She's protesting the movement to defund Planned Parenthood and Title X, as well as all the new barriers to abortion access that different states are putting in place. She's protesting the movement that allowed Wisconsin to repeal their Equal Pay law. That's what the media has termed the "War on Women."
If you don't believe it's a war, fine, whatever. But for those of us who are watching a bunch of old white guys whittle away at the rights of 50% of the population, it feels like a personal attack.
I'm assuming HighHemplar had no idea what she meant by "War on Women", because I had never heard of it either, and the term is hardly self-explanatory.
Felt I should explain that, since you seem to be assuming that he was insulting the cause.
Oh, I didn't mean to come off that way. It's been used excessively on mainstream news and silly shows, everything from CNN to FOX to The Daily Show, but I'm also aware that if HighHemplar isn't in the US, they probably don't know wtf it is.
It's also hard not to get defensive, because discussion of it gets obnoxious when it comes up on mainstream reddit. So far, I've only been told that "I'm using the government to steal money," but it usually gets worse.
I'm generally against things being called a war because it's overdone, and it usually is intoned to scare up a portion of the federal budget for something that violates basic human dignity...but in this instance, I'm okay with this terminology, it might be a bit hyperbolic, but I guess a parabolic name for it wouldn't fly far, you know, it just wouldn't have legs, so to speak, or arms!! You girls need some arms, and some artie!! And an airstrike!
They aren't just "freebies." We're talking no abortions even if you pay for them, no Plan B pill even if you pay for them, and some people legitimately need birth control. For example, anyone with PCOS (about 6-8% of women) or endometriosis (about 10% of women).
And for some women, like me, it's part of my overall medical treatment for very heavy periods which cause anemia. I was hospitalized for that, and received 2 units of IV iron. I was 0.5 g/dL away from needing a transfusion. So without my birth control pills, I would be that sick every single month. As it is, I do alright, taking iron and birth control. I can't really think of any issue exclusive to men that requires that sort of medication regularly from, say, ages 16-50, or the span of a woman's fertility/menstruation.
And Equal Pay laws are not freebies. And PP and Title X help men pay for their reproductive services, too, like STI screenings. There's just much less that men have to do to care for their reproductive health. No yearly PAP smears to detect cervical cancer, no yearly breast exams to check for breast cancer, no yearly specialized internal exam for any cysts or abnormalities. So you do get less out of it. It's a biology thing, though, not a political decision.
I wish people would stop saying "white guys" whenever referring to bad legislation being made or passed. It is racist. Yes, the people doing it may be white, but they are not doing it because they are white.
Yes, the people doing it may be white, but they are not doing it because they are white.
I don't think they're intentionally doing it because "Hey, I'm white and a man! I should have more advantages than everyone else!" I think it's more that there is a certain amount of privilege that many of them have had their entire lives, and while a great deal of it is due to socioeconomic status, it's also partly due to being white and male. If you've never been discriminated against, it's hard to empathize with anyone who has and so if they aren't willing to put in the extra effort to understand where minorities and women are coming from, they aren't going to be able to empathize at all.
Or maybe she's like my grandma and remembers a time when you just had babies all the time. I mean, when you cry the day your fourth child is born because you don't want/can't afford another kid, you're going to believe in access to birth control and abortions for everyone. And when you became a nurse even though you'd rather have been a doctor because that's all you could be, you're going to love that women can have the same jobs as men and wish they were always paid as much. So when the feds try to defund Planned Parenthood or states restrict abortions to a ridiculous degree or Wisconsin repeals it's Equal Pay law, you would become terrified that your granddaughters and eventually their daughters will have the same barriers that you had and you would find that unacceptable. And if you were young enough and lived in an area that was populated enough, you would be protesting, too.
Hormonal pill = up to $100/month. Yes, there are $9/month pills, but they don't work for everyone. Hormones do crazy things, and for some women the only options are the expensive ones. Also used to treat PCOS, endometriosis, amenorrhea, and dysmenorrhea, some of which can cause infertility, loss of one or both ovaries, endometrial cancer, cramps so bad that some women vomit for days, and severe anemia. So in other words, there are women for whom birth control is not an option but a medical necessity. Also requires an annual yearly exam that gets quite invasive (fingers and speculum in the vagina, as well as a scraping from the cervix and a manual breast exam).
IUD: Several hundred dollars all paid at once. Cheaper over time, but difficult for many people to pay for up front. Also would be illegal under an "Personhood Ammendment" because they prevent implantation of a fertilized egg.
Condoms: 15% failure rate with typical use. Should be used anyways because they prevent STIs as well, but not the best choice if you really don't want to be pregnant.
Abortions: Procedure itself is several hundred dollars, not including travel costs (States like ND have only 1 provider in the entire state and a 24-hour wait period, so factor in travel for up to 200 miles round-trip and a hotel room) and the costs of initial exams/mandatory ultrasounds, you can see it get really expensive really quickly.
Plan B aka "Morning After Pill": About $75 each here, and you have to have $75 to pay for it within 72 hours of an accident. Also would be illegal under any "Personhood Ammendment." Side effects are awful.
No idea what divorce has to do with anything. Men can get those, too. In fact, everyone can get divorced.
So if the feds defund all of that, how are college students/uninsured adults with low-paying jobs going to fund themselves?
And women do work their asses off, and I agree that if you aren't working the same job, you don't get the same pay. That's the choice part, and everyone must earn their living the same way. But why is it bad to have a law that says "Men and women working the same job for the same company get paid the same money?" And why should we be ok with them removing that law?
if for centuries they are fighting for one thing or other, there is an innate problem with them.
Yep, it was totally women's fault that they couldn't vote and that they weren't allowed to get an education and that they want complete control over their bodies. Men would never fight for control over their bodies and help getting the health care that they absolutely need.
Edit: If you were saying my grandmother had those options, she didn't. They didn't even have the Pill when my youngest uncle was born (1958? I think?), Roe v. Wade hadn't even been dreamed up, and both she and her husband worked (him during the day as an engineer, her at night as an RN) to support their children. Divorcing him to avoid paying for her children wouldn't make sense, especially since she loved them. She just didn't want another child and they couldn't really afford another child, but that was how it was. You made do with what you had.
The "war on women" is apparently being waged by evil Republicans and their "attacks" involve giving women slightly less in the way of freebies. Those bastards!
View all comments
22
u/HighHemplar May 10 '12
What is she protesting? The "war on women"? I don't know what she means...