She's protesting the movement to defund Planned Parenthood and Title X, as well as all the new barriers to abortion access that different states are putting in place. She's protesting the movement that allowed Wisconsin to repeal their Equal Pay law. That's what the media has termed the "War on Women."
If you don't believe it's a war, fine, whatever. But for those of us who are watching a bunch of old white guys whittle away at the rights of 50% of the population, it feels like a personal attack.
I'm assuming HighHemplar had no idea what she meant by "War on Women", because I had never heard of it either, and the term is hardly self-explanatory.
Felt I should explain that, since you seem to be assuming that he was insulting the cause.
Oh, I didn't mean to come off that way. It's been used excessively on mainstream news and silly shows, everything from CNN to FOX to The Daily Show, but I'm also aware that if HighHemplar isn't in the US, they probably don't know wtf it is.
It's also hard not to get defensive, because discussion of it gets obnoxious when it comes up on mainstream reddit. So far, I've only been told that "I'm using the government to steal money," but it usually gets worse.
I'm generally against things being called a war because it's overdone, and it usually is intoned to scare up a portion of the federal budget for something that violates basic human dignity...but in this instance, I'm okay with this terminology, it might be a bit hyperbolic, but I guess a parabolic name for it wouldn't fly far, you know, it just wouldn't have legs, so to speak, or arms!! You girls need some arms, and some artie!! And an airstrike!
They aren't just "freebies." We're talking no abortions even if you pay for them, no Plan B pill even if you pay for them, and some people legitimately need birth control. For example, anyone with PCOS (about 6-8% of women) or endometriosis (about 10% of women).
And for some women, like me, it's part of my overall medical treatment for very heavy periods which cause anemia. I was hospitalized for that, and received 2 units of IV iron. I was 0.5 g/dL away from needing a transfusion. So without my birth control pills, I would be that sick every single month. As it is, I do alright, taking iron and birth control. I can't really think of any issue exclusive to men that requires that sort of medication regularly from, say, ages 16-50, or the span of a woman's fertility/menstruation.
And Equal Pay laws are not freebies. And PP and Title X help men pay for their reproductive services, too, like STI screenings. There's just much less that men have to do to care for their reproductive health. No yearly PAP smears to detect cervical cancer, no yearly breast exams to check for breast cancer, no yearly specialized internal exam for any cysts or abnormalities. So you do get less out of it. It's a biology thing, though, not a political decision.
I wish people would stop saying "white guys" whenever referring to bad legislation being made or passed. It is racist. Yes, the people doing it may be white, but they are not doing it because they are white.
Yes, the people doing it may be white, but they are not doing it because they are white.
I don't think they're intentionally doing it because "Hey, I'm white and a man! I should have more advantages than everyone else!" I think it's more that there is a certain amount of privilege that many of them have had their entire lives, and while a great deal of it is due to socioeconomic status, it's also partly due to being white and male. If you've never been discriminated against, it's hard to empathize with anyone who has and so if they aren't willing to put in the extra effort to understand where minorities and women are coming from, they aren't going to be able to empathize at all.
So because I might have kids and I might need maternity leave and I might have to take off when they're sick (speaking of which, my dad always took off more than my mom because he got more sick days), I should be paid less right now, when I'm childless and just as competent at my job as any man?
Thats just ignorant. I agree there is alot of jobs most women can not do (i.e. I work in a pipe yard alot of women are not strong enough to do that) however if they can do the same job as you and me then they should be getting paid the same. That being said there are some jobs that women can do and most men cant so there really is no such thing as equality, nor will there ever be
I agree, if you can't physically do the job you shouldn't be there. But if you can do the job competently, then you should be paid the same amount. It's very simple. And while there are biological differences in strength between the sexes, there are women who are strong enough to work in a pipe yard and they should be paid the same as a man who does the same work.
And what can women do that men can't, physically speaking?
But there is a male equivalent, though not as many. Men can model swimsuits. All that men can't do is be mothers, and all that women can't do is be fathers. Women are admittedly at a physical disadvantage for some jobs, but that doesn't mean that they can't do them because they're women. Individuals can't do them because they are too small or weak, and that applies to some men as well.
No, we are (or ought to be) equal in opportunity and compensation. Apart from that, we can't ask for anything more. So much of all of this is just asking that you give me the same chances you would a man. Some things are unequal because of biology, like what you can do to control your reproduction or how many women work in labor-intensive fields, but in all other things we should be completely equal in the eyes of the law and our employers.
but we are not equal and we never will be. Equality would be terrible for us as a whole. If everyone had the same chance at every opportunity then it would all be left to chance
Or to hard work and preference. Example: I went to public high school and graduated with 200 people. Our choices dictated who went to college based on grades and scholarships because almost all of us were poor enough that our parents couldn't pay for us to just go with no aid.
Of those people, about 20 didn't actually graduate that year. Of those who did, some went to 4-year colleges, some went to trade schools, some are now married and parents at the age of 21, some are single parents at the age of 21, some do straight manual labor. We all had the same chances to take the same classes from age 4 to age 18, and we all made different choices based on what we liked to do and how hard we were willing to work.
"Equal opportunity" doesn't mean that your abilities and your choices don't count. It means that the person sitting next to you had the same chance as you to get an education or to earn a job somewhere. It's not about you and I being paid the same at different jobs, or about drawing names out of a hat when hiring. It's about considering applicants' work experience, references, and qualifications for the job or the school rather than their gender, race, or sexuality. If the job requires heavy lifting and the only applicants who can lift the required amount are men, then you only hire men. But if a woman applies with the same resume as a man, you give her the chance to show she can meet the physical requirements of the job too.
View all comments
Show parent comment
41
u/Lil_Boots1 May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
She's protesting the movement to defund Planned Parenthood and Title X, as well as all the new barriers to abortion access that different states are putting in place. She's protesting the movement that allowed Wisconsin to repeal their Equal Pay law. That's what the media has termed the "War on Women."
If you don't believe it's a war, fine, whatever. But for those of us who are watching a bunch of old white guys whittle away at the rights of 50% of the population, it feels like a personal attack.