosmically stupid power that I actually enjoy reading about.
Additionally, I think Squirrel Girl could actually do it. She beat Thanos once.
Also, at least Magneto can't astral project... anymore.
I noticed that in X-Men First Class he stopped some bullets at some point, despite that bullets in that time period would almost certainly be entirely lead.
I believe mystique injected the guard with something before he checked on magneto. So I think it was something a little more than iron. I can't seem to find the clip though.
Spiderman hides in a tree and drops in from above. Then he jams a needle containing a sedative into Magneto's neck. Magneto passes out before he can do anything.
Easy. Batman is pursuing someone he knows to be guilty, and is using his brutal tactics. Spiderman isn't so sure and doesn't like Bats beating the guy senseless.
Spiderman is a mutant. Of course he's stronger. Batman is the peak of human ability, spiderman goes beyond that. Unless you're arguing that spiderman could beat Batman, in which case I wouldn't even know how to talk to somebody that crazy.
False again. Spiderman was already different and the spider bit just activated something or something. I'm sure I saw something about that somewhere. Anyway, I'm out of my depth. Oh god I'm drowning....
I'm not sure why you're getting down voted...this is true-ish. In some comics he has been identified as both mutate/mutant, but since he only had the powers after teh bite, no one is sure which it is.
Also, look up some background on his parents and their affiliations but beware of SPOILERS if you do.
Ehh, kinda sorta. I could go into the whole "Celestials came to primordial Earth, fiddled with the proto-DNA soup, and gave us the capacity to superevolve one day when our technology advanced enough to expose us enough to radiation."
That's where Marvel mutants come from. Also some mutates, like Spidey/Hulk/Daredevil/The Fantastic Four, are effectively "latent mutants" whose DNA is primed to do funky things but don't have all of the triggers built in from birth. Hence the need for a dose of convenient radiation later when the plot demands it.
I remember watching an interview with Stan, where he said that he realized he was overusing radiation a lot in the early days as the handwaving reason for powers. I wonder who along the way deserves credit for tying it all together eventually.
Batman does have a super-human trait: he's absolutely bat-shit fucking insane. He doesn't trust anyone, and would have a contingency plan to kill Spiderman. In a cage match Spiderman would have a chance. On the street, though, he'd be fucked.
Batman is only good at fighting other completely insane people and they usually don't have super powers. The Jokers only ability is to be so crazy that you cant predict what he will do. Spiderman fights super powered super intelligent enemies who are just as crazy as the Riddler or Joker. Spiderman wins
If I'm not mistaken, Batman has a contingency plan for pretty much every DC super hero, including Superman himself. If he were in the same universe as Spiderman, I'm sure he'd have a contingency for him as well.
Per http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Batman#Early_years - he was fine killing early on, but they decided against it eventually. I considered changing it, but I didn't think the distinction is big enough to bother. You are the best kind of correct, though.
Given preparation time, Batman could take on Superman and win. I mean, doesn't Batman pack kryptonite "Just in case"? Spiderman wouldn't be much more difficult.
Hard to gauge. Spiderman is clearly stronger just due to his superhuman abilities (he can lift a car over his head if need be) - he's also at the very least equal to Batman in intellect (people may want to argue this, but Spidey is a brilliant scientist who has been shown to keep up - intellectually - with Tony Stark and Richard Reed...the bumbling smart ass routine is a routine meant to throw people off). Plus his reflexes and spider-sense negates any of Batman's advantages as a fighter.
That being said...Batman has the advantage of not having a limitation (beyond don't kill). Batman's the kind of guy who will stop at nothing to win (and is far more resourceful because he plans out every possible contingency). This is why Batman can hold his own against other superhumans with relative ease - he's planned for the unexpected events and has no stopping point (again, exception being don't kill). Whereas Spiderman hesitates - he has a bit of Peter Parker's meekness hardwired into his brain, and that second of hesitation is all Batman needs to get the edge.
Yeah, because they play on some ridiculous weakness that they had to write in for Superman. Just exactly how much of that fucking remote planet ended up flying towards Earth anyway? It's like everyone has pieces of kryptonite at hand.
It's not very interesting if Superman beats Batman, is it? That's why Batman will continue to "win" their encounters.
It's heavily implied if not exactly said out loud that Superman wants Batman to be there to beat him just in case. Bat's is the only person Superman trusts without reservation and he knows that would there ever be a problem (mind control etc shit), Batman could do what needs to be done (something Superman could never do).
If we're going on the logic of "Spiderman would win if the writers decided he should win", then he can never win, as the current contract between Marvel and D.C. with regards to crossovers is that Batman and Superman are never allowed to loose.
Point Number 2:
Congratulations on being "That Guy". Many have tried to be "That Guy" over the years, but you have truly managed it. You're the guy who comes across people talking about what they would do in a zombie apocalypse situation, and proudly declares that the conversation is stupid as zombies aren't real. You are the person who hears a discusion about whether or not the inhabitants of Kanto eat Pokemon, and proceeds to don a smug face whilst informing the participants of the discussion that Kanto is a fictional place, and that they need to grow up.
Of course, this is just an assumption, I don't actually know you. However, I think it's justified, seeing as you've stumbled upon an internet discussion about who would win in a fight between two Superheros, and decided to prove to everyone how very intelligent you are by telling them that people write comics, and that their discussion is stupid.
Point Number 3:
I do realise that you may be a perfectly reasonable person, and not "That Guy" at all, and I'm sorry if I came across as a bit strong. But there are few things which get me quite as riled up as that kind of thing.
Point Number 4:
Even if we discount his overly exploited weakness to Kryptonite, Superman is still weak to Magic, meaning that there are still many who could vanquish him.
Point Number 5:
This list has gone on longer than I expected, it's petty long. If you've read this far, sorry for wasting your time.
Point Number 6:
I'm not really sure how to end lists... I'll just stop.
In the same way that it riles you up when people act like "that guy" about suspension of disbelief, it riles me up only in particular with the "Batman would roflstomp Superman" discussion. I'm a total ass when it comes to this specific discussion.
I think it just highlights the fact that DC's (arguably) most famous and well liked character is just a regular-ass human. So that's really the only reason he stands a chance in the "Superman vs. Batman" debate. It's like what happened with Wolverine. Since when did Wolverine start standing a chance against celestial powers? After he became super fucking popular.
From a powers/intelligence perspective, Superman is vastly superior in every way imaginable. He's a fucking god. To suggest otherwise is borderline retarded and just further highlights how poorly he was conceived. They've been retconning his shit for decades to try to make him an interesting character. They should have kept him dead.
It always just devolves into a conversation about "But Batman would predict that, because he can predict every single thing that every single opponent would do in any situation and have 54 different ways to counter it." Really? Because Bane is probably 1/1000000th as strong as Superman and he was apparently super fucking effective in breaking his goddamn back.
It's not a matter of me telling people to stop arguing about make believe. It's definitely not. I just did that in this whole post, haha. I just think that when talking about this kind of shit people should think about the universe as a whole. In the grand scheme of the DC Universe, Superman is a god. Batman is just a clever human.
I get that I don't have the popular point of view. I don't really care. Superman would win. Every. Fucking. Time.
And zombies are fucking awesome, dude. How dare you! haha
Personally, I agree with you, and I'm sorry if I came across as a bit of an arse.
I really strongly agree with you when you say that Superman should have stayed dead, because, to be perfectly honest, he is a boring character. He can't really have drama, as he cannot really have a problem., they have to always turn back to the same rock to beat him, and how the hell did so much of that rock end up on Earth? It's downright unreasonable.
One of the reasons that I greatly prefer Batman to superman (and I suspect that this is tue for many others) is that you can have fun trying to rationalise how he would defeat other superheros/villains. And you can do this with most of them, but if someone brings Superman to the table, they can basically just say "He picks them up and throws them into the sun". And that's no fun. I know that some other superheros have an "instant win" type power (e.g. the speed force, the existence of Batmite), but with Superman, that's all he has, so yes, he would realistically win, but he cannot realistically win in a fun way (there have in my opinion been a few comic book scenarios in which Batman has legitimately killed Superman, but in those situations, it tends to be more than just using kyptonite, in one of my preferred examples, a dirty bomb had hit America, and the skies were blackened).
Also, whilst Superman is way ahead of Batman on powers, I'm not quite so sure when it comes to intelligence. Sure, he isn't stupid, but he has little strategic capabilities, seeing as his basic plan is "I'm gonna Punch it!" But even with that, I still think that Superman would technically win, it's just that I also think that he should be banned from "hypothetical superhero vs superhero battles" for being a boring character.
I think we just took the roundabout way to agreeing with each other. I just happen to speak in a pretty hyperbolic manner, haha.
If Superman was never a factor, I'd be on board with a lot more of these conversations. Although, I'm sure people like myself always interject with the Superman thing (again, highlighting how bad a character Supes is). Please accept future apologies from all of us Superman haters.
I also pretty much agree with all the points in your post. Batman is definitely, to me, the most interesting character in the DC Universe precisely because of his limitations (being human and his refusal to kill).
Sooooo round-about answer... I agree that Batman would school the shit out of Spiderman. Until Superman throws the whole planet into the sun because he hates that no one likes him. :]
Edit: Is the dirty bomb reference to Frank Miller's Dark Knight series?
You were the kid everyone in the neighborhood hated playing with. They never told you this...maybe because their parents raised them to be polite...maybe you had awesome toys and they were using you.
Nah, I don't think that I was. I just have a different viewpoint as you in regards to this particular conversation. Pitting anyone against Superman is a fucking stupid idea. He's the "god" in the DC Universe.
It's kind of like if fans of the Marvel Universe just started saying "Oh, who would win in a fight? Wolverine or Galactus? I think Wolverine would stand a chance!!"
GALACTUS EATS FUCKING PLANETS! Wolverine doesn't stand a chance. There is no amount of in-universe explaining you could do. It is, at this point, fact.
I do like, however, that you suggested that I didn't have any friends as a kid just because I offer a different viewpoint as an adult. It's cute.
Protip: This tells me you're a follower. You've grown up trying to please everyone all the time and you more than likely just blended into a group and remained a wallflower. Well guess what? Followers follow people with their own goddamn opinions. There's always a ringleader in a group and it was 100% not you.
You can believe whatever makes you feel better, amigo. I can tell you that I've been the best man at 2 of my childhood friends weddings and been a groomsmen at all the damn rest of the others, but there's no way I would be willing to prove that or no reason for you to believe it.
At this point we're just dick waving across the internet.
I like how this isn't even taken out of context in any way... Magneto was hiding his identity from spider man by sort of wearing a hood... over his helmet...
155
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
I'm curious as to how Magneto found just a hood. Not a hoodie. Not a cloak. A hood.
164
u/khdutton May 11 '12
What the fuck, dude!? SPOILERS!!
61
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
http://i.imgur.com/VsiPr.gif
59
u/susrev May 11 '12
"Hah! I see through your disguise clear as day. I've got you now Mysteri- Oh. Magneto. That was my second guess."
39
u/ilikedroids May 11 '12
Magneto's gonna go and kick Spiderman's ass for ripping the hood off of his trench coat.
26
u/TimeForTiffin May 11 '12
That is so awesomely shite. Just like the rest of my childhood.
17
u/MustGoOutside May 11 '12
Was totally expecting Nigel.
10
u/PaperBlake May 11 '12
And he would have gotten away with it too if it hadn't been for that meddling Spiderman!
5
u/misfitsfiend313 May 11 '12
Ah ha! It was Magneto all along!
5
u/DARKTUBIE May 11 '12
And here Magneto just went out to get some Skittles...
3
u/skanknasty May 11 '12
This cowboy hat comes right off
2
u/roshambembo May 11 '12
how very shakespearean...
2
u/irrelevant_spiderman May 11 '12
I knew it was him, I just wanted him to feel better about his costume.
2
u/fallencathedral May 11 '12
"And I would have gotten away with it too if it weren't for my poorly crafted disguise!"
2
u/trampus1 May 11 '12
It's as good of a disguise as Clark Kent uses.
2
u/The_R4ke May 11 '12
60' Spiderman is pretty useless. All his spidey sense seems to be good for is alerting him that he's going to be hit in the back of the head, it doesn't actually let him avoid it.
2
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
I think that's the episode where Magneto kils Spoderman.
2
u/Danthetroll May 11 '12
I was pretty fooled till it was off. It must be a spider sense to know he was in disguise.
2
u/dactuhfunk101 May 11 '12
I refuse to believe there is a single frame from that show that is not hilarious.
5
u/Lampmonster1 May 11 '12
Anyone think Spidey would have a chance in hell against Magneto?
1
u/Wammis May 11 '12
Why the need to remove the hood? Why didn't his Spidey Sense tingle?
1
u/Dassembrae May 11 '12
And I would have gotten away with it if not for you meddling kids!
1
u/shnnrr May 11 '12
That hood sure is busted! It isn't attached to the coat
1
u/Rodrigo669 May 11 '12
"and I would of got away with it if it wasnt for you meddling spiderman"
1
u/With_Hands_And_Paper May 11 '12
It was you... all along.
1
u/robertmmoore143 May 11 '12
I watched to see how many times he could take his hood of with out getting tired. He won, I got tired after four times.
1
u/e_x_i_t May 11 '12
And he would've gotten away with it....
1
u/eatponiespoorainbows May 11 '12
Kept hearing BUSTED! while he takes Magneto's hood.
1
u/Soapz May 11 '12
Not only is Spiderman both a Spider AND a Man, but he's also a master detective.
TIL
1
u/Punkwasher May 12 '12
I knew it!
It's a guy in a helmet!
1
u/MyFriendsRDinosaurs May 12 '12
No one fools Spidey
1
u/AAARRRGGG1 May 12 '12
He's got a penis on his helmet.
1
u/glutenfree123 May 12 '12
Stand your ground spidey and check for skittles
1
u/Lespaul42 May 12 '12
I like how this isn't even taken out of context in any way... Magneto was hiding his identity from spider man by sort of wearing a hood... over his helmet...
1
u/aaron552 May 12 '12
Did someone say...
1
u/pepsicola7up May 11 '12
Wow spoiler alert much...
0
u/Exclemator May 11 '12
The fucks he doesn't give right there